This entry presents the third and final installment on the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB), all of which are part of a larger series I've been writing on the Big Bang and inflationary cosmology. Part III discusses research that followed the CMB's discovery in the early 1960s and continues to the present.
As reported in this 2003 University of Chicago news release on the WMAP research mission, images of the CMB provide a “baby picture” of the universe, "as it looked 380,000 years after the big bang, some 200 million years before any stars or galaxies had formed."
Writes Simon Singh in his book, Big Bang:
It might not be immediately obvious that observing the CMB radiation is equivalent to looking back in time, but exactly the same thing happens when astronomers observe a distant star... ...if the CMB radiation was released billions of years ago and has taken billions of years to reach us, then when astronomers eventually detect it they are effectively sensing the universe as it was billions of years ago, when it was only 300,000 years old (p. 446).
WMAP (alluded to above) and its predecessor mission, the Nobel Prize-winning COBE, were the first to find tiny variations in the CMB across different areas of space. (WMAP's images were designed to be 35 times sharper than COBE's, as seen here in comparative images of the two.)
Prior to the WMAP and COBE missions, observations of the CMB radiation showed it to be absolutely uniform and homogeneous across space (Singh, p. 447). This was problematic, because our present-day universe is obviously not absolutely uniform; some areas of space have larger and denser aggregations of matter than do other areas. In other words, there would need to have been at least some tiny variations in the CMB so that gravity could trigger accretions of matter over billions of years to produce the various kinds of astronomical objects we see today.
The Smoot Cosmology Group -- Smoot being a co-recipient of the Nobel Prize for the COBE discoveries -- discusses the importance of finding even slight non-uniformities in the CMB (scientists use the term "anisotropy" for a non-uniformity; the way I think of it, "iso" means "same," as in the word "isomorphic" which means the same shape, so the "an" in front of "iso" would signify "not the same"). According to the Smoot Group's website:
These anisotropies, or "ripples" in the temperature map, correspond to areas of various density fluctuation in the early Universe. Eventually, gravity would draw these fluctuations into even denser ones. After billions of years, these minute ripples in the early universe evolved, through gravitational attraction, into the planets, stars, galaxies, and clusters of galaxies that we see today.
Dan Hooper's book Dark Cosmos, which I reviewed previously, also provides some nice discussion of the CMB, COBE, and WMAP.
Saturday, May 24, 2008
Saturday, May 10, 2008
Big Bang/Inflationary Cosmology V (Cosmic Microwave Background II)
Tonight, I present Part II on the Cosmic Microwave Background, focusing on its discovery. These entries on the CMB are part of a larger series on the Big Bang and inflationary cosmology. The prediction of the CMB (by Alpher and Herman, with Gamow) as a vestige of the Big Bang was discussed in the previous entry.
The discovery of the CMB derives from radio astronomy. In the early 1960s, the Bell Lab scientists Arno Penzias and Robert Wilson were working on some radio observations. There was a persistent noise in their observations and despite assiduous attempts by Penzias and Wilson to account for and remove the noise, it wouldn't go away. According to Simon Singh's book, Big Bang:
What the two frustrated radio astronomers had not realised was that they had stumbled into one of the most important discoveries in the history of cosmology. They were completely oblivious to the fact that the omnipresent noise was actually a remnant of the Big Bang: it was the 'echo' from the early expansion phase of the universe. This annoying 'noise' would turn out to be the most convincing evidence yet that the Big Bang model was correct (p. 429).
Penzias and Wilson were eventually put in touch with a team from nearby Princeton, Robert Dicke and James Peebles, who, it appears, were busy "re-inventing the wheel" regarding the CMB. According to Singh:
Dicke and Peebles had no idea that they were walking in the fifteen-year-old footstepts of Gamow, Alpher, and Herman. Independently and belatedly, they were re-postulating the CMB radiation (p. 431).
Among all the players in the CMB saga, the only ones to receive the Nobel Prize for it were Penzias and Wilson, in 1978 (official press release). The award to Penzias and Wilson, with no such recognition ever to CMB theorists Alpher, Herman, and Gamow, is discussed on this list of Nobel Prize controversies. Singh details the plight of Alpher, Herman, and Gamow:
When Gamow, Alpher, and Herman heard of the discovery of the CMB radiation, their joy was mixed with some bitterness. It was they who had predicted this echo of the Big Bang well before Dicke and Peebles, but they received virtually no acknowledgement for their pioneering efforts. They were not mentioned in the initial pair of papers [by Penzias and Wilson; and by Dicke and colleagues] announcing the breakthrough in the Astrophysical Journal... (p. 434).
When a journalist later asked Alpher if he had felt offended by Penzias and Wilson's failure to acknowledge his contribution, he spoke his mind: 'Was I hurt? Yes! How the hell did they think I'd feel? I was miffed at the time that they'd never even invited us down to see the damned radio telescope. It was silly to be annoyed, but I was' (p. 436).
Singh's book does, however, detail the efforts by Penzias to make contact with and publicly acknowledge the contributions of Gamow, Alpher, and Herman.
The discovery of the CMB derives from radio astronomy. In the early 1960s, the Bell Lab scientists Arno Penzias and Robert Wilson were working on some radio observations. There was a persistent noise in their observations and despite assiduous attempts by Penzias and Wilson to account for and remove the noise, it wouldn't go away. According to Simon Singh's book, Big Bang:
What the two frustrated radio astronomers had not realised was that they had stumbled into one of the most important discoveries in the history of cosmology. They were completely oblivious to the fact that the omnipresent noise was actually a remnant of the Big Bang: it was the 'echo' from the early expansion phase of the universe. This annoying 'noise' would turn out to be the most convincing evidence yet that the Big Bang model was correct (p. 429).
Penzias and Wilson were eventually put in touch with a team from nearby Princeton, Robert Dicke and James Peebles, who, it appears, were busy "re-inventing the wheel" regarding the CMB. According to Singh:
Dicke and Peebles had no idea that they were walking in the fifteen-year-old footstepts of Gamow, Alpher, and Herman. Independently and belatedly, they were re-postulating the CMB radiation (p. 431).
Among all the players in the CMB saga, the only ones to receive the Nobel Prize for it were Penzias and Wilson, in 1978 (official press release). The award to Penzias and Wilson, with no such recognition ever to CMB theorists Alpher, Herman, and Gamow, is discussed on this list of Nobel Prize controversies. Singh details the plight of Alpher, Herman, and Gamow:
When Gamow, Alpher, and Herman heard of the discovery of the CMB radiation, their joy was mixed with some bitterness. It was they who had predicted this echo of the Big Bang well before Dicke and Peebles, but they received virtually no acknowledgement for their pioneering efforts. They were not mentioned in the initial pair of papers [by Penzias and Wilson; and by Dicke and colleagues] announcing the breakthrough in the Astrophysical Journal... (p. 434).
When a journalist later asked Alpher if he had felt offended by Penzias and Wilson's failure to acknowledge his contribution, he spoke his mind: 'Was I hurt? Yes! How the hell did they think I'd feel? I was miffed at the time that they'd never even invited us down to see the damned radio telescope. It was silly to be annoyed, but I was' (p. 436).
Singh's book does, however, detail the efforts by Penzias to make contact with and publicly acknowledge the contributions of Gamow, Alpher, and Herman.
Wednesday, May 07, 2008
Big Bang/Inflationary Cosmology IV (Cosmic Microwave Background I)
As I briefly alluded to a couple of posts ago, in my series on the Big Bang and inflationary cosmology, the discovery of the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) played a decisive role in building support for the theory of a Big Bang and in undermining the Steady State model.
Tonight, I'd like to launch a three-part posting on the CMB. The remainder of the present piece will constitute Part I, focusing on the early theorizing about the CMB. In the coming weeks, Part II will focus on the accidental discovery of the CMB, and Part III on the more recent, high precision measurement of it.
According to Simon Singh's (2004) book, Big Bang, CMB theorizing goes back to Ralph Alpher and Robert Herman in 1948, with Alpher's mentor George Gamow also being associated. (The famous Alpher, Bethe, Gamow paper, with the name of Hans Bethe inserted primarily to make the authorship sound like the Greek letters alpha, beta, and gamma, dealt with a different issue, nucleosynthesis.)
What Alpher and Herman did was formulate ideas about the interactions of temperature, light, and states of matter (particularly one known as plasma) in the early universe. The following passages from Singh convey the main points of Alpher and Herman's theorizing:
They realised that as the universe expanded, its energy would become spread through a greater volume, so the universe and the plasma within it would steadily cool. The two young physicists deduced that there would be a critical moment when the temperature would become too cool for a plasma to exist, at which point the electrons would latch onto the nuclei and form stable, neutral atoms of hydrogen and helium. The transition from plasma to atoms happens at roughly 3,000 [degree Celsius] for hydrogen and helium, and the duo estimated that it would take 300,000 years or so for the universe to cool to this temperature. This event is generally known as recombination... (p. 330).
If the Big Bang model was correct, and if Alpher and Herman had got their physics right, then the light that was present at the moment of recombination should still be beaming its way around the universe today... In other words, the light that was released at the end of the plasma epoch should currently exist as a fossil. This light would be a legacy of the Big Bang (p. 332).
One further refinement involved accounting for the stretching of light waves in an expanding universe. "Alpher and Herman confidently predicted that the stretched Big Bang light should now have a wavelength... invisible to the human eye,... located in the so-called microwave region of the spectrum" (Singh, p. 333).
Hence the name Cosmic Microwave Background.
Brian Greene, in his 2004 book The Fabric of the Cosmos, presents an even more vivid account of how one can imagine the CMB:
If your eyes could see light whose wavelength is much longer than that of orange or red, you would not only be able to see the interior of your microwave oven burst into activity when you push the start button, but you would also see a faint and nearly uniform glow spread throughout what the rest of us perceive as a dark night sky (p. 226).
Given the importance of the CMB prediction for testing the theory of a Big Bang, and what seems like an intrinsically interesting idea in its own right, one would think that Alpher and Herman's suggestion would have sparked immediate attempts to detect the CMB. But, as Singh notes, "Unfortunately, Alpher and Herman were completely ignored. Nobody made any serious effort to search for their proposed CMB radiation" (p. 333).
How the CMB was ultimately discovered will be the topic of my next entry...
Tonight, I'd like to launch a three-part posting on the CMB. The remainder of the present piece will constitute Part I, focusing on the early theorizing about the CMB. In the coming weeks, Part II will focus on the accidental discovery of the CMB, and Part III on the more recent, high precision measurement of it.
According to Simon Singh's (2004) book, Big Bang, CMB theorizing goes back to Ralph Alpher and Robert Herman in 1948, with Alpher's mentor George Gamow also being associated. (The famous Alpher, Bethe, Gamow paper, with the name of Hans Bethe inserted primarily to make the authorship sound like the Greek letters alpha, beta, and gamma, dealt with a different issue, nucleosynthesis.)
What Alpher and Herman did was formulate ideas about the interactions of temperature, light, and states of matter (particularly one known as plasma) in the early universe. The following passages from Singh convey the main points of Alpher and Herman's theorizing:
They realised that as the universe expanded, its energy would become spread through a greater volume, so the universe and the plasma within it would steadily cool. The two young physicists deduced that there would be a critical moment when the temperature would become too cool for a plasma to exist, at which point the electrons would latch onto the nuclei and form stable, neutral atoms of hydrogen and helium. The transition from plasma to atoms happens at roughly 3,000 [degree Celsius] for hydrogen and helium, and the duo estimated that it would take 300,000 years or so for the universe to cool to this temperature. This event is generally known as recombination... (p. 330).
If the Big Bang model was correct, and if Alpher and Herman had got their physics right, then the light that was present at the moment of recombination should still be beaming its way around the universe today... In other words, the light that was released at the end of the plasma epoch should currently exist as a fossil. This light would be a legacy of the Big Bang (p. 332).
One further refinement involved accounting for the stretching of light waves in an expanding universe. "Alpher and Herman confidently predicted that the stretched Big Bang light should now have a wavelength... invisible to the human eye,... located in the so-called microwave region of the spectrum" (Singh, p. 333).
Hence the name Cosmic Microwave Background.
Brian Greene, in his 2004 book The Fabric of the Cosmos, presents an even more vivid account of how one can imagine the CMB:
If your eyes could see light whose wavelength is much longer than that of orange or red, you would not only be able to see the interior of your microwave oven burst into activity when you push the start button, but you would also see a faint and nearly uniform glow spread throughout what the rest of us perceive as a dark night sky (p. 226).
Given the importance of the CMB prediction for testing the theory of a Big Bang, and what seems like an intrinsically interesting idea in its own right, one would think that Alpher and Herman's suggestion would have sparked immediate attempts to detect the CMB. But, as Singh notes, "Unfortunately, Alpher and Herman were completely ignored. Nobody made any serious effort to search for their proposed CMB radiation" (p. 333).
How the CMB was ultimately discovered will be the topic of my next entry...
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)