Saturday, March 26, 2005

Matter Part II

This week, we'll finish up the topic I titled The Matter of Matter. We left off last week with the fact that an atom consisted of electrons, protons (a proton itself composed of two up quarks and a down quark), and neutrons (a neutron being composed of two downs and an up).

As I suggested at the end of the previous message, however, there are many more particles of matter. I will now present these additional types of particles. In doing so, I draw roughly from the structure and organization of the book Supersymmetry, by Gordon Kane. I will also be drawing from an excellent website called The Particle Adventure.

First, the electron has two "relatives." According to Kane:

There are two more particles like the electron. All their properties are identical to those of the electron, except that they are heavier... Although we don't have any idea why that is so, the Standard Model theory still correctly describes the behavior of these particles... They are unstable particles, decaying in less than a millionth of a second... One is called the muon, denoted by the Greek letter mu, and the other is known by the Greek letter tau. Because they behave in very similar ways, the electron, the muon, the tau, and their associated neutrinos [to be discussed next] are grouped together in a class of particles called leptons (p. 26, the bold emphases added are mine, and I'm unable to produce the Greek-letter symbols Kane showed).

The aforementioned neutrinos were referred to as "ghostly particles" by Brian Greene, in his book The Fabric of the Cosmos (p. 346). As discussed by Kane, it was discovered in 1930 that some nuclear decay processes experienced a mysterious loss of energy; he notes further that, "Wolfgang Pauli proposed that the energy was being carried off by an unseen particle..." (p. 25). These stealthy particles were named "neutrinos," and not directly detected until 1958. They are symbolized by the Greek letter nu. The electron, muon, and tau each has its own neutrino.

The lepton class of particles (electron, muon, tau, and their neutrinos) is nicely depicted in this Particle Adventure illustration. This particular linked graphic is part of a slide show, so when the new page comes up, you might also want to click on the forward arrow to see the next few slides, as well. (The Particle Adventure website requests that users of its images credit the Particle Data Group, which I am happy to do.)

Just as the electron has an "extended family," so do quarks. In addition to the two types of quarks mentioned thus far -- up and down -- there are four other kinds. These are the charm, strange, top, and bottom quarks. The full set of quarks is depicted here, in humorous fashion. The six different types of quarks (e.g., up, charm) are known as "flavors," though as best I can tell, they have no connection to sweet, sour, salty, and other tastes.

The top quark was the last to be discovered and documented, during 1994 and 1995, as described in Andrew Watson's recent book The Quantum Quark (p. 248).

According to Particle Adventure's page on quark naming, the name "strange" refers to the strangely long lifetime of a particle. My impression, gleaned from reading The Quantum Quark (p. 141), was that a class of particles was referred to as "strange" because they followed some properties of the strong nuclear force and others of the weak nuclear force (I will discuss forces in a future posting).

The Quantum Quark contains a display (Figure 4.76, p. 266) that attempts to show the relative masses of the six quark types with spheres of different volumes. Although the spheres in Watson's figure all have a three-dimensional, undifferentiated gray appearance, I will attempt to convey their relative sizes in terms of everyday objects, based on my own "retinal inspection" (quarks, again, are sub-atomic particles, so the everyday objects are merely used as an analogy).

Let's say that the smallest quark, the up, is analogous to the size of a pea that might appear on one's plate of vegetables. On this rough scale, the next biggest, the down, might be the size of a marble. The next biggest, the strange, might then be around the size of a ping-pong ball. The next biggest, the charm, might resemble a tennis ball. The next biggest, the bottom quark, might be roughly the size of a bowling ball, and finally, the largest, the top quark, might be analogous to a medicine ball, which people use to work out with in a gym.

All my talk of relatives and families of particles is bolstered by the fact that physicists themselves refer to "generations" of matter particles. As seen here, the first generation consists of the up quark (U), down quark (D), and electron (E), plus the electron's neutrino; remember that the up and down quarks and electrons comprise an atom. I remember the first generation by pronouncing UDE as a word (pronounced "ood"), as in, "Hey dude, the first generation is UDE."

The second generation consists of the charm quark (C), strange quark (S), muon (M), and muon neutrino, or CSM. The third generation consists of the top quark (T), bottom quark (B), tau (T), and tau neutrino, or TBT. I don't have any catchy memorization devices for these latter generations, sorry.

Just when it looks like we might be done, it turns out we're only halfway home; I will try to describe the other half of the particle "census" much more briefly than I have described the first half.

All particles have what are called antiparticles or, in the case of matter, antimatter. Kane notes in his glossary that, "Every particle has an associated antiparticle, another particle with the same mass but all charges opposite."

In his main text (p. 25), Kane explains that, "The particles and their antiparticles are all just particles with different charges. The antiparticles have all been observed."

An electron's antiparticle is called either an "antielectron" or "positron." Some of you may be familiar with the term positron from Positron Emission Tomography or PET scans, used for biomedical clinical and research purposes.

Another physics blog, Orange Quark, discusses an important point about matter and antimatter:

...in the early universe, one expects there to have been equal amounts of both matter and antimatter and then, as the universe cooled, for these particles to find each other, annihilate, and leave our present universe with very little matter around (and an equally small amount of antimatter).

This is clearly at odds with what we observe in the universe, where we have relatively large amounts of matter and essentially no evidence of primordial antimatter.


The name "Orange Quark" is a doubly clever one. First, the blog's operator, Mark Trodden, is a physics professor at Syracuse University; those of you who are sports fans will know that Syracuse's teams are referred to as the Orange. Second, as you physicists will know, quarks have not only "flavor," but "color."

In the Trodden posting I've excerpted, as you'll see if you click on the above link to the full entry, he also has a play on words utilizing the double meaning of the word "matter" (I guess it's not that hard to come up with!). Something I just came up with is that, if he were to become dispirited about his research and switch to studying, not up quarks, but a different kind, he could start a new blog called "Down Trodden."

An additional note: Brian Greene, whom I've discussed frequently in my postings, appeared this past week (March 22, to be exact) on The Late Show with David Letterman.

As I summarized in a message I posted to the Physics Forums discussion board (where my moniker is "PhysicsFan"):

Greene and Letterman seemed to have a nice banter for probably 7-8 minutes. Letterman asked about topics that one would reasonably associate with physics (e.g., Einstein, what science has to say about the origin of the universe). I think it was when Greene was talking about string theory -- about how, at a level smaller than atoms and quarks, things might be comprised of strings -- Letterman asked him, in that mischievous way, "How is my life the better for knowing that?" (paraphrased).

Greene has a good sense of wit and timing, so he rolled with it pretty well.

Friday, March 18, 2005

Matter Part I

(Updated, December 19, 2023, to fix a bad link and make text consistent with the new link.)

This week's posting might be entitled The Matter of Matter. Although the term matter has various technical definitions, in everyday terms, matter might be defined as what things are made of.

If you click here, you'll see a nice animated illustration of how matter can be broken down into smaller and smaller pieces. Going top to bottom in the linked figure, there's ordinary matter (which is depicted as a crystal), which is comprised of molecules, which are made up of atoms, which are composed of sub-atomic particles. The linked website also provides size estimates for the entities at each level of matter. (Actually, the figure depicts one additional set of entities down the smallness scale, called "strings;" string theory is very controversial, so for now we'll stop at sub-atomic particles.)

Two books really gave me an excellent introduction to sub-atomic particles. They are Supersymmetry by Gordon Kane, and The Fabric of the Cosmos by Brian Greene. Also, the Wikipedia, a free online encyclopedia, has proved very helpful to me. I will be drawing extensively from these sources.

Anyone who took high school chemistry should be familiar with molecules and atoms (my recollection of high school physics is that the subject matter is kept at a more macro level, such as a cart rolling down a hill). Molecules have been defined as:

...two or more atoms joined by shared pairs of electrons in a chemical bond. It may consist of atoms of the same chemical element, as with oxygen (O2), or of different elements, as with water (H2O).

Atoms, such as hydrogen atoms or helium atoms, are of course made of protons (which are postively charged), neutrons (which are neutral), and electrons (which are negatively charged). You can click here for a nice visual depiction of an atom.

An electron is considered a "fundamental" particle, in that it cannot be broken down into anything smaller.

Protons and neutrons -- and this is where things get fun -- can be broken down further into things called quarks. The eminent physicist Murray Gell-Mann introduced the term "quark" to the field, having seen it in James Joyce's book Finnegan's Wake. As we'll see in the course of my postings, physicists are quite adept at coming up with eclectic allusions and witty pieces of nomenclature.

Among the different types of quarks, two are referred to as "up" and "down" quarks. A proton consists of two up quarks and a down quark, and a neutron consists of two downs and an up. The composition of protons and neutrons is shown in the following illustration.

Many of you may have heard of particle accelerators and colliders that physicists use for their research, such as the Stanford Linear Accelerator Center (SLAC) or Fermilab, outside Chicago.

Writes Greene:

Over the past hundred years, physicists have prodded, pummeled, and pulverized matter in search of the universe's elementary constituents. And, indeed, they have found that in almost everything anyone has ever encountered, the fundamental ingredients are the electrons and quarks... electrons and two kinds of quarks, up-quarks and down-quarks, that differ in mass and in electrical charge (pp. 345-346).

Kane adds:

...everything we see in the universe, from the smallest cell to flowers to people to stars, is made of three kinds of matter particles... The three matter particles are the familiar electron and two particles similar to the electron called quarks, the up quark and the down quark (p. 20).

If the sub-atomic particles ended with the up and down quarks, the number of matter constituents would be pretty manageable for the lay observer of physics. As I'll discuss next week, however, there are many more particles of matter.

Saturday, March 12, 2005

Introduction and Welcome

For nearly a year now, I have been obsessed with particle physics! And I'm not even a physicist. I figure that if people can have hobbies such as gardening or playing cards, why can't particle physics be a hobby of mine?

I am a social scientist, an associate professor of human development and family studies (HDFS) at Texas Tech University. Although I took some physics when I was younger (a year of it in high school and one course in calculus-based physics for life-science majors as an undergrad at UCLA), my new interest in physics has developed only in recent years.

My primary research interest within HDFS is the study of social networks (e.g., friends, family members), particularly as related to young people's alcohol consumption.

In early 2003, while browsing in a bookstore, I came across the book Linked: The New Science of Networks, by Notre Dame physicist Albert László Barabási. That a physicist would be writing about the same topic I was studying was absolutely fascinating to me. To a considerable extent, Linked had to do with how networks we see in everyday life (people being linked through friendship, actors linked through appearances in the same movies, power plants and stations linked by wires, internet sites linked on the World Wide Web) often resemble mathematical representations of phenomena in physics. One example, which I'll discuss in a future posting, is how what are called "winner-take-all" networks resemble a Bose-Einstein condensate.

Other books coming out around the same time, such as Sync by Steven Strogatz and Six Degrees by Duncan Watts, presented similar ideas, linking everday events to mathematical/physical phenomena. These books all laid the foundation for my upcoming excursion into physics.

What really (pardon the pun) accelerated my interest in physics, however, was when, in April 2004, I was just flipping channels with my remote and I saw a very engaging speaker on C-SPAN's Book TV programming, talking about historical and contemporary issues in physics.

The speaker, I quickly learned, was Columbia University physicist and mathematician Brian Greene. Here was this articulate, clear, even humorous professor talking about physics in a way that was irresistable. Maybe it's just me, but I saw somewhat of a resemblance (both in physical appearance and in mannerisms) between Greene and one of my favorite comedians, Bill Maher (judge for yourself).

I immediately went out and bought Greene's book, The Fabric of the Cosmos. In this book, Greene put the advanced mathematics in the endnotes for anyone who was interested, but kept the main text of the book at a more conceptual level.

Greene's belief that the important ideas of physics can be made accessible to a general audience (albeit a pretty educated one) if the mathematics is put to the side is further exemplified by a statement of his in the following interview:

Q: How far can us readers really get in understanding the nature of the universe?

A: For most people, the major hurdle in grasping modern insights into the nature of the universe is that these developments are usually phrased using mathematics. But when the impediment of mathematics is removed and the ideas themselves are rephrased in common language, they're not that hard to understand. So, I say: give it a try--and most people do find that they grasp much more than they expected.

It is this idea of trying to convey the concepts of physics that animates my desire to develop this website. The mathematics associated with virtually any area of physics is way over my head, yet I feel I can grasp and convey a great deal. Given my minimal training in physics, I will of course stick closely to the appropriate scientific sources (generally either books or websites) when discussing a topic. Fortunately, a number of people have created animated, user-friendly websites illustrating a number of physical concepts, which I can link to.

A fortuitous coincidence that helped further reinforce my incipient interest in physics occurred at the July 2004 national convention of the Society for American Baseball Research (SABR) in Cincinnati. My main interest within SABR is baseball statistics, particularly a topic called "The Hot Hand" (if you get the idea that I like making webpages, you are correct).

One of the people I met at SABR was Alan Nathan, a physics professor at the University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign, who, appropriately enough, maintains a website on the physics of baseball (I plan to do some future entries on the physics of various sports).

When I met Nathan, I was midway through Greene's book. I immediately made it clear to Nathan that I was not a physicist and was interested in physics purely as a hobby. But there I was, discussing electroweak unification and the (as yet unfulfilled) idea of grand unification with him. One contribution Nathan made to my knowledge of physics was his correction of my pronunciation of the last name of Harvard physicist Howard Georgi. I had pronounced it "Georgie," whereas the proper pronunciation is "Georg-EYE."

From there, I have never looked back. I have read several additional physics books, covering such areas as quantum mechanics, supersymmetry, and quantum chromodynamics. In addition, I frequent a number of physics websites, many of which I'll note in my future postings.

I also attend some of the physics seminars at my home institution, Texas Tech University. Even though about 80% of what is said (the mathematical content) is over my head, I'm happy to try to grasp what I can of the remaining 20%. Within the Texas Tech physics department, I would like to thank professors Lynn Hatfield (department chair), Roger Lichti, Charley Myles, Beth Ann Thacker, and others for their friendliness, patience, and generosity in entertaining the questions of a physics novice from across campus.

These are all things I will discuss in the coming weeks, months, and (hopefully) years. I will try to post on a roughly weekly basis. Though particle physics is my favorite area, I will write about other areas of physics as well. The rationale for the name I've chosen for this website, Watered Down Physics, should be pretty apparent. Anything that I can understand is, of necessity, watered down from its full mathematical glory. Where some may use "watered down" in a pejorative sense, I find it an accurate (and catchy) name.

I hope you'll come along for the journey!