Tuesday, December 19, 2023

Book Review: "The Pope of Physics"

The Pope of Physics is a 2016 biography of Enrico Fermi (1901-1954), written by Gino Segre and Bettina Hoerlin. Segre's uncle Emilio was a student of Fermi's in Rome, whereas Hoerlin's father knew Fermi from Los Alamos, New Mexico in the post-World War II years.

I began reading the book earlier this year, before I knew that the movie Oppenheimer was coming out. Both The Pope of Physics and Oppenheimer chronicle the United States' development of the atomic bomb through nuclear fission and its use against Japan in World War II, along with the associated ethical questions. There is a Fermi character who makes brief appearances in Oppenheimer, whereas The Pope prominently discusses the real-life Robert Oppenheimer. I would urge anyone with an interest in the subject matter to read The Pope, either before or after seeing Oppenheimer, to obtain a better understanding of the movie and the physics underlying the atomic bomb.

The Pope tells the life story of Fermi, growing up and establishing his career in Italy, then moving to the US when Mussolini began implementing policies in the 1930s against Jewish people (which included Fermi's wife). Fermi taught at Columbia University in New York City and then worked on the bomb project at the University of Chicago, before dying prematurely of cancer. 

The book details Fermi's exceptional abilities in many areas: "the only twentieth-century physics genius to be entirely self-taught" (p. 16), someone who "considered himself an experimentalist as well as a theorist" (p. 32), and "probably the only person with expertise in every aspect of the physics problems being faced in the [Los Alamos] laboratory" (p. 224).

Fermi's early work included his theories of beta-decay and the weak force. However, he and his colleagues also discovered nuclear fission -- the process behind the atomic bomb -- but did not realize it! Instead, Fermi and colleagues thought they had discovered a chemical element with 93 protons, surpassing uranium (92). In this regard, Fermi, like Albert Einstein with his general-relativity equations in an earlier era, showed that even the most brilliant scientists are not immune from major blunders.* 

Early efforts at understanding the nature of atoms and nuclei involved firing certain kinds of particles at other particles (see this article on Ernest Rutherford's legacy). Fermi's team, known as The Boys, had bombarded many different kinds of chemical elements -- from hydrogen to uranium -- with neutrons, finding particles they thought were the heavy elements. As Segre and Hoerlin explained, however, German chemist Ida Noddack was correct in suggesting that "the supposed transuranic might be the nucleus of an element that lay far down the periodic table, a fragment produced by the splitting of the uranium nucleus" (p. 106). That splitting was, of course, nuclear fission.

Two other researchers, Hahn and Strassmann, had found a seemingly anomalous result from collisions of neutrons and uranium: "a radioactive isotope of barium. Since the barium nucleus has only 56 protons while uranium has 92, this seemed impossible" (Segre & Hoerlin, p. 129). Hahn and Strassmann's colleagues Meitner and Frisch then came up with a stunning interpretation, namely that fission had occurred and the missing mass had been converted to energy via Einstein's E = mc-squared. As the book elaborates, Meitner "realized that the sum of the two fragments' masses was less than the uranium mass. A rapid estimate showed her that the difference in mass was roughly equal to the energy of motion needed" (p. 130).

Initial fission experiments produced only a ripple of energy on laboratory detectors. Producing enough energy for the kinds of bombs used in Japan required chain reactions. As Fermi envisioned as a possible reaction between neutrons and uranium, "if an initial fission were to produce two neutrons, those two would generate four neutrons by colliding with other uranium nuclei. From 2 to 4 to 8 to 16 to 32 to 64 to... It would be a chain reaction. And if each collision generated the amount of energy Frisch and Meitner had estimated a month earlier, the end product would be a mammoth source of power" (p. 144-145). Oppenheimer was among the fastest to realize that fission could eventually lead to an atomic bomb (p. 146).

Though Fermi lived a long time ago and may be best known for the bomb, his and his colleagues' contributions in other areas have made an indelible impact on modern life. As Segre and Hoerlin note, "... without understanding the Pauli Principle, quantum mechanics, and Fermi-Dirac statistics, the world would not have been able to produce semiconductors, transistors, computers, MRIs, lasers and so many of the other inventions that shape our life" (p. 55). 

---

*Fermi received the 1938 Nobel Prize in physics, with the award notice reading, "To Professor Enrico Fermi of Rome for his identification of new radioactive elements produced by neutron bombardment and his discovery, made in connection with this work, of nuclear reactions brought about by slow neutrons" (Segre & Hoerlin, p. 95). The book acknowledges that, "Some detractors say Fermi got the Nobel for a faulty discovery. But his years of productive research, particularly showing the world the power of slow neutrons, suggest otherwise. Nevertheless, he never quite forgave himself for his mistake about transuranics [elements heavier than uranium]" (p. 123).

Friday, January 20, 2023

Vox Explains Henrietta Leavitt's 1908 Discovery of How to Measure Distances to Stars and Galaxies

Vox provides a very clear explanation of Henrietta Leavitt's 1908 discovery that allows us to estimate the distance to stars and galaxies. 

The book Einstein's Greatest Mistake (which I previously reviewed here) also discusses Leavitt's contributions (pages 137-142). This section of the book explains why stars differ in their degree of pulsation: "We're used to our sun shining pretty evenly, at just about the same intensity day after day. But that's because the layers of fuel in the sun burn fairly evenly. In some very different stars, the burning is highly uneven" (pp. 138-139). The latter type of stars alternate between states of hot, bright, expansion and, after the expansion releases pressure, a dimmed and slimmed down appearance.

Tuesday, October 04, 2022

2022 Nobel Physics Prize to Quantum Entanglement Researchers

The 2022 Nobel Prize in physics has been awarded to three researchers for their work in quantum entanglement and its applications. This posting from Daily Kos features a compilation of links, explanations, video tutorials, and other material pertaining to the prize-winning research. I wrote a watered-down introduction to quantum entanglement back in 2005, which is available here.

Sunday, May 08, 2022

Physicist Alan Nathan on Baseball Podcast

My friend Alan Nathan, a retired professor of physics at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign and one of the leading experts on the physics of baseball, appeared on the Society for American Baseball Research's SABRcast several weeks ago. The archived audio is available here (you have to scroll down a bit when the new page comes up). Professor Nathan discusses both historical and current trends in the study of bats (and bat swings), baseballs (and their spin, flight, etc.), and baserunners.

Saturday, April 16, 2022

Book Review: "Einstein's Greatest Mistake"

David Bodanis begins his 2016 book Einstein's Greatest Mistake with a depiction of a once-great scientist who had become a forlorn figure in his later years. He was usually alone when he walked home after a day at the Institute for Advanced Study in Princeton, New Jersey, isolated intellectually and socially from other scientists, many of whom "no longer took his ideas seriously" (p. xii). How Einstein got to that place in his life is for Bodanis to explain. The author's account is plausible, in my view, and reveals interesting facets of Einstein's personality along the way.

There actually are two major scientific mistakes Einstein made in his scientific career, his response to the first likely affecting his response to the second. Among Einstein's many accomplishments -- including the five momentous discoveries of his annus mirabilis (miracle year) of 1905 -- his 1915 general-relativity conception of gravity arguably is his best-known scientific contribution (along with E = mc-squared). The offshoots of general relativity, according to Bodanis, include "explaining why black holes exist, showing how the universe began and how it will likely end, and even laying the foundation for revolutionary technologies such as GPS navigation" (p. xii-xiii).

But there seemed to be a problem with general relativity. Conventional wisdom among astronomers at the time was that the size of the universe was constant. Yet, Einstein's general-relativity equations allowed the possibility of the universe expanding or collapsing (see pp. 115-116). To align with notions of a static universe, therefore, Einstein introduced a new term -- known as the cosmological constant or lambda -- into his formulation. 

Unfortunately for Einstein, that was not the end of the story. As the book describes, in 1929 Edwin Hubble and his associate Milton Humason determined from observations of the movement of stars and galaxies that the universe was indeed expanding. Einstein's equations were right the first time and now lambda could be eliminated (see pp. 135-154). A valuable aspect of this part of the book is its reporting on the work of less well-known scientists whose work informed the debate, such as Father Georges Lemaitre (click here for my review of The Day Without Yesterday, about Lemaitre's work), Alexander Friedmann, and Henrietta Leavitt.

The general-relativity/universe-expansion debacle only seemed to harden Einstein's resolve to stick to his own theories no matter what. As Bodanis noted, "When [Einstein's] critics tried to bring in evidence against his later beliefs, he ignored them, confident that he would be vindicated again" (p. xiii). From this stance emanated Einstein's second major mistake.

As Bodanis describes, from the early 1910s through the early 1930s, the study of quantum mechanics (QM) at the microscopic level of matter developed alongside the study of relativity at the large level of stars and galaxies. QM had a number of odd features, such as probabilistic predictions that a particle might end up in one place 70% of the time and in another place 30%. Einstein objected vigorously to this proposition, leading to his famous statement about God not playing dice with the universe.

At first, Einstein engaged with the ideas of quantum mechanics -- in an attempt to discredit them. Particularly interesting, as the book recounts, were the Brussels conferences of 1927 and 1930. Each morning, as the elite coterie of physicists (including QM proponent Niels Bohr) gathered for breakfast, Einstein would issue a daily challenge to QM, proffering some kind of thought-experiment that seemed to undercut the logic of the theory. Bohr and like-minded colleagues would then spend large amounts of time, sometimes deep into the early-morning hours, trying to rebut Einstein. Ultimately, the pro-QM group successfully answered Einstein every time.

According to Bodanis, "Einstein never again attended such a meeting; never again attempted to refute Bohr or [Werner] Heisenberg in public debate. Nor, however, did he change his beliefs." (p. 204).

The rest of Einstein's career, until his death in 1955, was largely an intellectual waste, according to Bodanis. These years were filled with missed opportunities. Potential collaborations with other leading physicists either fell through or did not interest Einstein in the first place. Princeton faculty “worshipped Einstein and would have relished the chance to collaborate with him. Their studies ultimately helped lead to the creation of the transistors that today operate inside all our phones and electronic devices. But Einstein couldn’t bring himself to grapple with these strange consequences of the new quantum mechanics“ (p. 219)

Even when Bohr visited Princeton in 1939, gone were Einstein's spirited and detailed challenges to Bohr. As the book notes, Einstein avoided most opportunities to interact with Bohr and when the two were together, "Einstein would speak only in banalities" (p. 226).

For laypersons interested in a  non-technical exposition of Einstein's and his intellectual opponents' ideas -- along with the human drama of Einstein's career arc -- it would be a great mistake not to read this book!

Monday, February 07, 2022

Vox on Olympic Ski Jumping

Vox explains "Why ski jumpers hold their skis in a V," as opposed to the older style of keeping their skis parallel (link).

Thursday, October 07, 2021

Vox on 2021 Nobel Physics Prize to Climate-Change Researchers

Vox explains the climate-change modeling -- "account[ing] for the roiling randomness present in everything from materials to the motion of the atmosphere, and still mak[ing] useful predictions" -- that earned three researchers this year's Nobel Prize in physics.

Friday, August 20, 2021

Physicist Samantha Schultz Helps Oakland A's Pitchers Optimize Their Delivery

The San Jose Mercury News reports on physicist Samantha Schultz's position as a pitching analyst with the Oakland A's Major League Baseball team (link). The following paragraphs from the article describe the kinds of things she does with A's pitchers:

“One of my biggest strengths is to take this complicated stuff and put it into baseball language,” Schultz said. “It’s not like I’m on the mound doing equations with the pitchers.” 

 Schultz understands a breaking ball can be more effective when its gyro spin — or bullet spin — is high. Or a two-seam fastball can be more effective when it creates turbulent pockets of air. She’ll suggest a pitcher adjust his grip or throw harder at a different angle to create the wanted movement. 

 “If I say, ‘OK, we need to get more gyro spin on this ball,’ what I might say to a pitcher is to roll it off your middle finger,” Schultz said.

(Thanks to the Society for American Baseball Research [SABR], from whose weekly newsletter I learned of this article.)

Saturday, October 17, 2020

Physics of Football's Spiral Forward Pass

For fans of American football, the New York Times has an article (link) on three physicists' explanation of why the axis of a spiral forward pass changes -- from nose pointing up at release to nose pointing down as the receiver catches the ball -- even though the laws of physics say the axis should remain the same.

Wednesday, November 20, 2019

Physics of Bowling: The Near Impossibility of a Spare on the 7-10 Split

The 7-10 split is when the only pins standing after a bowler's first shot of a frame are the leftmost and rightmost pins in the back row. It's obviously extremely difficult to knock out both pins on one's second shot, but until I saw this video from Wired, I didn't know how difficult. Professional bowlers, in fact, topple both pins for a spare less than 1 percent of the time! And the only reason a 7-10 spare is possible at all is the chance of a ricochet of the ball or a pin off the rubber doggie-flap-door-like curtain behind the pins, back into the other pin. Without the curtain, there would never be a successful conversion of the 7-10 spare. I highly recommend the above-linked video, which includes interviews with a pro bowler and an engineer, diagrams of a bowling lane and pins, and even a bowling robot!

Saturday, September 07, 2019

New York Times Piece on Quantum Mechanics

Sean Carroll has a piece in the New York Times, arguing that physicists have largely lost interest in understanding the foundational principles of quantum mechanics. The article provides a clear overview of what Carroll considers the two outstanding issues remaining to be understood.

Monday, June 03, 2019

Murray Gell-Mann (1929-2019)

To mark the passing of Murray Gell-Mann, who died 10 days ago at age 89, I offer a link to this 2000 article from The Atlantic on the often-difficult working relationship between Gell-Mann and his CalTech colleague Richard Feynman. The article doesn't always portray Gell-Mann in a favorable light, but describes his brilliance and, in my view, brings him to life so that readers will feel like they knew him.

Friday, April 26, 2019

Book Review: "The Cosmic Cocktail"

If you were to leave the book The Cosmic Cocktail on your coffee table, any guests would likely think it pertained to bartending. However, this book by University of Michigan professor Katherine Freese, actually details the quest to learn what material comprises dark matter.

Freese's preferred candidate for dark matter is the Weakly Interacting Massive Particle or WIMP. Writes Freese: "A major reason that WIMPs are taken so seriously as dark matter candidates is a feature known as the WIMP miracle. Because these particles undergo only weak interactions (in addition to feeling gravity), they miraculously turn out to have the right abundance today to solve the dark matter problem" (p. 104).

Freese reviews several projects that have tried to detect WIMPS, discussing evidence consistent and inconsistent with their appearance. As of 2014 (the book's publication year), Freese's conclusion was that, "Despite the uncertainties, theorists have become tremendously excited by all the recent hints of detection and are trying to reconcile the apparent discrepancies among the data" (p. 181). However, a December 2018 update from Sophia Chen in Wired magazine reports that only the DAMA experiment in Italy (discussed extensively by Freese) has produced "compelling evidence" of dark-matter WIMPS. Chen conveys, further, that some researchers are developing "WIMP fatigue."

Whereas facilities such as the Large Hadron Collider, which are built to produce new particles from proton collisions, get a lot of attention, there are other ways to approach the problem. Freese discusses, among other methods, how "dark matter particles from the Galaxy might interact with atomic nuclei in direct detection experiments located in underground laboratories beneath mountains or in abandoned mines" (p. 124). The process of getting an underground facility going can take 15 years or so (summarized on pp. 141-142).

Finally, Freese mixes in a healthy dose of personal stories, describing colorful and illustrious physicists (some of whom she studied under or worked with), graduate-school experiences, projects she's worked on, and conferences she's attended. Included in the latter is her (and other physicists') favorite spot for margaritas by the coast in Los Angeles! I would recommend the book for anyone with a particular interest in dark matter.

Thursday, April 11, 2019

The Technology Behind the Black-Hole Image

Five-Thirty-Eight explains the data collection and processing technology behind the just-released "glowing-doughnut" image of a black hole. As the article notes, the black hole was not directly photographed. Rather, "The telescopes collected high-frequency radio waves from space, and four independent teams of scientists used algorithms to convert the radio signals into visual images." The article also points out how the technology for the black hole imaging shares properties with MRI's in medicine and even self-driving cars.

Tuesday, April 09, 2019

Physics Data on Baseball Home Runs

The Twitter feed MLB Barrel Alert provides a lot of data on how well the batter has gotten the barrel of the bat on the ball for each home run hit in the major leagues. The tweets provide, in visual form, home-run balls' launch angle, exit velocity, peak height, final distance, and time in the air. The pitch's velocity and type of pitch (e.g., fastball, slider) are also given. For reasons unknown to me, some of the graphics are from a sky-view perspective, whereas others are from field-level. If you enjoy baseball and physics, this feed is absolutely a home run!

Friday, July 13, 2018

Book Review: "We Have No Idea"

Jorge Cham is the creator of PHD Comics and himself a Ph.D. holder from Stanford. Daniel Whiteson is professor of physics and astronomy at the University of California, Irvine. Put the two together and the result is the book We Have No Idea: A Guide to the Unknown Universe. Part comic book, part physics and astronomy text, and part compendium of hit-or-miss jokes, No Idea reviews unanswered questions in physics and astronomy and discusses possible solutions.

The first few chapters are about dark matter and dark energy. The next chapters cover the Standard Model of particle physics and "the mysteries of mass." The topic I found most interesting at this point was that of binding energy and its effect on mass. As the authors note, "...if you were to add the masses of three quarks... and compare that to the mass of those same three quarks bound together in a proton or neutron*... you would see a very big difference in mass. The masses of the individual quarks only account for about 1 percent of the mass of the proton or neutron. The rest is in the energy that's keeping those quarks together" (p. 63).

Greater mass of an object is associated with greater inertia (an object's"tendency to resist changes in its state of motion"). However,  as Cham and Whiteson explain, "Even though we can measure it, we don't really know what inertia is or why it's tied to both the mass of the particles and the energy that binds the particles together" (p. 64). This is but one example of how the authors set up an interesting physical phenomenon and then disclose that physicists and astronomers "have no idea" how or why the phenomenon works.

Other poorly understood phenomena discussed in the book include: why gravity is so different from all the other forces; what is the nature of space; what is time; and whether extra dimensions exist. (How particle colliders could lead to the inference of extra dimensions is another fascinating example from the book.)

By fortuitous coincidence, a new discovery reported in yesterday's New York Times may help answer one of the questions raised in the book: "Who is shooting superfast particles at the earth?" (p. 185). More technically, Cham and Whiteson are referring to cosmic rays and they claim that, "We don't know where they are coming from exactly, or why there are so many of them. And we don't know what process in nature could possibly be making such energetic ammunition" (pp. 185-186).

The discovery reported in the Times involves the "Ice Cube" detector in the South Pole being hit by a neutrino that could be traced to its source: TXS 0506+056, "a type of quasar known as a blazar, in which our line of sight from Earth is along the jet — right down the gun barrel." As noted in the Times article, "Astronomers said the discovery could provide a long sought clue to one of the enduring mysteries of physics and the cosmos. Where does the rain of high-energy particles from space known as cosmic rays come from?"

As can be seen, there are many topics in No Idea that I enjoyed. However, at 340 pages, the book is pretty long and probably could have been condensed to a shorter length. The cartoons and jokes may grow on a reader or become increasingly irritating. Will you enjoy this book? I have no idea!

---
*A proton consists of two up quarks and one down quark, whereas a neutron consists of two downs and an up.

Friday, May 11, 2018

What Makes Water Slippery?

This new article explain's water's slipperiness in terms of density, chemical-bonding, and friction. There's even a theory that there are two kinds of water! The writer quotes James Kakalios, whose book on quantum mechanics and technology I previously reviewed here.

Friday, March 02, 2018

Possible New Clues on Dark Matter

Two recent Nature articles offer possible progress in the quest to characterize dark matter. A Science Daily article quotes one of the authors, Tel Aviv University professor Rennan Barkana, to the effect that "the discovery offers the first direct proof that dark matter exists and that it is composed of low-mass particles."

Massive particles -- the weakly interacting variety being known as WIMPs and the strongly interacting version as SIMPs -- were long considered leading contenders to comprise dark matter. According to another article, WIMPs were pegged at being "about 100 times heavier than the proton." However, Barkana claims the new research puts the putative dark-matter particle at around "several" proton masses.

Saturday, January 27, 2018

Frustration for New Theories

Via Peter Woit/Not Even Wrong, the Economist has an article on how elaborate experiments designed to test unified theories are not providing support for them.

Wednesday, October 04, 2017

2017 Nobel Prize for Detection of Gravitational Waves

This year's Nobel Prize in Physics has been awarded to a trio of scientists for their work on the detection of gravitational waves. The official award announcement is available here, whereas some background information on the discovery can be found in this prior posting.