Sunday, April 24, 2005

Book Review: "QED"

A few days ago, I finished reading Richard Feynman's book QED: The Strange Theory of Light and Matter, which I originally alluded to in my posting of April 2, 2005.

Given that I discussed forces and force particles in my April 2 and April 8 postings, I wanted to add some clarifications in these areas based on Feynman's book, while the topic was still fresh.

The first thing I want to say is that Feynman provided the clearest explanation of the weak nuclear force that I've ever seen. In the material of Feynman's that I quote below, he refers to up quarks as "u" quarks and down quarks as "d" quarks (I first introduced up and down quarks in my March 18, 2005 posting). Feynman notes the following, in terms of the weak force's carrier particle, the W:

Quantum chromodynamics and quantum electrodynamics aren't all there is to physics. According to them, a quark cannot change its "flavor": once a u quark, always a u quark; once a d quark, always a d quark. But Nature behaves differently, sometimes. There is a form of radioactivity that happens slowly -- the kind that people worry about leaking out of nuclear reactors -- called beta decay, which involves a neutron changing into a proton. Since a neutron consists of two d's and a u-type quark while a proton is made of two u's and a d, what really happens is that one of the neutron's d-type quarks changes into a u-type quark... Here's how it happens: the d quark emits a new thing like a photon called a W, which has a coupling with an electron and with another new particle called an anti-neutrino... (pp. 139-140).

Further, as noted in the book's caption to Figure 85, "This process [of beta decay] happens relatively slowly, so an intermediate particle (called a "W-intermediate-boson")... was proposed."

Another thing that Feynman's book (pp. 134-135) helped crystallize in my mind is that quarks -- though held together by gluons and thus clearly associated with the strong nuclear force -- also have electromagnetic charges (which are associated with the electromagnetic force).

Specifically, the up quark has the charge +2/3, whereas the down quark's is -1/3. This makes sense because a proton is made up of two up quarks and a down, thus in total yielding the familiar proton charge of +1 (2/3 + 2/3 -1/3). Similarly, a neutron is comprised of two downs and an up, thus yielding the familiar neutral (i.e., zero) overall charge of a neutron (2/3 - 1/3 - 1/3).

Beta decay's conversion of a neutron into a proton, as Feynman notes, really comes down to one down quark changing into an up, the latter having a charge one greater than the former.

According to a web document by Kenneth R. Koehler, as an example of conservation of charge, "the loss of a negative one charge in the form of the W boson has changed the - 1/3 charge on the down quark to the + 2/3 of the up quark."

Thus, the W particle in this context is known as a W- (with a W+ being its antiparticle).

As noted above, the W particle is just an intermediate. Next, according to Koehler, "The neutral neutrino has changed to the negatively charged electron, and the neutral neutron (charge - 1/3 - 1/3 + 2/3) has become the positive proton (charge 2/3 + 2/3 - 1/3)."

As I noted in my April 8 entry, "The force particles of the weak nuclear force are called W and Z particles." Here, according to Feynman, is the origin of the Z particle:

There is another particle, which we could think of as a neutral W, called Zo [a Z, with a subscript zero]. The Zo does not change the charge of a quark... (p. 141).

The above clarifications thus refine our knowledge of the different forces and their carrier particles. I have had to add some complexities to my earlier "watered down" presentations, but by doing so, I think our understanding will be enhanced in the long run.

Monday, April 18, 2005

50th Anniversary of Einstein's Death

I've been busy grading papers lately, but I just wanted to make a brief posting to note that today is the 50th anniversary of Einstein's death. The following biographical sketch of him gives the span of his life:

Albert Einstein (March 14, 1879 – April 18, 1955)

Those of you who surf around physics blogs have almost certainly seen the logo (or other reference) for the World Year of Physics. This celebration is marking the 100th anniversary of Einstein's publishing four major ideas in 1905 (on Brownian motion, special relativity, photoelectric effect/quantum theory, and E = mc-squared).

Last night, the Discovery Science cable channel featured two one-hour documentaries on Einstein, one on his career (which really dwelled on his failures of the last 30-35 years of his career) and the other on how his discoveries helped lead to the atomic bomb and his reaction to that. I saw the first one, but only a tiny part of the second one.

In the weeks and months ahead, I will be writing about many of the aforementioned (and other) physics concepts associated with Einstein.

Friday, April 08, 2005

Forces Part II

Let's resume our discussion of forces, which were introduced last week. They are the gravitional, electromagnetic, strong nuclear, and weak nuclear forces. This week, we will discuss their operation, through force particles and fields. A key aspect of forces is that they appear to operate between entities that are not touching each other. Brian Greene provides some examples in his book The Fabric of the Cosmos:

When you go through airport security, how is it that a machine that doesn't touch you can determine whether you're carrying metallic objects? When you have an MRI, how is it that a device that remains outside your body can take a detailed picture of your insides? (p. 40)

Over the next few pages (pp. 40-42), Greene goes on to discuss magnetic fields (also noting the "deep interconnection between electric and magnetic fields"). Magnetic fields are characterized as an "invisible something that permeates the space around it" and "exert[s] a force beyond the physical extent of the magnet itself." Other kinds are fields, such as gravitional and nuclear ones, are also acknowledged.

Andrew Watson, in his book The Quantum Quark, raises conceptually similar questions:

How does a charged particle feel another nearby charged particle? How does a planet know to respond to the gravitational field of the Sun? (p. 58).

The answer, according to Watson, is that:

The force between two objects becomes the exchange of force-carrying quanta [particles] between them (p. 58).

As summarized on the following page from Particle Adventure, each of the four aforementioned forces has its own force particle(s) that "communicate" the respective forces between objects of matter. As you'll see, force particles often -- but not always -- have names that end with "on."

The photon is the force particle conveying the electromagnetic field; "photon" is also the term for a particle of light. Gluons are the force particles of the strong nuclear force and thus hold quarks together. The force particles of the weak nuclear force are called W and Z particles. Finally, the force particles of gravitation are called gravitons; at this stage, gravitons have not been experimentally detected.

As illustrated on another Particle Adventure page, a force particle may be seen as analogous to a basketball being passed back and forth between two players, who represent matter particles.

Watson notes that, "The idea that a stream of exchanged photons could explain the force between charged particles was introduced by [Enrico] Fermi and the German-American physicist Hans Bethe in 1932" (p. 59).

This is a very timely reference as Bethe died almost exactly one month ago (March 6, 2005) at the age of 98. Cornell University, where Bethe spent an unfathomable 70 years, has a tribute page for him. This page includes video links to lectures on quantum theory Bethe, at age 93, gave for his neighbors in an Ithaca, New York retirement community.

Fermi (1901-1954) has perhaps had more terms in physics and chemistry named after him than has any other scientist. In fact, matter particles, which I discussed in an earlier posting, fall within a category called fermions, whereas force particles (which I've just discussed) belong to a class called bosons.

I will revisit these latter terms, as well as the scientists for whom they are named, in future postings.

Saturday, April 02, 2005

Forces Part I

Now that we've completed our introduction to matter and the particles of which it is composed, today we'll begin our discussion of the forces that attract or repel particles. It has been common in some of the books I've read for matter and forces to be discussed together. Just as there are matter particles, there are also force particles. Another concept that comes up in conjuction with forces is that of fields, which I'll also discuss.

For conveying the ideas inherent in forces, I highly recommend the segment of the Particle Adventure online slide show entitled "What Holds it Together?" In fact, after you're done reading my entry on forces, I would urge you to go back and view this slide show.

According to the aforementioned Particle Adventure slide show, "...a force is the effect on a particle due to the presence of other particles."

There are four kinds of forces: gravitational, electromagnetic, strong nuclear, and weak nuclear.

We all know gravity as what keeps us tied down to the earth. As the late, great Caltech physicist Richard Feynman noted in a famous series of lectures at UCLA (preserved in the Feynman book QED: The Strange Theory of Light and Matter), gravity is "...the thing that holds you in your seats (actually, that's a combination of gravity and politeness, I think)..." (p. 8).

Gravity applies to any two objects, such as the earth, orbiting the sun. As noted in the Wikipedia's description:

Gravitation is the tendency of masses to move toward each other... Exactly why two masses separated in space have a gravitational attraction to one another remains largely unknown, despite much research and various theories.

I will discuss gravity further, in a future writing, when we explore Einstein's theory of general relativity.

The electromagnetic force, as the name implies, represents a combination of electricity and magnetism, as developed by 19th century physicist James Clerk Maxwell. As described in the Wikipedia:

...it turns out that the electromagnetic force is the one responsible for practically all the phenomena one encounters in daily life, with the exception of gravity. Roughly speaking, all the forces involved in interactions beween atoms can be traced to the electromagnetic force acting on the electrically charged protons and electrons inside the atoms...

Furthermore, light is actually a kind of travelling disturbance in the electromagnetic field (i.e. electromagnetic waves.) Therefore, all optical phenomena are actually electromagnetic phenomena.


The two other known forces are the strong nuclear and weak nuclear forces. Given that they both implicate "nuclear" forces, it will be helpful to review the basics of an atom's nucleus. As seen here for the example of the helium atom, the nucleus contains two protons and two neutrons, with two electrons on the atom's periphery. According to a "Nuclear Science Primer" by the Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory, chemical elements differ primarily by the number of protons they have.

As I discussed in an earlier posting on matter and subatomic particles, protons and neutrons are each comprised of different combinations of up and down quarks. Thus, two instances of "holding together" must occur. Quarks must be held together to form protons and neutrons, and the combinations of protons and neutrons must be held together in the nucleus.

This is where the strong nuclear force comes in. According to the aforementioned Nuclear Science Primer:

Because like electrical charges repel each other, scientists realized early on that packed protons—those little nuggets of positive charge—should cause any nucleus with two or more protons to blow itself apart. A quite different force was required, which researchers understandably named the "strong nuclear force."

It turns out that both protons and neutrons consist of smaller entities called quarks. The strong force is what holds quarks together; it is the leftover, "residual" strong force that binds the nuclei.


The strong force is associated with the theory of quantum chromodynamics (QCD), which appears to be a thriving area of particle physics. The 2004 Nobel Prize in physics was awarded to a trio of researchers -- David Gross, David Politzer, and Frank Wilczek -- who have studied the strong nuclear force/QCD. As I've alluded to previously, I recently read the book The Quantum Quark, by Andrew Watson, which is on QCD; I will discuss this theory in a future posting.

Finally, there is the weak nuclear force, which as best I can tell, gets the least attention. Brian Greene, in the public broadcasting documentary of his book The Elegant Universe, provides the following narration (click for transcript):

Now, the strong and weak forces may seem obscure, but in one sense at least, we're all very much aware of their power. At 5:29 on the morning of July 16th, 1945, that power was revealed by an act that would change the course of history. In the middle of the desert, in New Mexico, at the top of a steel tower about a hundred feet above the top of this monument, the first atomic bomb was detonated.

It was only about five feet across, but that bomb packed a punch equivalent to about twenty thousand tons of TNT. With that powerful explosion, scientists unleashed the strong nuclear force, the force that keeps neutrons and protons tightly glued together inside the nucleus of an atom. By breaking the bonds of that glue and splitting the atom apart, vast, truly unbelievable amounts of destructive energy were released.

We can still detect remnants of that explosion through the other nuclear force, the weak nuclear force, because it's responsible for radioactivity. And today, more than 50 years later, the radiation levels around here are still about 10 times higher than normal.


In summary, those are the four forces -- gravitational, elecromagnetic, strong nuclear, and weak nuclear. In what may be a surprise to many people, Greene notes in his later book The Fabric of the Cosmos that:

Gravity is by far the weakest of all forces (for example, an ordinary refrigerator magnet can pick up a paper clip, thereby overcoming the pull of the entire earth's gravity)... (p. 255).

This example, of course, can be used as your first do-it-at-home experiment!

Next week, we'll look at force particles and fields...