Friday, August 25, 2006

"Demotion" of Pluto as a Planet

As occasionally happens, a science-related development is one of the leading stories in the news, at the moment. I'm referring, of course, to the "demotion" of Pluto from the rank of planet.

What happened is that the International Astronomical Union (IAU) adopted a new definition of what constitutes a planet, which Pluto no longer meets. According to the Wikipedia summary of this matter, the following definition was adopted:

...A planet is a celestial body that (a) is in orbit around the Sun, (b) has sufficient mass for its self-gravity to overcome rigid body forces so that it assumes a hydrostatic equilibrium (nearly round) shape, and (c) has cleared the neighbourhood around its orbit.

As seen in this list of objects in the solar system ranked by mass, Pluto is pretty far down.

The references to mass and gravity, of course, implicate Newtonian physics (many universities have a "Department of Physics and Astronomy," thus illustrating the interconnectedness of the two disciplines). As conveyed on the Wikipedia's gravity page:

Newton’s law of gravitation states that: every particle in the universe attracts every other particle with a force that is directly proportional to the product of their masses and inversely proportional to the square of the distance between them.

Further:

Every planetary body, including the Earth, is surrounded by its own gravitational field, which exerts an attractive force on any object that comes under its influence. This field is proportional to the body's mass and varies inversely with the square of distance from the body.

A couple of areas warrant further discussion, in my view. First, I had never heard of the term "self-gravity" until seeing it in the new definition of planet (above). Professor Dave Hanes of Queen's University of Canada has a website that addresses several aspects of gravity. Most relevant to the aforementioned definition is a section of his site entitled "Self-Gravity Can Determine Form," excerpts of which follow:

So far my discussion of scales and function has focussed on things like ants and elephants, which are affected by the gravity of some nearby immense object like the Earth... Moreover, the gravitational force of nearby human-scale objects, even fairly large ones, can safely be ignored. For instance, when you walk past a city bus, you don't have to worry about its gravitational attraction pulling you off the sidewalk and into the road...

In astronomy, by contrast, we are dealing with very large bodies, like planets and stars. They are dominated by self-gravity, by which I mean that the shape and proportions of any object this big are determined by the way in which the various parts of it feel and respond to the gravitational forces exerted by its own other parts. This consideration explains, among other things, why the Earth and all sufficiently large objects must be spherical (or nearly so).

Why should this be? Why couldn't the Earth take on any shape into which we might choose to sculpt it? After all, you are used to the idea that the rocks of the Earth are very rigid and inflexible, at least the ones immediately beneath our feet. Couldn't you mould the Earth into any shape you desired, given sufficiently powerful earth-movers and other equipment?

The answer is no. Suppose, for instance, you tried to use enormous bulldozers to raise mountains to a height of even just a few tens of kilometers. You would not succeed: the sheer weight of material pressing down on the lower layers would overwhelm the structural strength provided by the rocks, and they would slump and flow sideways. The new-built mountain would collapse...

From the known strengths of materials, in fact, you can calculate just about how big a mountain could ever be, here on the Earth: it works out to be roughly the size of Mount Everest. On Mars, which is a smaller planet, the gravity is less, and mountains can be about three times larger. Remarkably, this was known before any spacecraft ever visited Mars, and Carl Sagan, an astronomer at Cornell, predicted that we might find such a huge mountain on Mars - which we did! It is called Olympus Mons (Mount Olympus); it is the largest mountain in the Solar System.

In astronomy, therefore, any body of sufficiently large size, bigger than a few hundred kilometers in diameter, MUST be spherical (although to be absolutely correct I should point out that if it is spinning very rapidly, it can be somewhat flattened out, although still possessing a very smooth and regular surface). The important thing to remember is that the apparently very irregular surface of the Earth, with features like hills, mountains, and valleys, is quite misleading: these features are big only compared to us. Relative to the size of the Earth itself, these features are tiny and easily understood in terms of the limited strengths of rocks and minerals, as I have noted. Bigger features simply could not survive.

By the way, if you were to build a scale model of the Earth about a meter in diameter, like a very large beach ball, even the very highest mountains on it would be represented by little bumps about half a millimeter in height, scarcely detectable to the touch. The surface of the Earth is actually remarkably smooth.


Another part of the new definition of planet is that the entity must "clear the neighborhood." The Wikipedia's page on that subject states the following:

The phrase refers to an orbiting body (a planet or protoplanet) "sweeping out" its orbital region over time, by gravitationally interacting with smaller bodies nearby. Over many orbital cycles, a large body will tend to cause small bodies either to accrete with it, or to be disturbed to another orbit. As a consequence it does not then share its orbital region with other bodies of significant size, except for its own satellites, or those governed by its own gravitational influence.

The bottom line:

Pluto has not cleared the neighborhood of its orbit (vis-à-vis Neptune and Kuiper Belt Objects such as the Plutinos)...

Indeed, failure to clear the neighborhood appears to be Pluto's primary deficiency. According to the following BBC article:

Charon was discovered in 1978... Until now, it has been regarded as a moon of Pluto. But both Pluto and Charon have enough mass to be spherical - both bodies independently satisfy the proposed definition of a planet.

I highly recommend this BBC document, written in Q & A format, for readers who want to investigate the Pluto story in greater detail.

Saturday, August 19, 2006

Brian Greene and Lee Smolin on National Public Radio

Good timing! With my first substantial posting on string theory having just recently been posted (immediately below), it turned out to have been just in time for yesterday's National Public Radio "Science Friday" show, which featured a discussion of string theory with Brian Greene and Lee Smolin. You can now listen to the archived audio here.

Tuesday, August 15, 2006

String Theory Part I

In the year and a half, roughly, that I've been operating this blog, I haven't yet talked about string theory. Actually, I can think of at least one instance where I've referred to string theory, only to say that we should ignore it at that point.

In one of my very first entries (March 18, 2005), I linked to this diagram of the components of matter at ever-decreasing scales: ordinary matter, molecules, atoms, and sub-atomic particles. I then noted that:

Actually, the figure depicts one additional set of entities down the smallness scale, called "strings;" string theory is very controversial, so for now we'll stop at sub-atomic particles.

In my March and April 2005 postings (see month-by-month archives on the right-hand side of the page, midway down) I talked about a variety of sub-atomic particles, both matter particles (e.g., electrons, quarks) and force-carrying particles (e.g., photons, gluons).

The basic idea of string theory, stated simply then, is that these particles themselves are made out of incredibly small strings, or as Brian Greene sometimes refers to them, "tiny filaments of energy" that behave like strings. As Greene elaborates on pp. 346-347 of his book, The Fabric of the Cosmos:

...the wealth of particle species simply reflects the different vibrational patterns that a string can execute. It's just like what happens with more familiar strings like those on a violin or cello. A cello string can vibrate in many different ways, and we hear each pattern as a different musical note... A [physics] string vibrating in one particular pattern might have the properties of an electron, while a string vibrating in a different pattern might have the properties of an up-quark...

OK, so I've now introduced string theory. Now seems like a good time to do so, with books, media articles (most recently in Time Magazine), and blogs bringing string theory to the general public with seemingly unprecedented volume and vigor.

Also, the current schedule calls for the Large Hadron Collider (LHC), the latest and most energetic experimental particle physics facility, to open in November 2007, a little over a year from now (although the full phase-in to the major experiments, never mind the results of them, will take at least several months beyond the opening of the collider).

I don't believe anyone expects direct evidence of strings to be found at the LHC, but some phenomena that bear more indirectly on string theory could be found.

For all these reasons, the focus of my postings over the next year will generally fall into three categories: additional key issues in string theory; related topics such as supersymmetry and extra dimensions; and the workings of particle accelerators and colliders.

Discussion of all of these issues in a single blog posting is impractical, so I'll have to "string you along."