Saturday, September 09, 2006

String Theory Part II

Let's resume the discussion of string theory, which I introduced in my August 15, 2006 posting. String theory is considered very controversial. To understand why, it will be useful to review the arguments in its favor and in opposition. Today's posting will cover the former, with the latter to come later. Much of my discussion of string theory will come from the book The Fabric of the Cosmos by Brian Greene, a well-known proponent of strings, but someone who seems open to the possibility that the whole idea could be wrong.

To many, the most compelling argument on behalf of string theory is its potential to unify two heretofore incompatible major ideas in physics -- general relativity and quantum mechanics -- in the spirit of Einstein's quest for a "theory of everything." (The original question motivating the development of string theory did not involve such unification, however.)

A few excerpts from Greene summarize the current state of affairs.

Years of astronomical observations have shown that general relativity describes the macro world of stars, galaxies, and even the entire expanse of the cosmos with impressive accuracy; decades of experiments have confirmed that quantum mechanics does the same for the micro world of molecules, atoms, and subatomic particles (p. 336).

...the incompatibility between general relativity and quantum mechanics rears its head in a very specific way. If you use the combined equations of general relativity and quantum mechanics, they almost always yield one answer: infinity. And that's a problem. It's nonsense. Experimenters never measure an infinite amount of anything... (p. 335).

Since [general relativity and quantum mechanics] works wonders in its own domain, why worry about combining them?... For physicists, though, the existence of a realm in which the known laws of physics break down -- no matter how esoteric the realm might seem -- throws up red flags. If the known laws of physics break down under any circumstances, it is a clear signal that we have not reached the deepest possible understanding... (pp. 336-337).

Enter string theory, which at the conceptual stage, makes the two theories compatible. Greene provides a detailed explanation of why this is so, on pp. 348-350, having to do with strings' putting a limit on how small entities can get, thus "avoid[ing] the catastrophic clash between quantum mechanics and general relativity."

Also, because general relativity is a theory of gravity, string theory integrates gravity with the other forces (electromagnetic, strong, and weak), which are all quantum theories within the Standard Model of particle physics.

String theory appears to look good, thus far. Its difficulties will be discussed in future postings.

[For additional background material, I wrote about general relativity on June 4, 2005, and about quantum mechanics in a series of entries from July 27-September 22, 2005. See the archives in the right-hand column of this page.]

Friday, August 25, 2006

"Demotion" of Pluto as a Planet

As occasionally happens, a science-related development is one of the leading stories in the news, at the moment. I'm referring, of course, to the "demotion" of Pluto from the rank of planet.

What happened is that the International Astronomical Union (IAU) adopted a new definition of what constitutes a planet, which Pluto no longer meets. According to the Wikipedia summary of this matter, the following definition was adopted:

...A planet is a celestial body that (a) is in orbit around the Sun, (b) has sufficient mass for its self-gravity to overcome rigid body forces so that it assumes a hydrostatic equilibrium (nearly round) shape, and (c) has cleared the neighbourhood around its orbit.

As seen in this list of objects in the solar system ranked by mass, Pluto is pretty far down.

The references to mass and gravity, of course, implicate Newtonian physics (many universities have a "Department of Physics and Astronomy," thus illustrating the interconnectedness of the two disciplines). As conveyed on the Wikipedia's gravity page:

Newton’s law of gravitation states that: every particle in the universe attracts every other particle with a force that is directly proportional to the product of their masses and inversely proportional to the square of the distance between them.

Further:

Every planetary body, including the Earth, is surrounded by its own gravitational field, which exerts an attractive force on any object that comes under its influence. This field is proportional to the body's mass and varies inversely with the square of distance from the body.

A couple of areas warrant further discussion, in my view. First, I had never heard of the term "self-gravity" until seeing it in the new definition of planet (above). Professor Dave Hanes of Queen's University of Canada has a website that addresses several aspects of gravity. Most relevant to the aforementioned definition is a section of his site entitled "Self-Gravity Can Determine Form," excerpts of which follow:

So far my discussion of scales and function has focussed on things like ants and elephants, which are affected by the gravity of some nearby immense object like the Earth... Moreover, the gravitational force of nearby human-scale objects, even fairly large ones, can safely be ignored. For instance, when you walk past a city bus, you don't have to worry about its gravitational attraction pulling you off the sidewalk and into the road...

In astronomy, by contrast, we are dealing with very large bodies, like planets and stars. They are dominated by self-gravity, by which I mean that the shape and proportions of any object this big are determined by the way in which the various parts of it feel and respond to the gravitational forces exerted by its own other parts. This consideration explains, among other things, why the Earth and all sufficiently large objects must be spherical (or nearly so).

Why should this be? Why couldn't the Earth take on any shape into which we might choose to sculpt it? After all, you are used to the idea that the rocks of the Earth are very rigid and inflexible, at least the ones immediately beneath our feet. Couldn't you mould the Earth into any shape you desired, given sufficiently powerful earth-movers and other equipment?

The answer is no. Suppose, for instance, you tried to use enormous bulldozers to raise mountains to a height of even just a few tens of kilometers. You would not succeed: the sheer weight of material pressing down on the lower layers would overwhelm the structural strength provided by the rocks, and they would slump and flow sideways. The new-built mountain would collapse...

From the known strengths of materials, in fact, you can calculate just about how big a mountain could ever be, here on the Earth: it works out to be roughly the size of Mount Everest. On Mars, which is a smaller planet, the gravity is less, and mountains can be about three times larger. Remarkably, this was known before any spacecraft ever visited Mars, and Carl Sagan, an astronomer at Cornell, predicted that we might find such a huge mountain on Mars - which we did! It is called Olympus Mons (Mount Olympus); it is the largest mountain in the Solar System.

In astronomy, therefore, any body of sufficiently large size, bigger than a few hundred kilometers in diameter, MUST be spherical (although to be absolutely correct I should point out that if it is spinning very rapidly, it can be somewhat flattened out, although still possessing a very smooth and regular surface). The important thing to remember is that the apparently very irregular surface of the Earth, with features like hills, mountains, and valleys, is quite misleading: these features are big only compared to us. Relative to the size of the Earth itself, these features are tiny and easily understood in terms of the limited strengths of rocks and minerals, as I have noted. Bigger features simply could not survive.

By the way, if you were to build a scale model of the Earth about a meter in diameter, like a very large beach ball, even the very highest mountains on it would be represented by little bumps about half a millimeter in height, scarcely detectable to the touch. The surface of the Earth is actually remarkably smooth.


Another part of the new definition of planet is that the entity must "clear the neighborhood." The Wikipedia's page on that subject states the following:

The phrase refers to an orbiting body (a planet or protoplanet) "sweeping out" its orbital region over time, by gravitationally interacting with smaller bodies nearby. Over many orbital cycles, a large body will tend to cause small bodies either to accrete with it, or to be disturbed to another orbit. As a consequence it does not then share its orbital region with other bodies of significant size, except for its own satellites, or those governed by its own gravitational influence.

The bottom line:

Pluto has not cleared the neighborhood of its orbit (vis-à-vis Neptune and Kuiper Belt Objects such as the Plutinos)...

Indeed, failure to clear the neighborhood appears to be Pluto's primary deficiency. According to the following BBC article:

Charon was discovered in 1978... Until now, it has been regarded as a moon of Pluto. But both Pluto and Charon have enough mass to be spherical - both bodies independently satisfy the proposed definition of a planet.

I highly recommend this BBC document, written in Q & A format, for readers who want to investigate the Pluto story in greater detail.

Saturday, August 19, 2006

Brian Greene and Lee Smolin on National Public Radio

Good timing! With my first substantial posting on string theory having just recently been posted (immediately below), it turned out to have been just in time for yesterday's National Public Radio "Science Friday" show, which featured a discussion of string theory with Brian Greene and Lee Smolin. You can now listen to the archived audio here.

Tuesday, August 15, 2006

String Theory Part I

In the year and a half, roughly, that I've been operating this blog, I haven't yet talked about string theory. Actually, I can think of at least one instance where I've referred to string theory, only to say that we should ignore it at that point.

In one of my very first entries (March 18, 2005), I linked to this diagram of the components of matter at ever-decreasing scales: ordinary matter, molecules, atoms, and sub-atomic particles. I then noted that:

Actually, the figure depicts one additional set of entities down the smallness scale, called "strings;" string theory is very controversial, so for now we'll stop at sub-atomic particles.

In my March and April 2005 postings (see month-by-month archives on the right-hand side of the page, midway down) I talked about a variety of sub-atomic particles, both matter particles (e.g., electrons, quarks) and force-carrying particles (e.g., photons, gluons).

The basic idea of string theory, stated simply then, is that these particles themselves are made out of incredibly small strings, or as Brian Greene sometimes refers to them, "tiny filaments of energy" that behave like strings. As Greene elaborates on pp. 346-347 of his book, The Fabric of the Cosmos:

...the wealth of particle species simply reflects the different vibrational patterns that a string can execute. It's just like what happens with more familiar strings like those on a violin or cello. A cello string can vibrate in many different ways, and we hear each pattern as a different musical note... A [physics] string vibrating in one particular pattern might have the properties of an electron, while a string vibrating in a different pattern might have the properties of an up-quark...

OK, so I've now introduced string theory. Now seems like a good time to do so, with books, media articles (most recently in Time Magazine), and blogs bringing string theory to the general public with seemingly unprecedented volume and vigor.

Also, the current schedule calls for the Large Hadron Collider (LHC), the latest and most energetic experimental particle physics facility, to open in November 2007, a little over a year from now (although the full phase-in to the major experiments, never mind the results of them, will take at least several months beyond the opening of the collider).

I don't believe anyone expects direct evidence of strings to be found at the LHC, but some phenomena that bear more indirectly on string theory could be found.

For all these reasons, the focus of my postings over the next year will generally fall into three categories: additional key issues in string theory; related topics such as supersymmetry and extra dimensions; and the workings of particle accelerators and colliders.

Discussion of all of these issues in a single blog posting is impractical, so I'll have to "string you along."

Sunday, July 30, 2006

Condensed Matter Physics

If you've visited this blog before, you've probably gathered that my two favorite areas of physics are particle/high energy physics and applications of physics to sports. Another area of physics, which I'd like to discuss today, is condensed matter physics, which, according to this Wikipedia summary:

...deals with the macroscopic physical properties of matter. In particular, it is concerned with the "condensed" phases that appear whenever the number of constituents in a system is extremely large and the interactions between the constituents are strong. The most familiar examples of condensed phases are solids and liquids, which arise from the bonding and electromagnetic force between atoms.

As also discussed in the Wikipedia document, the term solid state physics has often been used, but the term "condensed matter" is more general, taking in both solids and fluids. One additional fact from the same source is that, "Condensed matter physics is by far the largest field of contemporary physics... By one estimate, one third of all American physicists identify themselves as condensed matter physicists."

The late, legendary particle theorist Richard Feynman, who also worked on some condensed matter topics, noted the following roughly two decades ago in his book QED:

The branches of physics that deal with questions such as why iron (with 26 protons) is magnetic, while copper (with 29) is not, or why one gas is transparent and another one is not, are called "solid-state physics," or "liquid-state physics," or "honest physics"... The most interesting problems today -- and certainly the most practical problems -- are obviously in solid-state physics (p. 114).

Yet another perspective comes from the UCLA physics department's overview of its condensed matter physics program. I found this information to be surprisingly readable for a non-physicist such as myself, at least in the initial sections before the faculty members' research interests are discussed. According to this document:

...microscopic equations which describe an individual water molecule are of limited use when it comes to describing the macroscopic properties of matter, as are more refined descriptions at the atomic or subatomic scales... An entirely new set of concepts... must be introduced, such as temperature, entropy, and phase. The concept of temperature, for instance, makes no sense for an individual water molecule, but one can hardly understand a macroscopic body of water without it. These properties only emerge at macroscopic scales, which are the most interesting and important scales for humankind.

Further:

In considering such a perspective, one is immediately faced with such questions as why is a solid solid? If you open the door to a sauna and try to push against the steam which streams out, the water molecules near your hand will move out of the way, and your hand (and, eventually the rest of you) will be bathed in steam. This is precisely what you would naively expect of a collection of molecules, each of which acts fairly independently of the others in moving around your hand. However, if you try the same thing with a block of ice, the whole block will move as one. How can this be? The answer is that the water molecules interact strongly with each other in order to form one highly correlated whole in which the oxygen and hydrogen atoms sit as the sites of a rather rigid lattice. The same is true of all crystaline solids. Such highly correlated states are said to be condensed; it is their study which is the subject of condensed matter physics.

(The bold emphases in the above paragraph were added by me.)

What I glean from these descriptions is that condensed matter physics deals with coordinated structures of aggregating molecules. I'll conclude with two interesting examples of condensed matter physics, one of which is likely to be known to the general public, and the other of which won the 2001 Nobel Prize, having been inspired by one of Einstein's lesser-known ideas (at least "relative" to relativity and E = mc-squared).

Somewhere along the line, most people have probably heard the term superconductivity. Non-technical readers will probably want to skip down to the "Applications" section of the linked document, where technologies such as MRI are discussed.

The other example is the Bose-Einstein condensate, for which three researchers won the Nobel Prize. The Physics 2000 project at the University of Colorado, Boulder, has a nice multiple-page tutorial on Bose-Einstein condensates, including interactive, animated demonstrations (two of the three Nobel winners on this topic also happen to be based in Boulder). As you click through the Bose-Einstein tutorial, be sure to scroll down to the bottom of each page, to be sure to see the interactive exhibits (they also may take a little time to load, so be patient).

Monday, July 10, 2006

Alan Nathan's SABR Talk on Physics of Baseball

I recently attended the Society for American Baseball Research (SABR) conference in Seattle, where I attended a talk by my friend, University of Illinois physics professor Alan Nathan, whom I first met at the 2004 SABR in Cincinnati.

Whereas I'm drawn to SABR by my love of sports statistics (particularly those related to streakiness), Alan N.'s connection involves the physics of baseball, on which he maintains a very extensive website. He is also active in SABR's Committee on Science and Baseball.

Dr. Nathan's recent SABR talk was entitled "Baseball Aerodynamics: What Do We Know And How Do We Know It?" and dealt with such matters as the spin and flight of baseballs, hit as well as thrown. The PowerPoint slide show from his talk is available at his aforementioned Physics of Baseball website, and a summary of his presentation is available here -- for now at least -- from the online SABR program. Here's a photo I took of Alan N. in action...



While watching yesterday's men's Wimbledon tennis final between Roger Federer and Rafael Nadal, commentator John McEnroe stated that a particular shot looked to him like it was going to be out (past the baseline), but then it dipped dramatically and stayed in. Although referring to baseball rather than tennis, one of Dr. Nathan's slides notes that topspin makes a ball drop, which would seem to be the answer to McEnroe's conundrum.

Sunday, June 25, 2006

Brief Items: Soccer Balls; Neutrinos

A couple of brief items...

With the men's soccer World Cup going on, scientifically minded outlets have been doing a lot of stories on the physics of soccer balls and the kicking thereof. Syracuse University physicist Mark Trodden, basking in the success (thus far) of England's squad, posts a blog entry on star player David Beckham and his signature technique of kicking the ball to make it curve sharply. This is also the inspiration for the movie title, Bend it Like Beckham. Mark also links to a site called Soccer Ball World, which delves into the aerodynamics of flying soccer balls.

Further, the July-August 2006 issue of the journal American Scientist has an article on mathematical aspects of the design of soccer balls (only a brief introduction to the article is available online, unless one is a subscriber).

Another story on soccer ball design appeared on the Science Channel show "Discoveries This Week" earlier this month.

***

In some cities at least, the PBS show NOVA will in the coming days re-air its episode on neutrino physics, "The Ghost Particle," which was originally broadcast in February (click here for a transcript).

As discussed in Robert Oerter's book, The Theory of Almost Everything (reviewed here) and elsewhere, the idea of neutrinos having mass goes beyond the Standard Model, thus constituting an exciting current area of particle physics research.

Saturday, June 10, 2006

"Extreme Engineering" on Constructing a Modern Football Stadium

I was just watching an episode of the Discovery Channel show "Extreme Engineering," devoted to the construction of the Arizona Cardinals' new football stadium in Glendale, Arizona. As I've "discovered" in some web searching, this episode had its original airing long ago, and is now in reruns.

Here's a profile of the host, architect Danny Forster. This news release from Harvard, where Forster is a Master's student, summarizes his experience doing the stadium show:

Forster's first assignment was a new stadium built for the Arizona Cardinals football team. The 63,000-seat stadium features a retractable roof and a natural turf field that rolls out on tracks so the grass can get the full benefit of the Arizona sun between games. When Forster arrived, teams of masons, ironworkers, carpenters, electricians, and other specialists were working furiously to get the stadium ready for the 2006 season. It was up to Forster to enter this monumental hive and persuade the worker bees to explain their jobs on camera.

"There was no preparation. Everything was improvised. Mostly I would just walk up to people and say, 'What are you doing? Can I try it?' Then most of the time I would fail at whatever task it was, which adds comic value and also shows how incredibly skilled these workers are."

...In the show on the Cardinals stadium, which aired in April as a pilot, Forster watches as workers ignite a mini-volcano to fuse the steel rails carrying the moveable field, he gets stuck high above the ground in the gondola of a cherry picker, and he takes a vertiginous stroll across the stadium's thin fabric roof. One of the show's running jokes centers on Forster's fear of heights. When the workers coax him into ascending the stadium's 240-foot roof, Forster gazes out over the desert landscape nervously but with a visible sense of triumph.


And, all this done in 110 degree (F.) temperatures, which not only are uncomfortable for the workers, but also wreak havoc with the finely calibrated construction processes, due to expansion of the materials.

All television shows need to have some drama, so the show focuses on various "crisis" moments in the construction. As mentioned above, Forster gets stuck (along with his camera operator and a veteran iron-worker literally working his last day before retirement) in the cherry-picker. As Forster's further investigation shows, because the weight of the three men in the "bucket" component (555 pounds) exceeded the 500-pound limit, and the long arm was stretched out too far horizontally, there was a danger of everything tipping over; thus, the cherry-picker automatically halted, until the bucket could be lowered and brought in horizontally (this is just my recollection, I may be off a little in the details).

Another storyline is that a heavy piece of equipment has fallen from the roof onto the field, although luckily within a delineated "no walk" zone, so nobody has gotten hurt. This leads Forster to investigate what's being done "up on the roof," and he discovers the workers have been having difficulty lining up the "train tracks" for the retractable roof.

One component of rail is slightly misaligned with the others (by 1/27 inch beyond tolerance -- thinner than a credit card -- or, if I heard correctly, 0.06 degree, in engineering terms). As is pointed out on the show, even if the roof panels are able to glide along the tracks, any flaws can lead the wheels to wear out prematurely.

The people monitoring the project "on the ground" in Arizona then call Uni-Systems, the Minnesota engineering firm overseeing the construction, and get approval to accept this deviation from tolerance.

The Discovery Channel seems to re-air older shows periodically, so you may be able to see this show if you want to. Also, these shows can be purchased on DVD. Whether you see (or have seen) this episode or not, this description should give you some idea of what goes into building this type of stadium, the next time you view a football game from the Cardinals' new stadium or other retractable-roof facilities.

Also worth a look is the summary page for the new stadium at Ballparks.com. When the new page comes up, look in the upper-left corner and click by "Future" and "NFC," then on the Cardinals' stadium.

Tuesday, May 30, 2006

Angular Motion and Softball Pitching

Another of my hobbies is following women's college softball (and, yes, I have a blog on that, too). The big event of the year, the Women's College World Series, begins Thursday. One aspect I find interesting is that many of the dominant pitchers are very tall. Many of you are probably familiar with the underhand delivery of fastpitch softball, which implicates angular motion. The question is, does longer arm length lead to faster pitches? I address that question on my college softball blog.

Tuesday, May 16, 2006

Book Review: "The Theory of Almost Everything"

For the past two years or so, I've been reading a steady diet of books of a certain genre. These books attempt to present relatively non-technical introductions to particle physics and related topics, for an educated lay audience. I recently finished reading a new book of this type, entitled The Theory of Almost Everything: The Standard Model, the Unsung Triumph of Modern Physics, by George Mason University professor Robert Oerter. Henceforth, I'll abbreviate the book's title as ToAE.

The Standard Model basically is an enumeration of the known matter and force particles (except for the gravitational force), and the interactions among these particles. This Fermilab document provides easy-to-read charts that summarize the matter particles, the force particles, and then the two together (near the bottom of the page).

To quote Oerter, the Standard Model is, in fact, no less than "...by far the most successful scientific theory ever" (p. 219).

More formally, the Standard Model can be depicted in the form of equations, a simplified version of which Oerter presents on page 207. Illustrating what I think is a gift Oerter has for providing clear explanations, he notes later on the same page that:

There are 18 adjustable numerical parameters in total in the Standard Model. Think of the Standard Model as a machine with 18 knobs. If we twiddle the knobs just right, the machine spits out nearly perfect predictions about any (nongravitational) process in the universe.

That, for me, is the major story of ToAE -- how Oerter illuminated several concepts I either had not been aware of or had not been able to figure out when reading about them in the past. These concepts include:

*How the format of the Periodic Table of the Elements (ubiquitously displayed in chemistry classrooms) derives from the Pauli Exclusion Principle.

*Murray Gell-Mann's "Eightfold Way" of organizing the immense number of particles that began to be discovered in the 1950s. I had read about the Eightfold Way numerous times, but it was not until Oerter's explanation that I finally grasped how this model could be depicted by a simple visual diagram.

*I've been aware of and understood (I believe) the concept of Asymptotic Freedom for some time. Until reading how Oerter put the relevant research into context, however, I did not have an appreciation for the scientific contribution made by Asymptotic Freedom (i.e., what crucial scientific question did it answer?).

Another area Oerter explains beautifully is the working of particle accelerators and colliders, and how physicists interpret the outputs of the collisions. I plan to address this issue separately in a future posting, given the expected 2007 opening of the Large Hadron Collider in Geneva, with which physicists hope to find evidence of various theorized particles and phenomena.

The book's title claims the Standard Model to be the theory of almost everything, so accordingly the latter sections of the book discuss areas unexplained by the Standard Model and the kind of research being done to address these gaps.

There were some areas that I thought could have been addressed at greater length, such as quantum entanglement, which is what I believe Oerter was getting at in his allusion to "long-distance correlations" (p. 91). Topics receiving less coverage than I might have wanted were few and far between, however.

In conclusion, I would definitely recommend The Theory of Almost Everything. One slight concern I have is that the breakthroughs in understanding I achieved from ToAE may be a result of reading it after several other books (most notably Brian Greene's The Fabric of the Cosmos), thus giving me a prior working knowledge of many of the things Oerter talked about. If ToAE is the first physics book you ever read, you may (or may not) get the same benefit I got, but Oerter's down-to-earth explanations should take you a long way.

Wednesday, May 03, 2006

Gravitational Waves

I just came across an article about Cornell University professor Eanna Flanagan, whose research involves trying to detect grativational waves. Notes the article:

Now, nearly two decades after leaving Ireland to study for his doctorate under the famous relativist Kip Thorne at the California Institute of Technology, [Flanagan's] work focuses on predicting the size and shape of gravitational waves. These were forecast by Einstein's 1916 Theory of General Relativity but have never been directly detected.

My "watered-down" introduction to general relativity can be accessed here.

Thursday, April 27, 2006

Commission Studies Future of Physics in U.S.

I've haven't posted any new entries lately, as I'm currently reading a book on which I plan to write a review. In the meantime, however, today's New York Times had an article entitled "Physics in America at Crossroads and in Crisis, Panel Says" (NY Times registration required to access article).

The basic idea is that, barring construction of any major new particle accelerators in the United States, the study of particle physics will "wither" here, as the action shifts to the Large Hadron Collider in Geneva, Switzerland and elsewhere outside the U.S. The thing is, though, as the Times article states, construction of such a facility in the U.S. would cost around $500 million.

A personal side note: The commission that issued the report that is referenced in the Times article was chaired by Harold T. Shapiro, who was the President of the University of Michigan when I attended graduate school there in the 1980s.

Tuesday, February 21, 2006

Why Can We Skate on Ice?

Following up on my recent postings about the physics of Winter Olympic sports, today's New York Times has an article on the question of why ice is a skatable surface. Here's a link to the article, but one must have completed the Times's free registration process to access articles.

Saturday, February 11, 2006

Physics of Winter Olympic Sports

Now that the Winter Olympics have started, I wanted to supplement my write-up on the physics of figure skating (directly below) with links on the physics of other sports that are part of these Games:

Curling

Ice Hockey

Luge

Skiing

Ski Jumping and Freestyle Aerial

Multiple Sports

Enjoy watching the Olympics!

Wednesday, January 25, 2006

Physics of Figure Skating

With the Winter Olympics coming up in a little over two weeks (the Opening Ceremonies are February 10), I thought it would be interesting to look into the physics of figure skating, one of the more popular sports at the Games (as long as there aren't any judging scandals!). In searching the web for documents on the physics of figure skating, I've noticed that they tend to focus on spinning and jumping. I will focus primarily on skaters' spinning motions, which implicate the physics concept of angular momentum.

Probably the easiest starting point is the concept of linear momentum, pertaining to an object traveling in a straight line. Momentum (symbolized by p) is defined as p = mv, or mass times velocity. The idea of a big running back in football running at a high speed would probably fit most people's lay conceptions of momentum, and more symbolically, one could say that a sports team or a political candidate has "momentum".

Angular momentum applies to an object rotating or spinning in circular motion about a central axis. Nebraska physicist Timothy Gay, in his book Football Physics (which I reviewed here), uses the example of opening or closing a door, such as the front door of a house. The door rotates in circular motion about an axis that is defined by the pins that go down through the hinges. A household door, of course, does not rotate all 360 degrees of a circle, but instead rotates more like a quarter of a circle (perhaps a revolving door would be a better example!).

Writes Gay:

We now define the angular momentum, L, of an object around some axis of rotation. It looks just like a linear momentum, p = mv, except that we replace the mass (m) with the moment of inertia (I), and the velocities (v) with angular velocities [Greek lowercase omega, which looks like a curvy w]. Thus L = Iw (p. 132).

A page earlier, he gives a concrete example of angular velocity:

If the door swings open a quarter of a full circle -- 90 degrees -- in one second, we would say that it has an "angular velocity," w, of 90 degrees per second. (Another unit of angular velocity you're more familiar with is "rpm," or revolutions per minute...)... The "moment of inertia," I, is the property of a body that tells us how hard it is to get it rotating for a given amount of torque. An important thing to remember about the moment of inertia is that it depends not only on the object's mass, but on how that mass is distributed. (pp. 131-132)

According to the Wikipedia, "...the greater the concentration of material away from the object's centroid, the larger the moment of inertia." In practice, however, moment of inertia appears to be fairly complicated to calculate, as there are different formulas according to the type of object in question.

At this point, we can envision different types of spinning objects for which we could calculate the angular momentum: doors slamming about their hinge axis, car wheels about their axles, old-fashioned vinyl records (33, 45, and 78 rpm) on a record player, spinners on board games, playground merry-go-rounds, and... figure skaters.

One figure skating phenomenon that's often noted is that, when a skater goes into a spinning motion, he or she appears to make faster revolutions when his or her arms are in close to the body than when the arms are outstretched. At Section H of this Central Michigan University document describes, barring the influence of any external torques (rotational forces), angular momentum must be conserved. In other words, angular momentum (moment of inertia times angular velocity) during one portion of the spinning routine must be equal to angular momentum during other portions.

According to an example in the Central Michigan document, if the skater spins with outstretched arms, the moment of inertia will be relatively large and the angular velocity relatively small. Bringing the arms in will reduce the moment of inertia, and the requirement of conserved angular momentum thus means that angular velocity must increase.

Spinning, of course, is not the only aspect of figure skating that implicates physics. Karen Knierman and Jane Rigby have compiled a page of topics and links related to the physics of ice skating, including skaters' jumps during their routines, what makes ice a skatable surface, and more on torque.

After studying the physics of figure skating a little bit, perhaps you'll have a new perspective as you watch the Olympics.

Sunday, January 08, 2006

Quantum Gravity

To close the present series on the integration of quantum mechanics with the forces of nature, today we discuss efforts to develop quantum theories of gravity (i.e., bringing together quantum mechanics and the gravitational force). According to a Wikipedia document on the subject:

At present, one of the deepest problems in theoretical physics is harmonizing the theory of general relativity, which describes gravitation and applies to large-scale structures (stars, planets, galaxies), with quantum mechanics, which describes the other three fundamental forces acting on the microscopic scale.

In his book The Fabric of the Cosmos, Brian Greene notes that:

Even though we don't have a successful theory combining the strong nuclear force and the electroweak force, all three of these forces (electromagnetic, weak, strong) have been described by a single uniform language based on quantum mechanics. But general relativity, our most refined theory of the fourth force, stands outside this framework (p. 329).

He further describes the situation mathematically:

If you use the combined equations of general relativity and quantum mechanics, they almost always yield one answer: infinity. And that's a problem. It's nonsense (p. 335).

More specifically, according to the Wikipedia:

Much of the difficulty in merging these theories comes from the radically different assumptions that these theories make on how the universe works. Quantum field theory depends on particle fields embedded in the flat space-time of special relativity. General relativity models gravity as a curvature within space-time that changes as mass moves. The most obvious ways of combining the two (such as treating gravity as simply another particle field) run quickly into what is known as the renormalization problem. Gravity particles would attract each other and adding together all of the interactions results in many infinite values which cannot easily be cancelled out mathematically to yield sensible, finite results.

The Wikipedia document goes on to list 13 candidate theories that could possibly provide the long-sought-after integration of quantum mechanics and the gravitational force.

In preparation for writing today's entry, over the holidays I read the book Three Roads to Quantum Gravity, by Lee Smolin. This review of Three Roads... from the Guardian provides an excellent overview of the book, to which I will just add a few thoughts.

As noted in the Guardian's review, the three "roads" that Smolin discusses are string theory, loop quantum gravity (LQG), and black hole thermodynamics. String theory has been written about extensively, including by the aforementioned Greene. I did not know much about LQG prior to reading Three Roads... and LQG is indeed a theory associated with author Smolin, so that is where I thought I would learn the most. I found Smolin's writing to be very conceptual, discussing ideas such as relational theories, the universe being "made of processes, not things," and "background independence." LQG struck me as being very geometrically oriented, with less discussion of how matter and other physical processes would fit in.

I will do full postings in the future on string theory, LQG, and black hole thermodynamics. The ideas involving black holes were the hardest for me to grasp, so I'll have to do a lot more reading on them; the following web document helps a bit.

Coincidentally, within days after I finished reading Three Roads..., I noticed a new special issue of Scientific American on "The Frontiers of Physics." The contents include an article on LQG by Smolin and an interview with Greene on string theory. I have enjoyed reading the articles thus far.

To conclude this series on the integration of quantum mechanics with the forces, here's a link to a University of Oregon page that concisely summarizes Quantum Electrodynamics, Quantum Chromodynamics, and Quantum Gravity, all within a single document.

Saturday, December 17, 2005

Quantum Chromodynamics

Continuing with our discussion of the integration of quantum mechanics with the forces of nature, today's topic is Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD), the quantum theory of the strong nuclear force. As discussed previously, the matter particles of the strong force are quarks, whereas the force-carrying particles are gluons (see the March and April 2005 archives, in the lower right-hand portion of the page). On the Particle Adventure website, the section on "What Holds it Together?" nicely describes the operation of the strong force, as well as the other forces.

Hadrons are combinations of quarks (and/or antiquarks; see here for description of antiparticles, which are symbolized by a horizontal bar over the letter symbol for a given particle).

Two types of hadrons are baryons, which consist of three quarks, and mesons, which consist of a quark-antiquark pair. One property of quarks, discussed earlier, is "flavor": up, down, strange, charmed, top, and bottom. Probably the best known baryons are protons (two up quarks and a down quark) and neutrons (two downs and an up).

An additional property of quarks is "color" (which really has nothing to do with pigmentation). That is where the "chromo" in QCD comes from. Combinations of quarks must "add" up to "white" or "neutral." Quoting from a Caltech document:

...the strong force comes in three forms of charge, called colors: blue, green, and red. These aren’t real colors visible to the eye, of course, but they do exhibit a similar bit of behavior—one blue, one green, and one red quark add up to be colorless, just as equal parts of blue, green, and red light add up to white light. All observable particles—your protons, neutrons, pions, kaons, and what have you—are color-neutral. And just as all particles, including quarks, have antiparticles, colors have anticolors: antiblue (yellow), antigreen (magenta), and antired (cyan). A bound pair of a color and its anticolor is also color-neutral.

These combinations are illustrated in a color wheel on the Caltech document.

A baryon (with three quarks) can thus consist of a blue, a green, and a red quark, whereas an antibaryon would consist of an antiblue, antigreen, and antired quark. A meson (quark-antiquark pair) could be blue-antiblue, green-antigreen, etc. Pions and kaons, which were noted above, are both types of mesons.

Flavor and color can occur in all possible combinations for a quark (e.g., red-up, green-up, blue-down). According to a New Mexico Tech document, "Counting all color and flavor combinations, there are 6 X 3 = 18 known varieties of quarks."

Andrew Watson's book The Quantum Quark provides a thorough overview of QCD. According to this book:

The simple blunt truth is that without color there would be no QCD since, according to QCD, color is the particle attribute through which those particles interact. That means experimenters need to come up with some pretty rock-solid evidence for color. And not just that: they must be able to show that there are three colors, no more and no less.

Experimenters have risen to the challenge. They have produced support for the existence of color, or at least something that behaves in just the way folk expect color to behave. They have also found evidence that the number of colors really is three (p. 183, my emphasis added).


As the Wikipedia document on QCD notes, two of its key aspects are asymptotic freedom (for which David Gross, Frank Wilczek, and David Politzer received the Nobel Prize) and confinement.

My perusal of some dictionary definitions of the word "asymptote" on the web suggests that it refers to approaching a limit, tending to zero, or getting close to something. In this context, the description of asymptotic freedom in the aforementioned Nobel Prize announcement is clear:

...the closer the quarks are to each other, the weaker is the 'colour charge'. When the quarks are really close to each other, the force is so weak that they behave almost as free particles. This phenomenon is called ”asymptotic freedom”. The converse is true when the quarks move apart: the force becomes stronger when the distance increases. This property may be compared to a rubber band. The more the band is stretched, the stronger the force.

Confinement means that single quarks cannot be observed alone and must join with other quarks or an antiquark. According to Physics Today:

Try to pry loose one of the three valence quarks in a proton. Before going much farther than the radius of the proton (about 1 fm or 10-13 cm), you've done enough work to create a new quark-antiquark pair. Pairs promptly appear, choose new partners, and you find a meson in one hand and a proton or neutron in the other. No isolated quarks! (The 10-13 should be read as 10 the minus 13th power.)

Quantum Chromodynamics, the quantum theory of the strong nuclear force, thus appears to be a thriving, empirically supported area of research. Linking quantum mechanics to the remaining force -- gravity -- is still under development, and will be examined in my next posting.

Sunday, November 27, 2005

Quantum Electrodynamics

Way back on April 2, 2005, I introduced the four forces of nature. Then, from July to September, I wrote a series of essays describing quantum mechanics, the physics of extremely small scales (see archives at lower right-hand portion of the page). In fact, with varying degrees of success, the forces have been integrated with quantum mechanics to produce various quantum theories of the forces.

Today, I discuss Quantum Electrodynamics (QED), the quantum theory of the electromagnetic force. My main source on this topic is the book QED: The Strange Theory of Light and Matter, by the legendary physicist Richard P. Feynman. The book was based on a series of public lectures by Feynman; in my view, it starts off being reasonably understandable to a lay reader such as myself, but then increases in complexity.

In introducing the subject matter, Feynman goes back to the mid-1800's work of James Clerk Maxwell, one of the pioneering scientists in studying the connection between electricity and magnetism:

Because the theory of quantum mechanics could explain all of chemistry and the various properties of substances, it was a tremendous success. But still there was the problem of the interaction of light and matter. That is, Maxwell's theory of electricity and magnetism had to be changed to be in accord with the new principles of quantum mechanics that had been developed. So a new theory, the quantum theory of the interaction of light and matter, which is called by the horrible name "quantum electrodynamics," was finally developed by a number of physicists in 1929 (pp. 5-6).

Feynman, born in 1918, was thus just a youngster at the time of QED's founding (he died in 1988). It was around 1948, when Feynman was only about 30, that he made a major contribution to QED. As he notes in the book, he, Julian Schwinger, and Sin-Itiro Tomonaga came up with a breakthrough in how to calculate things in QED. For that, Feynman, Schwinger, and Tomonaga won the 1965 Nobel Prize. Writes Feynman in QED:

At last, we had a quantum theory of electricity and magnetism with which we could calculate!... The theory of quantum electrodynamics has now lasted for more than fifty years, and has been tested more and more accurately over a wider and wider range of conditions. At the present time I can proudly say that there is no significant difference between experiment and theory! (p. 7).

Feynman's discussion deals with photons (particles of light) and electrons. In keeping with the probabilistic nature of quantum mechanics (which I covered on September 10), Feynman begins with the example of "partial reflection." If one shines a light down on a piece of glass (about which Feynman notes, "... a piece of glass is a terrible monster of complexity -- huge numbers of electrons are jiggling about," p. 16), an average of 4% of the photons will bounce back up off the glass and 96% of photons will go through the glass.

Feynman then introduces a method for using arrows to conduct these probabilistic calculations, and then moves on to more complex examples. The use of arrows to depict processes in particle physics has been formalized in Feynman diagrams.

Another of the forces, the weak nuclear force, has also been integrated with QED, as part of "electroweak" theory. In the coming weeks, I will write about the quantum theory of the strong nuclear force (Quantum Chromodynamics) and about attempts to unify quantum mechanics with the remaining force, gravity.

Monday, November 07, 2005

Book Review: "Football Physics"

Another book that I've read recently, which matches the current sports season, is Football Physics: The Science of the Game, by University of Nebraska physics professor Timothy Gay.

Before reading the book, I thought that I would find it useful on at least two levels. First, most of the physics reading I've done during the past year and a half has been in the particle area; I thought that Football Physics would provide an accessible discussion of classical/Newtonian physics, that is, the study of large, everyday objects. Second, although I have always been a huge sports fan, I have been concerned for many years about the high injury rate in football. The book, I thought, would give me additional information on the physics of collisions and why players are so vulnerable. In both areas, I'm pleased to say, I got out of the book what I thought I would.

The book can be grouped into a number of different topics. Covered first is what might be called the physics of play in "the trenches." Blocking, tackling, collisions, quarterback sneaks, and offensive linemen exploding off the snap are all covered in the first two chapters. These chapters invoke physics concepts including Newton's laws of motion (such as the second law, where force equals mass times acceleration), momentum, torque, work, kinetic energy, and power. We learn that, for a linebacker such as Dick Butkus to stop a running back of a certain mass running at a certain speed, might take 1,150 pounds of force!

Next is the study of play in the open field: receivers' running of pass patterns (and timing with the quarterback), runners' "juking" to try to fake out defensive players, and defenders' pursuit of ball carriers (what fans might think of as who has the "angle"). Here we get vectors, Cartesian coordinates, and the Pythagorean theorem.

The projectile motion of the flying football (punted, kicked, and passed) takes up the next three chapters. Altitude, air drag, spiraling and spinning of the ball are all covered here, plus the mechanics of the kicking motion.

The study of players' football gear comes next, which is probably most relevant to my interest in football injuries. What I found most interesting is how the helmet serves a protective role. The surface or plastic shell of the helmet distributes the force of an incoming head-to-head hit more widely than if the recipient of the hit were not wearing a helmet (it hurts just thinking about the latter option!). Further, the padding within a helmet lengthens the duration of a collision, lessening the average force.

Another injury-related concern involves the type of turf in a stadium, either artificial turf (such as Astroturf) or natural grass. Old-fashioned artificial turf (carpet placed over a parking lot, with some thin padding in between) has been thought to create an injury hazard, due to its hardness and lack of "give" when a player plants his foot. Gay states that:

During the 1980s and mid-1990s, after a series of extensive studies, a consensus developed that playing football on Astroturf and its variants was, in fact, more likely to cause serious injury than playing on natural grass (p. 226).

(As Gay also notes, some newer hybrid surfaces have been introduced in recent years that appear to be more forgiving than old-fashioned artificial turf and perhaps safer; such hybrids include Field Turf and Sport Grass.)

In terms of the physics of turf, one important concept is friction. This area gets a little complicated, but a key distinction is between static friction (related to the traction or "grab" of the turf) and breakaway/sliding friction. Using the analogy of trying to pull apart connected pieces of Velcro, Gay notes that, "...the force required to initiate the sliding can be quite large, because each piece has its hooks firmly anchored in the other's 'loops.' Once the hooks have broken away, the sliding force becomes relatively small" (p. 233).

The final chapter, "Waves in the Stadium," concerns sound waves (noise) and fans doing the wave.

As Gay notes in the book, another contribution of his to popularizing physics within the football context is his appearance in short videos shown on the scoreboard at Nebraska football games, describing the physics of various football phenomena. Those video clips are also available on Gay's faculty website (click here).

Professor Gay also refers readers to a football physics site at the University of Tennessee.

In fact, nice tutorials have been written by a variety of authors on the physics of numerous different sports. In the months ahead, I will feature these tutorials.

Sunday, October 16, 2005

Book Review: "Constructing Quarks"

While working on my series of essays on quantum mechanics over the last couple of months, I was also reading some books related to other areas of physics. In my next couple of postings, I would like to discuss these books.

The first book I would like to discuss is an older one, published in 1984. It is entitled Constructing Quarks: A Sociological History of Particle Physics and written by Andrew Pickering. I introduced quarks and other particles of matter back on March 18 and March 26, 2005.

The main idea of Pickering's book is that, contrary to the image many may hold of science where conclusions about which theories to support are based on self-evident, objective findings of experiments, in actuality a lot of subjectivity goes into scientific judgments. I, myself, am a social scientist, so the study of how ideas become popular or unpopular had some appeal to me. It turns out, however, that the book's 400-plus pages contain quite a lot of technical physics, with some sociology sporadically inserted.

One example of Pickering's thesis about subjectivity involves acceptance of the "standard model of electroweak interactions" over possible alternatives (click here for the Wikipedia's coverage of the electroweak model, and here for my earlier discussion of the forces of nature, including the electromagnetic and weak forces). Pickering argues that:

In retrospect, it is easy to gloss the triumph of the standard model in the idiom of the 'scientist's account': the Weinberg-Salam model... made predictions which were verified by the facts. But missing from this gloss, as usual, is the element of choice. In assenting to the validity of the standard model, particle physicists chose to accept certain experimental reports and to reject others. This element of choice was most conspicuous in the communal change of heart over the Washington-Oxford atomic-physics experiments... ...in 1977 many physicists were prepared to accept the null-results of the Washington and Oxford experiments and to construct new electroweak models to explain them. We also saw that by 1979 attitudes had hardened. In the wake of Experiment E122, the Washington-Oxford results had come to be regarded as unreliable. In analysing this sequence, it is important to recognise that between 1977 and 1979 there had been no intrinsic change in the status of the Washington-Oxford experiments. No data were withdrawn, and no fatal flaws in the experimental practice of either group had been proposed. What had changed was the context within which the data were assessed... (p. 301).

In another episode, regarding "charmed" quarks, Pickering writes that:

It was no coincidence that the charm explanation of the new particles triumphed... The charm explanation sustained a multifaceted symbiosis of practice, wherein gauge theorists, hadron spectroscopists and experimenters in a whole range of traditions could draw upon one another's research for justification and subject matter for future practice... By 1976, charm was central to such a range of practice that arguments could always be marshalled in favour of seeing misfits between prediction and data as important results rather than as serious problems. That, for example, the hidden-charm [Greek letter symbols that I can't show] particles first appeared at the wrong masses and then disappeared caused few doubts, if any, over the validity of charm. Such discrepant phenomena were simply seen to call for further theoretical and experimental work, which would itself command the attention of a wide audience. Alternative models of the new particles did not inspire such dynamic acquiescence... (p. 272).

Thomas Kuhn is a major figure in the dynamics of scientific trends. His ideas are discussed as follows in a Caltech paper on "How Science Works" (p. 6):

A paradigm, for Kuhn, is a sort of consensual world view within which scientists work. It comprises an agreed upon set of assumptions, methods, language, and everything else needed to do science. Within a given paradigm, scientists make steady, incremental progress, doing what Kuhn calls “normal science.”

As time goes on, difficulties and contradictions arise that cannot be resolved, but one way or another, they are swept under the rug, rather than being allowed to threaten the central paradigm. However, at a certain point, enough of these difficulties have accumulated so that the situation becomes intolerable. At that point, a scientific revolution occurs, shattering the paradigm and replacing it with an entirely new one.