Sunday, September 17, 2006

String Theory Part III

Today begins discussion of what many consider some of the flaws or weaknesses of string theory (or, as it is often called, superstring theory, due to its "merger" with supersymmetry, which I will discuss later).

The first concerns whether there are dimensions of space beyond the three we're used to thinking about: west-east (or left-right), north-south (or forward-backward), and up-down (or higher-lower). In The Fabric of the Cosmos, Brian Greene summarizes the situation as he sees it:

...at the top of the skeptics' list of superstring theory's shortcomings was a feature I've yet to introduce. Superstring theory does indeed provide a successful merger of gravity and quantum mechanics, one that is free of the mathematical inconsistencies that plagued all previous attempts. However, strange as it may sound, in the early years after its discovery, physicists found that the equations of superstring theory do not have these enviable properties if the universe has three spatial dimensions. Instead, the equations of superstring theory are mathematically consistent only if the universe has nine spatial dimensions, or, including the time dimension, they work only in a universe with ten spacetime dimensions! (p. 359)

Further refinements, as Greene also notes, now require 11 spacetime dimensions, seven more than have ever been seen (here's another article that discusses this issue).

Here's how Greene explains the need for the extra dimensions:

If a string can vibrate in a fourth spatial dimension, it can execute more vibrational patterns than it could in only three; if a string can vibrate in a fifth spatial dimension, it can execute more vibrational patterns than it could in only four; and so on... but with nine space dimensions [later found to be ten], the constraint on the number of vibrational patterns is satisfied perfectly (pp. 370-371).

Further, with the work of some creative physicists and mathematicians -- some of it going back roughly 85 years -- ideas for accommodating extra dimensions are readily available.

Under what is known as the Kaluza-Klein model, one can envision how a garden hose, fully elongated, would appear to represent one dimension. However, if one considers the circumference of the hose's width, that could be an extra dimension (I think it's fitting to use the example of a hose to present this "watered-down" explanation). This hose illustration can be seen at the following website, in the first diagram under Kaluza's picture.

A more complex figure, known as a Calabi-Yau manifold, has been proposed as being able to account possibly for six additional dimensions.

Within the past year or so, two major books by physicists have come out, specifically on the topic of extra dimensions. One, by Lawrence Krauss, is entitled Hiding in the Mirror, whereas the other, by Lisa Randall, is entitled Warped Passages. My interest level would warrant reading one of the two books and, based on this recommendation, I chose Krauss's. I found it reasonably interesting.

Saturday, September 09, 2006

String Theory Part II

Let's resume the discussion of string theory, which I introduced in my August 15, 2006 posting. String theory is considered very controversial. To understand why, it will be useful to review the arguments in its favor and in opposition. Today's posting will cover the former, with the latter to come later. Much of my discussion of string theory will come from the book The Fabric of the Cosmos by Brian Greene, a well-known proponent of strings, but someone who seems open to the possibility that the whole idea could be wrong.

To many, the most compelling argument on behalf of string theory is its potential to unify two heretofore incompatible major ideas in physics -- general relativity and quantum mechanics -- in the spirit of Einstein's quest for a "theory of everything." (The original question motivating the development of string theory did not involve such unification, however.)

A few excerpts from Greene summarize the current state of affairs.

Years of astronomical observations have shown that general relativity describes the macro world of stars, galaxies, and even the entire expanse of the cosmos with impressive accuracy; decades of experiments have confirmed that quantum mechanics does the same for the micro world of molecules, atoms, and subatomic particles (p. 336).

...the incompatibility between general relativity and quantum mechanics rears its head in a very specific way. If you use the combined equations of general relativity and quantum mechanics, they almost always yield one answer: infinity. And that's a problem. It's nonsense. Experimenters never measure an infinite amount of anything... (p. 335).

Since [general relativity and quantum mechanics] works wonders in its own domain, why worry about combining them?... For physicists, though, the existence of a realm in which the known laws of physics break down -- no matter how esoteric the realm might seem -- throws up red flags. If the known laws of physics break down under any circumstances, it is a clear signal that we have not reached the deepest possible understanding... (pp. 336-337).

Enter string theory, which at the conceptual stage, makes the two theories compatible. Greene provides a detailed explanation of why this is so, on pp. 348-350, having to do with strings' putting a limit on how small entities can get, thus "avoid[ing] the catastrophic clash between quantum mechanics and general relativity."

Also, because general relativity is a theory of gravity, string theory integrates gravity with the other forces (electromagnetic, strong, and weak), which are all quantum theories within the Standard Model of particle physics.

String theory appears to look good, thus far. Its difficulties will be discussed in future postings.

[For additional background material, I wrote about general relativity on June 4, 2005, and about quantum mechanics in a series of entries from July 27-September 22, 2005. See the archives in the right-hand column of this page.]