Sunday, July 06, 2008

Big Bang/Inflationary Cosmology VIII

To close out our series on the Big Bang and inflationary cosmology, today we discuss Alan Guth's inflation model (a similar model developed independently by Alexei Starobinsky should also be acknowledged).

As Guth writes in this MIT Physics magazine-style article, "Despite the striking successes of the big bang theory, there is good reason to believe that the theory in its traditional form is incomplete." Adds Guth:

Could the big bang have been caused by a colossal stick of TNT, or perhaps a thermonuclear explosion? Or maybe a gigantic ball of matter collided with a gigantic ball of antimatter, releasing an untold amount of energy in a powerful cosmic blast. In fact, none of these scenarios can plausibly account for the big bang that started our universe... (p. 30).

Further, as Dan Hooper writes in his book Dark Cosmos (reviewed here), "...three puzzles -- the monopole, flatness, and horizon problems -- confounded cosmologists and particle physicists" (p. 195). The major contribution of Guth's model of dramatic, early expansion of the universe (i.e., in the tiniest infinitesimal fraction of a second) is thus its ability to solve these problems that existed in the traditional Big Bang model.

To get an initial visual image of what the inflation model proposes, this diagram from NASA is very helpful. Rather than emanating outward from a single point in linear fashion (analogously to a spotlight), the universe can be seen in the NASA diagram to have widened out from the initial point very early on. Until recently, the further widening of the universe over billions of years has been relatively modest, thus yielding a timeline that looks like a wastebasket laid on its side (also see Figures 9.2, 10.3, and 10.6 in Brian Greene's book, The Fabric of the Cosmos). An "inflaton" field may be the responsible mechanism.

The first problem listed above involves what are known as magnetic monopoles. As discussed by Hooper (pp. 190-194), there exist some theories of grand unification and symmetry -- invoking Maxwell's electromagnetism -- that call for there to be charged magnetic objects (i.e., with only one pole), just as there are charged electric particles such as electrons. However, mono-polar magnets do not appear to exist. Even after breaking a magnet, each new piece will have both north and south poles.

This Wikipedia entry on Alan Guth explains his solution to this conundrum:

The reason for the missing monopoles was that the universe was so big that the density of monopoles would be very low. The “enormous number of monopoles could have risen in the inflationary universe, yet we and all other observers would find them to be observationally far rarer than snowballs in the Sahara…Inflation would spread them so thin that the average observer would expect to find only a single monopole in the entire observable universe.”

The flatness problem pertains to how amazingly perfectly the universe appears to be situated for it to exist as it does -- where any deviation could throw things askew. To use the popular "Goldilocks" analogy, the physical parameters for the shape of the universe seem to be "just right."

As John Gribbin writes in his essay Inflation for Beginners, "This is the puzzle that the spacetime of the Universe is very nearly flat, which means that the Universe sits just on the dividing line between eternal expansion and eventual recollapse." Mathematically, as described by Guth's aforementioned MIT article, the flatness problem can be characterized thusly:

Unless, however, we postulate that the mass density at one second just happened to have a value between 0.999999999999999 and 1.000000000000001 times the critical density, the theory will not describe a universe that resembles the one in which we live (p. 32).

The proposed solution is described in Guth's Wikipedia profile:

Guth realized from his theory that the reason why the universe appears to be flat was because it was fantastically big, just the same way the spherical Earth appears flat to those on its surface. The observable universe was actually only a very small part of the actual universe.

Brian Greene's balloon depictions in Figure 10.4 of The Fabric... are also helpful in understanding solutions to the flatness problem.

A third difficulty, known as the horizon problem, pertains to the extreme uniformity of the Cosmic Microwave Background. It is characterized as follows by Guth in his MIT article:

Calculations show that energy and information would have to be transported at about 100 times the speed of light in order to achieve uniformity by 300,000 years after the big bang. Thus, the traditional big bang theory requires us to postulate, without explanation, that the primordial fireball filled space from the beginning. The temperature was the same everywhere by assumption, but not as a consequence of any physical process (p. 31).

However, as noted in the Wikipedia entry:

The paradox was resolved, as Guth soon realized, by the inflation theory. Since inflation started with a far small[er] amount of matter than the Big Bang had presupposed, [there was] an amount so small that all parts would have been in touch with each other. Inflation th[e]n blew up the universe so quickly that there was no time for the essential homogeneity to be broken.

This University of Arizona document conveys the situation somewhat differently:

If the Universe just expanded in a uniform way, it would have developed large uniformities over distances where the light communication time would be too long to even them out. The observed high degree of uniformity (to about 1 part in 100,000 for the 3K radiation!) must have been locked in at an early stage and maintained since then.

I recall this idea also being discussed during an episode of the History Channel's "Universe" series, but I cannot find a transcript online.

For those interested in pursuing another concise description of the flatness, horizon, monopole, and other problems -- and their solutions -- I would recommend this University of Maryland document.

As noted above, Guth has critiqued the original Big Bang model for its reliance on assumptions rather than proposed physical processes that may have generated conditions we observe in the universe. Regarding his own model, he asserts the following in his MIT article:

The crucial property of physical law that makes inflation possible is the existence of states of matter which have a high energy density that cannot be rapidly lowered. Such a state is called a false vacuum... (p. 33).

The false-vacuum concept appears relatively complex, so I would encourage interested readers to study this section of Guth's article -- which includes some drawings -- for themselves!

Where does inflationary theory stand today, in terms of scientific acceptance?

This NASA document (different from the one cited earlier) concludes, “So inflation remains a widely accepted but unconfirmed modification to the Big Bang theory.”

Wednesday, June 18, 2008

Big Bang/Inflationary Cosmology VII

My extended series of write-ups on the Big Bang and inflationary cosmology is nearing a close. Tonight, I will write about Einstein's cosmological constant, and then later on, I'll have a piece on Alan Guth's ideas on inflation. I will sometimes use "CC" as an abbreviation for the cosmological constant, although in scientific circles it is referred to by the Greek letter lambda (Λ).

Einstein intended the cosmological constant for one purpose, then jettisoned it as a mistake after the original premise for its use was discredited. Other physicists and cosmologists later resurrected the CC, however, for use in a different context. As Dan Hooper's book Dark Cosmos explains:

Einstein... had originally introduced the cosmological constant into his equations in order to force the mathematics to provide a Universe that was static, neither expanding nor contracting. Although he later abandoned this extra term after Hubble's observations demonstrated that the Universe was in fact expanding, today it seems that perhaps he shouldn't have been so eager to throw away this extra piece of mathematics after all.

...The value of the cosmological constant originally chosen by Einstein led to a static and unchanging Universe. But with a different value, it is also possible for such a term to cause the expansion of the Universe to accelerate over time
(p. 168).

Georges Lemaitre, the subject of John Farrell's book The Day Without Yesterday(which I reviewed here), was one scientist who tried to convince Einstein to put the CC to new use. In this way, the CC would fit with Lemaitre's ideas of a Big Bang and expanding universe. Writes Farrell:

In July 1947 Lemaitre wrote a letter to Einstein -- the last of their correspondence that survives -- in which he tried, once again, to persuade the founder of the general theory of relativity to reconsider his dismissal of the cosmological constant(p. 159).

[To Lemaitre and Sir Arthur Stanley Eddington, the] cosmological constant was not an arbitrary number, not a number picked out of thin air merely to balance the force of gravity. For them Λ represented something more, something physical. Lemaitre in particular began to treat the constant as the indicator of an actual force with a special role to play in an expanding universe(pp. 164-165).

Einstein's cosmological constant today is sometimes juxtaposed with the concepts of dark energy (a hypothetical entity driving the universe apart in an expansion) and vacuum (empty space) energy. Lemaitre's idea in the previous paragraph of an expansionary "force" also has some apparent similarity (to me at least) with Guth's model of inflationary cosmology, which I shall address in my next posting.

Back to our main discussion, the CC, dark energy, and vacuum energy all are proposed to account for the accelerated expansion of the universe observed in recent years.

A New York Times article from just a couple of weeks ago, after describing Einstein's abandonment of the CC, notes that "...quantum physics resurrected it by showing that empty space should be foaming with energy that had the properties of Einstein’s constant." However, a problem attends this formulation: "Alas, all attempts to calculate the amount of this energy come up with an unrealistically huge number, enough energy to blow away the contents of the cosmos like leaves in a storm before stars or galaxies could form. Nothing could live there."

Thus, to fit with observable nature, the CC must be much smaller than expected. Again quoting from the Times article, "But if dark energy is the cosmological constant, it is smaller than predicted by a shocking factor of 10^60 [10 raised to the 60th power]."

University of California Riverside professor John Baez has written a piece explaining the difficulties involved in determining the energy density of the vacuum. As he discusses, within the framework of Einstein's general relativity, a few steps are needed to understand the estimation of the energy density:

"...we've known for a long time that the universe is expanding... [and] this expansion is speeding up."

"...negative pressure makes the expansion tend to speed up."

Under the necessary conditions, the vacuum "must have a pressure equal to exactly -1 times its energy density..."

"From this, it follows that if the vacuum has positive energy density, the expansion of the universe will tend to speed up! This is what people see. And, vacuum energy is currently the most plausible explanation known for what's going on. ...the basic fact that the energy density of spacetime is very close to zero is almost unarguable: for it to be false, general relativity would have to be very wrong."

Other approaches, based in quantum field theories, yield other estimates.

Noting that "the conventionally defined cosmological constant Λ is proportional to the vacuum energy density PΛ," Sean Carroll concludes that, "If the recent observational suggestions of a nonzero Λ are confirmed, we will be faced with the additional task of inventing a theory which sets the vacuum energy to a very small value without setting it precisely to zero."

Another problem cited in the Times article: "Nor is there any solid evidence yet that dark energy is or is not varying with time — if it is not constant, it cannot be Einstein’s constant."

In light of the various conundrums involving the CC, vacuum energy, and dark energy, another theory being considered by some scientists is quintessence.

Finally, if your curiosity about Einstein's cosmological constant still has not been satiated, this University of Colorado page provides a seven-part, Q&A style, rundown of important themes.

Saturday, May 24, 2008

Big Bang/Inflationary Cosmology VI (Cosmic Microwave Background III)

This entry presents the third and final installment on the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB), all of which are part of a larger series I've been writing on the Big Bang and inflationary cosmology. Part III discusses research that followed the CMB's discovery in the early 1960s and continues to the present.

As reported in this 2003 University of Chicago news release on the WMAP research mission, images of the CMB provide a “baby picture” of the universe, "as it looked 380,000 years after the big bang, some 200 million years before any stars or galaxies had formed."

Writes Simon Singh in his book, Big Bang:

It might not be immediately obvious that observing the CMB radiation is equivalent to looking back in time, but exactly the same thing happens when astronomers observe a distant star... ...if the CMB radiation was released billions of years ago and has taken billions of years to reach us, then when astronomers eventually detect it they are effectively sensing the universe as it was billions of years ago, when it was only 300,000 years old (p. 446).

WMAP (alluded to above) and its predecessor mission, the Nobel Prize-winning COBE, were the first to find tiny variations in the CMB across different areas of space. (WMAP's images were designed to be 35 times sharper than COBE's, as seen here in comparative images of the two.)

Prior to the WMAP and COBE missions, observations of the CMB radiation showed it to be absolutely uniform and homogeneous across space (Singh, p. 447). This was problematic, because our present-day universe is obviously not absolutely uniform; some areas of space have larger and denser aggregations of matter than do other areas. In other words, there would need to have been at least some tiny variations in the CMB so that gravity could trigger accretions of matter over billions of years to produce the various kinds of astronomical objects we see today.

The Smoot Cosmology Group -- Smoot being a co-recipient of the Nobel Prize for the COBE discoveries -- discusses the importance of finding even slight non-uniformities in the CMB (scientists use the term "anisotropy" for a non-uniformity; the way I think of it, "iso" means "same," as in the word "isomorphic" which means the same shape, so the "an" in front of "iso" would signify "not the same"). According to the Smoot Group's website:

These anisotropies, or "ripples" in the temperature map, correspond to areas of various density fluctuation in the early Universe. Eventually, gravity would draw these fluctuations into even denser ones. After billions of years, these minute ripples in the early universe evolved, through gravitational attraction, into the planets, stars, galaxies, and clusters of galaxies that we see today.

Dan Hooper's book Dark Cosmos, which I reviewed previously, also provides some nice discussion of the CMB, COBE, and WMAP.

Saturday, May 10, 2008

Big Bang/Inflationary Cosmology V (Cosmic Microwave Background II)

Tonight, I present Part II on the Cosmic Microwave Background, focusing on its discovery. These entries on the CMB are part of a larger series on the Big Bang and inflationary cosmology. The prediction of the CMB (by Alpher and Herman, with Gamow) as a vestige of the Big Bang was discussed in the previous entry.

The discovery of the CMB derives from radio astronomy. In the early 1960s, the Bell Lab scientists Arno Penzias and Robert Wilson were working on some radio observations. There was a persistent noise in their observations and despite assiduous attempts by Penzias and Wilson to account for and remove the noise, it wouldn't go away. According to Simon Singh's book, Big Bang:

What the two frustrated radio astronomers had not realised was that they had stumbled into one of the most important discoveries in the history of cosmology. They were completely oblivious to the fact that the omnipresent noise was actually a remnant of the Big Bang: it was the 'echo' from the early expansion phase of the universe. This annoying 'noise' would turn out to be the most convincing evidence yet that the Big Bang model was correct (p. 429).

Penzias and Wilson were eventually put in touch with a team from nearby Princeton, Robert Dicke and James Peebles, who, it appears, were busy "re-inventing the wheel" regarding the CMB. According to Singh:

Dicke and Peebles had no idea that they were walking in the fifteen-year-old footstepts of Gamow, Alpher, and Herman. Independently and belatedly, they were re-postulating the CMB radiation (p. 431).

Among all the players in the CMB saga, the only ones to receive the Nobel Prize for it were Penzias and Wilson, in 1978 (official press release). The award to Penzias and Wilson, with no such recognition ever to CMB theorists Alpher, Herman, and Gamow, is discussed on this list of Nobel Prize controversies. Singh details the plight of Alpher, Herman, and Gamow:

When Gamow, Alpher, and Herman heard of the discovery of the CMB radiation, their joy was mixed with some bitterness. It was they who had predicted this echo of the Big Bang well before Dicke and Peebles, but they received virtually no acknowledgement for their pioneering efforts. They were not mentioned in the initial pair of papers [by Penzias and Wilson; and by Dicke and colleagues] announcing the breakthrough in the Astrophysical Journal... (p. 434).

When a journalist later asked Alpher if he had felt offended by Penzias and Wilson's failure to acknowledge his contribution, he spoke his mind: 'Was I hurt? Yes! How the hell did they think I'd feel? I was miffed at the time that they'd never even invited us down to see the damned radio telescope. It was silly to be annoyed, but I was' (p. 436).

Singh's book does, however, detail the efforts by Penzias to make contact with and publicly acknowledge the contributions of Gamow, Alpher, and Herman.

Wednesday, May 07, 2008

Big Bang/Inflationary Cosmology IV (Cosmic Microwave Background I)

As I briefly alluded to a couple of posts ago, in my series on the Big Bang and inflationary cosmology, the discovery of the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) played a decisive role in building support for the theory of a Big Bang and in undermining the Steady State model.

Tonight, I'd like to launch a three-part posting on the CMB. The remainder of the present piece will constitute Part I, focusing on the early theorizing about the CMB. In the coming weeks, Part II will focus on the accidental discovery of the CMB, and Part III on the more recent, high precision measurement of it.

According to Simon Singh's (2004) book, Big Bang, CMB theorizing goes back to Ralph Alpher and Robert Herman in 1948, with Alpher's mentor George Gamow also being associated. (The famous Alpher, Bethe, Gamow paper, with the name of Hans Bethe inserted primarily to make the authorship sound like the Greek letters alpha, beta, and gamma, dealt with a different issue, nucleosynthesis.)

What Alpher and Herman did was formulate ideas about the interactions of temperature, light, and states of matter (particularly one known as plasma) in the early universe. The following passages from Singh convey the main points of Alpher and Herman's theorizing:

They realised that as the universe expanded, its energy would become spread through a greater volume, so the universe and the plasma within it would steadily cool. The two young physicists deduced that there would be a critical moment when the temperature would become too cool for a plasma to exist, at which point the electrons would latch onto the nuclei and form stable, neutral atoms of hydrogen and helium. The transition from plasma to atoms happens at roughly 3,000 [degree Celsius] for hydrogen and helium, and the duo estimated that it would take 300,000 years or so for the universe to cool to this temperature. This event is generally known as recombination... (p. 330).

If the Big Bang model was correct, and if Alpher and Herman had got their physics right, then the light that was present at the moment of recombination should still be beaming its way around the universe today... In other words, the light that was released at the end of the plasma epoch should currently exist as a fossil. This light would be a legacy of the Big Bang (p. 332).

One further refinement involved accounting for the stretching of light waves in an expanding universe. "Alpher and Herman confidently predicted that the stretched Big Bang light should now have a wavelength... invisible to the human eye,... located in the so-called microwave region of the spectrum" (Singh, p. 333).

Hence the name Cosmic Microwave Background.

Brian Greene, in his 2004 book The Fabric of the Cosmos, presents an even more vivid account of how one can imagine the CMB:

If your eyes could see light whose wavelength is much longer than that of orange or red, you would not only be able to see the interior of your microwave oven burst into activity when you push the start button, but you would also see a faint and nearly uniform glow spread throughout what the rest of us perceive as a dark night sky (p. 226).

Given the importance of the CMB prediction for testing the theory of a Big Bang, and what seems like an intrinsically interesting idea in its own right, one would think that Alpher and Herman's suggestion would have sparked immediate attempts to detect the CMB. But, as Singh notes, "Unfortunately, Alpher and Herman were completely ignored. Nobody made any serious effort to search for their proposed CMB radiation" (p. 333).

How the CMB was ultimately discovered will be the topic of my next entry...

Thursday, April 10, 2008

Physics of Baseball Demonstrations

Here's another little break from my ongoing series on the Big Bang and inflationary cosmology. The following online article provides a visually rich set of demonstrations on the physics of baseball.

Sunday, March 30, 2008

Big Bang/Inflationary Cosmology III

Getting back to my series on the Big Bang and inflationary cosmology, I'd like to devote the third entry to what for many years was the leading scientific alternative to big bang theory, the Steady State model. Championed by Fred Hoyle, and colleagues Thomas Gold and Hermann Bondi, the Steady State model proposed "a universe that was expanding but which was still truly eternal and essentially unchanging," in the words of Simon Singh's book Big Bang (p. 341).

As noted in the above quote, the Steady State researchers accepted cosmological findings of an expanding universe. To keep the density of galaxies throughout the universe stable over time, even though the universe's expansion would drive existing galaxies further and further apart from each other and thus dilute the concentration of galaxies, required some unorthodox theorizing. According to Singh (p. 345), Gold suggested a process that:

...counteracted the thinning effect of the expansion and resulted in no overall change. This was the idea that the universe compensated for its expansion by creating new matter in the growing gaps between the receding galaxies, so that the overall density of the universe would remain the same.

The proposed constant density in an expanding universe is illustrated graphically here. Singh's Figure 86 on page 346 is also helpful.

The movie Dead of Night, in which events happen but everything at the end of the film turns out to be the same as at the beginning, is said to be an inspiration for Hoyle and colleagues' Steady State model.

Spontaneous creation of new matter, of course, appears to violate the foundational concepts of conservation of mass and of energy.

Georges Lemaitre, the early big bang theorist who was profiled in John Farrell's book, The Day Without Yesterday (which I reviewed here), among others, appears to have found the deviation from the conservation laws objectionable. Writes Farrell (p. 155):

Lemaitre did not agree with the steady state, either. For one thing, although he understood the reason for the theory's violation of the conservation of energy in order to pop hydrogen atoms out of nothingness to stabilize the eternal universe, and that it might be explained by quantum mechanics, he did not see why this one modification of the conservation laws should be singled out -- and not others as well. If conservation of energy should be altered for the sake of fitting a theory, for example, why stop there? Why not modify the other principles if they are not convenient to the theory?

Ultimately, the discovery of the Cosmic Microwave Background, which I will discuss in my next posting, decisively tipped the scales in favor of the Big Bang, as opposed to the Steady State model. Although Hoyle's view of the universe was discredited, it should be noted that his research on stellar nucleosynthesis remains well-respected; his exclusion from the Nobel Prize on the topic is listed among the great controversies in Nobel Prize awards (and non-awards).

Saturday, January 26, 2008

Scientific American: "The Future of Physics"

The February 2008 issue of Scientific American, now out on the newsstands, features a special series (with top billing on the cover) entitled "The Future of Physics." The series, consisting of three primary articles that together run for about 20 pages, focuses on the upcoming particle/high energy experiments that will take place at the Large Hadron Collider in the next year or so, and beyond. (I, myself, wrote an eight-part series on the LHC for this blog last year, spanning from the opening essay in May to the concluding piece in September; earlier postings can be accessed via the archives to this blog.)

The first article of the new Scientific American series ("The Discovery Machine") focuses on the engineering aspects of physically constructing the LHC. Two areas I found of interest were the detailed description of the detector systems and how they are designed to winnow down the incredible avalanche of data to the occurrences of greatest potential importance to scientists; and a summary of the malfunctions that have occurred in testing the LHC and have caused delays in the official opening of the facility.

The second article ("The Coming Revolutions in Particle Physics") focuses on the scientific aspects of what physicists expect (or at least hope) to find at the LHC. One historical development discussed in the article, which I don't recall ever learning about before, is how some of the key ideas of electroweak symmetry breaking (i.e., how the electromagnetic and weak forces diverged after being unified) were inspired by superconductivity research. This article is accompanied by nice colorful charts providing overviews of the Standard Model of particle physics, the "hierarchy problem," and "Five Goals for the LHC."

Finally, the third article ("Building the Next-Generation Collider") discusses the proposed successor to the LHC, the International Linear Collider (a website set up to provide basic information on the proposed ILC is available here). This article focuses both on the engineering of building the ILC and how it would complement the LHC scientifically.

The ILC is just a hypothetical entity at this point. What country it would be built in, and how its estimated cost of many billion dollars would be funded, remain to be seen. Also, the richness of scientific yield from the LHC (or relative lack thereof) may affect the prospects for the ILC. In any case, the article estimates that research at the ILC -- if it ever gets underway -- would not take place until sometime in the decade of the 2020's.

Saturday, January 19, 2008

Big Bang/Inflationary Cosmology Part II

As the second essay in my series on inflationary cosmology, I would like to discuss the phenomenon of redshifts in the visible spectrum of astronomical bodies, which has allowed scientists to infer that such bodies are moving away from us.

This Wikipedia page offers an illustrative -- and colorful -- diagram of how "Absorption lines in the optical spectrum of a supercluster of distant galaxies" is redshifted away from the Sun. The same Wikipedia page notes that, among other mechanisms:

Another cause of redshift is the expansion of the universe, which explains the observation that the redshifts of distant galaxies, quasars, and intergalactic gas clouds increase in proportion to their distance from the earth. This mechanism is a key feature of the Big Bang model of physical cosmology.

Another webpage, this time from the Exploratorium, discusses the Doppler Effect and presents an analogy between the sound of a police car's siren and light waves (along with some nice graphics):

Like sound, light is a wave that can be described in terms of its frequency, the number of wave peaks that pass by each second. Just like a cosmic police car, a star zooming toward you has its light waves squeezed together. You see these light waves as having a higher frequency than normal. Since blue is at the high-frequency end of the visible spectrum, we say the light from an approaching star is shifted toward blue, or blueshifted.

Likewise, if a star is zooming away from you, any light it emits gets stretched. You see these stretched-out light waves as having a lower frequency. Since red is at the low-frequency end of the visible spectrum, we say that light from a receding star is shifted toward red, or redshifted.


A naive, layperson question that occurred to me is how we know the movement of galaxies and other objects away from us represents the expansion of the universe, rather than the movement of these objects into what was previously existing, empty space in the universe.

While not (apparently) addressing my exact question, Brian Greene's 2004 book, The Fabric of the Cosmos, explains the basis for why the universe must be expanding:

Just as the gravitational pull of the earth implies that a baseball popped high above the catcher must either be heading farther upward or must be heading downward but certainly cannot be staying put (except for the single moment when it reaches its highest point), [Alexander] Friedmann and [Georges] Lemaitre realized that the gravitational pull of the matter and radiation spread throughout the entire cosmos implies that the fabric of space must either be stretching or contracting, but that it could not be staying fixed in size (p. 230).

Tuesday, January 01, 2008

Big Bang/Inflationary Cosmology Part I -- Book Review: "The Day Without Yesterday"

Happy New Year! To get 2008 off to a bang, I will be kicking off a series on the big bang and the expanding universe (also known as "inflationary cosmology"). An excellent way to do so, in my view, is by reviewing John Farrell's 2005 book, The Day Without Yesterday: Lemaitre, Einstein, and the Birth of Modern Cosmology.

As noted in the title, the book is about Georges Lemaitre (1894-1966), a Belgian astrophysicist (Ph.D. from MIT) and priest. It is Lemaitre who, with some later modifications by others, laid the groundwork for the modern big bang theory of an expanding universe, at a time when there was widespread belief among scientists in a static universe.

A few weeks ago, I had seen an episode of the History Channel series, The Universe, which introduced me to Lemaitre for the first time. Shortly thereafter, I found The Day Without Yesterday in a bookstore, and it seemed to be a perfect way for me to expand my knowledge from what I had seen in the documentary.

With access to letters and photographs from the Lemaitre and Einstein archives, Farrell weaves, to my mind, the perfect blend of scientific exposition and personal story. The duality of Lemaitre's scientific and theological commitments is discussed somewhat, toward the end of the book, and the overwhelming sense is that he kept the two quite separate. At a little over 200 pages, the book is a quick read, easily capable of being finished in a few sittings.

As the book conveys, Lemaitre's ideas stemmed from his thoughtful responses to Einstein's general relativity and Willem de Sitter's initial elaborations on Einstein's theory. In fact, Farrell quotes one of Einstein's letters to Lemaitre, as follows (p. 169):

"I doubt that anybody has so carefully studied the cosmological implications of the theory of relativity as you have."

Further, as the book discusses, development of the big bang theory from roughly 1925-1950 went through at least three stages:

First, having learned of data from astronomical observations suggestive of receding objects, Lemaitre introduced the idea of an expanding universe. Writes Farrell:

It's important to note here that Lemaitre was not yet interested in discussing a temporal beginning of the cosmos in any sense of the term, as has often been inaccurately stated in many books about twentieth-century cosmology. His 1927 paper suggested an expansion of the universe beginning from an initial static Einstein state -- not a big bang, not an explosion of matter from nothing (p. 90).

As a second stage, quoting from Farrell (p. 91), Lemaitre's "further theory of a primeval atom, or initial cosmic origin, would come later, once he realized the physical deficiencies of beginning with Einstein's model."

Third, Lemaitre predicted that there would be a physical residue of the initial expansion of the universe, but his version consisted of a "cold" process of radioactive decay, involving cosmic rays. A later alternative by George Gamow and colleagues, involving a "hot explosion" and the cosmic microwave background as the residue, along with the eventual detection of the background, ended up providing major support for the big bang theory (Farrell, pp. 101-109, plus Chapter 7).

One other topic from Farrell's book that is worth noting is the argument about sociological factors playing a large role in what types of theories the scientific community would find acceptable at any given time (back in October 2005, I reviewed a book titled Constructing Quarks, which dealt with similar issues).

Focusing on Einstein's seeming obsession with preserving the idea of a static universe -- even going so far as to insert a "cosmological constant" into his equations to ensure such -- Farrell offers the following observation:

It's somewhat odd to see in retrospect how conservatism and hesitation manifest themselves in the history of science... Perhaps because of the general nature of this conservatism, it's unfair to ask why Einstein was content to plug the cosmological constant into his equations -- in reaction to their clear suggestion that the universe as a whole could not be static. Einstein was preceded by generation after generation of thinkers who believed the same thing (pp. 52-53).

As this series continues, future topics I plan to discuss include redshifts, Hoyle's steady-state theory, the cosmic microwave background, the cosmological constant, and Guth's inflationary cosmology.

Sunday, December 16, 2007

Dark Matter Talk

As seen a couple of postings down, dark matter has been a topic of recent interest on this blog. A few weeks ago, Texas Tech astrophysicist Ron Wilhelm gave a talk on campus about dark matter and his research on visible matter from the stars, which I was able to attend (on Ron's website, you'll notice his self-description as a "stellar astronomer;" whether the pun is intentional or not, I don't know).

An exciting development for Ron is that an article from his research team has just appeared in the prestigious general-science journal, Nature (Texas Tech news release; abstract from Nature). The article is about our Milky Way galaxy's two stellar halos.

This University of Tennessee document provides a nice overview of the visible and invisible components of a galaxy, with the dark-matter halo included among the latter. The dark matter halo is said to be "of unknown composition but [it] makes itself felt by its gravitational influence on the visible matter." This page also notes that:

In our own galaxy, the observed rotation of the stars and gas clouds indicates that the visible matter is surrounded by a halo of this dark matter containing the major portion of the total galaxy mass and extending very far beyond the visible matter.

The Wikipedia provides this page on dark matter halos, whereas this news release from the University of California, Santa Cruz discusses how computer simulation has been used to characterize them.

Also, the January 2008 issue of Discover magazine has awarded dark-matter research the No. 7 slot in the "100 Top Science Stories of 2007." Quoting from the dark-matter article:

In the early universe, astronomers believe, dark matter provided the gravitational scaffolding on which ordinary matter coalesced and grew into galaxies.

In addition to dark-matter halos surrounding visible-matter galaxies, dark matter galaxies also appear to exist. The Discover article notes that "small, dark matter-dominated satellite galaxies," which had been hypothesized but gone undetected, have now been found in greater numbers (this finding is elaborated in this CalTech news release).

As far as future approaches to detecting dark matter, the Discover article cites the following:

Some astrophysicists believe that dark matter particles may occasionally annihilate each other, producing bursts of high-energy gamma rays. If the Milky Way has dark matter satellites, and if they do emit gamma rays, the Gamma-Ray Large Area Space Telescope, scheduled for launch in February, might detect them.

The GLAST search for dark matter, and related topics, are summarized in this University of California, Irvine document.

In conclusion, the various lines of research described herein should help the scientific community become less in the "dark" about this unusual type of matter.

Sunday, October 14, 2007

Explanation of Science Behind Recent Nobel Prize

Over at Daily Kos -- which is primarily a political website (left-leaning), but which also discusses cultural and societal issues -- one of the writers attempts to explain the research that won the Nobel Prize for physics last week via an analogy to square-dancing. Here's a link to the official Nobel Prize announcement, for a more traditional description of the research.

Saturday, October 13, 2007

Book Review: "Dark Cosmos"

I read Dan Hooper's book Dark Cosmos: In Search of Our Universe's Missing Mass and Energy a while back. In fact, I cited it my late August posting on supersymmetry. For whatever reason, however, I've kept putting off writing a review of Dark Cosmos.

My delay is in no way a reflection of my opinion of Dark Cosmos, as I'm quite favorably disposed toward it. This past Thursday, I attended a physics colloquium at Texas Tech pertaining to dark energy (given by Gary Hill of the University of Texas, Austin) and that's motivated me to write again about the book. So, here's my review.

Dark Cosmos introduces dark matter and dark energy for a general, well-educated audience, with both clarity and relative brevity (a little over 200 pages). Even though I'd read about the book's two key concepts previously, I was still a little bit in the "dark" about them, so reading the book was a welcome learning experience. For those who might want to consider reading the book, an excerpt of it from Smithsonian magazine is available here.

Hooper writes considerably more about dark matter than about dark energy, given that the former has been studied for longer and more is known about it, than the latter. As a way to compile the main ideas from the book in an easily digestible format, I made the following chart (which you can click on to enlarge).


The initial chapters of the book, which are on dark matter, are written almost in detective-novel style. Possible candidates for what might comprise dark matter are discussed -- and cast in doubt -- sequentially. One class of objects that had been considered candidates are:

...massive compact halo objects, or MACHOs. The group includes dead stars like white dwarfs, stars that never burned like brown dwarfs, strange exotic stellar entities like neutron stars and black holes, and large Jupiter-like planets... (p. 36).

On p. 41, however, Hooper reviews research suggesting that MACHOs are not plentiful enough to constitute the dark matter, rendering them "rather poor candidates..." As an aside, I found Hooper's tutorial on the life cycle of stars and related entities to be very helpful.

Other dark-matter candidates discuss include neutrinos and supersymmetric superpartners.

The book then shifts to dark energy, which in turn sparks a discussion of the Big Bang and inflationary cosmology. The latter concepts are fascinating in their own right, so I think I'll write a separate entry about them in the future.

As Hill alluded to in his Texas Tech talk, Science magazine, upon its 125th anniversary, identified 125 outstanding scientific questions. Heading the list is the question of "What Is the Universe Made Of?," which implicates dark matter and dark energy. For an excellent introduction to these concepts, I highly recommend Hooper's Dark Cosmos.

Saturday, September 15, 2007

Large Hadron Collider Part VIII

Today's posting will be the eighth and final entry in my series on the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). I wanted to end with a brief discussion of possible new things that may be found at the LHC, beyond the Higgs boson and supersymmetric particles, which I've already covered.

At this moment, however, Peter Woit's "Not Even Wrong" blog is reporting rumors that technical difficulties may delay the start of physics data collection at the LHC until 2009. Thus, we may end up waiting longer than expected to find out if the various proposed types of new particles are discovered.

One development that some researchers are looking toward is the possible appearance of evidence for extra spatial dimensions beyond the three we're familiar with. String theory, among other ideas, posits the existence of extra dimensions.

The December 2005-January 2006 issue of Symmetry magazine included an article entitled "The Search for Extra Dimensions," which suggests what kinds of signs could be suggestive of extra dimensions. The article focuses on research at Fermilab's Tevatron collider, but also mentions the LHC. A key step in the search would be finding evidence for the graviton, an as-yet-undiscovered particle that's posited to communicate the gravitational force. According to the article:

One way Fermilab experimentalists... hope to detect extra dimensions is to catch a graviton in the act of disappearing into another dimension. Collisions create a symmetrical ball of energy and, like fireworks, particles should spray in all directions. A tell-tale sign of extra dimensions would be a collision in which visible particles sprayed only in one direction, suggesting that an invisible particle traveled in the other direction. This particle could be the key to extra dimensions—a graviton, leaving our visible universe and disappearing into a fourth spatial dimension. Unfortunately, gravitons are not the only invisible particles. Lightweight particles called neutrinos, which very rarely interact with matter, can also travel right through a detector without a trace.

The ability to search for extra dimensions hinges on a researcher's ability to track neutrinos. "If you don't know your neutrinos, you don't know anything about extra dimensions," says [Joe] Lykken. By calculating the probability of creating a neutrino and comparing that to the number of asymmetrical events observed in the Tevatron, Fermilab researchers hope to discover an excess of events unaccounted for by neutrinos. Such a discrepancy could be the first experimental evidence of gravitons disappearing into extra dimensions.

The article concludes thusly:

But even if the Tevatron fails to find evidence of extra dimensions, CERN's LHC will continue the search in 2007. With significantly more energy, the LHC will be able to probe ever smaller radii.

"If we haven't found extra dimensions with the Tevatron by then, the LHC may still do it," says Lykken. "This is the type of discovery we should be able to make in the next five years."

I'll leave you with this Seed magazine piece from July 2006, in which several prominent scientists discuss their visions for discoveries at the LHC.

Wednesday, September 05, 2007

Physics of Baseball -- Flight Trajectories of Home Runs

University of Illinois physics professor Alan Nathan, whom I've gotten to know in recent years through the annual conferences of SABR (Society for American Baseball Research), has just posted a brief analysis of the flight trajectory of Barry Bonds's record-breaking 756th career home run. If you watch baseball games on television, from time to time you've probably heard announcers provide estimates, following a home run, of how far the ball has travelled. Professor Nathan's write-up demonstrates how such estimates can be obtained.

Sunday, August 26, 2007

Large Hadron Collider Part VII

In addition to the Higgs boson (discussed in the previous entry, below), another type of particle physicists are hoping to find are so-called supersymmetric "superpartners" of the particle of the Standard Model.

To review the Standard Model, we have fermions (matter particles such as quarks, electrons, and neutrinos, which all share the property of half-unit spin) and bosons (force-carrying particles such as photons, for the electromagnetic force, and gluons, for the strong nuclear force, which all have full-unit spins).

As depicted on this page by physics instructor Bram Boroson, supersymmetry involves each standard fermion having a supersymmetric boson partner, and each standard boson having a supersymmetric fermion partner.

For the boson superpartner of a fermion, the letter "s" is placed at the beginning of the fermion's name, thus creating terms such as squark and selectron.

For the fermion superpartner of a boson, the suffix "-ino" is added to the bosonic name, yielding terms such as photino and gluino.

Boroson also raises a very important issue. From the perspective of why physicists might support supersymmetry, he notes that whereas it "doubl[es] the number of kinds of particles. There's got to be some kind of payoff, where this makes the theory simpler in the long run!"

Various introductions to supersymmetry are available. These include online sources such as Boroson's and this web document by Michal Szleper. Dan Hooper's (2006) book Dark Cosmos (which I will review in an upcoming posting) and Gordon Kane's (2000) book Supersymmetry (particularly the section entitled "Some Mysteries Supersymmetry Would Solve", pp. 55-62) also are useful.

Based on these sources, four potential benefits of supersymmetry stand out to me:

1. According to Grand Unification Theories (GUTs), the strong nuclear, weak nuclear, and electromagnetic forces should exhibit the same strength at a given energy level. As shown in Figure 7 of this report by Swagato Banerjee, such convergence does not occur within the Standard Model, but is projected to occur within supersymmetry.

2. Certain types of supersymmetric particles (or even combinations thereof) are possible candidates for something known as dark matter. This topic is discussed extensively in the aforementioned book by Hooper, in the chapter entitled "A Grand Symmetry."

3. According to Hooper, early string theories had a problem with tachyons (something that is "defined as a particle that travels faster than the speed of light," but also can be viewed "in some other frame of reference [as] moving backward in time" (p. 123).

Hooper goes on to note, however, that the first superstring revolution came up with a way to overcome the tachyon problem: "Namely, it was found that if supersymmetry was included in a string theory, the tachyons present in the theory would naturally disappear" (p. 124). The term superstring theory thus derives from this contribution of supersymmetry.

4. Supersymmetry also appears to keep the Higgs boson to a reasonable mass. A May 15, 2007 NY Times article on the Large Hadron Collider states that: “These superpartners cancel out all the quantum effects that make the Higgs mass skyrocket. “Supersymmetry is the only known way to manage this,” Dr. [Joe] Lykken said.”

Book authors Kane and Hooper each discuss detection of supersymmetric superpartners at the particle colliders. Kane writes that:

The superpartners that weigh the least are the ones most likely to be produced first, because it takes less energy to produce them... We don't know for sure which are the lightest ones, but most approaches suggest they might be the photino, Wino, Zino, and higgsinos (p. 157).

Adds Hooper:

Assuming that supersymmetry exists in nature, there should be a slew of new particles with masses between roughly a few tens and a few thousands of giga-electron volts -- perfectly suited for discovery at the LHC (p. 224).

Not all researchers find the idea of supersymmetry convincing. One such skeptic is Lee Smolin, author of the 2006 book The Trouble with Physics. Says Smolin, "My own guess, for what it's worth, is that (at least in the form so far studied) supersymmetry will not explain the observations at the LHC" (p. 78).

Further detail on Smolin's views is available in my review of his book.

Sunday, August 12, 2007

Large Hadron Collider Part VI

Having completed the first part of my series on the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) -- pertaining to the workings of particle colliders -- it's time to move on to the second part, dealing with new particles (or types of particles) physicists will be looking out for.

The first priority would appear to be discovery of something called a Higgs boson. A New York Times article on the LHC from May 15, 2007 notes that: “The new collider was specifically designed to hunt for the Higgs particle, which is key both to the Standard Model and to any greater theory that would supersede it.”

Tonight's entry will first detail what a field of Higgs particles is hypothesized to embody, drawing from Brian Greene's (2004) book The Fabric of the Cosmos. How a Higgs boson is likely to be detected -- which was already touched upon in my previous, July 14, 2007, entry on particle detection in connection with an online interactive activity called “The Hunt for Higgs” -- will next be addressed briefly. Finally, the implications of various potential findings at LHC regarding the Higgs will be addressed.

Envisioning what a Higgs field is

What I grasped about Higgs fields from Greene's book is that two key areas of theoretical interest they address are: differential masses of different types of particles; and unification of different forces of nature.

Higgs fields create barriers to the movement of other kinds of particles, with different types of particles encountering different degrees of resistance. The more resistance a type of particle encounters, the more mass it is said to have. Higgs fields have been analogized to molasses or a bunch of paparazzi photographers. As Greene explains:

If we liken a particle's mass to a person's fame, then the Higgs ocean is like the paparazzi: those who are unknown pass through the swarming photographers with ease, but famous politicians and movie stars have to push much harder to reach their destination (p. 263).

Greene also notes that:

Photons pass completely unhindered through the Higgs ocean and so have no mass at all. If, to the contrary, a particle interacts significantly with the Higgs ocean, it will have a higher mass. The heaviest quark (it's called the top quark), with a mass that's about 350,000 times an electron's, interacts 350,000 times more strongly with the Higgs ocean than does an electron; it has greater difficulty accelerating through the Higgs ocean, and that's why it has a greater mass (p. 263).

In terms of unifying the different forces, Greene discusses how photons ("messenger particles" of the electromagnetic force) and W and Z particles (particles of the weak nuclear force) were indistinguishable at one point (known as "electroweak unification"), but are now considered to be different, due to the influence of the Higgs field.

Glashow, Salam, and Weinberg:

...realized that before the Higgs ocean formed, not only did all the force particles have identical masses -- zero -- but the photons and W and Z particles were identical in essentially every other way as well... At high enough temperatures, therefore, temperatures that would vaporize today's Higgs-filled vacuum, there is no distinction between the weak nuclear force and the electromagnetic force... The symmetry between the electromagnetic and weak forces is not apparent today because as the universe cooled, the Higgs ocean formed, and -- this is vital -- photons and W and Z particles interact with the condensed Higgs field differently. Photons zip through the Higgs ocean... and therefore remain massless. W and Z particles... have to slog their way through, acquiring masses that are 86 and 97 times that of a proton, respectively (excerpts from pp. 264-265).

A common term used to describe this phenomenon is "symmetry breaking."

Detecting the Higgs

The Higgs boson is posited to decay into other particles, thus forcing scientists to look for a "signature" indicative of the Higgs. This Physics World article (especially the section entitled, "Getting to know the Higgs") goes into further detail, such as in the following excerpt:

The Higgs signature depends on its mass. A relatively light Higgs with a mass of about 120 GeV will decay into pairs of B-mesons, tau leptons or photons, which will be easy to produce but hard to detect among the background of other processes and particles. If the Higgs is heavy, about 160 GeV, it will decay to pairs of W or Z bosons. These will be harder to produce, says [CERN's Jos] Engelen, but easier to spot. If there is no Higgs mechanism, the LHC will see scattering events between pairs of W bosons that would otherwise be "absorbed" by the standard Higgs mechanism.

Implications of possible Higgs-related findings

The March 23, 2007 issue of Science ran a spread of articles on the LHC, including one entitled "Physicists' Nightmare Scenario: The Higgs and Nothing Else." Probably the most succinct summary of the situation is revealed in the following quote:

Discovering the Higgs would complete the standard model. But finding only the Higgs would give physicists little to go on in their quest to answer deeper questions, such as whether the four forces of nature are somehow different aspects of the same thing... (pp. 1657-1658).

Were the LHC to find additional types of new particles, such as supersymmetric superpartners, or evidence of extra dimensions, for example, these would provide strong stimuli for further theorizing and discovery. Or, as the Science article notes:

If, on the other hand, the LHC sees no new particles at all, then the very rules of quantum mechanics and even Einstein's special theory of relativity must be wrong... (p. 1657).

For background on the Standard Model of particle physics, which the Higgs boson would round out, see this review I wrote of a book on the topic.

Saturday, July 14, 2007

Large Hadron Collider Part V

To conclude the series of postings on technical aspects of the Large Hadron Collider, tonight we will look at how physicists interpret the information they receive in their particle detectors.

The Science Museum (UK) has an online interactive activity called "The Hunt for Higgs," which uses the example of a Higgs boson, a particle many physicists expect to be found at the LHC. In this demonstration activity, viewers click on the animated image of a detector and are taken through the steps that would be involved in identifying a potential Higgs particle.

An important concept illustrated by the demonstration exercise is that massive particles -- such as the Higgs -- can be very short-lived, and can thus be detected only by the presence in the detector of combinations of other, lighter particles. As the demonstration indicates, however, the combinations are only ones physicists think might be the "signatures" of a Higgs.

The discovery of the top quark -- the heaviest of the quarks -- in 1995 serves as an excellent case study in how the existence of a highly tranient particle was inferred. According to the linked Wikipedia page on the top quark, "The Standard Model predicts its lifetime to be roughly 1×10 [to the]−25 [power] seconds...", which would be .0000000000000000000000001 of a second.

This Fermilab information page on the discovery of the top quark and the process of confirming its existence, is very useful. In particular, the two following headings on the Fermlab page are worth clicking on, for further detail: "Is it a top quark? The signature of a top event" and "How do we know when we've found the top quark?"

For all of the hype and expense of the LHC, it is important to note that it is not expected to offer the ultimate in detector clarity. Texas A&M University physicist Teruki Kamon, whom I once saw give a talk at Texas Tech, has a slide in some of his PowerPoint presentations that uses a photographic analogy to demonstrate the upgrades in information (quantity and quality) that will be available as researchers move from Fermilab's Tevatron to the LHC to the proposed International Linear Collider (ILC).

If you go to this slide show and then scroll down to page 3, you'll see a sequence of three depictions of the same picture (a girl jumping in the air, with her shadow showing below). At the Tevatron, according to this analogy, only perhaps the bottom one-fifth of the picture would be observable, and with a very fuzzy appearance, at that. At the LHC, the full picture would be available, but would still be fuzzy. Only at the ILC would the picture be both fully available and sharp.

The next set of LHC-related postings will discuss new types of particles and other phenomena that scientists hope to find.

Friday, June 29, 2007

Large Hadron Collider Part IV

Tonight, we return to my series on the Large Hadron Collider (LHC). I previously wrote about one very important property of a collider, its energy. Tonight, I write about another important property, luminosity. Dictionary definitions of luminosity typically refer to the presence of light or brightness; in other words, a luminous object is easy to see, such as something that is illuminated.

Conceptually, the term luminosity as used in particle physics also refers to ease of detecting something. In his book, Not Even Wrong (associated with a blog of the same name), Peter Woit states the following:

Besides the energy of its [particle] beams, the most important characteristic of any collider is its "luminosity." The luminosity of a collider is a measure of how many particles are in the beam and how small the interaction region is in which the beams coming from opposite directions are brought together inside a detector (p. 19).

The most layperson-friendly description of the units of luminosity I've been able to find is "collisions per square centimeter per second...", from this Berkeley Lab document.

Greater density of particles' concentration -- how many of them there are, in how small of an area -- thus would make them easier to detect. The LHC's luminosity is planned to be 10 to the 34th power (that's a lot of zeroes).

Increasing colliders' luminosities, however, is very difficult to do, as discussed by Woit and also in this Stanford Linear Accelerator Center (SLAC) document. The SLAC document also includes a graph that shows the luminosity levels for a number of colliders, including the LHC.

Luminosity is serious business. Major international conferences known as LUMI '06 and LUMI '05 have been held to track research developments in this area.

Friday, June 15, 2007

Book Review: "The Physics of Basketball"

I thought I'd take a break from my series on the Large Hadron Collider (see the three previous postings below) to write a mini-review of a book I recently finished reading. The book is The Physics of Basketball, by U.S. Naval Academy professor John Fontanella, himself a former player.

It’s actually more of a lengthy monograph (~130 pages) than a typical book. The book concentrates heavily on the trajectory of basketball shots, both of the “nothing but net” variety and those that bounce around off the backboard and/or rim. Fontanella’s enumeration of all the forces acting on a released basketball shot (e.g., gravity, magnus, drag, and buoyancy) may have some similarity to the talk University of Illinois physicist Alan Nathan presented at last year’s Society for American Baseball Research (SABR) meeting on the aerodynamics of a flying baseball.

Fontanella also addresses a few other issues besides basketball shooting. One is the illusion of "hang time," or a player (former NBA star Gus Johnson being a favorite of the author) who's driving to the hoop "hanging or floating in air, apparently defying gravity and the laws of physics" (p. 121).

The author has a ready explanation for this phenomenon -- a player's initial upward movement is quick, but gravity slows the upward motion. According to a calculation by Fontanella, "a jumping player spends only 29% of the time in the bottom half of the jump. Correspondingly, a player must spend 71% of the time in the upper half of the jump" (p. 122). Thus, we see prolonged periods of a player high in the air.

Another question Fontanella addresses -- for those of you dying of curiosity -- is why you hear so much squeaking of the players' basketball shoes when you're observing from near the court (p. 115).

There’s an online NPR interview (link) with Fontanella you can listen to, which might help you decide if you want to read the book.