Saturday, January 26, 2008

Scientific American: "The Future of Physics"

The February 2008 issue of Scientific American, now out on the newsstands, features a special series (with top billing on the cover) entitled "The Future of Physics." The series, consisting of three primary articles that together run for about 20 pages, focuses on the upcoming particle/high energy experiments that will take place at the Large Hadron Collider in the next year or so, and beyond. (I, myself, wrote an eight-part series on the LHC for this blog last year, spanning from the opening essay in May to the concluding piece in September; earlier postings can be accessed via the archives to this blog.)

The first article of the new Scientific American series ("The Discovery Machine") focuses on the engineering aspects of physically constructing the LHC. Two areas I found of interest were the detailed description of the detector systems and how they are designed to winnow down the incredible avalanche of data to the occurrences of greatest potential importance to scientists; and a summary of the malfunctions that have occurred in testing the LHC and have caused delays in the official opening of the facility.

The second article ("The Coming Revolutions in Particle Physics") focuses on the scientific aspects of what physicists expect (or at least hope) to find at the LHC. One historical development discussed in the article, which I don't recall ever learning about before, is how some of the key ideas of electroweak symmetry breaking (i.e., how the electromagnetic and weak forces diverged after being unified) were inspired by superconductivity research. This article is accompanied by nice colorful charts providing overviews of the Standard Model of particle physics, the "hierarchy problem," and "Five Goals for the LHC."

Finally, the third article ("Building the Next-Generation Collider") discusses the proposed successor to the LHC, the International Linear Collider (a website set up to provide basic information on the proposed ILC is available here). This article focuses both on the engineering of building the ILC and how it would complement the LHC scientifically.

The ILC is just a hypothetical entity at this point. What country it would be built in, and how its estimated cost of many billion dollars would be funded, remain to be seen. Also, the richness of scientific yield from the LHC (or relative lack thereof) may affect the prospects for the ILC. In any case, the article estimates that research at the ILC -- if it ever gets underway -- would not take place until sometime in the decade of the 2020's.

Saturday, January 19, 2008

Big Bang/Inflationary Cosmology Part II

As the second essay in my series on inflationary cosmology, I would like to discuss the phenomenon of redshifts in the visible spectrum of astronomical bodies, which has allowed scientists to infer that such bodies are moving away from us.

This Wikipedia page offers an illustrative -- and colorful -- diagram of how "Absorption lines in the optical spectrum of a supercluster of distant galaxies" is redshifted away from the Sun. The same Wikipedia page notes that, among other mechanisms:

Another cause of redshift is the expansion of the universe, which explains the observation that the redshifts of distant galaxies, quasars, and intergalactic gas clouds increase in proportion to their distance from the earth. This mechanism is a key feature of the Big Bang model of physical cosmology.

Another webpage, this time from the Exploratorium, discusses the Doppler Effect and presents an analogy between the sound of a police car's siren and light waves (along with some nice graphics):

Like sound, light is a wave that can be described in terms of its frequency, the number of wave peaks that pass by each second. Just like a cosmic police car, a star zooming toward you has its light waves squeezed together. You see these light waves as having a higher frequency than normal. Since blue is at the high-frequency end of the visible spectrum, we say the light from an approaching star is shifted toward blue, or blueshifted.

Likewise, if a star is zooming away from you, any light it emits gets stretched. You see these stretched-out light waves as having a lower frequency. Since red is at the low-frequency end of the visible spectrum, we say that light from a receding star is shifted toward red, or redshifted.


A naive, layperson question that occurred to me is how we know the movement of galaxies and other objects away from us represents the expansion of the universe, rather than the movement of these objects into what was previously existing, empty space in the universe.

While not (apparently) addressing my exact question, Brian Greene's 2004 book, The Fabric of the Cosmos, explains the basis for why the universe must be expanding:

Just as the gravitational pull of the earth implies that a baseball popped high above the catcher must either be heading farther upward or must be heading downward but certainly cannot be staying put (except for the single moment when it reaches its highest point), [Alexander] Friedmann and [Georges] Lemaitre realized that the gravitational pull of the matter and radiation spread throughout the entire cosmos implies that the fabric of space must either be stretching or contracting, but that it could not be staying fixed in size (p. 230).

Tuesday, January 01, 2008

Big Bang/Inflationary Cosmology Part I -- Book Review: "The Day Without Yesterday"

Happy New Year! To get 2008 off to a bang, I will be kicking off a series on the big bang and the expanding universe (also known as "inflationary cosmology"). An excellent way to do so, in my view, is by reviewing John Farrell's 2005 book, The Day Without Yesterday: Lemaitre, Einstein, and the Birth of Modern Cosmology.

As noted in the title, the book is about Georges Lemaitre (1894-1966), a Belgian astrophysicist (Ph.D. from MIT) and priest. It is Lemaitre who, with some later modifications by others, laid the groundwork for the modern big bang theory of an expanding universe, at a time when there was widespread belief among scientists in a static universe.

A few weeks ago, I had seen an episode of the History Channel series, The Universe, which introduced me to Lemaitre for the first time. Shortly thereafter, I found The Day Without Yesterday in a bookstore, and it seemed to be a perfect way for me to expand my knowledge from what I had seen in the documentary.

With access to letters and photographs from the Lemaitre and Einstein archives, Farrell weaves, to my mind, the perfect blend of scientific exposition and personal story. The duality of Lemaitre's scientific and theological commitments is discussed somewhat, toward the end of the book, and the overwhelming sense is that he kept the two quite separate. At a little over 200 pages, the book is a quick read, easily capable of being finished in a few sittings.

As the book conveys, Lemaitre's ideas stemmed from his thoughtful responses to Einstein's general relativity and Willem de Sitter's initial elaborations on Einstein's theory. In fact, Farrell quotes one of Einstein's letters to Lemaitre, as follows (p. 169):

"I doubt that anybody has so carefully studied the cosmological implications of the theory of relativity as you have."

Further, as the book discusses, development of the big bang theory from roughly 1925-1950 went through at least three stages:

First, having learned of data from astronomical observations suggestive of receding objects, Lemaitre introduced the idea of an expanding universe. Writes Farrell:

It's important to note here that Lemaitre was not yet interested in discussing a temporal beginning of the cosmos in any sense of the term, as has often been inaccurately stated in many books about twentieth-century cosmology. His 1927 paper suggested an expansion of the universe beginning from an initial static Einstein state -- not a big bang, not an explosion of matter from nothing (p. 90).

As a second stage, quoting from Farrell (p. 91), Lemaitre's "further theory of a primeval atom, or initial cosmic origin, would come later, once he realized the physical deficiencies of beginning with Einstein's model."

Third, Lemaitre predicted that there would be a physical residue of the initial expansion of the universe, but his version consisted of a "cold" process of radioactive decay, involving cosmic rays. A later alternative by George Gamow and colleagues, involving a "hot explosion" and the cosmic microwave background as the residue, along with the eventual detection of the background, ended up providing major support for the big bang theory (Farrell, pp. 101-109, plus Chapter 7).

One other topic from Farrell's book that is worth noting is the argument about sociological factors playing a large role in what types of theories the scientific community would find acceptable at any given time (back in October 2005, I reviewed a book titled Constructing Quarks, which dealt with similar issues).

Focusing on Einstein's seeming obsession with preserving the idea of a static universe -- even going so far as to insert a "cosmological constant" into his equations to ensure such -- Farrell offers the following observation:

It's somewhat odd to see in retrospect how conservatism and hesitation manifest themselves in the history of science... Perhaps because of the general nature of this conservatism, it's unfair to ask why Einstein was content to plug the cosmological constant into his equations -- in reaction to their clear suggestion that the universe as a whole could not be static. Einstein was preceded by generation after generation of thinkers who believed the same thing (pp. 52-53).

As this series continues, future topics I plan to discuss include redshifts, Hoyle's steady-state theory, the cosmic microwave background, the cosmological constant, and Guth's inflationary cosmology.