Thursday, September 22, 2005

Quantum Mechanics Part VI

My previous postings on quantum mechanics have emphasized its probabilistic nature and the role of uncertainty. Another important aspect of quantum mechanics, which I will discuss in today's concluding essay of the series, is how, under quantum mechanics, many properties must take on integer (i.e., whole-number or discrete) values.

According to a document from the Stanford Linear Accelerator Center (SLAC), specifically a section entitled, "Discrete Energy, Momenta, and Angular Momenta," here is how one could think of quantum mechanics:

To get some idea of how counter-intuitive this idea of discrete values is, imagine if someone told you that water could have only integer temperatures as you boiled it. For example, the water could have temperatures of 85º, 86º or 87º, but not 85.7º or 86.5º. It would be a pretty strange world you were living in if that were true.

In fact, according to the Wikipedia, the word quantum "is often used in the more specific sense which it has in physics, where a quantum refers to an indivisible, and perhaps elementary entity."

Perhaps the most interesting illustration of discrete, whole-number phenomena -- to me at least -- is the Bohr model of the atom (sometimes also known as the Rutherford-Bohr model), with electrons orbiting the nucleus like the planets orbiting the sun in the solar system. These orbits have discrete distances from the nucleus. According to an Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) document:

Each orbit around the nucleus represents an energy level, and electrons cannot exist in between orbits. Orbits closer to the nucleus have lower energy. If energy is added, an electron can be "excited" to jump to a higher energy level--an orbit farther from the nucleus. Eventually, though, the electron will return to its original state, and the atom will give off energy equal to the difference between the two orbits.

In some materials, the energy is given off as X-rays; other materials produce specific colors of visible light, or other types of electromagnetic energy.


The University of Colorado's Physics 2000 website has an interactive activity where you can click to move the electron to an orbit closer to or farther from the nucleus and see what happens. In this demonstration, when the electron moves to a more inner orbit, it gives up a photon (a particle of light, also known as a quantum of light). When it moves to a more outer orbit, it takes on a photon.

According to the aforementioned EPA document, the Rutherford-Bohr model was not perfect. However, Schrodinger (a name we've seen in the past) was able to propose some corrective modifications.

Frequently during this series, I've noted Albert Einstein's objections to many ideas that emerged from quantum mechanics. In fact, Einstein actually played a major role in launching quantum mechanics!

Washington University (St. Louis) physicist John Rigden argues in a Physics World article that, of the multiple landmark papers published by Einstein in 1905, the one characterizing light in terms of discrete particles is the one that really stands out:

The big idea in Einstein's March paper was his gentle suggestion that light consists of individual, discrete, localized and indivisible quantum particles. This blithely made, audacious claim contradicted a century of compelling empirical evidence, and it challenged the crowning achievement of 19th-century theoretical physics: the electromagnetic theory of light. It can be argued persuasively that Einstein's March paper was the start of quantum physics.

Saturday, September 10, 2005

Quantum Mechanics Part V

As has been discussed in this series of postings on quantum mechanics, probability and uncertainty are key elements of the subatomic world. Einstein found this aspect of quantum mechanics particularly distasteful, making a famous statement that "God does not play dice with the universe" (the exact wording of this quote differs, depending on the source one looks at).

Physicists have come up with some creative ways of conceptualizing probability within quantum mechanics. A particle may take on one property or another, each with some probability. How the different possibilities are represented is where the ideas get, shall we say, interesting.

Three excellent sources on quantum probability include the 1959 book The Strange Story of the Quantum by Banesh Hoffmann, the 2002 book Quantum Physics: A Beginner's Guide to the Subatomic World by John Gribbin, and a June 2005 profile of Sir Roger Penrose in Discover magazine by Tim Folger.

One approach, known as the Copenhagen Interpretation, essentially says that a system shifts around between possible outcomes while not being observed, but settles upon one definite outcome upon observation. According to Gribbin:

The Interpretation says that a quantum system does not exist in a definite state until it is measured. For example, an electron traveling through the double-slit experiment does so as a spread-out wave, and does not have a precise location in space. It is only when it arrives at the detector screen that it makes a "choice" from the probabilities (like a tumbling die finally settling with three spots facing up) which causes the wave function to "collapse," as Bohr put it, onto a single point (p. 30).

(My earlier discussion of the double-slit experiment is available here.)

Hoffmann uses a different analogy:

When we flip a coin, it is neither heads nor tails until it actually lands... The state would be changed from a combination to a pure state, and it would be changed by the very act of observation... we might even imagine the coin could be twirling... The only trouble would be that we had no way of observing the actual twirling itself... the joke is that we really do not know whether the coin was twirling at all... (excerpts from pp. 161-164).

Another approach, known as the Many Worlds Interpretation, says that each possible outcome can exist in a definite state, but each would do so in a different world (or "Parallel Universe"). As described by Folger, in his profile of Penrose:

Called the many worlds interpretation, it was proposed in 1957 by Princeton University doctoral candidate Hugh Everett III. Its adherents take the laws of quantum theory at face value: Every possible quantum outcome really exists -- but in worlds parallel to our own. In one universe, Penrose is talking with me in Oxford; in another, he is watching a monster-truck rally (p. 32).

Folger notes that, "Penrose cannot believe anyone finds either the Copenhagen interpretation or the many worlds picture satisfactory" (p. 32). Penrose has his own gravity-based interpretation, which the Discover article spells out.

Another famous vehicle for examining these issues is the Schrodinger cat scenario, which I'll also leave for readers to read about on their own.

In conclusion, unlike Einstein, others are not bothered by the probabilistic foundation of quantum mechanics. Notes Hoffmann:

...probabilities are potent things -- if only they are applied to large numbers... we really place far more confidence in the certainty of probabilities than we sometimes like to admit to ourselves when thinking of them abstractly... Roulette casinos rely on probabilities for their gambling profits... (p. 175)

Saturday, September 03, 2005

Quantum Mechanics Part IV

Where I last left off, Einstein (with colleagues Podolsky and Rosen, a trio sometimes known as EPR) had questioned the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle's suggestion that a particle could not simultaneously have a definite position and a definite velocity, and had questioned quantum mechanics more generally. One of the arguments put forth by EPR leads into a discussion of the topic I'd like to cover in today's entry, quantum entanglement.

In his book The Fabric of the Cosmos, Brian Greene notes how there are analogies in particle physics to the example of two people standing back to back then each starting to walk in opposite directions at the same speed. However many miles east, let's say, of the starting point one person is, the other person would be the same number of miles west of it. Greene notes that:

...if an initial single particle should disintegrate into two particles of equal mass that fly off "back-to-back"..., something that is common in the realm of subatomic particle physics, the velocities of the two constituents will be equal and opposite (p. 100).

According to Greene, EPR's argument followed thusly:

...imagine you measure the position of the right-moving particle and in this way learn, indirectly, the position of the left-moving particle. EPR argued that since you have done nothing, absolutely nothing, to the left-moving particle, it must have had this position, and all you have done is determine it, albeit indirectly (p. 101).

The research that ultimately contradicted EPR and supported quantum mechanics and all its weirdness showed that measurement of one particle of a pair actually did appear to affect the properties of the other particle. This type of finding has now been demonstrated with the two particles being as far as 11 kilometers (over 6 miles) apart. Adds Greene:

On the microscopic scale of the photon's wavelengths, 11 kilometers is gargantuan. It might as well be 11 million kilometers -- or 11 billion light-years, for that matter. There is every reason to believe that the correlation between the photons would persist no matter how far apart the detectors are placed (p. 115).

When two particles of a pair had corresponding (correlated) properties, skeptics initially could argue that such correlation may have been preprogrammed into the pair from their common origin. Such an objection was ultimately overcome by a statistical type of argument (credited to John Bell) and experiments supportive of it. This is all summarized at great length in Greene's chapter on quantum entanglement.

On this whole phenomenon and whether special relativity's provision that nothing can travel faster than the speed of light is possibly violated, Greene offers some reflections:

At the end of the day... two widely separated particles... somehow stay sufficiently "in touch" so that whatever one does, the other instantly does too. And that seems to suggest that some kind of faster-than-light something is operating between them. Where do we stand? There is no ironclad, universally accepted answer... (pp. 117-118).

Quantum entanglement may also serve as a mechanism for teleportation, which is sort of like "faxing" a physical object from one place to another. Greene discusses this in another of his chapters.

For further reading, general-audience articles on quantum entanglement and its possible implications are available here and here.