Friday, July 13, 2018

Book Review: "We Have No Idea"

Jorge Cham is the creator of PHD Comics and himself a Ph.D. holder from Stanford. Daniel Whiteson is professor of physics and astronomy at the University of California, Irvine. Put the two together and the result is the book We Have No Idea: A Guide to the Unknown Universe. Part comic book, part physics and astronomy text, and part compendium of hit-or-miss jokes, No Idea reviews unanswered questions in physics and astronomy and discusses possible solutions.

The first few chapters are about dark matter and dark energy. The next chapters cover the Standard Model of particle physics and "the mysteries of mass." The topic I found most interesting at this point was that of binding energy and its effect on mass. As the authors note, "...if you were to add the masses of three quarks... and compare that to the mass of those same three quarks bound together in a proton or neutron*... you would see a very big difference in mass. The masses of the individual quarks only account for about 1 percent of the mass of the proton or neutron. The rest is in the energy that's keeping those quarks together" (p. 63).

Greater mass of an object is associated with greater inertia (an object's"tendency to resist changes in its state of motion"). However,  as Cham and Whiteson explain, "Even though we can measure it, we don't really know what inertia is or why it's tied to both the mass of the particles and the energy that binds the particles together" (p. 64). This is but one example of how the authors set up an interesting physical phenomenon and then disclose that physicists and astronomers "have no idea" how or why the phenomenon works.

Other poorly understood phenomena discussed in the book include: why gravity is so different from all the other forces; what is the nature of space; what is time; and whether extra dimensions exist. (How particle colliders could lead to the inference of extra dimensions is another fascinating example from the book.)

By fortuitous coincidence, a new discovery reported in yesterday's New York Times may help answer one of the questions raised in the book: "Who is shooting superfast particles at the earth?" (p. 185). More technically, Cham and Whiteson are referring to cosmic rays and they claim that, "We don't know where they are coming from exactly, or why there are so many of them. And we don't know what process in nature could possibly be making such energetic ammunition" (pp. 185-186).

The discovery reported in the Times involves the "Ice Cube" detector in the South Pole being hit by a neutrino that could be traced to its source: TXS 0506+056, "a type of quasar known as a blazar, in which our line of sight from Earth is along the jet — right down the gun barrel." As noted in the Times article, "Astronomers said the discovery could provide a long sought clue to one of the enduring mysteries of physics and the cosmos. Where does the rain of high-energy particles from space known as cosmic rays come from?"

As can be seen, there are many topics in No Idea that I enjoyed. However, at 340 pages, the book is pretty long and probably could have been condensed to a shorter length. The cartoons and jokes may grow on a reader or become increasingly irritating. Will you enjoy this book? I have no idea!

---
*A proton consists of two up quarks and one down quark, whereas a neutron consists of two downs and an up.

Friday, May 11, 2018

What Makes Water Slippery?

This new article explain's water's slipperiness in terms of density, chemical-bonding, and friction. There's even a theory that there are two kinds of water! The writer quotes James Kakalios, whose book on quantum mechanics and technology I previously reviewed here.

Friday, March 02, 2018

Possible New Clues on Dark Matter

Two recent Nature articles offer possible progress in the quest to characterize dark matter. A Science Daily article quotes one of the authors, Tel Aviv University professor Rennan Barkana, to the effect that "the discovery offers the first direct proof that dark matter exists and that it is composed of low-mass particles."

Massive particles -- the weakly interacting variety being known as WIMPs and the strongly interacting version as SIMPs -- were long considered leading contenders to comprise dark matter. According to another article, WIMPs were pegged at being "about 100 times heavier than the proton." However, Barkana claims the new research puts the putative dark-matter particle at around "several" proton masses.

Saturday, January 27, 2018

Frustration for New Theories

Via Peter Woit/Not Even Wrong, the Economist has an article on how elaborate experiments designed to test unified theories are not providing support for them.

Wednesday, October 04, 2017

2017 Nobel Prize for Detection of Gravitational Waves

This year's Nobel Prize in Physics has been awarded to a trio of scientists for their work on the detection of gravitational waves. The official award announcement is available here, whereas some background information on the discovery can be found in this prior posting.

Saturday, July 01, 2017

Brian Greene Demonstrates Quantum Mechanics on CBS Late Show

Columbia University physicist Brian Greene recently brought an animation of the double-slit experiment to the CBS Late Show with Stephen Colbert, to mark the 90th anniversary of the study that helped launch the development of quantum mechanics. "The math of quantum physics... describes [the seemingly strange result of the double-slit experiment] perfectly," noted Greene, but arguments continue to this day about what the famous study says about "the nature of reality." Greene also conducted a live experiment with superconductors and magnets to illustrate "quantum levitation" and "quantum spikes." Here's a video clip of Greene's appearance.

Friday, May 26, 2017

Book Review: "Why String Theory?"

A decade ago, two books for educated, lay readers attempted to poke holes in string theory: Peter Woit's Not Even Wrong (which I reviewed here) and Lee Smolin's The Trouble with Physics (which I reviewed here). While I can't claim with certainty that no books were published in this genre over the past decade that attempted to argue for string theory, I at least did not see any. That changed with the 2016 publication of Why String Theory?, by Joseph Conlon. I recently finished reading Conlon's book and I review it here.

The greatest potential promise many physicists see in string theory is its (theoretical) ability to link the heretofore incompatible areas of general relativity/gravity and quantum mechanics, so that the equations of one theory do not yield nonsensical answers at the scale of the other theory. Conlon, however, contends that, "very few [people associated with string theory] actually work on quantum gravity or have their main interests in quantum gravity" (p. 228).

Conlon also shows a sense of humor regarding the lack of direct empirical evidence for string theory. Chapter 7 is entitled "Direct Experimental Evidence for String Theory," and the entire text of the chapter consists of this one sentence: "There is no direct experimental evidence for string theory."

What, then, are Conlon's reasons for urging the study of string theory? A major claim of his is that string theory offers conceptual and analytic tools to physicists and mathematicians working outside quantum gravity, which can help these scholars in their own domains. As one example, notes Conlon, string theory "... came to the field theorists and showed them how it could be used to compute quantities of interest to them... string theory was able to show them a way to solve their own problems and on their own terms" (p. 230).

Conlon weaves some technical topics into the various chapters, such as the "AdS/CFT Correspondence," which make the reading very challenging in places. I think the larger arguments in the book come through clearly, however. Also, I found some of Conlon's general impressions about physics and science to be very interesting.

One is what he refers to as "gold" and "silver" standards for theories. The gold standard "has always been to make predictions in advance of the experiment, and then to see these predictions verified." Conlon notes further that, "All research involving quantum gravity lacks this gold standard" (p. 234). The silver standard "is to make predictions for theoretical problems, for which the answer is not known in advance but can be checked using very different techniques." By that, for example, he means reaching the same mathematical solution after coming at the problem from very different approaches. Conlon pronounces the silver standard to have been "abundantly satisfied" with string theory, but not for a competing theory, loop quantum gravity.

Another interesting fact, mentioned early in the book, is that the last theorizing in particle physics to be awarded the Nobel Prize (in 2004) was originally published in 1973 (independently by Politzer, and by the team of Gross and Wilczek on asymptotic freedom in the strong force). A Nobel has been awarded more recently than 2004 for theoretical particle physics (i.e., the 2013 prize to Peter Higgs and Francois Englert), but their research predated 1973. Conlon contends that the Standard Model of particle physics, which "originally appeared a temporary ersatz construction that would be good for a few years..." (p. 4), has unexpectedly withstood all experimental tests since the 1970s, and consequently has directed a great deal of research toward further refinements of the Standard Model.

Much remains to be learned, about quantum gravity and many other areas of physics. And, as Conlon argues in his book, string theory is a valuable tool for these diverse pursuits.

Thursday, March 09, 2017

Physics of Volleyball Float Serve

Pete Heureux, a beach volleyball player with a degree in physics, analyzes the float serve for Volleyball Magazine. What I found most interesting was the information presented in Figure 7. Researchers had a machine deliver simulated serves, varying features of the ball itself (e.g., a honeycomb outer surface), along with contact speeds and angles, and the part of the ball struck. Serves with certain specifications consistently landed within a relatively small zone (1 X 2 meters), whereas balls served under a different set of specifications landed anywhere within an area five meters long. The latter, of course, would be more unpredictable and difficult for a receiving player to handle. Heureux also cites principles of air-flow physics (e.g., laminar flow, turbulent flow, Reynolds number, drag crisis) to explain what's going on as the served ball makes its way over the net to the receiving team's side of the court.

Saturday, December 03, 2016

"The Map of Physics"

Dominic Walliman provides an eight-minute video entitled "The Map of Physics" to illustrate the different subdisciplines in the field and how they relate to each other.

Sunday, November 06, 2016

Five Signs of New Physics

Ethan Siegel writes in Forbes magazine that, despite results at the Large Hadron Collider falling completely in line with the Standard Model of particle physics, "there are a large number of observations that tell us quite clearly that there’s very likely more to the Universe than just the quarks, leptons and bosons of the Standard Model." Some of the five areas should be familiar, such as dark matter, but others are less so.

Thursday, July 21, 2016

Physics of the Sneeze

Who knew? A team from MIT is investigating the physics of the sneeze, using concepts from fluid dynamics. A video from Nature, intended for a lay audience, is available here, whereas the lead scientist's website can be accessed here. In terms of potentially aiding public-health officials in stemming disease-progression, these findings are nothing to sneeze at!

Wednesday, April 13, 2016

Physics of Home Runs in Baseball

How do launch angle and exit velocity combine to determine what becomes of a batted ball? Five-Thirty-Eight has the answer here.

Thursday, February 11, 2016

Videos Explaining Today's Report on Gravitational Waves

Two videos, one from the New York Times and the other from PhD Comics, explain the detection of gravitational waves. This Q & A from Yahoo! News does the same. My thanks to Alan Nathan and Charley Myles for publicizing these sites on Facebook.

Tuesday, November 24, 2015

100th Anniversary of General-Relativity Discovery

Today's New York Times marks the 100th anniversary of Einstein's Theory of General Relativity. As the linked article notes, Einstein and colleagues had published versions of the theory prior to 1915 that weren't quite right. But in November 2015, the theory was finally ready for prime time. What made the theory "general" is that it applied to all situations, including those involving acceleration. Einstein's earlier Special Theory of Relativity was confined to constant speed. My earlier postings on Special and General Relativity can be found in the links section in the right-hand column.  

Wednesday, October 21, 2015

New Finding Supports Quantum Entanglement

The New York Times reports on a new European study supporting quantum entanglement, the notion that "objects separated by great distance can instantaneously affect each other’s behavior" (link). The finding appears to counteract one of Einstein's objections to quantum mechanics. My introductory overview of quantum entanglement is available here.

Sunday, October 18, 2015

Book Review: "The Amazing Story of Quantum Mechanics"

University of Minnesota physics professor James Kakalios sets out to tie together three separate threads in his 2010 book The Amazing Story of Quantum Mechanics: A Math-Free Exploration of the Science That Made Our World. These threads are futuristic science-fiction literature from the 1920s, 1930s, and beyond; historical developments in quantum mechanics; and modern-day consumer gadgets.

Occasionally, I would get the feeling the author was delving too single-mindedly into one of the three areas, to the exclusion of the other two. In the end, however, I think all three major topics received their fair share of coverage.

Kakalios gives away a major theme early on: Whereas much futuristic science-fiction predicted scientific-engineering advances in compact energy storage (e.g., so that people could readily fly around with their personal jet-packs), the real advances have come in information storage. Notes Kakalios, "A modest laptop computer currently employs approximately more than a hundred million solid-state transistors for data storage and processing. If all of these transistors were replaced with vacuum tubes [the older technology]... [the result] would yield a vacuum tube computer larger than the White House" (p. XIII).

A key aspect of quantum mechanics is the restriction of certain physical changes to discrete units. As I quoted from a Stanford document in an earlier posting, a hypothetical example would be to "...imagine if someone told you that water could have only integer temperatures as you boiled it. For example, the water could have temperatures of 85º, 86º or 87º, but not 85.7º or 86.5º."

Through much of the book, Kakalios relies on the metaphor of a performing-arts center with orchestra pit, mezzanine, and balcony as the only allowable levels, to illustrate how electrons can be "promoted" up to higher levels, with light (photons) emitted as electrons fall back down (e.g., pp. 178-179, 186). Kakalios presents a fairly lengthy, yet layperson-friendly, description of the SchrÓ§dinger equation, concluding that "One intriguing consequence of the SchrÓ§dinger equation is that it explained that electrons in an atom could have only certain energy values, and that all other electronic energies were forbidden" (p. 71).

One example of electrons moving between levels and producing photon emission is glow-in-the-dark objects. Marvels Kakalios, "From such simple quantum mechanical phenomena are totally awesome toys made" (p. 181). Similar principles have allowed hands on wristwatches and alarm clocks to be viewable in the dark, and for lasers to be created.

Advances in solid-state/condensed-matter physics, engineering, and manufacturing, from semiconductors, to diodes (including light-emiting diodes or LED), to the aforementioned transistor have brought a host of devices to the consumer. As the book notes, "Semiconductors make convenient light-detectors, as the separation between the bands of filled and empty states corresponds to energies in the visible portion of the spectrum" (p. 199).* As a result, among other things, we have television remote-controls, smoke-alarms, automatically opening doors, and street lights that come on upon darkness outside. I have long been fascinated by touch-screen technology and Kakalios explains the latest developments in that area, as well.

As the book moves along, the technical aspects get increasingly challenging in my view. I found n- and p-typed semiconductors a bit hard to grasp. Fortunately, there are some YouTube videos that help (for example, here, here, and here).

Finally, Kakalios discusses prospects for future technological advances. One would be quantum computers, which could greatly speed up calculations. If a quantum computer is ever realized, however, "It will be up to all of us to ensure that this technology does not fall into the wrong hands, for who could forget when the evil Decepticons used quantum computers to hack into the Pentagon's secure computer system in the Transformers movie (2007), cracking a code in ten seconds that would take more than two decades for the most power[ful] supercomputer" (p. 244). Other potential advances include expanded use of solar cells for electricity and "high-speed magnetically levitating trains" (p. 254).

If you're a fan of futuristic science fiction, modern technological gadgetry, or quantum mechanics, you'll probably like The Amazing Story of Quantum Mechanics. If you're a fan of all three, you'll love it!

---------
*I initially omitted the closing quotation mark. My apologies for the confusion.

Sunday, October 11, 2015

2015 Nobel Physics Prize Goes to Neutrino Researchers

This year's Nobel Prize in Physics has gone to a pair of neutrino researchers, Arthur McDonald (Canada) and Takaaki Kajita (Japan). This article provides an overview of what neutrinos are, their importance to understanding the universe, and the Nobel Prize-winning research.

Monday, March 23, 2015

Restarting of the LHC & Emmy Noether Biography from Vox

The explanatory journalism website Vox has a pair of physics-related articles today:

One previews the restarting of the Large Hadron Collider after a two-year hiatus for upgrades. The article also refreshes our memory on what was previously discovered at the LHC.

The other reviews the life of mathematician/physicist Emmy Noether, including her discoveries on symmetries and conservation, and the gender-discrimination she faced, on the 133rd anniversary of her birth. I wrote about Noether and symmetry back in this 2009 entry.

Monday, September 22, 2014

Vox Explains Recent Search for Gravitational Waves

The website vox.com, which debuted earlier this year, is devoted to explanatory journalism. Today, the site had an excellent article describing what gravitational waves are, what their implications are for understanding the Big Bang and the inflation of the universe immediately thereafter, and why a trumpeted finding from last March on gravitational waves may be flawed.

Sunday, August 17, 2014

Book Review: "The Theoretical Minimum"

The Theoretical Minimum: What You Need to Know to Start Doing Physics, by Leonard Susskind and George Hrabovsky, seemed like the perfect book for me and people like me to read. Based on Susskind's continuing-education lectures on classical mechanics at Stanford (which are also available here on Youtube), The Theoretical Minimal is aimed at the "ardent amateur," according to the book jacket. The target audience, it seems, would be people with some background in physics and/or calculus -- perhaps many years in the rear-view mirror -- who want to see how concepts and problems in physics are formulated, derived, and solved in all their glory.

I figured I fit the target profile, having taken a year of college calculus at UCLA, a year of high school physics, and one calculus-based college physics course, all between 1979-1981. And, of course, my writing of this blog for nearly a decade reflects my keen interest in physics. If The Theoretical Minimal could help bring back some of my calculus knowledge (beyond simple derivatives and integrals) and help me apply it to physics, that would be great.

It quickly became apparent to me, however, that the book was way over my head. The explanations just went too quickly for me, with too many new terms and symbols for me to keep up with. In fairness, I did find some explanations to be well-suited for my level of understanding (such as that for the Euler-Lagrange equations of motion on page 202). However, that was more the exception than the rule.

Further, the authors do appear to recognize that some readers may find the material highly complex. Key portions of the book are devoted to conceptual/mathematical systems known as Langrangians and Hamiltonians and, on page 158, the authors acknowledge that, "We still have a couple of courses on relativity and quantum mechanics before the real meanings of the Lagrangian and Hamiltonian become completely clear."

In retrospect, I think I almost certainly would have learned more had I gone back-and-forth between watching parts of the lecture videos and reading the corresponding sections of the book. I plan to do that when I read the second book in Susskind's series (Quantum Mechanics: The Theoretical Minimum, by Susskind and Art Friedman). In the meantime, I'm also doing more to bring my calculus back up to speed, viewing online lectures from MIT's Math 18.01 (at this point, I have watched through Lecture 23).