In addition to the Higgs boson (discussed in the previous entry, below), another type of particle physicists are hoping to find are so-called supersymmetric "superpartners" of the particle of the Standard Model.
To review the Standard Model, we have fermions (matter particles such as quarks, electrons, and neutrinos, which all share the property of half-unit spin) and bosons (force-carrying particles such as photons, for the electromagnetic force, and gluons, for the strong nuclear force, which all have full-unit spins).
As depicted on this page by physics instructor Bram Boroson, supersymmetry involves each standard fermion having a supersymmetric boson partner, and each standard boson having a supersymmetric fermion partner.
For the boson superpartner of a fermion, the letter "s" is placed at the beginning of the fermion's name, thus creating terms such as squark and selectron.
For the fermion superpartner of a boson, the suffix "-ino" is added to the bosonic name, yielding terms such as photino and gluino.
Boroson also raises a very important issue. From the perspective of why physicists might support supersymmetry, he notes that whereas it "doubl[es] the number of kinds of particles. There's got to be some kind of payoff, where this makes the theory simpler in the long run!"
Various introductions to supersymmetry are available. These include online sources such as Boroson's and this web document by Michal Szleper. Dan Hooper's (2006) book Dark Cosmos (which I will review in an upcoming posting) and Gordon Kane's (2000) book Supersymmetry (particularly the section entitled "Some Mysteries Supersymmetry Would Solve", pp. 55-62) also are useful.
Based on these sources, four potential benefits of supersymmetry stand out to me:
1. According to Grand Unification Theories (GUTs), the strong nuclear, weak nuclear, and electromagnetic forces should exhibit the same strength at a given energy level. As shown in Figure 7 of this report by Swagato Banerjee, such convergence does not occur within the Standard Model, but is projected to occur within supersymmetry.
2. Certain types of supersymmetric particles (or even combinations thereof) are possible candidates for something known as dark matter. This topic is discussed extensively in the aforementioned book by Hooper, in the chapter entitled "A Grand Symmetry."
3. According to Hooper, early string theories had a problem with tachyons (something that is "defined as a particle that travels faster than the speed of light," but also can be viewed "in some other frame of reference [as] moving backward in time" (p. 123).
Hooper goes on to note, however, that the first superstring revolution came up with a way to overcome the tachyon problem: "Namely, it was found that if supersymmetry was included in a string theory, the tachyons present in the theory would naturally disappear" (p. 124). The term superstring theory thus derives from this contribution of supersymmetry.
4. Supersymmetry also appears to keep the Higgs boson to a reasonable mass. A May 15, 2007 NY Times article on the Large Hadron Collider states that: “These superpartners cancel out all the quantum effects that make the Higgs mass skyrocket. “Supersymmetry is the only known way to manage this,” Dr. [Joe] Lykken said.”
Book authors Kane and Hooper each discuss detection of supersymmetric superpartners at the particle colliders. Kane writes that:
The superpartners that weigh the least are the ones most likely to be produced first, because it takes less energy to produce them... We don't know for sure which are the lightest ones, but most approaches suggest they might be the photino, Wino, Zino, and higgsinos (p. 157).
Adds Hooper:
Assuming that supersymmetry exists in nature, there should be a slew of new particles with masses between roughly a few tens and a few thousands of giga-electron volts -- perfectly suited for discovery at the LHC (p. 224).
Not all researchers find the idea of supersymmetry convincing. One such skeptic is Lee Smolin, author of the 2006 book The Trouble with Physics. Says Smolin, "My own guess, for what it's worth, is that (at least in the form so far studied) supersymmetry will not explain the observations at the LHC" (p. 78).
Further detail on Smolin's views is available in my review of his book.
Sunday, August 26, 2007
Sunday, August 12, 2007
Large Hadron Collider Part VI
Having completed the first part of my series on the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) -- pertaining to the workings of particle colliders -- it's time to move on to the second part, dealing with new particles (or types of particles) physicists will be looking out for.
The first priority would appear to be discovery of something called a Higgs boson. A New York Times article on the LHC from May 15, 2007 notes that: “The new collider was specifically designed to hunt for the Higgs particle, which is key both to the Standard Model and to any greater theory that would supersede it.”
Tonight's entry will first detail what a field of Higgs particles is hypothesized to embody, drawing from Brian Greene's (2004) book The Fabric of the Cosmos. How a Higgs boson is likely to be detected -- which was already touched upon in my previous, July 14, 2007, entry on particle detection in connection with an online interactive activity called “The Hunt for Higgs” -- will next be addressed briefly. Finally, the implications of various potential findings at LHC regarding the Higgs will be addressed.
Envisioning what a Higgs field is
What I grasped about Higgs fields from Greene's book is that two key areas of theoretical interest they address are: differential masses of different types of particles; and unification of different forces of nature.
Higgs fields create barriers to the movement of other kinds of particles, with different types of particles encountering different degrees of resistance. The more resistance a type of particle encounters, the more mass it is said to have. Higgs fields have been analogized to molasses or a bunch of paparazzi photographers. As Greene explains:
If we liken a particle's mass to a person's fame, then the Higgs ocean is like the paparazzi: those who are unknown pass through the swarming photographers with ease, but famous politicians and movie stars have to push much harder to reach their destination (p. 263).
Greene also notes that:
Photons pass completely unhindered through the Higgs ocean and so have no mass at all. If, to the contrary, a particle interacts significantly with the Higgs ocean, it will have a higher mass. The heaviest quark (it's called the top quark), with a mass that's about 350,000 times an electron's, interacts 350,000 times more strongly with the Higgs ocean than does an electron; it has greater difficulty accelerating through the Higgs ocean, and that's why it has a greater mass (p. 263).
In terms of unifying the different forces, Greene discusses how photons ("messenger particles" of the electromagnetic force) and W and Z particles (particles of the weak nuclear force) were indistinguishable at one point (known as "electroweak unification"), but are now considered to be different, due to the influence of the Higgs field.
Glashow, Salam, and Weinberg:
...realized that before the Higgs ocean formed, not only did all the force particles have identical masses -- zero -- but the photons and W and Z particles were identical in essentially every other way as well... At high enough temperatures, therefore, temperatures that would vaporize today's Higgs-filled vacuum, there is no distinction between the weak nuclear force and the electromagnetic force... The symmetry between the electromagnetic and weak forces is not apparent today because as the universe cooled, the Higgs ocean formed, and -- this is vital -- photons and W and Z particles interact with the condensed Higgs field differently. Photons zip through the Higgs ocean... and therefore remain massless. W and Z particles... have to slog their way through, acquiring masses that are 86 and 97 times that of a proton, respectively (excerpts from pp. 264-265).
A common term used to describe this phenomenon is "symmetry breaking."
Detecting the Higgs
The Higgs boson is posited to decay into other particles, thus forcing scientists to look for a "signature" indicative of the Higgs. This Physics World article (especially the section entitled, "Getting to know the Higgs") goes into further detail, such as in the following excerpt:
The Higgs signature depends on its mass. A relatively light Higgs with a mass of about 120 GeV will decay into pairs of B-mesons, tau leptons or photons, which will be easy to produce but hard to detect among the background of other processes and particles. If the Higgs is heavy, about 160 GeV, it will decay to pairs of W or Z bosons. These will be harder to produce, says [CERN's Jos] Engelen, but easier to spot. If there is no Higgs mechanism, the LHC will see scattering events between pairs of W bosons that would otherwise be "absorbed" by the standard Higgs mechanism.
Implications of possible Higgs-related findings
The March 23, 2007 issue of Science ran a spread of articles on the LHC, including one entitled "Physicists' Nightmare Scenario: The Higgs and Nothing Else." Probably the most succinct summary of the situation is revealed in the following quote:
Discovering the Higgs would complete the standard model. But finding only the Higgs would give physicists little to go on in their quest to answer deeper questions, such as whether the four forces of nature are somehow different aspects of the same thing... (pp. 1657-1658).
Were the LHC to find additional types of new particles, such as supersymmetric superpartners, or evidence of extra dimensions, for example, these would provide strong stimuli for further theorizing and discovery. Or, as the Science article notes:
If, on the other hand, the LHC sees no new particles at all, then the very rules of quantum mechanics and even Einstein's special theory of relativity must be wrong... (p. 1657).
For background on the Standard Model of particle physics, which the Higgs boson would round out, see this review I wrote of a book on the topic.
The first priority would appear to be discovery of something called a Higgs boson. A New York Times article on the LHC from May 15, 2007 notes that: “The new collider was specifically designed to hunt for the Higgs particle, which is key both to the Standard Model and to any greater theory that would supersede it.”
Tonight's entry will first detail what a field of Higgs particles is hypothesized to embody, drawing from Brian Greene's (2004) book The Fabric of the Cosmos. How a Higgs boson is likely to be detected -- which was already touched upon in my previous, July 14, 2007, entry on particle detection in connection with an online interactive activity called “The Hunt for Higgs” -- will next be addressed briefly. Finally, the implications of various potential findings at LHC regarding the Higgs will be addressed.
Envisioning what a Higgs field is
What I grasped about Higgs fields from Greene's book is that two key areas of theoretical interest they address are: differential masses of different types of particles; and unification of different forces of nature.
Higgs fields create barriers to the movement of other kinds of particles, with different types of particles encountering different degrees of resistance. The more resistance a type of particle encounters, the more mass it is said to have. Higgs fields have been analogized to molasses or a bunch of paparazzi photographers. As Greene explains:
If we liken a particle's mass to a person's fame, then the Higgs ocean is like the paparazzi: those who are unknown pass through the swarming photographers with ease, but famous politicians and movie stars have to push much harder to reach their destination (p. 263).
Greene also notes that:
Photons pass completely unhindered through the Higgs ocean and so have no mass at all. If, to the contrary, a particle interacts significantly with the Higgs ocean, it will have a higher mass. The heaviest quark (it's called the top quark), with a mass that's about 350,000 times an electron's, interacts 350,000 times more strongly with the Higgs ocean than does an electron; it has greater difficulty accelerating through the Higgs ocean, and that's why it has a greater mass (p. 263).
In terms of unifying the different forces, Greene discusses how photons ("messenger particles" of the electromagnetic force) and W and Z particles (particles of the weak nuclear force) were indistinguishable at one point (known as "electroweak unification"), but are now considered to be different, due to the influence of the Higgs field.
Glashow, Salam, and Weinberg:
...realized that before the Higgs ocean formed, not only did all the force particles have identical masses -- zero -- but the photons and W and Z particles were identical in essentially every other way as well... At high enough temperatures, therefore, temperatures that would vaporize today's Higgs-filled vacuum, there is no distinction between the weak nuclear force and the electromagnetic force... The symmetry between the electromagnetic and weak forces is not apparent today because as the universe cooled, the Higgs ocean formed, and -- this is vital -- photons and W and Z particles interact with the condensed Higgs field differently. Photons zip through the Higgs ocean... and therefore remain massless. W and Z particles... have to slog their way through, acquiring masses that are 86 and 97 times that of a proton, respectively (excerpts from pp. 264-265).
A common term used to describe this phenomenon is "symmetry breaking."
Detecting the Higgs
The Higgs boson is posited to decay into other particles, thus forcing scientists to look for a "signature" indicative of the Higgs. This Physics World article (especially the section entitled, "Getting to know the Higgs") goes into further detail, such as in the following excerpt:
The Higgs signature depends on its mass. A relatively light Higgs with a mass of about 120 GeV will decay into pairs of B-mesons, tau leptons or photons, which will be easy to produce but hard to detect among the background of other processes and particles. If the Higgs is heavy, about 160 GeV, it will decay to pairs of W or Z bosons. These will be harder to produce, says [CERN's Jos] Engelen, but easier to spot. If there is no Higgs mechanism, the LHC will see scattering events between pairs of W bosons that would otherwise be "absorbed" by the standard Higgs mechanism.
Implications of possible Higgs-related findings
The March 23, 2007 issue of Science ran a spread of articles on the LHC, including one entitled "Physicists' Nightmare Scenario: The Higgs and Nothing Else." Probably the most succinct summary of the situation is revealed in the following quote:
Discovering the Higgs would complete the standard model. But finding only the Higgs would give physicists little to go on in their quest to answer deeper questions, such as whether the four forces of nature are somehow different aspects of the same thing... (pp. 1657-1658).
Were the LHC to find additional types of new particles, such as supersymmetric superpartners, or evidence of extra dimensions, for example, these would provide strong stimuli for further theorizing and discovery. Or, as the Science article notes:
If, on the other hand, the LHC sees no new particles at all, then the very rules of quantum mechanics and even Einstein's special theory of relativity must be wrong... (p. 1657).
For background on the Standard Model of particle physics, which the Higgs boson would round out, see this review I wrote of a book on the topic.
Saturday, July 14, 2007
Large Hadron Collider Part V
To conclude the series of postings on technical aspects of the Large Hadron Collider, tonight we will look at how physicists interpret the information they receive in their particle detectors.
The Science Museum (UK) has an online interactive activity called "The Hunt for Higgs," which uses the example of a Higgs boson, a particle many physicists expect to be found at the LHC. In this demonstration activity, viewers click on the animated image of a detector and are taken through the steps that would be involved in identifying a potential Higgs particle.
An important concept illustrated by the demonstration exercise is that massive particles -- such as the Higgs -- can be very short-lived, and can thus be detected only by the presence in the detector of combinations of other, lighter particles. As the demonstration indicates, however, the combinations are only ones physicists think might be the "signatures" of a Higgs.
The discovery of the top quark -- the heaviest of the quarks -- in 1995 serves as an excellent case study in how the existence of a highly tranient particle was inferred. According to the linked Wikipedia page on the top quark, "The Standard Model predicts its lifetime to be roughly 1×10 [to the]−25 [power] seconds...", which would be .0000000000000000000000001 of a second.
This Fermilab information page on the discovery of the top quark and the process of confirming its existence, is very useful. In particular, the two following headings on the Fermlab page are worth clicking on, for further detail: "Is it a top quark? The signature of a top event" and "How do we know when we've found the top quark?"
For all of the hype and expense of the LHC, it is important to note that it is not expected to offer the ultimate in detector clarity. Texas A&M University physicist Teruki Kamon, whom I once saw give a talk at Texas Tech, has a slide in some of his PowerPoint presentations that uses a photographic analogy to demonstrate the upgrades in information (quantity and quality) that will be available as researchers move from Fermilab's Tevatron to the LHC to the proposed International Linear Collider (ILC).
If you go to this slide show and then scroll down to page 3, you'll see a sequence of three depictions of the same picture (a girl jumping in the air, with her shadow showing below). At the Tevatron, according to this analogy, only perhaps the bottom one-fifth of the picture would be observable, and with a very fuzzy appearance, at that. At the LHC, the full picture would be available, but would still be fuzzy. Only at the ILC would the picture be both fully available and sharp.
The next set of LHC-related postings will discuss new types of particles and other phenomena that scientists hope to find.
The Science Museum (UK) has an online interactive activity called "The Hunt for Higgs," which uses the example of a Higgs boson, a particle many physicists expect to be found at the LHC. In this demonstration activity, viewers click on the animated image of a detector and are taken through the steps that would be involved in identifying a potential Higgs particle.
An important concept illustrated by the demonstration exercise is that massive particles -- such as the Higgs -- can be very short-lived, and can thus be detected only by the presence in the detector of combinations of other, lighter particles. As the demonstration indicates, however, the combinations are only ones physicists think might be the "signatures" of a Higgs.
The discovery of the top quark -- the heaviest of the quarks -- in 1995 serves as an excellent case study in how the existence of a highly tranient particle was inferred. According to the linked Wikipedia page on the top quark, "The Standard Model predicts its lifetime to be roughly 1×10 [to the]−25 [power] seconds...", which would be .0000000000000000000000001 of a second.
This Fermilab information page on the discovery of the top quark and the process of confirming its existence, is very useful. In particular, the two following headings on the Fermlab page are worth clicking on, for further detail: "Is it a top quark? The signature of a top event" and "How do we know when we've found the top quark?"
For all of the hype and expense of the LHC, it is important to note that it is not expected to offer the ultimate in detector clarity. Texas A&M University physicist Teruki Kamon, whom I once saw give a talk at Texas Tech, has a slide in some of his PowerPoint presentations that uses a photographic analogy to demonstrate the upgrades in information (quantity and quality) that will be available as researchers move from Fermilab's Tevatron to the LHC to the proposed International Linear Collider (ILC).
If you go to this slide show and then scroll down to page 3, you'll see a sequence of three depictions of the same picture (a girl jumping in the air, with her shadow showing below). At the Tevatron, according to this analogy, only perhaps the bottom one-fifth of the picture would be observable, and with a very fuzzy appearance, at that. At the LHC, the full picture would be available, but would still be fuzzy. Only at the ILC would the picture be both fully available and sharp.
The next set of LHC-related postings will discuss new types of particles and other phenomena that scientists hope to find.
Friday, June 29, 2007
Large Hadron Collider Part IV
Tonight, we return to my series on the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). I previously wrote about one very important property of a collider, its energy. Tonight, I write about another important property, luminosity. Dictionary definitions of luminosity typically refer to the presence of light or brightness; in other words, a luminous object is easy to see, such as something that is illuminated.
Conceptually, the term luminosity as used in particle physics also refers to ease of detecting something. In his book, Not Even Wrong (associated with a blog of the same name), Peter Woit states the following:
Besides the energy of its [particle] beams, the most important characteristic of any collider is its "luminosity." The luminosity of a collider is a measure of how many particles are in the beam and how small the interaction region is in which the beams coming from opposite directions are brought together inside a detector (p. 19).
The most layperson-friendly description of the units of luminosity I've been able to find is "collisions per square centimeter per second...", from this Berkeley Lab document.
Greater density of particles' concentration -- how many of them there are, in how small of an area -- thus would make them easier to detect. The LHC's luminosity is planned to be 10 to the 34th power (that's a lot of zeroes).
Increasing colliders' luminosities, however, is very difficult to do, as discussed by Woit and also in this Stanford Linear Accelerator Center (SLAC) document. The SLAC document also includes a graph that shows the luminosity levels for a number of colliders, including the LHC.
Luminosity is serious business. Major international conferences known as LUMI '06 and LUMI '05 have been held to track research developments in this area.
Conceptually, the term luminosity as used in particle physics also refers to ease of detecting something. In his book, Not Even Wrong (associated with a blog of the same name), Peter Woit states the following:
Besides the energy of its [particle] beams, the most important characteristic of any collider is its "luminosity." The luminosity of a collider is a measure of how many particles are in the beam and how small the interaction region is in which the beams coming from opposite directions are brought together inside a detector (p. 19).
The most layperson-friendly description of the units of luminosity I've been able to find is "collisions per square centimeter per second...", from this Berkeley Lab document.
Greater density of particles' concentration -- how many of them there are, in how small of an area -- thus would make them easier to detect. The LHC's luminosity is planned to be 10 to the 34th power (that's a lot of zeroes).
Increasing colliders' luminosities, however, is very difficult to do, as discussed by Woit and also in this Stanford Linear Accelerator Center (SLAC) document. The SLAC document also includes a graph that shows the luminosity levels for a number of colliders, including the LHC.
Luminosity is serious business. Major international conferences known as LUMI '06 and LUMI '05 have been held to track research developments in this area.
Friday, June 15, 2007
Book Review: "The Physics of Basketball"
I thought I'd take a break from my series on the Large Hadron Collider (see the three previous postings below) to write a mini-review of a book I recently finished reading. The book is The Physics of Basketball, by U.S. Naval Academy professor John Fontanella, himself a former player.
It’s actually more of a lengthy monograph (~130 pages) than a typical book. The book concentrates heavily on the trajectory of basketball shots, both of the “nothing but net” variety and those that bounce around off the backboard and/or rim. Fontanella’s enumeration of all the forces acting on a released basketball shot (e.g., gravity, magnus, drag, and buoyancy) may have some similarity to the talk University of Illinois physicist Alan Nathan presented at last year’s Society for American Baseball Research (SABR) meeting on the aerodynamics of a flying baseball.
Fontanella also addresses a few other issues besides basketball shooting. One is the illusion of "hang time," or a player (former NBA star Gus Johnson being a favorite of the author) who's driving to the hoop "hanging or floating in air, apparently defying gravity and the laws of physics" (p. 121).
The author has a ready explanation for this phenomenon -- a player's initial upward movement is quick, but gravity slows the upward motion. According to a calculation by Fontanella, "a jumping player spends only 29% of the time in the bottom half of the jump. Correspondingly, a player must spend 71% of the time in the upper half of the jump" (p. 122). Thus, we see prolonged periods of a player high in the air.
Another question Fontanella addresses -- for those of you dying of curiosity -- is why you hear so much squeaking of the players' basketball shoes when you're observing from near the court (p. 115).
There’s an online NPR interview (link) with Fontanella you can listen to, which might help you decide if you want to read the book.
It’s actually more of a lengthy monograph (~130 pages) than a typical book. The book concentrates heavily on the trajectory of basketball shots, both of the “nothing but net” variety and those that bounce around off the backboard and/or rim. Fontanella’s enumeration of all the forces acting on a released basketball shot (e.g., gravity, magnus, drag, and buoyancy) may have some similarity to the talk University of Illinois physicist Alan Nathan presented at last year’s Society for American Baseball Research (SABR) meeting on the aerodynamics of a flying baseball.
Fontanella also addresses a few other issues besides basketball shooting. One is the illusion of "hang time," or a player (former NBA star Gus Johnson being a favorite of the author) who's driving to the hoop "hanging or floating in air, apparently defying gravity and the laws of physics" (p. 121).
The author has a ready explanation for this phenomenon -- a player's initial upward movement is quick, but gravity slows the upward motion. According to a calculation by Fontanella, "a jumping player spends only 29% of the time in the bottom half of the jump. Correspondingly, a player must spend 71% of the time in the upper half of the jump" (p. 122). Thus, we see prolonged periods of a player high in the air.
Another question Fontanella addresses -- for those of you dying of curiosity -- is why you hear so much squeaking of the players' basketball shoes when you're observing from near the court (p. 115).
There’s an online NPR interview (link) with Fontanella you can listen to, which might help you decide if you want to read the book.
Saturday, June 09, 2007
Large Hadron Collider Part III
Continuing on with our series on the Large Hadron Collider (LHC), today we'll address its energy aspects. Specifically, two primary questions are why high energies are needed, and how they are achieved. First, though, let's briefly go over the terminology for energy scales of magnitude.
The unit of energy referred to in particle physics is the electronvolt (eV). The most straightforward explanation of an electronvolt comes from this Fermilab document, which characterizes 1 eV as "very tiny." As illustrated on the page, if an electron passes through a 1.5 V battery (which many of you probably have in your home), that would represent 1.5 eV of energy.
Further, from dealing with computer memory sizes (bytes) or other measurment contexts, many of you are probably familiar with the terminology for thousandfold orders of magnitude, such as kilo (1,000 or 10^3, where ^ stands for raising to a power) and mega (1 million or 10^6). Continuing onward, we have giga (1 billion or 10^9) and tera (1 trillion or 10^12). This University College London document lists these milestones.
In fact, the Tevatron collider at Fermilab is so named because of its ability to reach 1 tera electronvolts ("TeV") of energy. As discussed below, the LHC will go even higher.
So why do we need ever-increasing energy performance from our particle colliders? It's because the new particles scientists are looking for tend to be very massive and, as a result of the direct relationship between energy and mass in Einstein's E = mc^2 (c standing for the speed of light, which gets squared), the creation of high-mass particles requires high energy. This Canadian document makes the basic point:
It is realized that the mass-energy relation (E = mc^2) provides a new way to get information about particles. If particles could be made very energetic and then used to collide with other particles, some of their energy could be converted into the creation of previously unknown particles. When particles are produced in a collision, they are not particles that were somehow inside the colliding ones. They are really produced by converting the collision energy into mass, the mass of other particles… Which particles will be produced is partly determined by their mass - the lighter they are, the easier it is to produced them [sic], other things being equal - and also by the probabilities calculated from the Feynman diagrams.
One type of particle that is eagerly being sought at the LHC is something known as the Higgs boson, about which I will have much to say later. The New Yorker magazine article that I linked to in the opening essay of this series talks about how the Higgs has not been found at the Tevatron, so the LHC, with its higher energy, is the next hope.
By now, the Higgs has been sought for so long that physicists have a pretty clear idea of how much it must weigh. The lower bound is around 120 times more than a proton... The upper bound is about 210 times as much as a proton. The most powerful collider currently in operation is Fermilab’s Tevatron, outside Chicago. The Tevatron, which smashes protons into antiprotons, can accelerate particles to an energy of just under a trillion electron volts, or one TeV... So far, the Tevatron has failed to reveal the Higgs, though physicists there are actively looking for it. The L.H.C. will accelerate particles to seven TeV, which means that it will be seven times as powerful as the Tevatron. This should be more than enough energy to produce the Higgs, if there is a Higgs to produce. It may also be enough to uncover much more than the Higgs... (page 3 of online New Yorker article).
OK, so finally, how have accelerators and colliders over the years been able to keep raising the energy levels capable of being studied? This Stanford Linear Accelerator Center (SLAC) document provides an excellent summary of the historical evolution of accelerators and colliders, including their increasing energy levels. Referring to a graph of accelerators’ particle energy plotted against a timeline from 1930-1990, the report states the following:
One of the first things to notice is that the energy of man-made accelerators has been growing exponentially in time. Starting from the 1930s, the energy has increased – roughly speaking – by about a factor of 10 every six to eight years. A second conclusion is that this spectacular achievement has resulted from a succession of technologies rather than from construction of bigger and better machines of a given type (pp. 38-39).
Further:
The [e]nergy that really matters in doing elementary particle physics is the collision energy – that is, the energy available to induce a reaction, including the creation of new particles… If two particles of equal mass traveling in opposite directions collide head on, however, the total kinetic energy of the combined system after collision is zero, and therefore the entire energy of the two particles becomes available as collision energy. This is the basic energy advantage offered by colliding-beam machines, or colliders (p. 40).
The brief summaries and excerpts above are meant simply to convey rudimentary ideas on the topic. The linked documents are, of course, available for you to read in toto, should you wish further information. Additional web documents and books are also available, and shouldn't be too hard to find via some web searching.
The unit of energy referred to in particle physics is the electronvolt (eV). The most straightforward explanation of an electronvolt comes from this Fermilab document, which characterizes 1 eV as "very tiny." As illustrated on the page, if an electron passes through a 1.5 V battery (which many of you probably have in your home), that would represent 1.5 eV of energy.
Further, from dealing with computer memory sizes (bytes) or other measurment contexts, many of you are probably familiar with the terminology for thousandfold orders of magnitude, such as kilo (1,000 or 10^3, where ^ stands for raising to a power) and mega (1 million or 10^6). Continuing onward, we have giga (1 billion or 10^9) and tera (1 trillion or 10^12). This University College London document lists these milestones.
In fact, the Tevatron collider at Fermilab is so named because of its ability to reach 1 tera electronvolts ("TeV") of energy. As discussed below, the LHC will go even higher.
So why do we need ever-increasing energy performance from our particle colliders? It's because the new particles scientists are looking for tend to be very massive and, as a result of the direct relationship between energy and mass in Einstein's E = mc^2 (c standing for the speed of light, which gets squared), the creation of high-mass particles requires high energy. This Canadian document makes the basic point:
It is realized that the mass-energy relation (E = mc^2) provides a new way to get information about particles. If particles could be made very energetic and then used to collide with other particles, some of their energy could be converted into the creation of previously unknown particles. When particles are produced in a collision, they are not particles that were somehow inside the colliding ones. They are really produced by converting the collision energy into mass, the mass of other particles… Which particles will be produced is partly determined by their mass - the lighter they are, the easier it is to produced them [sic], other things being equal - and also by the probabilities calculated from the Feynman diagrams.
One type of particle that is eagerly being sought at the LHC is something known as the Higgs boson, about which I will have much to say later. The New Yorker magazine article that I linked to in the opening essay of this series talks about how the Higgs has not been found at the Tevatron, so the LHC, with its higher energy, is the next hope.
By now, the Higgs has been sought for so long that physicists have a pretty clear idea of how much it must weigh. The lower bound is around 120 times more than a proton... The upper bound is about 210 times as much as a proton. The most powerful collider currently in operation is Fermilab’s Tevatron, outside Chicago. The Tevatron, which smashes protons into antiprotons, can accelerate particles to an energy of just under a trillion electron volts, or one TeV... So far, the Tevatron has failed to reveal the Higgs, though physicists there are actively looking for it. The L.H.C. will accelerate particles to seven TeV, which means that it will be seven times as powerful as the Tevatron. This should be more than enough energy to produce the Higgs, if there is a Higgs to produce. It may also be enough to uncover much more than the Higgs... (page 3 of online New Yorker article).
OK, so finally, how have accelerators and colliders over the years been able to keep raising the energy levels capable of being studied? This Stanford Linear Accelerator Center (SLAC) document provides an excellent summary of the historical evolution of accelerators and colliders, including their increasing energy levels. Referring to a graph of accelerators’ particle energy plotted against a timeline from 1930-1990, the report states the following:
One of the first things to notice is that the energy of man-made accelerators has been growing exponentially in time. Starting from the 1930s, the energy has increased – roughly speaking – by about a factor of 10 every six to eight years. A second conclusion is that this spectacular achievement has resulted from a succession of technologies rather than from construction of bigger and better machines of a given type (pp. 38-39).
Further:
The [e]nergy that really matters in doing elementary particle physics is the collision energy – that is, the energy available to induce a reaction, including the creation of new particles… If two particles of equal mass traveling in opposite directions collide head on, however, the total kinetic energy of the combined system after collision is zero, and therefore the entire energy of the two particles becomes available as collision energy. This is the basic energy advantage offered by colliding-beam machines, or colliders (p. 40).
The brief summaries and excerpts above are meant simply to convey rudimentary ideas on the topic. The linked documents are, of course, available for you to read in toto, should you wish further information. Additional web documents and books are also available, and shouldn't be too hard to find via some web searching.
Monday, May 28, 2007
Large Hadron Collider Part II
Following up on the introductory essay (below) to my series on the Large Hadron Collider (LHC), today I provide the first substantive posting, on the basics of particle-physics colliders.
A good place to start is with an analogy from George Mason University professor Robert Oerter, in his book The Theory of Almost Everything (which I reviewed here). The analogy is presented primarily on pp. 135-137, but the remainder of the chapter also provides important historical information.
To paraphrase Oerter's analogy, let's say we have a sponge-rubber Nerf football that may have objects embedded within it, such as a baseball or even a ball made of steel.
We are not allowed to squeeze or cut open the Nerf ball, nor can we see inside of it. Instead, we must fire pellets into the ball and make inferences about the inner content of the ball by what happens to the fired pellets. Depending upon whether pellets go completely through the ball and come out, get stuck in the ball, or ricochet back out at some angle, estimates of the size, position, and hardness of the inner objects can be made.
Similarly, it is through inferences from records of particle collisions that physicists learn about the micro world of matter. I will have a later write-up specifically on detection of particle collisions.
In looking at the LHC and earlier facilities such as Fermilab's Tevatron, CERN's Large Electron Positron collider (whose tunnel has been converted to use with the LHC), and Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, three major distinctions arise. These distinctions, and the pros and cons of different alternatives, are discussed below.
Fixed vs. Particle-Beam Targets
One distinction is between experiments that aim a beam of particles at a fixed target, and those that aim two particle beams into each other. Quoting from Peter Woit's book Not Even Wrong, "Accelerators that collide two beams together are now called colliders..." (p. 15).
This CERN document discusses the arguments in favor of fixed-target and beam-on-beam (collider) designs. In short, colliders are said to be more economical to run and can produce higher energies. On the other hand, "Firing a particle beam into a solid metal target or large tank of liquid ensures that almost every particle will collide with a nucleus but getting two particle beams to interact is much harder."
Lepton (e.g., electron) vs. Hadron (e.g., proton) Colliders
The same CERN document as discussed in the preceding section also addresses lepton vs. hadron colliders. Leptons are said to be advantageous for precision energy measurement, whereas hadrons are better suited to discovery of new particles. Electrons (one type of lepton) also have a problem with something called "synchrotron radiation," as discussed below.
For additional background on leptons and hadrons, you can look over a couple of my previous postings. One on leptons is available here, whereas one on hadrons can be found here.
Linear vs. Circular
This Wikipedia entry on particle accelerators lists some advantages of circular designs over linear ones:
In the circular accelerator, particles move in a circle until they reach sufficient energy. The particle track is typically bent into a circle using electromagnets. The advantage of circular accelerators over linear accelerators (linacs) is that the ring topology allows continuous acceleration, as the particle can transit indefinitely. Another advantage is that a circular accelerator is relatively smaller than a linear accelerator of comparable power (i.e. a linac would have to be extremely long to have the equivalent power of a circular accelerator).
Circular accelerators have evolved from the original cyclotrons to the more elaborate synchrotrons. As Woit explains, "Higher-energy accelerators could not be built using a single magnet, but instead used a doughnut-like ring of smaller magnets. This design was called a 'synchrotron'..." (p. 13).
The technical mathematical name for a doughnut-like structure is a torus. In fact, one of the experiments to be carried out at the LHC is known as ATLAS, for "A Toroidal LHC ApparatuS." See the Wikipedia page on the LHC for further information on the individual experiments.
According to the Wikipedia page on synchrotrons:
While a cyclotron uses a constant magnetic field and a constant-frequency applied electric field, and one of these is varied in the synchrocyclotron, both of these are varied in the synchrotron...
In a cyclotron the maximum radius is quite limited as the particles start at the center and spiral outward, thus this entire path must be a self-supporting disc-shaped evacuated chamber... The arrangement of the single pair of magnets the full width of the device also limits the economic size of the device.
Synchrotrons overcome these limitations, using a narrow beam pipe which can be surrounded by much smaller and more tightly focused magnets.
Under certain conditions, synchotrons can lose energy through a process called "synchrotron radiation," as is described in this excellent educational graphic from the Nobel Foundation.
Synchrotron radiation appears to be a problem when two conditions coexist: (1) a circular accelerator is being used, and (2) electrons are being studied. A Fermilab document states the following:
Linear electron accelerators do not produce much synchrotron radiation. Circular electron accelerators and storage rings produce copious synchrotron radiation in all the bending magnets, especially when the magnetic fields are high or the beam energy is high.
Further, Woit notes that:
While the main constraint on the energy of an electron-positron ring is the problem of synchrotron radiation loss, for a proton ring this is not much of an issue, since protons are so much heavier than electrons (p. 23).
For further information, I would suggest this CERN LHC page of Frequently Asked Questions and this PowerPoint slide show by Florida State University professor Horst Wahl.
A good place to start is with an analogy from George Mason University professor Robert Oerter, in his book The Theory of Almost Everything (which I reviewed here). The analogy is presented primarily on pp. 135-137, but the remainder of the chapter also provides important historical information.
To paraphrase Oerter's analogy, let's say we have a sponge-rubber Nerf football that may have objects embedded within it, such as a baseball or even a ball made of steel.
We are not allowed to squeeze or cut open the Nerf ball, nor can we see inside of it. Instead, we must fire pellets into the ball and make inferences about the inner content of the ball by what happens to the fired pellets. Depending upon whether pellets go completely through the ball and come out, get stuck in the ball, or ricochet back out at some angle, estimates of the size, position, and hardness of the inner objects can be made.
Similarly, it is through inferences from records of particle collisions that physicists learn about the micro world of matter. I will have a later write-up specifically on detection of particle collisions.
In looking at the LHC and earlier facilities such as Fermilab's Tevatron, CERN's Large Electron Positron collider (whose tunnel has been converted to use with the LHC), and Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, three major distinctions arise. These distinctions, and the pros and cons of different alternatives, are discussed below.
Fixed vs. Particle-Beam Targets
One distinction is between experiments that aim a beam of particles at a fixed target, and those that aim two particle beams into each other. Quoting from Peter Woit's book Not Even Wrong, "Accelerators that collide two beams together are now called colliders..." (p. 15).
This CERN document discusses the arguments in favor of fixed-target and beam-on-beam (collider) designs. In short, colliders are said to be more economical to run and can produce higher energies. On the other hand, "Firing a particle beam into a solid metal target or large tank of liquid ensures that almost every particle will collide with a nucleus but getting two particle beams to interact is much harder."
Lepton (e.g., electron) vs. Hadron (e.g., proton) Colliders
The same CERN document as discussed in the preceding section also addresses lepton vs. hadron colliders. Leptons are said to be advantageous for precision energy measurement, whereas hadrons are better suited to discovery of new particles. Electrons (one type of lepton) also have a problem with something called "synchrotron radiation," as discussed below.
For additional background on leptons and hadrons, you can look over a couple of my previous postings. One on leptons is available here, whereas one on hadrons can be found here.
Linear vs. Circular
This Wikipedia entry on particle accelerators lists some advantages of circular designs over linear ones:
In the circular accelerator, particles move in a circle until they reach sufficient energy. The particle track is typically bent into a circle using electromagnets. The advantage of circular accelerators over linear accelerators (linacs) is that the ring topology allows continuous acceleration, as the particle can transit indefinitely. Another advantage is that a circular accelerator is relatively smaller than a linear accelerator of comparable power (i.e. a linac would have to be extremely long to have the equivalent power of a circular accelerator).
Circular accelerators have evolved from the original cyclotrons to the more elaborate synchrotrons. As Woit explains, "Higher-energy accelerators could not be built using a single magnet, but instead used a doughnut-like ring of smaller magnets. This design was called a 'synchrotron'..." (p. 13).
The technical mathematical name for a doughnut-like structure is a torus. In fact, one of the experiments to be carried out at the LHC is known as ATLAS, for "A Toroidal LHC ApparatuS." See the Wikipedia page on the LHC for further information on the individual experiments.
According to the Wikipedia page on synchrotrons:
While a cyclotron uses a constant magnetic field and a constant-frequency applied electric field, and one of these is varied in the synchrocyclotron, both of these are varied in the synchrotron...
In a cyclotron the maximum radius is quite limited as the particles start at the center and spiral outward, thus this entire path must be a self-supporting disc-shaped evacuated chamber... The arrangement of the single pair of magnets the full width of the device also limits the economic size of the device.
Synchrotrons overcome these limitations, using a narrow beam pipe which can be surrounded by much smaller and more tightly focused magnets.
Under certain conditions, synchotrons can lose energy through a process called "synchrotron radiation," as is described in this excellent educational graphic from the Nobel Foundation.
Synchrotron radiation appears to be a problem when two conditions coexist: (1) a circular accelerator is being used, and (2) electrons are being studied. A Fermilab document states the following:
Linear electron accelerators do not produce much synchrotron radiation. Circular electron accelerators and storage rings produce copious synchrotron radiation in all the bending magnets, especially when the magnetic fields are high or the beam energy is high.
Further, Woit notes that:
While the main constraint on the energy of an electron-positron ring is the problem of synchrotron radiation loss, for a proton ring this is not much of an issue, since protons are so much heavier than electrons (p. 23).
For further information, I would suggest this CERN LHC page of Frequently Asked Questions and this PowerPoint slide show by Florida State University professor Horst Wahl.
Tuesday, May 15, 2007
Large Hadron Collider Part I
As most people who would visit this blog are probably aware, the Large Hadron Collider, a facility straddling the Swiss-French border that will host the highest-energy physics experiments ever, is scheduled to begin data collection at some point in the relatively near future (official LHC website, Wikipedia page).
In anticipation of the LHC's opening for research, two major publications from the Big Apple, the New York Times and the New Yorker magazine, have each published major articles on the collider in recent days. The two articles are very similar contentwise -- each covering both the physical construction and science of the LHC -- and lengthwise (prepare to block out some time to read either).
New York Times articles tend to be taken down from the web fairly quickly, so the best online option would probably be to seek out the piece on Lexis/Nexis at a library that subscribes to this service ("A Giant Takes On Physics’ Biggest Questions," by Dennis Overbye, May 15, 2007). I'm not sure how long the New Yorker makes its articles available free, full-text, but here it is, for now at least.
Peter Woit, whose "Not Even Wrong" blog (associated with his book of the same name) I read frequently, questions the timing of this media barrage:
I do fear all this LHC coverage is peaking too early. With still probably at least a year to go before the machine even starts taking data, the coverage may already be generating an LHC overexposure problem...
For the last several months, I have been collecting articles to do my own series of postings on the LHC. On the positive side, I think the NYT and New Yorker articles will motivate me to get my stuff up here "sooner rather than later."
Over the next few months, you can expect a new posting here every couple of weeks. The topics I plan to address in my series include:
*What is a particle-physics collider, in the first place?
*Energy aspects of the LHC (why high energies are needed and how they are achieved).
*Another important aspect of a collider, its luminosity.
*How the data are detected, collected, and interpreted.
*How the various LHC studies might (or might not) inform several theoretical proposals of the Standard Model and beyond, including Higgs physics, supersymmetry, and extra dimensions.
In anticipation of the LHC's opening for research, two major publications from the Big Apple, the New York Times and the New Yorker magazine, have each published major articles on the collider in recent days. The two articles are very similar contentwise -- each covering both the physical construction and science of the LHC -- and lengthwise (prepare to block out some time to read either).
New York Times articles tend to be taken down from the web fairly quickly, so the best online option would probably be to seek out the piece on Lexis/Nexis at a library that subscribes to this service ("A Giant Takes On Physics’ Biggest Questions," by Dennis Overbye, May 15, 2007). I'm not sure how long the New Yorker makes its articles available free, full-text, but here it is, for now at least.
Peter Woit, whose "Not Even Wrong" blog (associated with his book of the same name) I read frequently, questions the timing of this media barrage:
I do fear all this LHC coverage is peaking too early. With still probably at least a year to go before the machine even starts taking data, the coverage may already be generating an LHC overexposure problem...
For the last several months, I have been collecting articles to do my own series of postings on the LHC. On the positive side, I think the NYT and New Yorker articles will motivate me to get my stuff up here "sooner rather than later."
Over the next few months, you can expect a new posting here every couple of weeks. The topics I plan to address in my series include:
*What is a particle-physics collider, in the first place?
*Energy aspects of the LHC (why high energies are needed and how they are achieved).
*Another important aspect of a collider, its luminosity.
*How the data are detected, collected, and interpreted.
*How the various LHC studies might (or might not) inform several theoretical proposals of the Standard Model and beyond, including Higgs physics, supersymmetry, and extra dimensions.
Saturday, April 21, 2007
String Theory "Cribsheet"
As I gather, Seed magazine occasionally puts together one-page "cribsheets" on various scientific topics. It has recently put one out on string theory. Clicking here will take you to Seed's page about the string theory cribsheet, where, after scrolling down a bit on the new page, you can download your own copy of the sheet.
Naturally, I commend the idea of trying to bring physics concepts to a broad audience. Further, I would say that, given the space limitations of a single page, the cribsheet covers a lot of ground. Further reading is obviously necessary for a fuller understanding, however, such as some of the books I have reviewed over the last couple of years on this blog.
Naturally, I commend the idea of trying to bring physics concepts to a broad audience. Further, I would say that, given the space limitations of a single page, the cribsheet covers a lot of ground. Further reading is obviously necessary for a fuller understanding, however, such as some of the books I have reviewed over the last couple of years on this blog.
Tuesday, April 10, 2007
Book Review: "Not Even Wrong"
I recently finished reading Peter Woit's book Not Even Wrong, one of the two books that have received great attention in recent months for their critical examinations of string theory. The other such book is Lee Smolin's The Trouble with Physics, which I reviewed here.
I have been a longtime visitor to Woit's Not Even Wrong blog. That gave me a good idea of what to expect and, indeed, I found the book to be a systematic expansion of ideas discussed on the blog.
In the Preface (p. xii), Woit explains the expression from Wolfgang Pauli that became the title of his (Woit's) book. Woit notes that the phrase "carries two different connotations, both of which Pauli likely had in mind." As Woit continues:
A theory can be "not even wrong" because it is so incomplete and ill-defined that it can't be used to make firm predictions whose failure would show it to be wrong. This has been the situation of superstring theory from its beginnings to the present day...
...there is a second connotation of "not even wrong": something worse than a wrong idea... worse than being wrong is to refuse to admit it when one is wrong.
For all the hype over Woit's book in relation to string theory, it doesn't even take up the topic until about halfway through. The first half presents a history of particle physics, with a heavy emphasis on the interface between physics and mathematics. The standard model of particle physics receives a lot of attention, and there's also a nice early chapter on accelerators and colliders. Woit himself, in both his blog and book, warns about the technical references to mathematical concepts in the book, but I didn't find it to be any worse than other books in terms of mathematical complexity (which is not to say that I understood any more than a little of the math).
A substantial component of Woit's critique of string theory has to do with the potentially huge (i.e., hundreds of thousands, if not hundreds of millions, or more) number of possible scenarios that would satisfy string theory's requirements, but not produce a unique solution characterizing a single universe. Part of the problem stems from the need for extra dimensions and the applicability of something called Calabi-Yau manifolds (discussed in this earlier posting of mine). Writes Woit:
The predictions of heterotic string theory [one form of the theory] strongly depend on which Calabi-Yau spaces one chooses. In 1984, only a few Calabi-Yau spaces were known, but by now hundreds of thousands have been constructed (p. 153).
A few chapters later, he resumes the discussion, in terms of possible background spaces for the universe(s):
There are many, perhaps infinitely many, classes of background spaces that appear to be possible consistent choices, and each one of these classes comes with a large number of parameters that determine the size and shape of the background space-time... [Regarding possible parameters, one of the proposed mechanisms] picks out not a unique value for the values..., but a very large set of values, any one of which should be as good as any other. Estimates of the number of these possible values are absurdly large (e.g., 10^100, 10^500, or even 10^1000 [where ^ stands for raising to a power]) far beyond the number of particles in the universe or anything else one can imagine counting... The possible existence of, say, 10^500 consistent different vacuum states for superstring theory probably destroys the hope of using the theory to predict anything... (pp. 237-239).
Woit also discusses the landscape/anthropic principle, an attempt by some to salvage the string theory conception of innumerable universes. According to the Wikipedia entry linked in the previous sentence, "The idea of the string theory landscape has been used to propose a concrete implementation of the anthropic principle, the idea that fundamental constants may have the values they have not for fundamental physical reasons, but rather because such values are necessary for life."
Also thrown into the mix by Woit is a chapter entitled "The Bogdanov Affair," the larger point of which seems to be that certain areas of physics have gotten so complex that few people can even follow what is being written. In brief, two brothers named Bogdanov managed to publish several articles that appeared to contain little or no merit, but whose prose was so impenetrable that journal referees appeared to let the manuscripts get by. Writes Woit:
Leaving aside the issue of whether the Bogdanovs are hoaxers or really believe in their own work, this episode definitively showed that in the field of quantum gravity one can easily publish complete gibberish in many journals, some of them rather prominent... Why did the referees in this case accept for publication such obviously incoherent nonsense? One reason is undoubtedly that many physicists do not willingly admit that they don't understand things...(pp. 218-219).
Sean Carroll, who blogs at Cosmic Variance, had an entry about a week and a half ago entitled, "String Theory is Losing the Public Debate." He writes:
...there are very good reasons to think that something like string theory is going to be part of the ultimate understanding of quantum gravity, and it would be nice if more people knew what those reasons were.
Of course, it would be even nicer if those reasons were explained (to interested non-physicists as well as other physicists who are not specialists) by string theorists themselves. Unfortunately, they’re not. Most string theorists... seem to not deem it worth their time to make much of an effort to explain why this theory with no empirical support whatsoever is nevertheless so promising. (Which it is.) Meanwhile, people who think that string theory has hit a dead end and should admit defeat — who are a tiny minority of those who are well-informed about the subject — are getting their message out with devastating effectiveness.
As I've noted periodically on the present blog, at least one prominent physicist, Columbia University's Brian Greene (whom Carroll also mentions), has been assiduously arguing for the promise of string theory in various forums. I agree with Carroll, though. I too would like to see more advocates of string theory explain their perspective.
I have been a longtime visitor to Woit's Not Even Wrong blog. That gave me a good idea of what to expect and, indeed, I found the book to be a systematic expansion of ideas discussed on the blog.
In the Preface (p. xii), Woit explains the expression from Wolfgang Pauli that became the title of his (Woit's) book. Woit notes that the phrase "carries two different connotations, both of which Pauli likely had in mind." As Woit continues:
A theory can be "not even wrong" because it is so incomplete and ill-defined that it can't be used to make firm predictions whose failure would show it to be wrong. This has been the situation of superstring theory from its beginnings to the present day...
...there is a second connotation of "not even wrong": something worse than a wrong idea... worse than being wrong is to refuse to admit it when one is wrong.
For all the hype over Woit's book in relation to string theory, it doesn't even take up the topic until about halfway through. The first half presents a history of particle physics, with a heavy emphasis on the interface between physics and mathematics. The standard model of particle physics receives a lot of attention, and there's also a nice early chapter on accelerators and colliders. Woit himself, in both his blog and book, warns about the technical references to mathematical concepts in the book, but I didn't find it to be any worse than other books in terms of mathematical complexity (which is not to say that I understood any more than a little of the math).
A substantial component of Woit's critique of string theory has to do with the potentially huge (i.e., hundreds of thousands, if not hundreds of millions, or more) number of possible scenarios that would satisfy string theory's requirements, but not produce a unique solution characterizing a single universe. Part of the problem stems from the need for extra dimensions and the applicability of something called Calabi-Yau manifolds (discussed in this earlier posting of mine). Writes Woit:
The predictions of heterotic string theory [one form of the theory] strongly depend on which Calabi-Yau spaces one chooses. In 1984, only a few Calabi-Yau spaces were known, but by now hundreds of thousands have been constructed (p. 153).
A few chapters later, he resumes the discussion, in terms of possible background spaces for the universe(s):
There are many, perhaps infinitely many, classes of background spaces that appear to be possible consistent choices, and each one of these classes comes with a large number of parameters that determine the size and shape of the background space-time... [Regarding possible parameters, one of the proposed mechanisms] picks out not a unique value for the values..., but a very large set of values, any one of which should be as good as any other. Estimates of the number of these possible values are absurdly large (e.g., 10^100, 10^500, or even 10^1000 [where ^ stands for raising to a power]) far beyond the number of particles in the universe or anything else one can imagine counting... The possible existence of, say, 10^500 consistent different vacuum states for superstring theory probably destroys the hope of using the theory to predict anything... (pp. 237-239).
Woit also discusses the landscape/anthropic principle, an attempt by some to salvage the string theory conception of innumerable universes. According to the Wikipedia entry linked in the previous sentence, "The idea of the string theory landscape has been used to propose a concrete implementation of the anthropic principle, the idea that fundamental constants may have the values they have not for fundamental physical reasons, but rather because such values are necessary for life."
Also thrown into the mix by Woit is a chapter entitled "The Bogdanov Affair," the larger point of which seems to be that certain areas of physics have gotten so complex that few people can even follow what is being written. In brief, two brothers named Bogdanov managed to publish several articles that appeared to contain little or no merit, but whose prose was so impenetrable that journal referees appeared to let the manuscripts get by. Writes Woit:
Leaving aside the issue of whether the Bogdanovs are hoaxers or really believe in their own work, this episode definitively showed that in the field of quantum gravity one can easily publish complete gibberish in many journals, some of them rather prominent... Why did the referees in this case accept for publication such obviously incoherent nonsense? One reason is undoubtedly that many physicists do not willingly admit that they don't understand things...(pp. 218-219).
Sean Carroll, who blogs at Cosmic Variance, had an entry about a week and a half ago entitled, "String Theory is Losing the Public Debate." He writes:
...there are very good reasons to think that something like string theory is going to be part of the ultimate understanding of quantum gravity, and it would be nice if more people knew what those reasons were.
Of course, it would be even nicer if those reasons were explained (to interested non-physicists as well as other physicists who are not specialists) by string theorists themselves. Unfortunately, they’re not. Most string theorists... seem to not deem it worth their time to make much of an effort to explain why this theory with no empirical support whatsoever is nevertheless so promising. (Which it is.) Meanwhile, people who think that string theory has hit a dead end and should admit defeat — who are a tiny minority of those who are well-informed about the subject — are getting their message out with devastating effectiveness.
As I've noted periodically on the present blog, at least one prominent physicist, Columbia University's Brian Greene (whom Carroll also mentions), has been assiduously arguing for the promise of string theory in various forums. I agree with Carroll, though. I too would like to see more advocates of string theory explain their perspective.
Sunday, March 11, 2007
Scientific American Special Edition on Astrophysics
Scientific American magazine has recently come out with a "Scientific American Reports: Special Edition on Astrophysics," the focus of which is on black holes. Scientific American's website has information on the special issue, although no free full-text access is available.
Many researchers have been exploring the links between astrophysics/cosmology and particle physics, as studied at accelerators such as the upcoming Large Hadron Collider (LHC). In fact, according this MSNBC article, one scenario for the LHC is, "Upon collision, the beams are expected to create many new particles and possibly a reconstruction of the universe in its very first moments."
On a related note, one of the articles in the Scientific American issue, by Bernard Carr and Steven Giddings, talks about the possibility of creating microscopic black holes at the LHC. The article notes that, under conventional thinking, the LHC would not have sufficient energy to produce black holes. However, if there are extra, hidden dimensions there could be sufficient energy. The appearance of black holes at the LHC would then offer "compelling evidence of the previously hidden dimensions of space..." (p. 27).
Convrersely, there is some new research suggesting that, in some sense, the Milky Way galaxy's black hole may emulate what will be happening at the LHC. As reported in this news release from the University of Arizona:
"It's similar to the same kind of particle physics experiments that the Large Hadron Collider being built at CERN will perform," UA astrophysicist David Ballantyne said.
When complete, the Large Hadron Collider in Switzerland will be able to accelerate protons to seven trillion electronvolts. Our galaxy's black hole whips protons to energies as much as 100 trillion electronvolts, according to the team's new study. That's all the more impressive because "Our black hole is pretty inactive compared to massive black holes sitting in other galaxies," Ballantyne noted.
Getting back to the Scientific American special issue, other articles cover topics such as the history of black hole research (which involves, among others, Albert Einstein and J. Robert Oppenheimer), the possibility of time travel, and holographic theories of the universe.
Many researchers have been exploring the links between astrophysics/cosmology and particle physics, as studied at accelerators such as the upcoming Large Hadron Collider (LHC). In fact, according this MSNBC article, one scenario for the LHC is, "Upon collision, the beams are expected to create many new particles and possibly a reconstruction of the universe in its very first moments."
On a related note, one of the articles in the Scientific American issue, by Bernard Carr and Steven Giddings, talks about the possibility of creating microscopic black holes at the LHC. The article notes that, under conventional thinking, the LHC would not have sufficient energy to produce black holes. However, if there are extra, hidden dimensions there could be sufficient energy. The appearance of black holes at the LHC would then offer "compelling evidence of the previously hidden dimensions of space..." (p. 27).
Convrersely, there is some new research suggesting that, in some sense, the Milky Way galaxy's black hole may emulate what will be happening at the LHC. As reported in this news release from the University of Arizona:
"It's similar to the same kind of particle physics experiments that the Large Hadron Collider being built at CERN will perform," UA astrophysicist David Ballantyne said.
When complete, the Large Hadron Collider in Switzerland will be able to accelerate protons to seven trillion electronvolts. Our galaxy's black hole whips protons to energies as much as 100 trillion electronvolts, according to the team's new study. That's all the more impressive because "Our black hole is pretty inactive compared to massive black holes sitting in other galaxies," Ballantyne noted.
Getting back to the Scientific American special issue, other articles cover topics such as the history of black hole research (which involves, among others, Albert Einstein and J. Robert Oppenheimer), the possibility of time travel, and holographic theories of the universe.
Monday, January 15, 2007
Book Review: "The Trouble with Physics"
Over the holiday break, I read Lee Smolin's book, The Trouble with Physics. I've already alluded to the book a couple of times on this blog -- citing a New Yorker magazine review of it in the posting immediately below the present one and linking to the audio of a radio interview with Smolin and Brian Greene in my August 19, 2006 entry -- so I don't think a detailed review on my part is needed.
Rather, I just want to share, briefly, a few of my major reactions to Smolin's book. First, I feel Smolin provides very clear explanations of a number of concepts in string theory, supersymmetry, etc. For example, regarding Edward Witten's famous "M-Theory" Second Superstring Revolution, in which Witten integrated the five major string theories extant at the time, Smolin explains the use of dualities to bring the theories together, in a very readable manner.
Second, from my position of having no technical training or expertise in the subject matter, just an educated layperson's interest, the book portrays string theory and supersymmetry (together known as "superstring theory") as having a fairly tenuous foundation. Even having read a number of critical writings in the past, Smolin's book has enhanced my skepticism of superstring theory. Three areas of concern are as follows:
(a) String/M theory, as I interpreted Smolin's writing, pertained to "the five consistent superstring theories in ten-dimensional spacetime," but there were "millions of variants in the cases where some dimensions were wrapped up" (p. 129). Smolin had earlier defined a mathematically consistent theory as one that, "...never gives two results that contradict each other... [and] all physical qualities the theory describes involve finite numbers" (p. 112, footnote). Ten spacetime dimensions refer to time, plus nine dimensions of space (six beyond the three we see). Further, Witten "did not actually present a new unified superstring theory; he simply proposed that it existed and that it would have certain features" (p. 129).
(b) Another concern involves the apparent malleability of the equations in superstring theory. Smolin notes that, "...the original standard model has about 20 free constants we have to adjust by hand to get predictions that agree with experiment. The [Minimally Supersymmetric Standard Model] adds 105 more free constants. The theorist is at liberty to adjust them all to ensure that the theory agrees with experiments... There turn out to be many different ways to tune the dials to ensure that all the particles we don't see are so heavy that they're as yet unseeable" (pp. 75-76).
(c) In addition, the generality of many calculations is in question. Regarding work following the second revolution, "To get any results, we had to choose special examples and conditions. In many instances, we were left not knowing whether the calculations we could do gave results that were a true guide to the general situation or not" (p. 146).
Another direction taken in an attempt to advance string theory is its potential applicability to black holes. However, such attempts "all suffer from a general problem, which is that whenever they stray from the very special black holes where we can use supersymmetry to do calculations, they fail to lead to precise results... So we are left with the same dilemma that afflicts so much research in string theory: We get marvelous results for very special cases, and we are unable to decide whether the results extend to the whole theory or are true only of the special cases where we can do the calculations" (p. 190).
The first 250 or so pages of the book, focusing on substantive theoretical physics, would probably be more than sufficiently filling (using the metaphor of "food for thought") for most readers. However, another 100 pages of more epistemological discussion follow, which leads to my third major reaction.
Smolin's perceptions of how science in general, and university-based science in particular, do operate and should operate, are reasonably interesting, as is his call for the support of unconventional thinkers. What struck me the most, however, was a possibility raised by Smolin. Perhaps what is hampering the string-theory enterprise to integrate general relativity (gravity) and quantum mechanics is that the traditionally accepted conceptualizations of relativity and quantum mechanics are themselves flawed.
After discussing some lines of inquiry questioning relativity, Smolin writes:
So much for questioning relativity. What if quantum theory is wrong? This is the soft underbelly of the whole project of quantum gravity. If quantum theory is wrong, then trying to combine it with gravity will have been a huge waste of time... (pp. 316-317).
Whether the foundations of theoretical physics will ultimately be rocked to this extent is unknown. But Smolin asks his readers to remain open-minded to a variety of possibilities.
Rather, I just want to share, briefly, a few of my major reactions to Smolin's book. First, I feel Smolin provides very clear explanations of a number of concepts in string theory, supersymmetry, etc. For example, regarding Edward Witten's famous "M-Theory" Second Superstring Revolution, in which Witten integrated the five major string theories extant at the time, Smolin explains the use of dualities to bring the theories together, in a very readable manner.
Second, from my position of having no technical training or expertise in the subject matter, just an educated layperson's interest, the book portrays string theory and supersymmetry (together known as "superstring theory") as having a fairly tenuous foundation. Even having read a number of critical writings in the past, Smolin's book has enhanced my skepticism of superstring theory. Three areas of concern are as follows:
(a) String/M theory, as I interpreted Smolin's writing, pertained to "the five consistent superstring theories in ten-dimensional spacetime," but there were "millions of variants in the cases where some dimensions were wrapped up" (p. 129). Smolin had earlier defined a mathematically consistent theory as one that, "...never gives two results that contradict each other... [and] all physical qualities the theory describes involve finite numbers" (p. 112, footnote). Ten spacetime dimensions refer to time, plus nine dimensions of space (six beyond the three we see). Further, Witten "did not actually present a new unified superstring theory; he simply proposed that it existed and that it would have certain features" (p. 129).
(b) Another concern involves the apparent malleability of the equations in superstring theory. Smolin notes that, "...the original standard model has about 20 free constants we have to adjust by hand to get predictions that agree with experiment. The [Minimally Supersymmetric Standard Model] adds 105 more free constants. The theorist is at liberty to adjust them all to ensure that the theory agrees with experiments... There turn out to be many different ways to tune the dials to ensure that all the particles we don't see are so heavy that they're as yet unseeable" (pp. 75-76).
(c) In addition, the generality of many calculations is in question. Regarding work following the second revolution, "To get any results, we had to choose special examples and conditions. In many instances, we were left not knowing whether the calculations we could do gave results that were a true guide to the general situation or not" (p. 146).
Another direction taken in an attempt to advance string theory is its potential applicability to black holes. However, such attempts "all suffer from a general problem, which is that whenever they stray from the very special black holes where we can use supersymmetry to do calculations, they fail to lead to precise results... So we are left with the same dilemma that afflicts so much research in string theory: We get marvelous results for very special cases, and we are unable to decide whether the results extend to the whole theory or are true only of the special cases where we can do the calculations" (p. 190).
The first 250 or so pages of the book, focusing on substantive theoretical physics, would probably be more than sufficiently filling (using the metaphor of "food for thought") for most readers. However, another 100 pages of more epistemological discussion follow, which leads to my third major reaction.
Smolin's perceptions of how science in general, and university-based science in particular, do operate and should operate, are reasonably interesting, as is his call for the support of unconventional thinkers. What struck me the most, however, was a possibility raised by Smolin. Perhaps what is hampering the string-theory enterprise to integrate general relativity (gravity) and quantum mechanics is that the traditionally accepted conceptualizations of relativity and quantum mechanics are themselves flawed.
After discussing some lines of inquiry questioning relativity, Smolin writes:
So much for questioning relativity. What if quantum theory is wrong? This is the soft underbelly of the whole project of quantum gravity. If quantum theory is wrong, then trying to combine it with gravity will have been a huge waste of time... (pp. 316-317).
Whether the foundations of theoretical physics will ultimately be rocked to this extent is unknown. But Smolin asks his readers to remain open-minded to a variety of possibilities.
Friday, November 24, 2006
String Theory Part V
Among my last several postings, the main focus has been string theory and criticisms thereof. One problem I said I would discuss further was the theory's lack of falsifiable predictions. Fortunately, I learned recently that a New Yorker magazine article from early fall provides a substantial discussion of this topic, so I can now draw upon the article (thanks to Matt Russell for showing me the magazine issue).
The New Yorker article reviews two books that are critical of string theory, Lee Smolin's The Trouble with Physics and Peter Woit's Not Even Wrong (the latter having a very active blog associated with it). In reviewing the books, the New Yorker piece manages also to succinctly summarize a century of research -- on general relativity, quantum mechanics, and the standard model of particle physics -- leading up to today's controversies. Some key quotes from the article are as follows:
Today, more than a decade after the second revolution, the theory formerly known as strings [the article alludes to the more recent "M theory"] remains a seductive conjecture rather than an actual set of equations, and the non-uniqueness problem has grown to ridiculous proportions. At the latest count, the number of string theories is estimated to be something like one followed by five hundred zeros...
In their books against string theory, Smolin and Woit view the anthropic approach as a betrayal of science. Both agree with Karl Popper’s dictum that if a theory is to be scientific it must be open to falsification. But string theory, Woit points out, is like Alice’s Restaurant, where, as Arlo Guthrie’s song had it, “you can get anything you want.” It comes in so many versions that it predicts anything and everything. In that sense, string theory is, in the words of Woit’s title, “not even wrong.”
[A brief description from Seed Magazine of the aforementioned anthropic principle and the associated concept of a landscape is available here. A Scientific American article that fleshes out these ideas in greater depth is introduced here; this article can either be purchased online or looked up at a library.]
In his book The Theory of Almost Everything, on the standard model, George Mason University physicist Robert Oerter notes that there actually are some empirical predictions that follow from string theory (pp. 273-274). These predictions involve very massive particles, fractionally charged particles, deviations in how gravity behaves for very small and large objects, and light from distant galaxies -- and all have failed to be confirmed by observation.
Oerter asks, "With so many negative experimental results, why do physicists continue to be excited about string theory?" His answer: "The experiments that have been performed rule out some versions of string theory, but there are literally billions of other versions that could still be true."
The New Yorker article reviews two books that are critical of string theory, Lee Smolin's The Trouble with Physics and Peter Woit's Not Even Wrong (the latter having a very active blog associated with it). In reviewing the books, the New Yorker piece manages also to succinctly summarize a century of research -- on general relativity, quantum mechanics, and the standard model of particle physics -- leading up to today's controversies. Some key quotes from the article are as follows:
Today, more than a decade after the second revolution, the theory formerly known as strings [the article alludes to the more recent "M theory"] remains a seductive conjecture rather than an actual set of equations, and the non-uniqueness problem has grown to ridiculous proportions. At the latest count, the number of string theories is estimated to be something like one followed by five hundred zeros...
In their books against string theory, Smolin and Woit view the anthropic approach as a betrayal of science. Both agree with Karl Popper’s dictum that if a theory is to be scientific it must be open to falsification. But string theory, Woit points out, is like Alice’s Restaurant, where, as Arlo Guthrie’s song had it, “you can get anything you want.” It comes in so many versions that it predicts anything and everything. In that sense, string theory is, in the words of Woit’s title, “not even wrong.”
[A brief description from Seed Magazine of the aforementioned anthropic principle and the associated concept of a landscape is available here. A Scientific American article that fleshes out these ideas in greater depth is introduced here; this article can either be purchased online or looked up at a library.]
In his book The Theory of Almost Everything, on the standard model, George Mason University physicist Robert Oerter notes that there actually are some empirical predictions that follow from string theory (pp. 273-274). These predictions involve very massive particles, fractionally charged particles, deviations in how gravity behaves for very small and large objects, and light from distant galaxies -- and all have failed to be confirmed by observation.
Oerter asks, "With so many negative experimental results, why do physicists continue to be excited about string theory?" His answer: "The experiments that have been performed rule out some versions of string theory, but there are literally billions of other versions that could still be true."
Monday, November 06, 2006
Coefficient of Restitution for Bounces of the New NBA Basketball
Let's take a little break from the discussion of string theory.
With the start of the National Basketball Association (NBA) season about a week ago, the new type of ball being used has attracted much attention.

As can be seen in the photo, the new ball differs from the old kind not just in its replacement of leather with a synthetic surface, but also in the design of the segments of the exterior.
I learned from this ESPN.com article about some scientific research being conducted on the new balls. At the request of Dallas Mavericks owner Mark Cuban, physicists at the University of Texas-Arlington tested the performance of the new ball vs. the old kind.
One of the tests was of the height of the bounce of the new versus old types of basketball. Having read University of Nebraska professor Timothy Gay's book Football Physics a while back, I immediately thought of the relevant physics term, the Coefficient of Restitution (COR). As described in the linked document, the COR has a very simple formula, especially when the tested object is being dropped onto a stationary surface.
I did some searching of UT-Arlington webpages and came upon this project website for the basketball studies. From the project site, you can access a copy of the report submitted to the Mavericks, as well as other pages related to the research. Indeed the COR was a major element mentioned in the research report.
Another interesting aspect of the UT-A investigations dealt with the absorption of moisture (which the new ball is designed to prevent) and how that affects the ball.
Of course, the main thing a basketball does in a game is go through the hoop and net. I guess this posting did have something to do with strings, after all.
With the start of the National Basketball Association (NBA) season about a week ago, the new type of ball being used has attracted much attention.

As can be seen in the photo, the new ball differs from the old kind not just in its replacement of leather with a synthetic surface, but also in the design of the segments of the exterior.
I learned from this ESPN.com article about some scientific research being conducted on the new balls. At the request of Dallas Mavericks owner Mark Cuban, physicists at the University of Texas-Arlington tested the performance of the new ball vs. the old kind.
One of the tests was of the height of the bounce of the new versus old types of basketball. Having read University of Nebraska professor Timothy Gay's book Football Physics a while back, I immediately thought of the relevant physics term, the Coefficient of Restitution (COR). As described in the linked document, the COR has a very simple formula, especially when the tested object is being dropped onto a stationary surface.
I did some searching of UT-Arlington webpages and came upon this project website for the basketball studies. From the project site, you can access a copy of the report submitted to the Mavericks, as well as other pages related to the research. Indeed the COR was a major element mentioned in the research report.
Another interesting aspect of the UT-A investigations dealt with the absorption of moisture (which the new ball is designed to prevent) and how that affects the ball.
Of course, the main thing a basketball does in a game is go through the hoop and net. I guess this posting did have something to do with strings, after all.
Thursday, October 26, 2006
String Theory Part IV
In addition to the controversy over proposed extra dimensions (discussed in my previous posting), a second line of argument voiced by string theory critics involves what some have called the "disconnect" between string theory and traditional empirical research.
In an interview done with the PBS show NOVA in conjunction with the network's documentary on "The Elegant Universe," Nobel laureate Sheldon Glashow critiques this aspect of string theory in several quotes:
It's called superstring theory and it is, so far as I can see, totally divorced from experiment or observation. If not totally divorced, pretty well divorced...
No experiment can ever check up what's going on at the distances that are being studied. No observation can relate to these tiny distances or high energies...
[String theory] gives a quantum theory of gravity that appears to be consistent but doesn't make any other predictions. That is to say, there ain't no experiment that could be done nor is there any observation that could be made that would say, "You guys are wrong." The theory is safe, permanently safe. I ask you, is that a theory of physics or a philosophy?...
Two subthemes from Glashow's quotes are thus the seeming impossibility (now and for as long as many people can envision) of studying strings in traditional particle accelerators, and the lack of falsifiable predictions on the part of string theorists. The remainder of today's posting will focus on the first of these problems, with the second to be addressed in a later entry.
The basic idea in string theory is that each of the known particles in physics (e.g., an electron, a gluon) is distinguished by its own "signature" pattern of string vibrations (see the quotes from Brian Greene's book The Fabric of the Cosmos that I included in this earlier posting).
These strings are thought to be extremely small ("...so small that a direct observation would be tantamount to reading the text on this page from a distance of 100 light-years...", Greene, p. 352). Further, extremely high energy collisions are needed to jolt these tiny strings into their various vibrational patterns. However, as Greene acknowledges, current accelerators are "far too feeble to excite any but string theory's most placid vibrational patterns" (p. 358).
Elaborating on the same thing, a December 7, 2004 New York Times article by Dennis Overbye on string theory notes that:
Strings are generally presumed to be so small that "stringy" effects should show up only when particles are smashed together at prohibitive energies, roughly 10^19 [10 raised to the 19th power] billion electron volts. That is orders of magnitude beyond the capability of any particle accelerator that will ever be built on earth.
Fear not, seems to be Greene's attitude: "While we may never have technology capable of seeing strings directly, the history of science is replete with theories that were tested experimentally through indirect means" (p. 352).
In an interview done with the PBS show NOVA in conjunction with the network's documentary on "The Elegant Universe," Nobel laureate Sheldon Glashow critiques this aspect of string theory in several quotes:
It's called superstring theory and it is, so far as I can see, totally divorced from experiment or observation. If not totally divorced, pretty well divorced...
No experiment can ever check up what's going on at the distances that are being studied. No observation can relate to these tiny distances or high energies...
[String theory] gives a quantum theory of gravity that appears to be consistent but doesn't make any other predictions. That is to say, there ain't no experiment that could be done nor is there any observation that could be made that would say, "You guys are wrong." The theory is safe, permanently safe. I ask you, is that a theory of physics or a philosophy?...
Two subthemes from Glashow's quotes are thus the seeming impossibility (now and for as long as many people can envision) of studying strings in traditional particle accelerators, and the lack of falsifiable predictions on the part of string theorists. The remainder of today's posting will focus on the first of these problems, with the second to be addressed in a later entry.
The basic idea in string theory is that each of the known particles in physics (e.g., an electron, a gluon) is distinguished by its own "signature" pattern of string vibrations (see the quotes from Brian Greene's book The Fabric of the Cosmos that I included in this earlier posting).
These strings are thought to be extremely small ("...so small that a direct observation would be tantamount to reading the text on this page from a distance of 100 light-years...", Greene, p. 352). Further, extremely high energy collisions are needed to jolt these tiny strings into their various vibrational patterns. However, as Greene acknowledges, current accelerators are "far too feeble to excite any but string theory's most placid vibrational patterns" (p. 358).
Elaborating on the same thing, a December 7, 2004 New York Times article by Dennis Overbye on string theory notes that:
Strings are generally presumed to be so small that "stringy" effects should show up only when particles are smashed together at prohibitive energies, roughly 10^19 [10 raised to the 19th power] billion electron volts. That is orders of magnitude beyond the capability of any particle accelerator that will ever be built on earth.
Fear not, seems to be Greene's attitude: "While we may never have technology capable of seeing strings directly, the history of science is replete with theories that were tested experimentally through indirect means" (p. 352).
Sunday, September 17, 2006
String Theory Part III
Today begins discussion of what many consider some of the flaws or weaknesses of string theory (or, as it is often called, superstring theory, due to its "merger" with supersymmetry, which I will discuss later).
The first concerns whether there are dimensions of space beyond the three we're used to thinking about: west-east (or left-right), north-south (or forward-backward), and up-down (or higher-lower). In The Fabric of the Cosmos, Brian Greene summarizes the situation as he sees it:
...at the top of the skeptics' list of superstring theory's shortcomings was a feature I've yet to introduce. Superstring theory does indeed provide a successful merger of gravity and quantum mechanics, one that is free of the mathematical inconsistencies that plagued all previous attempts. However, strange as it may sound, in the early years after its discovery, physicists found that the equations of superstring theory do not have these enviable properties if the universe has three spatial dimensions. Instead, the equations of superstring theory are mathematically consistent only if the universe has nine spatial dimensions, or, including the time dimension, they work only in a universe with ten spacetime dimensions! (p. 359)
Further refinements, as Greene also notes, now require 11 spacetime dimensions, seven more than have ever been seen (here's another article that discusses this issue).
Here's how Greene explains the need for the extra dimensions:
If a string can vibrate in a fourth spatial dimension, it can execute more vibrational patterns than it could in only three; if a string can vibrate in a fifth spatial dimension, it can execute more vibrational patterns than it could in only four; and so on... but with nine space dimensions [later found to be ten], the constraint on the number of vibrational patterns is satisfied perfectly (pp. 370-371).
Further, with the work of some creative physicists and mathematicians -- some of it going back roughly 85 years -- ideas for accommodating extra dimensions are readily available.
Under what is known as the Kaluza-Klein model, one can envision how a garden hose, fully elongated, would appear to represent one dimension. However, if one considers the circumference of the hose's width, that could be an extra dimension (I think it's fitting to use the example of a hose to present this "watered-down" explanation). This hose illustration can be seen at the following website, in the first diagram under Kaluza's picture.
A more complex figure, known as a Calabi-Yau manifold, has been proposed as being able to account possibly for six additional dimensions.
Within the past year or so, two major books by physicists have come out, specifically on the topic of extra dimensions. One, by Lawrence Krauss, is entitled Hiding in the Mirror, whereas the other, by Lisa Randall, is entitled Warped Passages. My interest level would warrant reading one of the two books and, based on this recommendation, I chose Krauss's. I found it reasonably interesting.
The first concerns whether there are dimensions of space beyond the three we're used to thinking about: west-east (or left-right), north-south (or forward-backward), and up-down (or higher-lower). In The Fabric of the Cosmos, Brian Greene summarizes the situation as he sees it:
...at the top of the skeptics' list of superstring theory's shortcomings was a feature I've yet to introduce. Superstring theory does indeed provide a successful merger of gravity and quantum mechanics, one that is free of the mathematical inconsistencies that plagued all previous attempts. However, strange as it may sound, in the early years after its discovery, physicists found that the equations of superstring theory do not have these enviable properties if the universe has three spatial dimensions. Instead, the equations of superstring theory are mathematically consistent only if the universe has nine spatial dimensions, or, including the time dimension, they work only in a universe with ten spacetime dimensions! (p. 359)
Further refinements, as Greene also notes, now require 11 spacetime dimensions, seven more than have ever been seen (here's another article that discusses this issue).
Here's how Greene explains the need for the extra dimensions:
If a string can vibrate in a fourth spatial dimension, it can execute more vibrational patterns than it could in only three; if a string can vibrate in a fifth spatial dimension, it can execute more vibrational patterns than it could in only four; and so on... but with nine space dimensions [later found to be ten], the constraint on the number of vibrational patterns is satisfied perfectly (pp. 370-371).
Further, with the work of some creative physicists and mathematicians -- some of it going back roughly 85 years -- ideas for accommodating extra dimensions are readily available.
Under what is known as the Kaluza-Klein model, one can envision how a garden hose, fully elongated, would appear to represent one dimension. However, if one considers the circumference of the hose's width, that could be an extra dimension (I think it's fitting to use the example of a hose to present this "watered-down" explanation). This hose illustration can be seen at the following website, in the first diagram under Kaluza's picture.
A more complex figure, known as a Calabi-Yau manifold, has been proposed as being able to account possibly for six additional dimensions.
Within the past year or so, two major books by physicists have come out, specifically on the topic of extra dimensions. One, by Lawrence Krauss, is entitled Hiding in the Mirror, whereas the other, by Lisa Randall, is entitled Warped Passages. My interest level would warrant reading one of the two books and, based on this recommendation, I chose Krauss's. I found it reasonably interesting.
Saturday, September 09, 2006
String Theory Part II
Let's resume the discussion of string theory, which I introduced in my August 15, 2006 posting. String theory is considered very controversial. To understand why, it will be useful to review the arguments in its favor and in opposition. Today's posting will cover the former, with the latter to come later. Much of my discussion of string theory will come from the book The Fabric of the Cosmos by Brian Greene, a well-known proponent of strings, but someone who seems open to the possibility that the whole idea could be wrong.
To many, the most compelling argument on behalf of string theory is its potential to unify two heretofore incompatible major ideas in physics -- general relativity and quantum mechanics -- in the spirit of Einstein's quest for a "theory of everything." (The original question motivating the development of string theory did not involve such unification, however.)
A few excerpts from Greene summarize the current state of affairs.
Years of astronomical observations have shown that general relativity describes the macro world of stars, galaxies, and even the entire expanse of the cosmos with impressive accuracy; decades of experiments have confirmed that quantum mechanics does the same for the micro world of molecules, atoms, and subatomic particles (p. 336).
...the incompatibility between general relativity and quantum mechanics rears its head in a very specific way. If you use the combined equations of general relativity and quantum mechanics, they almost always yield one answer: infinity. And that's a problem. It's nonsense. Experimenters never measure an infinite amount of anything... (p. 335).
Since [general relativity and quantum mechanics] works wonders in its own domain, why worry about combining them?... For physicists, though, the existence of a realm in which the known laws of physics break down -- no matter how esoteric the realm might seem -- throws up red flags. If the known laws of physics break down under any circumstances, it is a clear signal that we have not reached the deepest possible understanding... (pp. 336-337).
Enter string theory, which at the conceptual stage, makes the two theories compatible. Greene provides a detailed explanation of why this is so, on pp. 348-350, having to do with strings' putting a limit on how small entities can get, thus "avoid[ing] the catastrophic clash between quantum mechanics and general relativity."
Also, because general relativity is a theory of gravity, string theory integrates gravity with the other forces (electromagnetic, strong, and weak), which are all quantum theories within the Standard Model of particle physics.
String theory appears to look good, thus far. Its difficulties will be discussed in future postings.
[For additional background material, I wrote about general relativity on June 4, 2005, and about quantum mechanics in a series of entries from July 27-September 22, 2005. See the archives in the right-hand column of this page.]
To many, the most compelling argument on behalf of string theory is its potential to unify two heretofore incompatible major ideas in physics -- general relativity and quantum mechanics -- in the spirit of Einstein's quest for a "theory of everything." (The original question motivating the development of string theory did not involve such unification, however.)
A few excerpts from Greene summarize the current state of affairs.
Years of astronomical observations have shown that general relativity describes the macro world of stars, galaxies, and even the entire expanse of the cosmos with impressive accuracy; decades of experiments have confirmed that quantum mechanics does the same for the micro world of molecules, atoms, and subatomic particles (p. 336).
...the incompatibility between general relativity and quantum mechanics rears its head in a very specific way. If you use the combined equations of general relativity and quantum mechanics, they almost always yield one answer: infinity. And that's a problem. It's nonsense. Experimenters never measure an infinite amount of anything... (p. 335).
Since [general relativity and quantum mechanics] works wonders in its own domain, why worry about combining them?... For physicists, though, the existence of a realm in which the known laws of physics break down -- no matter how esoteric the realm might seem -- throws up red flags. If the known laws of physics break down under any circumstances, it is a clear signal that we have not reached the deepest possible understanding... (pp. 336-337).
Enter string theory, which at the conceptual stage, makes the two theories compatible. Greene provides a detailed explanation of why this is so, on pp. 348-350, having to do with strings' putting a limit on how small entities can get, thus "avoid[ing] the catastrophic clash between quantum mechanics and general relativity."
Also, because general relativity is a theory of gravity, string theory integrates gravity with the other forces (electromagnetic, strong, and weak), which are all quantum theories within the Standard Model of particle physics.
String theory appears to look good, thus far. Its difficulties will be discussed in future postings.
[For additional background material, I wrote about general relativity on June 4, 2005, and about quantum mechanics in a series of entries from July 27-September 22, 2005. See the archives in the right-hand column of this page.]
Friday, August 25, 2006
"Demotion" of Pluto as a Planet
As occasionally happens, a science-related development is one of the leading stories in the news, at the moment. I'm referring, of course, to the "demotion" of Pluto from the rank of planet.
What happened is that the International Astronomical Union (IAU) adopted a new definition of what constitutes a planet, which Pluto no longer meets. According to the Wikipedia summary of this matter, the following definition was adopted:
...A planet is a celestial body that (a) is in orbit around the Sun, (b) has sufficient mass for its self-gravity to overcome rigid body forces so that it assumes a hydrostatic equilibrium (nearly round) shape, and (c) has cleared the neighbourhood around its orbit.
As seen in this list of objects in the solar system ranked by mass, Pluto is pretty far down.
The references to mass and gravity, of course, implicate Newtonian physics (many universities have a "Department of Physics and Astronomy," thus illustrating the interconnectedness of the two disciplines). As conveyed on the Wikipedia's gravity page:
Newton’s law of gravitation states that: every particle in the universe attracts every other particle with a force that is directly proportional to the product of their masses and inversely proportional to the square of the distance between them.
Further:
Every planetary body, including the Earth, is surrounded by its own gravitational field, which exerts an attractive force on any object that comes under its influence. This field is proportional to the body's mass and varies inversely with the square of distance from the body.
A couple of areas warrant further discussion, in my view. First, I had never heard of the term "self-gravity" until seeing it in the new definition of planet (above). Professor Dave Hanes of Queen's University of Canada has a website that addresses several aspects of gravity. Most relevant to the aforementioned definition is a section of his site entitled "Self-Gravity Can Determine Form," excerpts of which follow:
So far my discussion of scales and function has focussed on things like ants and elephants, which are affected by the gravity of some nearby immense object like the Earth... Moreover, the gravitational force of nearby human-scale objects, even fairly large ones, can safely be ignored. For instance, when you walk past a city bus, you don't have to worry about its gravitational attraction pulling you off the sidewalk and into the road...
In astronomy, by contrast, we are dealing with very large bodies, like planets and stars. They are dominated by self-gravity, by which I mean that the shape and proportions of any object this big are determined by the way in which the various parts of it feel and respond to the gravitational forces exerted by its own other parts. This consideration explains, among other things, why the Earth and all sufficiently large objects must be spherical (or nearly so).
Why should this be? Why couldn't the Earth take on any shape into which we might choose to sculpt it? After all, you are used to the idea that the rocks of the Earth are very rigid and inflexible, at least the ones immediately beneath our feet. Couldn't you mould the Earth into any shape you desired, given sufficiently powerful earth-movers and other equipment?
The answer is no. Suppose, for instance, you tried to use enormous bulldozers to raise mountains to a height of even just a few tens of kilometers. You would not succeed: the sheer weight of material pressing down on the lower layers would overwhelm the structural strength provided by the rocks, and they would slump and flow sideways. The new-built mountain would collapse...
From the known strengths of materials, in fact, you can calculate just about how big a mountain could ever be, here on the Earth: it works out to be roughly the size of Mount Everest. On Mars, which is a smaller planet, the gravity is less, and mountains can be about three times larger. Remarkably, this was known before any spacecraft ever visited Mars, and Carl Sagan, an astronomer at Cornell, predicted that we might find such a huge mountain on Mars - which we did! It is called Olympus Mons (Mount Olympus); it is the largest mountain in the Solar System.
In astronomy, therefore, any body of sufficiently large size, bigger than a few hundred kilometers in diameter, MUST be spherical (although to be absolutely correct I should point out that if it is spinning very rapidly, it can be somewhat flattened out, although still possessing a very smooth and regular surface). The important thing to remember is that the apparently very irregular surface of the Earth, with features like hills, mountains, and valleys, is quite misleading: these features are big only compared to us. Relative to the size of the Earth itself, these features are tiny and easily understood in terms of the limited strengths of rocks and minerals, as I have noted. Bigger features simply could not survive.
By the way, if you were to build a scale model of the Earth about a meter in diameter, like a very large beach ball, even the very highest mountains on it would be represented by little bumps about half a millimeter in height, scarcely detectable to the touch. The surface of the Earth is actually remarkably smooth.
Another part of the new definition of planet is that the entity must "clear the neighborhood." The Wikipedia's page on that subject states the following:
The phrase refers to an orbiting body (a planet or protoplanet) "sweeping out" its orbital region over time, by gravitationally interacting with smaller bodies nearby. Over many orbital cycles, a large body will tend to cause small bodies either to accrete with it, or to be disturbed to another orbit. As a consequence it does not then share its orbital region with other bodies of significant size, except for its own satellites, or those governed by its own gravitational influence.
The bottom line:
Pluto has not cleared the neighborhood of its orbit (vis-Ã -vis Neptune and Kuiper Belt Objects such as the Plutinos)...
Indeed, failure to clear the neighborhood appears to be Pluto's primary deficiency. According to the following BBC article:
Charon was discovered in 1978... Until now, it has been regarded as a moon of Pluto. But both Pluto and Charon have enough mass to be spherical - both bodies independently satisfy the proposed definition of a planet.
I highly recommend this BBC document, written in Q & A format, for readers who want to investigate the Pluto story in greater detail.
What happened is that the International Astronomical Union (IAU) adopted a new definition of what constitutes a planet, which Pluto no longer meets. According to the Wikipedia summary of this matter, the following definition was adopted:
...A planet is a celestial body that (a) is in orbit around the Sun, (b) has sufficient mass for its self-gravity to overcome rigid body forces so that it assumes a hydrostatic equilibrium (nearly round) shape, and (c) has cleared the neighbourhood around its orbit.
As seen in this list of objects in the solar system ranked by mass, Pluto is pretty far down.
The references to mass and gravity, of course, implicate Newtonian physics (many universities have a "Department of Physics and Astronomy," thus illustrating the interconnectedness of the two disciplines). As conveyed on the Wikipedia's gravity page:
Newton’s law of gravitation states that: every particle in the universe attracts every other particle with a force that is directly proportional to the product of their masses and inversely proportional to the square of the distance between them.
Further:
Every planetary body, including the Earth, is surrounded by its own gravitational field, which exerts an attractive force on any object that comes under its influence. This field is proportional to the body's mass and varies inversely with the square of distance from the body.
A couple of areas warrant further discussion, in my view. First, I had never heard of the term "self-gravity" until seeing it in the new definition of planet (above). Professor Dave Hanes of Queen's University of Canada has a website that addresses several aspects of gravity. Most relevant to the aforementioned definition is a section of his site entitled "Self-Gravity Can Determine Form," excerpts of which follow:
So far my discussion of scales and function has focussed on things like ants and elephants, which are affected by the gravity of some nearby immense object like the Earth... Moreover, the gravitational force of nearby human-scale objects, even fairly large ones, can safely be ignored. For instance, when you walk past a city bus, you don't have to worry about its gravitational attraction pulling you off the sidewalk and into the road...
In astronomy, by contrast, we are dealing with very large bodies, like planets and stars. They are dominated by self-gravity, by which I mean that the shape and proportions of any object this big are determined by the way in which the various parts of it feel and respond to the gravitational forces exerted by its own other parts. This consideration explains, among other things, why the Earth and all sufficiently large objects must be spherical (or nearly so).
Why should this be? Why couldn't the Earth take on any shape into which we might choose to sculpt it? After all, you are used to the idea that the rocks of the Earth are very rigid and inflexible, at least the ones immediately beneath our feet. Couldn't you mould the Earth into any shape you desired, given sufficiently powerful earth-movers and other equipment?
The answer is no. Suppose, for instance, you tried to use enormous bulldozers to raise mountains to a height of even just a few tens of kilometers. You would not succeed: the sheer weight of material pressing down on the lower layers would overwhelm the structural strength provided by the rocks, and they would slump and flow sideways. The new-built mountain would collapse...
From the known strengths of materials, in fact, you can calculate just about how big a mountain could ever be, here on the Earth: it works out to be roughly the size of Mount Everest. On Mars, which is a smaller planet, the gravity is less, and mountains can be about three times larger. Remarkably, this was known before any spacecraft ever visited Mars, and Carl Sagan, an astronomer at Cornell, predicted that we might find such a huge mountain on Mars - which we did! It is called Olympus Mons (Mount Olympus); it is the largest mountain in the Solar System.
In astronomy, therefore, any body of sufficiently large size, bigger than a few hundred kilometers in diameter, MUST be spherical (although to be absolutely correct I should point out that if it is spinning very rapidly, it can be somewhat flattened out, although still possessing a very smooth and regular surface). The important thing to remember is that the apparently very irregular surface of the Earth, with features like hills, mountains, and valleys, is quite misleading: these features are big only compared to us. Relative to the size of the Earth itself, these features are tiny and easily understood in terms of the limited strengths of rocks and minerals, as I have noted. Bigger features simply could not survive.
By the way, if you were to build a scale model of the Earth about a meter in diameter, like a very large beach ball, even the very highest mountains on it would be represented by little bumps about half a millimeter in height, scarcely detectable to the touch. The surface of the Earth is actually remarkably smooth.
Another part of the new definition of planet is that the entity must "clear the neighborhood." The Wikipedia's page on that subject states the following:
The phrase refers to an orbiting body (a planet or protoplanet) "sweeping out" its orbital region over time, by gravitationally interacting with smaller bodies nearby. Over many orbital cycles, a large body will tend to cause small bodies either to accrete with it, or to be disturbed to another orbit. As a consequence it does not then share its orbital region with other bodies of significant size, except for its own satellites, or those governed by its own gravitational influence.
The bottom line:
Pluto has not cleared the neighborhood of its orbit (vis-Ã -vis Neptune and Kuiper Belt Objects such as the Plutinos)...
Indeed, failure to clear the neighborhood appears to be Pluto's primary deficiency. According to the following BBC article:
Charon was discovered in 1978... Until now, it has been regarded as a moon of Pluto. But both Pluto and Charon have enough mass to be spherical - both bodies independently satisfy the proposed definition of a planet.
I highly recommend this BBC document, written in Q & A format, for readers who want to investigate the Pluto story in greater detail.
Saturday, August 19, 2006
Brian Greene and Lee Smolin on National Public Radio
Good timing! With my first substantial posting on string theory having just recently been posted (immediately below), it turned out to have been just in time for yesterday's National Public Radio "Science Friday" show, which featured a discussion of string theory with Brian Greene and Lee Smolin. You can now listen to the archived audio here.
Tuesday, August 15, 2006
String Theory Part I
In the year and a half, roughly, that I've been operating this blog, I haven't yet talked about string theory. Actually, I can think of at least one instance where I've referred to string theory, only to say that we should ignore it at that point.
In one of my very first entries (March 18, 2005), I linked to this diagram of the components of matter at ever-decreasing scales: ordinary matter, molecules, atoms, and sub-atomic particles. I then noted that:
Actually, the figure depicts one additional set of entities down the smallness scale, called "strings;" string theory is very controversial, so for now we'll stop at sub-atomic particles.
In my March and April 2005 postings (see month-by-month archives on the right-hand side of the page, midway down) I talked about a variety of sub-atomic particles, both matter particles (e.g., electrons, quarks) and force-carrying particles (e.g., photons, gluons).
The basic idea of string theory, stated simply then, is that these particles themselves are made out of incredibly small strings, or as Brian Greene sometimes refers to them, "tiny filaments of energy" that behave like strings. As Greene elaborates on pp. 346-347 of his book, The Fabric of the Cosmos:
...the wealth of particle species simply reflects the different vibrational patterns that a string can execute. It's just like what happens with more familiar strings like those on a violin or cello. A cello string can vibrate in many different ways, and we hear each pattern as a different musical note... A [physics] string vibrating in one particular pattern might have the properties of an electron, while a string vibrating in a different pattern might have the properties of an up-quark...
OK, so I've now introduced string theory. Now seems like a good time to do so, with books, media articles (most recently in Time Magazine), and blogs bringing string theory to the general public with seemingly unprecedented volume and vigor.
Also, the current schedule calls for the Large Hadron Collider (LHC), the latest and most energetic experimental particle physics facility, to open in November 2007, a little over a year from now (although the full phase-in to the major experiments, never mind the results of them, will take at least several months beyond the opening of the collider).
I don't believe anyone expects direct evidence of strings to be found at the LHC, but some phenomena that bear more indirectly on string theory could be found.
For all these reasons, the focus of my postings over the next year will generally fall into three categories: additional key issues in string theory; related topics such as supersymmetry and extra dimensions; and the workings of particle accelerators and colliders.
Discussion of all of these issues in a single blog posting is impractical, so I'll have to "string you along."
In one of my very first entries (March 18, 2005), I linked to this diagram of the components of matter at ever-decreasing scales: ordinary matter, molecules, atoms, and sub-atomic particles. I then noted that:
Actually, the figure depicts one additional set of entities down the smallness scale, called "strings;" string theory is very controversial, so for now we'll stop at sub-atomic particles.
In my March and April 2005 postings (see month-by-month archives on the right-hand side of the page, midway down) I talked about a variety of sub-atomic particles, both matter particles (e.g., electrons, quarks) and force-carrying particles (e.g., photons, gluons).
The basic idea of string theory, stated simply then, is that these particles themselves are made out of incredibly small strings, or as Brian Greene sometimes refers to them, "tiny filaments of energy" that behave like strings. As Greene elaborates on pp. 346-347 of his book, The Fabric of the Cosmos:
...the wealth of particle species simply reflects the different vibrational patterns that a string can execute. It's just like what happens with more familiar strings like those on a violin or cello. A cello string can vibrate in many different ways, and we hear each pattern as a different musical note... A [physics] string vibrating in one particular pattern might have the properties of an electron, while a string vibrating in a different pattern might have the properties of an up-quark...
OK, so I've now introduced string theory. Now seems like a good time to do so, with books, media articles (most recently in Time Magazine), and blogs bringing string theory to the general public with seemingly unprecedented volume and vigor.
Also, the current schedule calls for the Large Hadron Collider (LHC), the latest and most energetic experimental particle physics facility, to open in November 2007, a little over a year from now (although the full phase-in to the major experiments, never mind the results of them, will take at least several months beyond the opening of the collider).
I don't believe anyone expects direct evidence of strings to be found at the LHC, but some phenomena that bear more indirectly on string theory could be found.
For all these reasons, the focus of my postings over the next year will generally fall into three categories: additional key issues in string theory; related topics such as supersymmetry and extra dimensions; and the workings of particle accelerators and colliders.
Discussion of all of these issues in a single blog posting is impractical, so I'll have to "string you along."
Sunday, July 30, 2006
Condensed Matter Physics
If you've visited this blog before, you've probably gathered that my two favorite areas of physics are particle/high energy physics and applications of physics to sports. Another area of physics, which I'd like to discuss today, is condensed matter physics, which, according to this Wikipedia summary:
...deals with the macroscopic physical properties of matter. In particular, it is concerned with the "condensed" phases that appear whenever the number of constituents in a system is extremely large and the interactions between the constituents are strong. The most familiar examples of condensed phases are solids and liquids, which arise from the bonding and electromagnetic force between atoms.
As also discussed in the Wikipedia document, the term solid state physics has often been used, but the term "condensed matter" is more general, taking in both solids and fluids. One additional fact from the same source is that, "Condensed matter physics is by far the largest field of contemporary physics... By one estimate, one third of all American physicists identify themselves as condensed matter physicists."
The late, legendary particle theorist Richard Feynman, who also worked on some condensed matter topics, noted the following roughly two decades ago in his book QED:
The branches of physics that deal with questions such as why iron (with 26 protons) is magnetic, while copper (with 29) is not, or why one gas is transparent and another one is not, are called "solid-state physics," or "liquid-state physics," or "honest physics"... The most interesting problems today -- and certainly the most practical problems -- are obviously in solid-state physics (p. 114).
Yet another perspective comes from the UCLA physics department's overview of its condensed matter physics program. I found this information to be surprisingly readable for a non-physicist such as myself, at least in the initial sections before the faculty members' research interests are discussed. According to this document:
...microscopic equations which describe an individual water molecule are of limited use when it comes to describing the macroscopic properties of matter, as are more refined descriptions at the atomic or subatomic scales... An entirely new set of concepts... must be introduced, such as temperature, entropy, and phase. The concept of temperature, for instance, makes no sense for an individual water molecule, but one can hardly understand a macroscopic body of water without it. These properties only emerge at macroscopic scales, which are the most interesting and important scales for humankind.
Further:
In considering such a perspective, one is immediately faced with such questions as why is a solid solid? If you open the door to a sauna and try to push against the steam which streams out, the water molecules near your hand will move out of the way, and your hand (and, eventually the rest of you) will be bathed in steam. This is precisely what you would naively expect of a collection of molecules, each of which acts fairly independently of the others in moving around your hand. However, if you try the same thing with a block of ice, the whole block will move as one. How can this be? The answer is that the water molecules interact strongly with each other in order to form one highly correlated whole in which the oxygen and hydrogen atoms sit as the sites of a rather rigid lattice. The same is true of all crystaline solids. Such highly correlated states are said to be condensed; it is their study which is the subject of condensed matter physics.
(The bold emphases in the above paragraph were added by me.)
What I glean from these descriptions is that condensed matter physics deals with coordinated structures of aggregating molecules. I'll conclude with two interesting examples of condensed matter physics, one of which is likely to be known to the general public, and the other of which won the 2001 Nobel Prize, having been inspired by one of Einstein's lesser-known ideas (at least "relative" to relativity and E = mc-squared).
Somewhere along the line, most people have probably heard the term superconductivity. Non-technical readers will probably want to skip down to the "Applications" section of the linked document, where technologies such as MRI are discussed.
The other example is the Bose-Einstein condensate, for which three researchers won the Nobel Prize. The Physics 2000 project at the University of Colorado, Boulder, has a nice multiple-page tutorial on Bose-Einstein condensates, including interactive, animated demonstrations (two of the three Nobel winners on this topic also happen to be based in Boulder). As you click through the Bose-Einstein tutorial, be sure to scroll down to the bottom of each page, to be sure to see the interactive exhibits (they also may take a little time to load, so be patient).
...deals with the macroscopic physical properties of matter. In particular, it is concerned with the "condensed" phases that appear whenever the number of constituents in a system is extremely large and the interactions between the constituents are strong. The most familiar examples of condensed phases are solids and liquids, which arise from the bonding and electromagnetic force between atoms.
As also discussed in the Wikipedia document, the term solid state physics has often been used, but the term "condensed matter" is more general, taking in both solids and fluids. One additional fact from the same source is that, "Condensed matter physics is by far the largest field of contemporary physics... By one estimate, one third of all American physicists identify themselves as condensed matter physicists."
The late, legendary particle theorist Richard Feynman, who also worked on some condensed matter topics, noted the following roughly two decades ago in his book QED:
The branches of physics that deal with questions such as why iron (with 26 protons) is magnetic, while copper (with 29) is not, or why one gas is transparent and another one is not, are called "solid-state physics," or "liquid-state physics," or "honest physics"... The most interesting problems today -- and certainly the most practical problems -- are obviously in solid-state physics (p. 114).
Yet another perspective comes from the UCLA physics department's overview of its condensed matter physics program. I found this information to be surprisingly readable for a non-physicist such as myself, at least in the initial sections before the faculty members' research interests are discussed. According to this document:
...microscopic equations which describe an individual water molecule are of limited use when it comes to describing the macroscopic properties of matter, as are more refined descriptions at the atomic or subatomic scales... An entirely new set of concepts... must be introduced, such as temperature, entropy, and phase. The concept of temperature, for instance, makes no sense for an individual water molecule, but one can hardly understand a macroscopic body of water without it. These properties only emerge at macroscopic scales, which are the most interesting and important scales for humankind.
Further:
In considering such a perspective, one is immediately faced with such questions as why is a solid solid? If you open the door to a sauna and try to push against the steam which streams out, the water molecules near your hand will move out of the way, and your hand (and, eventually the rest of you) will be bathed in steam. This is precisely what you would naively expect of a collection of molecules, each of which acts fairly independently of the others in moving around your hand. However, if you try the same thing with a block of ice, the whole block will move as one. How can this be? The answer is that the water molecules interact strongly with each other in order to form one highly correlated whole in which the oxygen and hydrogen atoms sit as the sites of a rather rigid lattice. The same is true of all crystaline solids. Such highly correlated states are said to be condensed; it is their study which is the subject of condensed matter physics.
(The bold emphases in the above paragraph were added by me.)
What I glean from these descriptions is that condensed matter physics deals with coordinated structures of aggregating molecules. I'll conclude with two interesting examples of condensed matter physics, one of which is likely to be known to the general public, and the other of which won the 2001 Nobel Prize, having been inspired by one of Einstein's lesser-known ideas (at least "relative" to relativity and E = mc-squared).
Somewhere along the line, most people have probably heard the term superconductivity. Non-technical readers will probably want to skip down to the "Applications" section of the linked document, where technologies such as MRI are discussed.
The other example is the Bose-Einstein condensate, for which three researchers won the Nobel Prize. The Physics 2000 project at the University of Colorado, Boulder, has a nice multiple-page tutorial on Bose-Einstein condensates, including interactive, animated demonstrations (two of the three Nobel winners on this topic also happen to be based in Boulder). As you click through the Bose-Einstein tutorial, be sure to scroll down to the bottom of each page, to be sure to see the interactive exhibits (they also may take a little time to load, so be patient).
Monday, July 10, 2006
Alan Nathan's SABR Talk on Physics of Baseball
I recently attended the Society for American Baseball Research (SABR) conference in Seattle, where I attended a talk by my friend, University of Illinois physics professor Alan Nathan, whom I first met at the 2004 SABR in Cincinnati.
Whereas I'm drawn to SABR by my love of sports statistics (particularly those related to streakiness), Alan N.'s connection involves the physics of baseball, on which he maintains a very extensive website. He is also active in SABR's Committee on Science and Baseball.
Dr. Nathan's recent SABR talk was entitled "Baseball Aerodynamics: What Do We Know And How Do We Know It?" and dealt with such matters as the spin and flight of baseballs, hit as well as thrown. The PowerPoint slide show from his talk is available at his aforementioned Physics of Baseball website, and a summary of his presentation is available here -- for now at least -- from the online SABR program. Here's a photo I took of Alan N. in action...

While watching yesterday's men's Wimbledon tennis final between Roger Federer and Rafael Nadal, commentator John McEnroe stated that a particular shot looked to him like it was going to be out (past the baseline), but then it dipped dramatically and stayed in. Although referring to baseball rather than tennis, one of Dr. Nathan's slides notes that topspin makes a ball drop, which would seem to be the answer to McEnroe's conundrum.
Whereas I'm drawn to SABR by my love of sports statistics (particularly those related to streakiness), Alan N.'s connection involves the physics of baseball, on which he maintains a very extensive website. He is also active in SABR's Committee on Science and Baseball.
Dr. Nathan's recent SABR talk was entitled "Baseball Aerodynamics: What Do We Know And How Do We Know It?" and dealt with such matters as the spin and flight of baseballs, hit as well as thrown. The PowerPoint slide show from his talk is available at his aforementioned Physics of Baseball website, and a summary of his presentation is available here -- for now at least -- from the online SABR program. Here's a photo I took of Alan N. in action...

While watching yesterday's men's Wimbledon tennis final between Roger Federer and Rafael Nadal, commentator John McEnroe stated that a particular shot looked to him like it was going to be out (past the baseline), but then it dipped dramatically and stayed in. Although referring to baseball rather than tennis, one of Dr. Nathan's slides notes that topspin makes a ball drop, which would seem to be the answer to McEnroe's conundrum.
Sunday, June 25, 2006
Brief Items: Soccer Balls; Neutrinos
A couple of brief items...
With the men's soccer World Cup going on, scientifically minded outlets have been doing a lot of stories on the physics of soccer balls and the kicking thereof. Syracuse University physicist Mark Trodden, basking in the success (thus far) of England's squad, posts a blog entry on star player David Beckham and his signature technique of kicking the ball to make it curve sharply. This is also the inspiration for the movie title, Bend it Like Beckham. Mark also links to a site called Soccer Ball World, which delves into the aerodynamics of flying soccer balls.
Further, the July-August 2006 issue of the journal American Scientist has an article on mathematical aspects of the design of soccer balls (only a brief introduction to the article is available online, unless one is a subscriber).
Another story on soccer ball design appeared on the Science Channel show "Discoveries This Week" earlier this month.
***
In some cities at least, the PBS show NOVA will in the coming days re-air its episode on neutrino physics, "The Ghost Particle," which was originally broadcast in February (click here for a transcript).
As discussed in Robert Oerter's book, The Theory of Almost Everything (reviewed here) and elsewhere, the idea of neutrinos having mass goes beyond the Standard Model, thus constituting an exciting current area of particle physics research.
With the men's soccer World Cup going on, scientifically minded outlets have been doing a lot of stories on the physics of soccer balls and the kicking thereof. Syracuse University physicist Mark Trodden, basking in the success (thus far) of England's squad, posts a blog entry on star player David Beckham and his signature technique of kicking the ball to make it curve sharply. This is also the inspiration for the movie title, Bend it Like Beckham. Mark also links to a site called Soccer Ball World, which delves into the aerodynamics of flying soccer balls.
Further, the July-August 2006 issue of the journal American Scientist has an article on mathematical aspects of the design of soccer balls (only a brief introduction to the article is available online, unless one is a subscriber).
Another story on soccer ball design appeared on the Science Channel show "Discoveries This Week" earlier this month.
***
In some cities at least, the PBS show NOVA will in the coming days re-air its episode on neutrino physics, "The Ghost Particle," which was originally broadcast in February (click here for a transcript).
As discussed in Robert Oerter's book, The Theory of Almost Everything (reviewed here) and elsewhere, the idea of neutrinos having mass goes beyond the Standard Model, thus constituting an exciting current area of particle physics research.
Saturday, June 10, 2006
"Extreme Engineering" on Constructing a Modern Football Stadium
I was just watching an episode of the Discovery Channel show "Extreme Engineering," devoted to the construction of the Arizona Cardinals' new football stadium in Glendale, Arizona. As I've "discovered" in some web searching, this episode had its original airing long ago, and is now in reruns.
Here's a profile of the host, architect Danny Forster. This news release from Harvard, where Forster is a Master's student, summarizes his experience doing the stadium show:
Forster's first assignment was a new stadium built for the Arizona Cardinals football team. The 63,000-seat stadium features a retractable roof and a natural turf field that rolls out on tracks so the grass can get the full benefit of the Arizona sun between games. When Forster arrived, teams of masons, ironworkers, carpenters, electricians, and other specialists were working furiously to get the stadium ready for the 2006 season. It was up to Forster to enter this monumental hive and persuade the worker bees to explain their jobs on camera.
"There was no preparation. Everything was improvised. Mostly I would just walk up to people and say, 'What are you doing? Can I try it?' Then most of the time I would fail at whatever task it was, which adds comic value and also shows how incredibly skilled these workers are."
...In the show on the Cardinals stadium, which aired in April as a pilot, Forster watches as workers ignite a mini-volcano to fuse the steel rails carrying the moveable field, he gets stuck high above the ground in the gondola of a cherry picker, and he takes a vertiginous stroll across the stadium's thin fabric roof. One of the show's running jokes centers on Forster's fear of heights. When the workers coax him into ascending the stadium's 240-foot roof, Forster gazes out over the desert landscape nervously but with a visible sense of triumph.
And, all this done in 110 degree (F.) temperatures, which not only are uncomfortable for the workers, but also wreak havoc with the finely calibrated construction processes, due to expansion of the materials.
All television shows need to have some drama, so the show focuses on various "crisis" moments in the construction. As mentioned above, Forster gets stuck (along with his camera operator and a veteran iron-worker literally working his last day before retirement) in the cherry-picker. As Forster's further investigation shows, because the weight of the three men in the "bucket" component (555 pounds) exceeded the 500-pound limit, and the long arm was stretched out too far horizontally, there was a danger of everything tipping over; thus, the cherry-picker automatically halted, until the bucket could be lowered and brought in horizontally (this is just my recollection, I may be off a little in the details).
Another storyline is that a heavy piece of equipment has fallen from the roof onto the field, although luckily within a delineated "no walk" zone, so nobody has gotten hurt. This leads Forster to investigate what's being done "up on the roof," and he discovers the workers have been having difficulty lining up the "train tracks" for the retractable roof.
One component of rail is slightly misaligned with the others (by 1/27 inch beyond tolerance -- thinner than a credit card -- or, if I heard correctly, 0.06 degree, in engineering terms). As is pointed out on the show, even if the roof panels are able to glide along the tracks, any flaws can lead the wheels to wear out prematurely.
The people monitoring the project "on the ground" in Arizona then call Uni-Systems, the Minnesota engineering firm overseeing the construction, and get approval to accept this deviation from tolerance.
The Discovery Channel seems to re-air older shows periodically, so you may be able to see this show if you want to. Also, these shows can be purchased on DVD. Whether you see (or have seen) this episode or not, this description should give you some idea of what goes into building this type of stadium, the next time you view a football game from the Cardinals' new stadium or other retractable-roof facilities.
Also worth a look is the summary page for the new stadium at Ballparks.com. When the new page comes up, look in the upper-left corner and click by "Future" and "NFC," then on the Cardinals' stadium.
Here's a profile of the host, architect Danny Forster. This news release from Harvard, where Forster is a Master's student, summarizes his experience doing the stadium show:
Forster's first assignment was a new stadium built for the Arizona Cardinals football team. The 63,000-seat stadium features a retractable roof and a natural turf field that rolls out on tracks so the grass can get the full benefit of the Arizona sun between games. When Forster arrived, teams of masons, ironworkers, carpenters, electricians, and other specialists were working furiously to get the stadium ready for the 2006 season. It was up to Forster to enter this monumental hive and persuade the worker bees to explain their jobs on camera.
"There was no preparation. Everything was improvised. Mostly I would just walk up to people and say, 'What are you doing? Can I try it?' Then most of the time I would fail at whatever task it was, which adds comic value and also shows how incredibly skilled these workers are."
...In the show on the Cardinals stadium, which aired in April as a pilot, Forster watches as workers ignite a mini-volcano to fuse the steel rails carrying the moveable field, he gets stuck high above the ground in the gondola of a cherry picker, and he takes a vertiginous stroll across the stadium's thin fabric roof. One of the show's running jokes centers on Forster's fear of heights. When the workers coax him into ascending the stadium's 240-foot roof, Forster gazes out over the desert landscape nervously but with a visible sense of triumph.
And, all this done in 110 degree (F.) temperatures, which not only are uncomfortable for the workers, but also wreak havoc with the finely calibrated construction processes, due to expansion of the materials.
All television shows need to have some drama, so the show focuses on various "crisis" moments in the construction. As mentioned above, Forster gets stuck (along with his camera operator and a veteran iron-worker literally working his last day before retirement) in the cherry-picker. As Forster's further investigation shows, because the weight of the three men in the "bucket" component (555 pounds) exceeded the 500-pound limit, and the long arm was stretched out too far horizontally, there was a danger of everything tipping over; thus, the cherry-picker automatically halted, until the bucket could be lowered and brought in horizontally (this is just my recollection, I may be off a little in the details).
Another storyline is that a heavy piece of equipment has fallen from the roof onto the field, although luckily within a delineated "no walk" zone, so nobody has gotten hurt. This leads Forster to investigate what's being done "up on the roof," and he discovers the workers have been having difficulty lining up the "train tracks" for the retractable roof.
One component of rail is slightly misaligned with the others (by 1/27 inch beyond tolerance -- thinner than a credit card -- or, if I heard correctly, 0.06 degree, in engineering terms). As is pointed out on the show, even if the roof panels are able to glide along the tracks, any flaws can lead the wheels to wear out prematurely.
The people monitoring the project "on the ground" in Arizona then call Uni-Systems, the Minnesota engineering firm overseeing the construction, and get approval to accept this deviation from tolerance.
The Discovery Channel seems to re-air older shows periodically, so you may be able to see this show if you want to. Also, these shows can be purchased on DVD. Whether you see (or have seen) this episode or not, this description should give you some idea of what goes into building this type of stadium, the next time you view a football game from the Cardinals' new stadium or other retractable-roof facilities.
Also worth a look is the summary page for the new stadium at Ballparks.com. When the new page comes up, look in the upper-left corner and click by "Future" and "NFC," then on the Cardinals' stadium.
Tuesday, May 30, 2006
Angular Motion and Softball Pitching
Another of my hobbies is following women's college softball (and, yes, I have a blog on that, too). The big event of the year, the Women's College World Series, begins Thursday. One aspect I find interesting is that many of the dominant pitchers are very tall. Many of you are probably familiar with the underhand delivery of fastpitch softball, which implicates angular motion. The question is, does longer arm length lead to faster pitches? I address that question on my college softball blog.
Tuesday, May 16, 2006
Book Review: "The Theory of Almost Everything"
For the past two years or so, I've been reading a steady diet of books of a certain genre. These books attempt to present relatively non-technical introductions to particle physics and related topics, for an educated lay audience. I recently finished reading a new book of this type, entitled The Theory of Almost Everything: The Standard Model, the Unsung Triumph of Modern Physics, by George Mason University professor Robert Oerter. Henceforth, I'll abbreviate the book's title as ToAE.
The Standard Model basically is an enumeration of the known matter and force particles (except for the gravitational force), and the interactions among these particles. This Fermilab document provides easy-to-read charts that summarize the matter particles, the force particles, and then the two together (near the bottom of the page).
To quote Oerter, the Standard Model is, in fact, no less than "...by far the most successful scientific theory ever" (p. 219).
More formally, the Standard Model can be depicted in the form of equations, a simplified version of which Oerter presents on page 207. Illustrating what I think is a gift Oerter has for providing clear explanations, he notes later on the same page that:
There are 18 adjustable numerical parameters in total in the Standard Model. Think of the Standard Model as a machine with 18 knobs. If we twiddle the knobs just right, the machine spits out nearly perfect predictions about any (nongravitational) process in the universe.
That, for me, is the major story of ToAE -- how Oerter illuminated several concepts I either had not been aware of or had not been able to figure out when reading about them in the past. These concepts include:
*How the format of the Periodic Table of the Elements (ubiquitously displayed in chemistry classrooms) derives from the Pauli Exclusion Principle.
*Murray Gell-Mann's "Eightfold Way" of organizing the immense number of particles that began to be discovered in the 1950s. I had read about the Eightfold Way numerous times, but it was not until Oerter's explanation that I finally grasped how this model could be depicted by a simple visual diagram.
*I've been aware of and understood (I believe) the concept of Asymptotic Freedom for some time. Until reading how Oerter put the relevant research into context, however, I did not have an appreciation for the scientific contribution made by Asymptotic Freedom (i.e., what crucial scientific question did it answer?).
Another area Oerter explains beautifully is the working of particle accelerators and colliders, and how physicists interpret the outputs of the collisions. I plan to address this issue separately in a future posting, given the expected 2007 opening of the Large Hadron Collider in Geneva, with which physicists hope to find evidence of various theorized particles and phenomena.
The book's title claims the Standard Model to be the theory of almost everything, so accordingly the latter sections of the book discuss areas unexplained by the Standard Model and the kind of research being done to address these gaps.
There were some areas that I thought could have been addressed at greater length, such as quantum entanglement, which is what I believe Oerter was getting at in his allusion to "long-distance correlations" (p. 91). Topics receiving less coverage than I might have wanted were few and far between, however.
In conclusion, I would definitely recommend The Theory of Almost Everything. One slight concern I have is that the breakthroughs in understanding I achieved from ToAE may be a result of reading it after several other books (most notably Brian Greene's The Fabric of the Cosmos), thus giving me a prior working knowledge of many of the things Oerter talked about. If ToAE is the first physics book you ever read, you may (or may not) get the same benefit I got, but Oerter's down-to-earth explanations should take you a long way.
The Standard Model basically is an enumeration of the known matter and force particles (except for the gravitational force), and the interactions among these particles. This Fermilab document provides easy-to-read charts that summarize the matter particles, the force particles, and then the two together (near the bottom of the page).
To quote Oerter, the Standard Model is, in fact, no less than "...by far the most successful scientific theory ever" (p. 219).
More formally, the Standard Model can be depicted in the form of equations, a simplified version of which Oerter presents on page 207. Illustrating what I think is a gift Oerter has for providing clear explanations, he notes later on the same page that:
There are 18 adjustable numerical parameters in total in the Standard Model. Think of the Standard Model as a machine with 18 knobs. If we twiddle the knobs just right, the machine spits out nearly perfect predictions about any (nongravitational) process in the universe.
That, for me, is the major story of ToAE -- how Oerter illuminated several concepts I either had not been aware of or had not been able to figure out when reading about them in the past. These concepts include:
*How the format of the Periodic Table of the Elements (ubiquitously displayed in chemistry classrooms) derives from the Pauli Exclusion Principle.
*Murray Gell-Mann's "Eightfold Way" of organizing the immense number of particles that began to be discovered in the 1950s. I had read about the Eightfold Way numerous times, but it was not until Oerter's explanation that I finally grasped how this model could be depicted by a simple visual diagram.
*I've been aware of and understood (I believe) the concept of Asymptotic Freedom for some time. Until reading how Oerter put the relevant research into context, however, I did not have an appreciation for the scientific contribution made by Asymptotic Freedom (i.e., what crucial scientific question did it answer?).
Another area Oerter explains beautifully is the working of particle accelerators and colliders, and how physicists interpret the outputs of the collisions. I plan to address this issue separately in a future posting, given the expected 2007 opening of the Large Hadron Collider in Geneva, with which physicists hope to find evidence of various theorized particles and phenomena.
The book's title claims the Standard Model to be the theory of almost everything, so accordingly the latter sections of the book discuss areas unexplained by the Standard Model and the kind of research being done to address these gaps.
There were some areas that I thought could have been addressed at greater length, such as quantum entanglement, which is what I believe Oerter was getting at in his allusion to "long-distance correlations" (p. 91). Topics receiving less coverage than I might have wanted were few and far between, however.
In conclusion, I would definitely recommend The Theory of Almost Everything. One slight concern I have is that the breakthroughs in understanding I achieved from ToAE may be a result of reading it after several other books (most notably Brian Greene's The Fabric of the Cosmos), thus giving me a prior working knowledge of many of the things Oerter talked about. If ToAE is the first physics book you ever read, you may (or may not) get the same benefit I got, but Oerter's down-to-earth explanations should take you a long way.
Wednesday, May 03, 2006
Gravitational Waves
I just came across an article about Cornell University professor Eanna Flanagan, whose research involves trying to detect grativational waves. Notes the article:
Now, nearly two decades after leaving Ireland to study for his doctorate under the famous relativist Kip Thorne at the California Institute of Technology, [Flanagan's] work focuses on predicting the size and shape of gravitational waves. These were forecast by Einstein's 1916 Theory of General Relativity but have never been directly detected.
My "watered-down" introduction to general relativity can be accessed here.
Now, nearly two decades after leaving Ireland to study for his doctorate under the famous relativist Kip Thorne at the California Institute of Technology, [Flanagan's] work focuses on predicting the size and shape of gravitational waves. These were forecast by Einstein's 1916 Theory of General Relativity but have never been directly detected.
My "watered-down" introduction to general relativity can be accessed here.
Thursday, April 27, 2006
Commission Studies Future of Physics in U.S.
I've haven't posted any new entries lately, as I'm currently reading a book on which I plan to write a review. In the meantime, however, today's New York Times had an article entitled "Physics in America at Crossroads and in Crisis, Panel Says" (NY Times registration required to access article).
The basic idea is that, barring construction of any major new particle accelerators in the United States, the study of particle physics will "wither" here, as the action shifts to the Large Hadron Collider in Geneva, Switzerland and elsewhere outside the U.S. The thing is, though, as the Times article states, construction of such a facility in the U.S. would cost around $500 million.
A personal side note: The commission that issued the report that is referenced in the Times article was chaired by Harold T. Shapiro, who was the President of the University of Michigan when I attended graduate school there in the 1980s.
The basic idea is that, barring construction of any major new particle accelerators in the United States, the study of particle physics will "wither" here, as the action shifts to the Large Hadron Collider in Geneva, Switzerland and elsewhere outside the U.S. The thing is, though, as the Times article states, construction of such a facility in the U.S. would cost around $500 million.
A personal side note: The commission that issued the report that is referenced in the Times article was chaired by Harold T. Shapiro, who was the President of the University of Michigan when I attended graduate school there in the 1980s.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)