Continuing with our series on symmetry, in Part IV we discuss a frequently encountered term, gauge symmetry. Terry Tao, who among his many distinctions earned full professor status at UCLA at age 24, has addressed the concept of a gauge, on his blog:
“Gauge theory” is a term which has connotations of being a fearsomely complicated part of mathematics – for instance, playing an important role in quantum field theory, general relativity, geometric PDE, and so forth. But the underlying concept is really quite simple: a gauge is nothing more than a “coordinate system” that varies depending on one’s “location” with respect to some “base space” or “parameter space”, a gauge transform is a change of coordinates applied to each such location, and a gauge theory is a model for some physical or mathematical system to which gauge transforms can be applied (and is typically gauge invariant, in that all physically meaningful quantities are left unchanged (or transform naturally) under gauge transformations).
Writers have offered several everyday examples of gauge systems. The main idea I extract from them is that, if you add a constant to every value in a system, the behavior of the system is unchanged.
Dan Hooper, whose previous book Dark Cosmos I reviewed here, uses the example of mountain-climbing and altitude to explain the gauge concept in his new book, Nature's Blueprint. The amount of upward climbing a person does from the base to the top of Mount Everest is the same -- 11,528 feet -- whether the frame of reference is sea level (where the base is said to be at 17,500 feet and the top at 29,028) or the reference is the lowest point on earth beneath the oceans (53,338 to 64,866).
As Hooper notes, "With global gauge symmetries, the arbitrary scale can be changed without affecting anything, but it must be changed at every location at the same time" (p. 64). If, therefore, in our discussions of altitude we added a constant 35,838 feet all throughout the earth in order to change the baseline from the depths of the oceans to sea level, we would have a global gauge symmetry.
Another kind of symmetry, where one type of change is made at one location but a different type of change is made at another, is called local gauge symmetry. Hooper credits Hermann Weyl with realizing the implications of local gauge symmetries for physics.
Ian Stewart, in his book on symmetry, Why Beauty is Truth, uses monetary systems to illustrate local gauge symmetry:
Suppose that you are traveling in a different country -- let us call it Duplicatia -- and you need money. The Duplicatian currency is the pfunnig, and the exchange rate is two pfunnigs to the dollar. ...everything costs twice as many pfunnigs as you would expect to pay in dollars.
This is a kind of symmetry. The "laws" of commercial transactions are unchanged if you double all the numbers. To compensate for the numerical difference, though, you have to pay in pfunnigs, not in dollars.
...Just across the border, in neighboring Triplicatia, the local currency is the boodle, and these are valued at three to the dollar. When you take a day trip to Triplicatia, the corresponding symmetry requires all sums to be multiplied by three. But again the laws of commerce remain invariant.
Now we have a "symmetry" that differs from one place to another. In Duplicatia, it is multiplication by two; in Triplicatia, by three. You would not be surprised to find that on visiting Quintuplicatia the corresponding multiple is five. All of these symmetry operations can be applied simultaneously, but each is valid only in the corresponding country...
This local rescaling of currency transactions is a gauge symmetry of the laws of commerce. In principle, the exchange rate could be different at every point of space and time, but the laws would still be invariant provided you interpreted all transactions in terms of the local value of the "currency field" (p. 231).
If you go to the "Review of the Universe" summary of particle physics, particularly the section entitled, "Gauge Theory and the Standard Model," you will find a graphical representation of the distinction between global and local transformations in Figure 15-06a. The original and globally transformed objects (spheres) look identical, whereas the locally transformed one looks very different.
The next figure, 15-06b, shows (schematically) the process of local transformation. Between steps 1 and 2, the small dial on the right appears from visual inspection to have been rotated 180 degrees, whereas the other two dials have been rotated by amounts other than 180. Yet as step 3's caption says, the gauge field compensates for the change, and as step 4's caption says (pointing upward on the right), "The original field configuration is restored." (Note that the term "compensation" was also used by Stewart in his above quotes about the hypothetical monetary unit, the pfunnig.)
Such local symmetries are behind many of the major concepts of physics. Writes Stewart:
The possibility of changing the phase arbitrarily at each point of space-time, with no global constraint to make the same change everywhere, is a gauge symmetry of Maxwell's equations, and it carries over into the quantum version of those equations, quantum electrodynamics (p. 233).
Sunday, June 21, 2009
Tuesday, June 02, 2009
Symmetry (Math and Physics) Part III
In Part III of our series on symmetry, we introduce symmetry groups, which fall within a branch of mathematics known as group theory. According to this Wikipedia document, "In mathematics, a group is an algebraic structure consisting of a set together with an operation that combines any two of its elements to form a third element." A very simple example of a group, as noted on the Wikipedia page, is that of ordinary numbers (integers, technically), with addition as the operation: "For any two integers a and b, the sum a + b is also an integer. In other words, the process of adding integers two at a time can never yield a result that is not an integer. This property is known as closure under addition."
This overview document from Minnesota-Morris professor Barry McQuarrie introduces mathematical groups and uses the example of how equilateral triangles can form a symmetry group of operations (turns) that leave the appearance of the triange unaltered.
Over the last year or two, I've been reading books on symmetry that I hoped would be accessible to a non-physicist, non-mathematician such as myself. When one reads a book on symmetry, one inevitably seems to confront the concept of Galois groups. It took a while, but I think I finally understand the general concept. At a very basic level, Galois groups can inform someone performing mathematical calculations if a given equation is solvable.
In particular, Galois groups are focused on algebraic equations with x raised to different powers. An equation with x-squared (x^2) as the highest power is known as a quadratic equation and can be solved using the quadratic formula. Mark Ronan's book Symmetry and the Monster contains a chapter ("Galois: Death of a Genius") that traces the history of how the quadratic formula was followed hundreds and thousands of years later with formulas for solving cubic (x^3) and quartic (x^4) equations. The ideas of Galois enter at the level of quintic (x^5) equations, as summarized in Ian Stewart's book Why Beauty is Truth: A History of Symmetry:
Now we begin to see the beauty of Galois's idea. Not only does it prove that the general quintic has no radical solutions, it also explains why the general quadratic, cubic, and quartic do have radical solutions and tells us roughly what they look like. With extra work, it tells us exactly what they look like. Finally, it distinguishes those quintics that can be solved from those that can't, and tells us how to solve the ones that can (p. 116).
As noted in the above-linked Wikipedia document, solving equations "by radicals" refers to "solutions expressible using solely addition, multiplication, and roots."
In other words, some quintics, such as the very simple x^5 = 1, can be solved (x = 1). Among other quintics, some can be solved by radicals and some cannot. Galois groups can distinguish the solvable from the unsolvable -- on the basis of symmetry. John Baez, who writes an online series, "This Week's Finds in Mathematical Physics," wrote the following in an entry about Galois and symmetry:
The basic idea is something like this. In general, a quintic equation has 5 solutions - and there's no "best one", so your formula has got to be a formula for all five. And there's a puzzle: how do you give one formula for five things?
Well, think about the quadratic formula! It has that "plus or minus" in it, which comes from taking a square root. So, it's really a formula for both solutions of the quadratic equation. If there were a formula for the quintic that worked like this, we'd have to get all 5 solutions from different choices of nth roots in this formula.
Galois showed this can't happen. And the way he did it used symmetry! Roughly speaking, he showed that the general quintic equation is completely symmetrical under permuting all 5 solutions, and that this symmetry group - the group of permutations of 5 things - can't be built up from the symmetry groups that arise when you take nth roots.
The moral is this: you can't solve a problem if the answer has some symmetry, and your method of solution doesn't let you write down a correct answer that has this symmetry!
An old example of this principle is the medieval puzzle called "Buridan's Ass". Placed equidistant between two equally good piles of hay, this donkey starves to death because it can't make up its mind which alternative is best. The problem has a symmetry, but the donkey can't go to both bales of hay, so the only symmetrical thing he can do is stand there.
Buridan's ass would also get stuck if you asked it for the solution to the quadratic equation. Galois proof of the unsolvability of the quintic by radicals is just a more sophisticated variation on this theme. (Of course, you can solve the quintic if you strengthen your methods.)
Not that solving quintics is easy. According to a different Wikipedia page, this one on quintics, sometimes “the solution requires about 600 symbols to write.”
I urge interested readers to check out the websites and books I've referenced. One other book, which I found too technical for my own knowledge level but others of you might find worthwhile, is entitled Fearless Symmetry: Exposing the Hidden Patterns of Numbers, by Avner Ash and Robert Gross.
Next time, we'll look at another type of symmetry group, Lie groups.
This overview document from Minnesota-Morris professor Barry McQuarrie introduces mathematical groups and uses the example of how equilateral triangles can form a symmetry group of operations (turns) that leave the appearance of the triange unaltered.
Over the last year or two, I've been reading books on symmetry that I hoped would be accessible to a non-physicist, non-mathematician such as myself. When one reads a book on symmetry, one inevitably seems to confront the concept of Galois groups. It took a while, but I think I finally understand the general concept. At a very basic level, Galois groups can inform someone performing mathematical calculations if a given equation is solvable.
In particular, Galois groups are focused on algebraic equations with x raised to different powers. An equation with x-squared (x^2) as the highest power is known as a quadratic equation and can be solved using the quadratic formula. Mark Ronan's book Symmetry and the Monster contains a chapter ("Galois: Death of a Genius") that traces the history of how the quadratic formula was followed hundreds and thousands of years later with formulas for solving cubic (x^3) and quartic (x^4) equations. The ideas of Galois enter at the level of quintic (x^5) equations, as summarized in Ian Stewart's book Why Beauty is Truth: A History of Symmetry:
Now we begin to see the beauty of Galois's idea. Not only does it prove that the general quintic has no radical solutions, it also explains why the general quadratic, cubic, and quartic do have radical solutions and tells us roughly what they look like. With extra work, it tells us exactly what they look like. Finally, it distinguishes those quintics that can be solved from those that can't, and tells us how to solve the ones that can (p. 116).
As noted in the above-linked Wikipedia document, solving equations "by radicals" refers to "solutions expressible using solely addition, multiplication, and roots."
In other words, some quintics, such as the very simple x^5 = 1, can be solved (x = 1). Among other quintics, some can be solved by radicals and some cannot. Galois groups can distinguish the solvable from the unsolvable -- on the basis of symmetry. John Baez, who writes an online series, "This Week's Finds in Mathematical Physics," wrote the following in an entry about Galois and symmetry:
The basic idea is something like this. In general, a quintic equation has 5 solutions - and there's no "best one", so your formula has got to be a formula for all five. And there's a puzzle: how do you give one formula for five things?
Well, think about the quadratic formula! It has that "plus or minus" in it, which comes from taking a square root. So, it's really a formula for both solutions of the quadratic equation. If there were a formula for the quintic that worked like this, we'd have to get all 5 solutions from different choices of nth roots in this formula.
Galois showed this can't happen. And the way he did it used symmetry! Roughly speaking, he showed that the general quintic equation is completely symmetrical under permuting all 5 solutions, and that this symmetry group - the group of permutations of 5 things - can't be built up from the symmetry groups that arise when you take nth roots.
The moral is this: you can't solve a problem if the answer has some symmetry, and your method of solution doesn't let you write down a correct answer that has this symmetry!
An old example of this principle is the medieval puzzle called "Buridan's Ass". Placed equidistant between two equally good piles of hay, this donkey starves to death because it can't make up its mind which alternative is best. The problem has a symmetry, but the donkey can't go to both bales of hay, so the only symmetrical thing he can do is stand there.
Buridan's ass would also get stuck if you asked it for the solution to the quadratic equation. Galois proof of the unsolvability of the quintic by radicals is just a more sophisticated variation on this theme. (Of course, you can solve the quintic if you strengthen your methods.)
Not that solving quintics is easy. According to a different Wikipedia page, this one on quintics, sometimes “the solution requires about 600 symbols to write.”
I urge interested readers to check out the websites and books I've referenced. One other book, which I found too technical for my own knowledge level but others of you might find worthwhile, is entitled Fearless Symmetry: Exposing the Hidden Patterns of Numbers, by Avner Ash and Robert Gross.
Next time, we'll look at another type of symmetry group, Lie groups.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)