Tuesday, February 21, 2006
Why Can We Skate on Ice?
Following up on my recent postings about the physics of Winter Olympic sports, today's New York Times has an article on the question of why ice is a skatable surface. Here's a link to the article, but one must have completed the Times's free registration process to access articles.
Saturday, February 11, 2006
Physics of Winter Olympic Sports
Now that the Winter Olympics have started, I wanted to supplement my write-up on the physics of figure skating (directly below) with links on the physics of other sports that are part of these Games:
Curling
Ice Hockey
Luge
Skiing
Ski Jumping and Freestyle Aerial
Multiple Sports
Enjoy watching the Olympics!
Curling
Ice Hockey
Luge
Skiing
Ski Jumping and Freestyle Aerial
Multiple Sports
Enjoy watching the Olympics!
Wednesday, January 25, 2006
Physics of Figure Skating
With the Winter Olympics coming up in a little over two weeks (the Opening Ceremonies are February 10), I thought it would be interesting to look into the physics of figure skating, one of the more popular sports at the Games (as long as there aren't any judging scandals!). In searching the web for documents on the physics of figure skating, I've noticed that they tend to focus on spinning and jumping. I will focus primarily on skaters' spinning motions, which implicate the physics concept of angular momentum.
Probably the easiest starting point is the concept of linear momentum, pertaining to an object traveling in a straight line. Momentum (symbolized by p) is defined as p = mv, or mass times velocity. The idea of a big running back in football running at a high speed would probably fit most people's lay conceptions of momentum, and more symbolically, one could say that a sports team or a political candidate has "momentum".
Angular momentum applies to an object rotating or spinning in circular motion about a central axis. Nebraska physicist Timothy Gay, in his book Football Physics (which I reviewed here), uses the example of opening or closing a door, such as the front door of a house. The door rotates in circular motion about an axis that is defined by the pins that go down through the hinges. A household door, of course, does not rotate all 360 degrees of a circle, but instead rotates more like a quarter of a circle (perhaps a revolving door would be a better example!).
Writes Gay:
We now define the angular momentum, L, of an object around some axis of rotation. It looks just like a linear momentum, p = mv, except that we replace the mass (m) with the moment of inertia (I), and the velocities (v) with angular velocities [Greek lowercase omega, which looks like a curvy w]. Thus L = Iw (p. 132).
A page earlier, he gives a concrete example of angular velocity:
If the door swings open a quarter of a full circle -- 90 degrees -- in one second, we would say that it has an "angular velocity," w, of 90 degrees per second. (Another unit of angular velocity you're more familiar with is "rpm," or revolutions per minute...)... The "moment of inertia," I, is the property of a body that tells us how hard it is to get it rotating for a given amount of torque. An important thing to remember about the moment of inertia is that it depends not only on the object's mass, but on how that mass is distributed. (pp. 131-132)
According to the Wikipedia, "...the greater the concentration of material away from the object's centroid, the larger the moment of inertia." In practice, however, moment of inertia appears to be fairly complicated to calculate, as there are different formulas according to the type of object in question.
At this point, we can envision different types of spinning objects for which we could calculate the angular momentum: doors slamming about their hinge axis, car wheels about their axles, old-fashioned vinyl records (33, 45, and 78 rpm) on a record player, spinners on board games, playground merry-go-rounds, and... figure skaters.
One figure skating phenomenon that's often noted is that, when a skater goes into a spinning motion, he or she appears to make faster revolutions when his or her arms are in close to the body than when the arms are outstretched. At Section H of this Central Michigan University document describes, barring the influence of any external torques (rotational forces), angular momentum must be conserved. In other words, angular momentum (moment of inertia times angular velocity) during one portion of the spinning routine must be equal to angular momentum during other portions.
According to an example in the Central Michigan document, if the skater spins with outstretched arms, the moment of inertia will be relatively large and the angular velocity relatively small. Bringing the arms in will reduce the moment of inertia, and the requirement of conserved angular momentum thus means that angular velocity must increase.
Spinning, of course, is not the only aspect of figure skating that implicates physics. Karen Knierman and Jane Rigby have compiled a page of topics and links related to the physics of ice skating, including skaters' jumps during their routines, what makes ice a skatable surface, and more on torque.
After studying the physics of figure skating a little bit, perhaps you'll have a new perspective as you watch the Olympics.
Probably the easiest starting point is the concept of linear momentum, pertaining to an object traveling in a straight line. Momentum (symbolized by p) is defined as p = mv, or mass times velocity. The idea of a big running back in football running at a high speed would probably fit most people's lay conceptions of momentum, and more symbolically, one could say that a sports team or a political candidate has "momentum".
Angular momentum applies to an object rotating or spinning in circular motion about a central axis. Nebraska physicist Timothy Gay, in his book Football Physics (which I reviewed here), uses the example of opening or closing a door, such as the front door of a house. The door rotates in circular motion about an axis that is defined by the pins that go down through the hinges. A household door, of course, does not rotate all 360 degrees of a circle, but instead rotates more like a quarter of a circle (perhaps a revolving door would be a better example!).
Writes Gay:
We now define the angular momentum, L, of an object around some axis of rotation. It looks just like a linear momentum, p = mv, except that we replace the mass (m) with the moment of inertia (I), and the velocities (v) with angular velocities [Greek lowercase omega, which looks like a curvy w]. Thus L = Iw (p. 132).
A page earlier, he gives a concrete example of angular velocity:
If the door swings open a quarter of a full circle -- 90 degrees -- in one second, we would say that it has an "angular velocity," w, of 90 degrees per second. (Another unit of angular velocity you're more familiar with is "rpm," or revolutions per minute...)... The "moment of inertia," I, is the property of a body that tells us how hard it is to get it rotating for a given amount of torque. An important thing to remember about the moment of inertia is that it depends not only on the object's mass, but on how that mass is distributed. (pp. 131-132)
According to the Wikipedia, "...the greater the concentration of material away from the object's centroid, the larger the moment of inertia." In practice, however, moment of inertia appears to be fairly complicated to calculate, as there are different formulas according to the type of object in question.
At this point, we can envision different types of spinning objects for which we could calculate the angular momentum: doors slamming about their hinge axis, car wheels about their axles, old-fashioned vinyl records (33, 45, and 78 rpm) on a record player, spinners on board games, playground merry-go-rounds, and... figure skaters.
One figure skating phenomenon that's often noted is that, when a skater goes into a spinning motion, he or she appears to make faster revolutions when his or her arms are in close to the body than when the arms are outstretched. At Section H of this Central Michigan University document describes, barring the influence of any external torques (rotational forces), angular momentum must be conserved. In other words, angular momentum (moment of inertia times angular velocity) during one portion of the spinning routine must be equal to angular momentum during other portions.
According to an example in the Central Michigan document, if the skater spins with outstretched arms, the moment of inertia will be relatively large and the angular velocity relatively small. Bringing the arms in will reduce the moment of inertia, and the requirement of conserved angular momentum thus means that angular velocity must increase.
Spinning, of course, is not the only aspect of figure skating that implicates physics. Karen Knierman and Jane Rigby have compiled a page of topics and links related to the physics of ice skating, including skaters' jumps during their routines, what makes ice a skatable surface, and more on torque.
After studying the physics of figure skating a little bit, perhaps you'll have a new perspective as you watch the Olympics.
Sunday, January 08, 2006
Quantum Gravity
To close the present series on the integration of quantum mechanics with the forces of nature, today we discuss efforts to develop quantum theories of gravity (i.e., bringing together quantum mechanics and the gravitational force). According to a Wikipedia document on the subject:
At present, one of the deepest problems in theoretical physics is harmonizing the theory of general relativity, which describes gravitation and applies to large-scale structures (stars, planets, galaxies), with quantum mechanics, which describes the other three fundamental forces acting on the microscopic scale.
In his book The Fabric of the Cosmos, Brian Greene notes that:
Even though we don't have a successful theory combining the strong nuclear force and the electroweak force, all three of these forces (electromagnetic, weak, strong) have been described by a single uniform language based on quantum mechanics. But general relativity, our most refined theory of the fourth force, stands outside this framework (p. 329).
He further describes the situation mathematically:
If you use the combined equations of general relativity and quantum mechanics, they almost always yield one answer: infinity. And that's a problem. It's nonsense (p. 335).
More specifically, according to the Wikipedia:
Much of the difficulty in merging these theories comes from the radically different assumptions that these theories make on how the universe works. Quantum field theory depends on particle fields embedded in the flat space-time of special relativity. General relativity models gravity as a curvature within space-time that changes as mass moves. The most obvious ways of combining the two (such as treating gravity as simply another particle field) run quickly into what is known as the renormalization problem. Gravity particles would attract each other and adding together all of the interactions results in many infinite values which cannot easily be cancelled out mathematically to yield sensible, finite results.
The Wikipedia document goes on to list 13 candidate theories that could possibly provide the long-sought-after integration of quantum mechanics and the gravitational force.
In preparation for writing today's entry, over the holidays I read the book Three Roads to Quantum Gravity, by Lee Smolin. This review of Three Roads... from the Guardian provides an excellent overview of the book, to which I will just add a few thoughts.
As noted in the Guardian's review, the three "roads" that Smolin discusses are string theory, loop quantum gravity (LQG), and black hole thermodynamics. String theory has been written about extensively, including by the aforementioned Greene. I did not know much about LQG prior to reading Three Roads... and LQG is indeed a theory associated with author Smolin, so that is where I thought I would learn the most. I found Smolin's writing to be very conceptual, discussing ideas such as relational theories, the universe being "made of processes, not things," and "background independence." LQG struck me as being very geometrically oriented, with less discussion of how matter and other physical processes would fit in.
I will do full postings in the future on string theory, LQG, and black hole thermodynamics. The ideas involving black holes were the hardest for me to grasp, so I'll have to do a lot more reading on them; the following web document helps a bit.
Coincidentally, within days after I finished reading Three Roads..., I noticed a new special issue of Scientific American on "The Frontiers of Physics." The contents include an article on LQG by Smolin and an interview with Greene on string theory. I have enjoyed reading the articles thus far.
To conclude this series on the integration of quantum mechanics with the forces, here's a link to a University of Oregon page that concisely summarizes Quantum Electrodynamics, Quantum Chromodynamics, and Quantum Gravity, all within a single document.
At present, one of the deepest problems in theoretical physics is harmonizing the theory of general relativity, which describes gravitation and applies to large-scale structures (stars, planets, galaxies), with quantum mechanics, which describes the other three fundamental forces acting on the microscopic scale.
In his book The Fabric of the Cosmos, Brian Greene notes that:
Even though we don't have a successful theory combining the strong nuclear force and the electroweak force, all three of these forces (electromagnetic, weak, strong) have been described by a single uniform language based on quantum mechanics. But general relativity, our most refined theory of the fourth force, stands outside this framework (p. 329).
He further describes the situation mathematically:
If you use the combined equations of general relativity and quantum mechanics, they almost always yield one answer: infinity. And that's a problem. It's nonsense (p. 335).
More specifically, according to the Wikipedia:
Much of the difficulty in merging these theories comes from the radically different assumptions that these theories make on how the universe works. Quantum field theory depends on particle fields embedded in the flat space-time of special relativity. General relativity models gravity as a curvature within space-time that changes as mass moves. The most obvious ways of combining the two (such as treating gravity as simply another particle field) run quickly into what is known as the renormalization problem. Gravity particles would attract each other and adding together all of the interactions results in many infinite values which cannot easily be cancelled out mathematically to yield sensible, finite results.
The Wikipedia document goes on to list 13 candidate theories that could possibly provide the long-sought-after integration of quantum mechanics and the gravitational force.
In preparation for writing today's entry, over the holidays I read the book Three Roads to Quantum Gravity, by Lee Smolin. This review of Three Roads... from the Guardian provides an excellent overview of the book, to which I will just add a few thoughts.
As noted in the Guardian's review, the three "roads" that Smolin discusses are string theory, loop quantum gravity (LQG), and black hole thermodynamics. String theory has been written about extensively, including by the aforementioned Greene. I did not know much about LQG prior to reading Three Roads... and LQG is indeed a theory associated with author Smolin, so that is where I thought I would learn the most. I found Smolin's writing to be very conceptual, discussing ideas such as relational theories, the universe being "made of processes, not things," and "background independence." LQG struck me as being very geometrically oriented, with less discussion of how matter and other physical processes would fit in.
I will do full postings in the future on string theory, LQG, and black hole thermodynamics. The ideas involving black holes were the hardest for me to grasp, so I'll have to do a lot more reading on them; the following web document helps a bit.
Coincidentally, within days after I finished reading Three Roads..., I noticed a new special issue of Scientific American on "The Frontiers of Physics." The contents include an article on LQG by Smolin and an interview with Greene on string theory. I have enjoyed reading the articles thus far.
To conclude this series on the integration of quantum mechanics with the forces, here's a link to a University of Oregon page that concisely summarizes Quantum Electrodynamics, Quantum Chromodynamics, and Quantum Gravity, all within a single document.
Saturday, December 17, 2005
Quantum Chromodynamics
Continuing with our discussion of the integration of quantum mechanics with the forces of nature, today's topic is Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD), the quantum theory of the strong nuclear force. As discussed previously, the matter particles of the strong force are quarks, whereas the force-carrying particles are gluons (see the March and April 2005 archives, in the lower right-hand portion of the page). On the Particle Adventure website, the section on "What Holds it Together?" nicely describes the operation of the strong force, as well as the other forces.
Hadrons are combinations of quarks (and/or antiquarks; see here for description of antiparticles, which are symbolized by a horizontal bar over the letter symbol for a given particle).
Two types of hadrons are baryons, which consist of three quarks, and mesons, which consist of a quark-antiquark pair. One property of quarks, discussed earlier, is "flavor": up, down, strange, charmed, top, and bottom. Probably the best known baryons are protons (two up quarks and a down quark) and neutrons (two downs and an up).
An additional property of quarks is "color" (which really has nothing to do with pigmentation). That is where the "chromo" in QCD comes from. Combinations of quarks must "add" up to "white" or "neutral." Quoting from a Caltech document:
...the strong force comes in three forms of charge, called colors: blue, green, and red. These aren’t real colors visible to the eye, of course, but they do exhibit a similar bit of behavior—one blue, one green, and one red quark add up to be colorless, just as equal parts of blue, green, and red light add up to white light. All observable particles—your protons, neutrons, pions, kaons, and what have you—are color-neutral. And just as all particles, including quarks, have antiparticles, colors have anticolors: antiblue (yellow), antigreen (magenta), and antired (cyan). A bound pair of a color and its anticolor is also color-neutral.
These combinations are illustrated in a color wheel on the Caltech document.
A baryon (with three quarks) can thus consist of a blue, a green, and a red quark, whereas an antibaryon would consist of an antiblue, antigreen, and antired quark. A meson (quark-antiquark pair) could be blue-antiblue, green-antigreen, etc. Pions and kaons, which were noted above, are both types of mesons.
Flavor and color can occur in all possible combinations for a quark (e.g., red-up, green-up, blue-down). According to a New Mexico Tech document, "Counting all color and flavor combinations, there are 6 X 3 = 18 known varieties of quarks."
Andrew Watson's book The Quantum Quark provides a thorough overview of QCD. According to this book:
The simple blunt truth is that without color there would be no QCD since, according to QCD, color is the particle attribute through which those particles interact. That means experimenters need to come up with some pretty rock-solid evidence for color. And not just that: they must be able to show that there are three colors, no more and no less.
Experimenters have risen to the challenge. They have produced support for the existence of color, or at least something that behaves in just the way folk expect color to behave. They have also found evidence that the number of colors really is three (p. 183, my emphasis added).
As the Wikipedia document on QCD notes, two of its key aspects are asymptotic freedom (for which David Gross, Frank Wilczek, and David Politzer received the Nobel Prize) and confinement.
My perusal of some dictionary definitions of the word "asymptote" on the web suggests that it refers to approaching a limit, tending to zero, or getting close to something. In this context, the description of asymptotic freedom in the aforementioned Nobel Prize announcement is clear:
...the closer the quarks are to each other, the weaker is the 'colour charge'. When the quarks are really close to each other, the force is so weak that they behave almost as free particles. This phenomenon is called ”asymptotic freedom”. The converse is true when the quarks move apart: the force becomes stronger when the distance increases. This property may be compared to a rubber band. The more the band is stretched, the stronger the force.
Confinement means that single quarks cannot be observed alone and must join with other quarks or an antiquark. According to Physics Today:
Try to pry loose one of the three valence quarks in a proton. Before going much farther than the radius of the proton (about 1 fm or 10-13 cm), you've done enough work to create a new quark-antiquark pair. Pairs promptly appear, choose new partners, and you find a meson in one hand and a proton or neutron in the other. No isolated quarks! (The 10-13 should be read as 10 the minus 13th power.)
Quantum Chromodynamics, the quantum theory of the strong nuclear force, thus appears to be a thriving, empirically supported area of research. Linking quantum mechanics to the remaining force -- gravity -- is still under development, and will be examined in my next posting.
Hadrons are combinations of quarks (and/or antiquarks; see here for description of antiparticles, which are symbolized by a horizontal bar over the letter symbol for a given particle).
Two types of hadrons are baryons, which consist of three quarks, and mesons, which consist of a quark-antiquark pair. One property of quarks, discussed earlier, is "flavor": up, down, strange, charmed, top, and bottom. Probably the best known baryons are protons (two up quarks and a down quark) and neutrons (two downs and an up).
An additional property of quarks is "color" (which really has nothing to do with pigmentation). That is where the "chromo" in QCD comes from. Combinations of quarks must "add" up to "white" or "neutral." Quoting from a Caltech document:
...the strong force comes in three forms of charge, called colors: blue, green, and red. These aren’t real colors visible to the eye, of course, but they do exhibit a similar bit of behavior—one blue, one green, and one red quark add up to be colorless, just as equal parts of blue, green, and red light add up to white light. All observable particles—your protons, neutrons, pions, kaons, and what have you—are color-neutral. And just as all particles, including quarks, have antiparticles, colors have anticolors: antiblue (yellow), antigreen (magenta), and antired (cyan). A bound pair of a color and its anticolor is also color-neutral.
These combinations are illustrated in a color wheel on the Caltech document.
A baryon (with three quarks) can thus consist of a blue, a green, and a red quark, whereas an antibaryon would consist of an antiblue, antigreen, and antired quark. A meson (quark-antiquark pair) could be blue-antiblue, green-antigreen, etc. Pions and kaons, which were noted above, are both types of mesons.
Flavor and color can occur in all possible combinations for a quark (e.g., red-up, green-up, blue-down). According to a New Mexico Tech document, "Counting all color and flavor combinations, there are 6 X 3 = 18 known varieties of quarks."
Andrew Watson's book The Quantum Quark provides a thorough overview of QCD. According to this book:
The simple blunt truth is that without color there would be no QCD since, according to QCD, color is the particle attribute through which those particles interact. That means experimenters need to come up with some pretty rock-solid evidence for color. And not just that: they must be able to show that there are three colors, no more and no less.
Experimenters have risen to the challenge. They have produced support for the existence of color, or at least something that behaves in just the way folk expect color to behave. They have also found evidence that the number of colors really is three (p. 183, my emphasis added).
As the Wikipedia document on QCD notes, two of its key aspects are asymptotic freedom (for which David Gross, Frank Wilczek, and David Politzer received the Nobel Prize) and confinement.
My perusal of some dictionary definitions of the word "asymptote" on the web suggests that it refers to approaching a limit, tending to zero, or getting close to something. In this context, the description of asymptotic freedom in the aforementioned Nobel Prize announcement is clear:
...the closer the quarks are to each other, the weaker is the 'colour charge'. When the quarks are really close to each other, the force is so weak that they behave almost as free particles. This phenomenon is called ”asymptotic freedom”. The converse is true when the quarks move apart: the force becomes stronger when the distance increases. This property may be compared to a rubber band. The more the band is stretched, the stronger the force.
Confinement means that single quarks cannot be observed alone and must join with other quarks or an antiquark. According to Physics Today:
Try to pry loose one of the three valence quarks in a proton. Before going much farther than the radius of the proton (about 1 fm or 10-13 cm), you've done enough work to create a new quark-antiquark pair. Pairs promptly appear, choose new partners, and you find a meson in one hand and a proton or neutron in the other. No isolated quarks! (The 10-13 should be read as 10 the minus 13th power.)
Quantum Chromodynamics, the quantum theory of the strong nuclear force, thus appears to be a thriving, empirically supported area of research. Linking quantum mechanics to the remaining force -- gravity -- is still under development, and will be examined in my next posting.
Sunday, November 27, 2005
Quantum Electrodynamics
Way back on April 2, 2005, I introduced the four forces of nature. Then, from July to September, I wrote a series of essays describing quantum mechanics, the physics of extremely small scales (see archives at lower right-hand portion of the page). In fact, with varying degrees of success, the forces have been integrated with quantum mechanics to produce various quantum theories of the forces.
Today, I discuss Quantum Electrodynamics (QED), the quantum theory of the electromagnetic force. My main source on this topic is the book QED: The Strange Theory of Light and Matter, by the legendary physicist Richard P. Feynman. The book was based on a series of public lectures by Feynman; in my view, it starts off being reasonably understandable to a lay reader such as myself, but then increases in complexity.
In introducing the subject matter, Feynman goes back to the mid-1800's work of James Clerk Maxwell, one of the pioneering scientists in studying the connection between electricity and magnetism:
Because the theory of quantum mechanics could explain all of chemistry and the various properties of substances, it was a tremendous success. But still there was the problem of the interaction of light and matter. That is, Maxwell's theory of electricity and magnetism had to be changed to be in accord with the new principles of quantum mechanics that had been developed. So a new theory, the quantum theory of the interaction of light and matter, which is called by the horrible name "quantum electrodynamics," was finally developed by a number of physicists in 1929 (pp. 5-6).
Feynman, born in 1918, was thus just a youngster at the time of QED's founding (he died in 1988). It was around 1948, when Feynman was only about 30, that he made a major contribution to QED. As he notes in the book, he, Julian Schwinger, and Sin-Itiro Tomonaga came up with a breakthrough in how to calculate things in QED. For that, Feynman, Schwinger, and Tomonaga won the 1965 Nobel Prize. Writes Feynman in QED:
At last, we had a quantum theory of electricity and magnetism with which we could calculate!... The theory of quantum electrodynamics has now lasted for more than fifty years, and has been tested more and more accurately over a wider and wider range of conditions. At the present time I can proudly say that there is no significant difference between experiment and theory! (p. 7).
Feynman's discussion deals with photons (particles of light) and electrons. In keeping with the probabilistic nature of quantum mechanics (which I covered on September 10), Feynman begins with the example of "partial reflection." If one shines a light down on a piece of glass (about which Feynman notes, "... a piece of glass is a terrible monster of complexity -- huge numbers of electrons are jiggling about," p. 16), an average of 4% of the photons will bounce back up off the glass and 96% of photons will go through the glass.
Feynman then introduces a method for using arrows to conduct these probabilistic calculations, and then moves on to more complex examples. The use of arrows to depict processes in particle physics has been formalized in Feynman diagrams.
Another of the forces, the weak nuclear force, has also been integrated with QED, as part of "electroweak" theory. In the coming weeks, I will write about the quantum theory of the strong nuclear force (Quantum Chromodynamics) and about attempts to unify quantum mechanics with the remaining force, gravity.
Today, I discuss Quantum Electrodynamics (QED), the quantum theory of the electromagnetic force. My main source on this topic is the book QED: The Strange Theory of Light and Matter, by the legendary physicist Richard P. Feynman. The book was based on a series of public lectures by Feynman; in my view, it starts off being reasonably understandable to a lay reader such as myself, but then increases in complexity.
In introducing the subject matter, Feynman goes back to the mid-1800's work of James Clerk Maxwell, one of the pioneering scientists in studying the connection between electricity and magnetism:
Because the theory of quantum mechanics could explain all of chemistry and the various properties of substances, it was a tremendous success. But still there was the problem of the interaction of light and matter. That is, Maxwell's theory of electricity and magnetism had to be changed to be in accord with the new principles of quantum mechanics that had been developed. So a new theory, the quantum theory of the interaction of light and matter, which is called by the horrible name "quantum electrodynamics," was finally developed by a number of physicists in 1929 (pp. 5-6).
Feynman, born in 1918, was thus just a youngster at the time of QED's founding (he died in 1988). It was around 1948, when Feynman was only about 30, that he made a major contribution to QED. As he notes in the book, he, Julian Schwinger, and Sin-Itiro Tomonaga came up with a breakthrough in how to calculate things in QED. For that, Feynman, Schwinger, and Tomonaga won the 1965 Nobel Prize. Writes Feynman in QED:
At last, we had a quantum theory of electricity and magnetism with which we could calculate!... The theory of quantum electrodynamics has now lasted for more than fifty years, and has been tested more and more accurately over a wider and wider range of conditions. At the present time I can proudly say that there is no significant difference between experiment and theory! (p. 7).
Feynman's discussion deals with photons (particles of light) and electrons. In keeping with the probabilistic nature of quantum mechanics (which I covered on September 10), Feynman begins with the example of "partial reflection." If one shines a light down on a piece of glass (about which Feynman notes, "... a piece of glass is a terrible monster of complexity -- huge numbers of electrons are jiggling about," p. 16), an average of 4% of the photons will bounce back up off the glass and 96% of photons will go through the glass.
Feynman then introduces a method for using arrows to conduct these probabilistic calculations, and then moves on to more complex examples. The use of arrows to depict processes in particle physics has been formalized in Feynman diagrams.
Another of the forces, the weak nuclear force, has also been integrated with QED, as part of "electroweak" theory. In the coming weeks, I will write about the quantum theory of the strong nuclear force (Quantum Chromodynamics) and about attempts to unify quantum mechanics with the remaining force, gravity.
Monday, November 07, 2005
Book Review: "Football Physics"
Another book that I've read recently, which matches the current sports season, is Football Physics: The Science of the Game, by University of Nebraska physics professor Timothy Gay.
Before reading the book, I thought that I would find it useful on at least two levels. First, most of the physics reading I've done during the past year and a half has been in the particle area; I thought that Football Physics would provide an accessible discussion of classical/Newtonian physics, that is, the study of large, everyday objects. Second, although I have always been a huge sports fan, I have been concerned for many years about the high injury rate in football. The book, I thought, would give me additional information on the physics of collisions and why players are so vulnerable. In both areas, I'm pleased to say, I got out of the book what I thought I would.
The book can be grouped into a number of different topics. Covered first is what might be called the physics of play in "the trenches." Blocking, tackling, collisions, quarterback sneaks, and offensive linemen exploding off the snap are all covered in the first two chapters. These chapters invoke physics concepts including Newton's laws of motion (such as the second law, where force equals mass times acceleration), momentum, torque, work, kinetic energy, and power. We learn that, for a linebacker such as Dick Butkus to stop a running back of a certain mass running at a certain speed, might take 1,150 pounds of force!
Next is the study of play in the open field: receivers' running of pass patterns (and timing with the quarterback), runners' "juking" to try to fake out defensive players, and defenders' pursuit of ball carriers (what fans might think of as who has the "angle"). Here we get vectors, Cartesian coordinates, and the Pythagorean theorem.
The projectile motion of the flying football (punted, kicked, and passed) takes up the next three chapters. Altitude, air drag, spiraling and spinning of the ball are all covered here, plus the mechanics of the kicking motion.
The study of players' football gear comes next, which is probably most relevant to my interest in football injuries. What I found most interesting is how the helmet serves a protective role. The surface or plastic shell of the helmet distributes the force of an incoming head-to-head hit more widely than if the recipient of the hit were not wearing a helmet (it hurts just thinking about the latter option!). Further, the padding within a helmet lengthens the duration of a collision, lessening the average force.
Another injury-related concern involves the type of turf in a stadium, either artificial turf (such as Astroturf) or natural grass. Old-fashioned artificial turf (carpet placed over a parking lot, with some thin padding in between) has been thought to create an injury hazard, due to its hardness and lack of "give" when a player plants his foot. Gay states that:
During the 1980s and mid-1990s, after a series of extensive studies, a consensus developed that playing football on Astroturf and its variants was, in fact, more likely to cause serious injury than playing on natural grass (p. 226).
(As Gay also notes, some newer hybrid surfaces have been introduced in recent years that appear to be more forgiving than old-fashioned artificial turf and perhaps safer; such hybrids include Field Turf and Sport Grass.)
In terms of the physics of turf, one important concept is friction. This area gets a little complicated, but a key distinction is between static friction (related to the traction or "grab" of the turf) and breakaway/sliding friction. Using the analogy of trying to pull apart connected pieces of Velcro, Gay notes that, "...the force required to initiate the sliding can be quite large, because each piece has its hooks firmly anchored in the other's 'loops.' Once the hooks have broken away, the sliding force becomes relatively small" (p. 233).
The final chapter, "Waves in the Stadium," concerns sound waves (noise) and fans doing the wave.
As Gay notes in the book, another contribution of his to popularizing physics within the football context is his appearance in short videos shown on the scoreboard at Nebraska football games, describing the physics of various football phenomena. Those video clips are also available on Gay's faculty website (click here).
Professor Gay also refers readers to a football physics site at the University of Tennessee.
In fact, nice tutorials have been written by a variety of authors on the physics of numerous different sports. In the months ahead, I will feature these tutorials.
Before reading the book, I thought that I would find it useful on at least two levels. First, most of the physics reading I've done during the past year and a half has been in the particle area; I thought that Football Physics would provide an accessible discussion of classical/Newtonian physics, that is, the study of large, everyday objects. Second, although I have always been a huge sports fan, I have been concerned for many years about the high injury rate in football. The book, I thought, would give me additional information on the physics of collisions and why players are so vulnerable. In both areas, I'm pleased to say, I got out of the book what I thought I would.
The book can be grouped into a number of different topics. Covered first is what might be called the physics of play in "the trenches." Blocking, tackling, collisions, quarterback sneaks, and offensive linemen exploding off the snap are all covered in the first two chapters. These chapters invoke physics concepts including Newton's laws of motion (such as the second law, where force equals mass times acceleration), momentum, torque, work, kinetic energy, and power. We learn that, for a linebacker such as Dick Butkus to stop a running back of a certain mass running at a certain speed, might take 1,150 pounds of force!
Next is the study of play in the open field: receivers' running of pass patterns (and timing with the quarterback), runners' "juking" to try to fake out defensive players, and defenders' pursuit of ball carriers (what fans might think of as who has the "angle"). Here we get vectors, Cartesian coordinates, and the Pythagorean theorem.
The projectile motion of the flying football (punted, kicked, and passed) takes up the next three chapters. Altitude, air drag, spiraling and spinning of the ball are all covered here, plus the mechanics of the kicking motion.
The study of players' football gear comes next, which is probably most relevant to my interest in football injuries. What I found most interesting is how the helmet serves a protective role. The surface or plastic shell of the helmet distributes the force of an incoming head-to-head hit more widely than if the recipient of the hit were not wearing a helmet (it hurts just thinking about the latter option!). Further, the padding within a helmet lengthens the duration of a collision, lessening the average force.
Another injury-related concern involves the type of turf in a stadium, either artificial turf (such as Astroturf) or natural grass. Old-fashioned artificial turf (carpet placed over a parking lot, with some thin padding in between) has been thought to create an injury hazard, due to its hardness and lack of "give" when a player plants his foot. Gay states that:
During the 1980s and mid-1990s, after a series of extensive studies, a consensus developed that playing football on Astroturf and its variants was, in fact, more likely to cause serious injury than playing on natural grass (p. 226).
(As Gay also notes, some newer hybrid surfaces have been introduced in recent years that appear to be more forgiving than old-fashioned artificial turf and perhaps safer; such hybrids include Field Turf and Sport Grass.)
In terms of the physics of turf, one important concept is friction. This area gets a little complicated, but a key distinction is between static friction (related to the traction or "grab" of the turf) and breakaway/sliding friction. Using the analogy of trying to pull apart connected pieces of Velcro, Gay notes that, "...the force required to initiate the sliding can be quite large, because each piece has its hooks firmly anchored in the other's 'loops.' Once the hooks have broken away, the sliding force becomes relatively small" (p. 233).
The final chapter, "Waves in the Stadium," concerns sound waves (noise) and fans doing the wave.
As Gay notes in the book, another contribution of his to popularizing physics within the football context is his appearance in short videos shown on the scoreboard at Nebraska football games, describing the physics of various football phenomena. Those video clips are also available on Gay's faculty website (click here).
Professor Gay also refers readers to a football physics site at the University of Tennessee.
In fact, nice tutorials have been written by a variety of authors on the physics of numerous different sports. In the months ahead, I will feature these tutorials.
Sunday, October 16, 2005
Book Review: "Constructing Quarks"
While working on my series of essays on quantum mechanics over the last couple of months, I was also reading some books related to other areas of physics. In my next couple of postings, I would like to discuss these books.
The first book I would like to discuss is an older one, published in 1984. It is entitled Constructing Quarks: A Sociological History of Particle Physics and written by Andrew Pickering. I introduced quarks and other particles of matter back on March 18 and March 26, 2005.
The main idea of Pickering's book is that, contrary to the image many may hold of science where conclusions about which theories to support are based on self-evident, objective findings of experiments, in actuality a lot of subjectivity goes into scientific judgments. I, myself, am a social scientist, so the study of how ideas become popular or unpopular had some appeal to me. It turns out, however, that the book's 400-plus pages contain quite a lot of technical physics, with some sociology sporadically inserted.
One example of Pickering's thesis about subjectivity involves acceptance of the "standard model of electroweak interactions" over possible alternatives (click here for the Wikipedia's coverage of the electroweak model, and here for my earlier discussion of the forces of nature, including the electromagnetic and weak forces). Pickering argues that:
In retrospect, it is easy to gloss the triumph of the standard model in the idiom of the 'scientist's account': the Weinberg-Salam model... made predictions which were verified by the facts. But missing from this gloss, as usual, is the element of choice. In assenting to the validity of the standard model, particle physicists chose to accept certain experimental reports and to reject others. This element of choice was most conspicuous in the communal change of heart over the Washington-Oxford atomic-physics experiments... ...in 1977 many physicists were prepared to accept the null-results of the Washington and Oxford experiments and to construct new electroweak models to explain them. We also saw that by 1979 attitudes had hardened. In the wake of Experiment E122, the Washington-Oxford results had come to be regarded as unreliable. In analysing this sequence, it is important to recognise that between 1977 and 1979 there had been no intrinsic change in the status of the Washington-Oxford experiments. No data were withdrawn, and no fatal flaws in the experimental practice of either group had been proposed. What had changed was the context within which the data were assessed... (p. 301).
In another episode, regarding "charmed" quarks, Pickering writes that:
It was no coincidence that the charm explanation of the new particles triumphed... The charm explanation sustained a multifaceted symbiosis of practice, wherein gauge theorists, hadron spectroscopists and experimenters in a whole range of traditions could draw upon one another's research for justification and subject matter for future practice... By 1976, charm was central to such a range of practice that arguments could always be marshalled in favour of seeing misfits between prediction and data as important results rather than as serious problems. That, for example, the hidden-charm [Greek letter symbols that I can't show] particles first appeared at the wrong masses and then disappeared caused few doubts, if any, over the validity of charm. Such discrepant phenomena were simply seen to call for further theoretical and experimental work, which would itself command the attention of a wide audience. Alternative models of the new particles did not inspire such dynamic acquiescence... (p. 272).
Thomas Kuhn is a major figure in the dynamics of scientific trends. His ideas are discussed as follows in a Caltech paper on "How Science Works" (p. 6):
A paradigm, for Kuhn, is a sort of consensual world view within which scientists work. It comprises an agreed upon set of assumptions, methods, language, and everything else needed to do science. Within a given paradigm, scientists make steady, incremental progress, doing what Kuhn calls “normal science.”
As time goes on, difficulties and contradictions arise that cannot be resolved, but one way or another, they are swept under the rug, rather than being allowed to threaten the central paradigm. However, at a certain point, enough of these difficulties have accumulated so that the situation becomes intolerable. At that point, a scientific revolution occurs, shattering the paradigm and replacing it with an entirely new one.
The first book I would like to discuss is an older one, published in 1984. It is entitled Constructing Quarks: A Sociological History of Particle Physics and written by Andrew Pickering. I introduced quarks and other particles of matter back on March 18 and March 26, 2005.
The main idea of Pickering's book is that, contrary to the image many may hold of science where conclusions about which theories to support are based on self-evident, objective findings of experiments, in actuality a lot of subjectivity goes into scientific judgments. I, myself, am a social scientist, so the study of how ideas become popular or unpopular had some appeal to me. It turns out, however, that the book's 400-plus pages contain quite a lot of technical physics, with some sociology sporadically inserted.
One example of Pickering's thesis about subjectivity involves acceptance of the "standard model of electroweak interactions" over possible alternatives (click here for the Wikipedia's coverage of the electroweak model, and here for my earlier discussion of the forces of nature, including the electromagnetic and weak forces). Pickering argues that:
In retrospect, it is easy to gloss the triumph of the standard model in the idiom of the 'scientist's account': the Weinberg-Salam model... made predictions which were verified by the facts. But missing from this gloss, as usual, is the element of choice. In assenting to the validity of the standard model, particle physicists chose to accept certain experimental reports and to reject others. This element of choice was most conspicuous in the communal change of heart over the Washington-Oxford atomic-physics experiments... ...in 1977 many physicists were prepared to accept the null-results of the Washington and Oxford experiments and to construct new electroweak models to explain them. We also saw that by 1979 attitudes had hardened. In the wake of Experiment E122, the Washington-Oxford results had come to be regarded as unreliable. In analysing this sequence, it is important to recognise that between 1977 and 1979 there had been no intrinsic change in the status of the Washington-Oxford experiments. No data were withdrawn, and no fatal flaws in the experimental practice of either group had been proposed. What had changed was the context within which the data were assessed... (p. 301).
In another episode, regarding "charmed" quarks, Pickering writes that:
It was no coincidence that the charm explanation of the new particles triumphed... The charm explanation sustained a multifaceted symbiosis of practice, wherein gauge theorists, hadron spectroscopists and experimenters in a whole range of traditions could draw upon one another's research for justification and subject matter for future practice... By 1976, charm was central to such a range of practice that arguments could always be marshalled in favour of seeing misfits between prediction and data as important results rather than as serious problems. That, for example, the hidden-charm [Greek letter symbols that I can't show] particles first appeared at the wrong masses and then disappeared caused few doubts, if any, over the validity of charm. Such discrepant phenomena were simply seen to call for further theoretical and experimental work, which would itself command the attention of a wide audience. Alternative models of the new particles did not inspire such dynamic acquiescence... (p. 272).
Thomas Kuhn is a major figure in the dynamics of scientific trends. His ideas are discussed as follows in a Caltech paper on "How Science Works" (p. 6):
A paradigm, for Kuhn, is a sort of consensual world view within which scientists work. It comprises an agreed upon set of assumptions, methods, language, and everything else needed to do science. Within a given paradigm, scientists make steady, incremental progress, doing what Kuhn calls “normal science.”
As time goes on, difficulties and contradictions arise that cannot be resolved, but one way or another, they are swept under the rug, rather than being allowed to threaten the central paradigm. However, at a certain point, enough of these difficulties have accumulated so that the situation becomes intolerable. At that point, a scientific revolution occurs, shattering the paradigm and replacing it with an entirely new one.
Thursday, September 22, 2005
Quantum Mechanics Part VI
My previous postings on quantum mechanics have emphasized its probabilistic nature and the role of uncertainty. Another important aspect of quantum mechanics, which I will discuss in today's concluding essay of the series, is how, under quantum mechanics, many properties must take on integer (i.e., whole-number or discrete) values.
According to a document from the Stanford Linear Accelerator Center (SLAC), specifically a section entitled, "Discrete Energy, Momenta, and Angular Momenta," here is how one could think of quantum mechanics:
To get some idea of how counter-intuitive this idea of discrete values is, imagine if someone told you that water could have only integer temperatures as you boiled it. For example, the water could have temperatures of 85º, 86º or 87º, but not 85.7º or 86.5º. It would be a pretty strange world you were living in if that were true.
In fact, according to the Wikipedia, the word quantum "is often used in the more specific sense which it has in physics, where a quantum refers to an indivisible, and perhaps elementary entity."
Perhaps the most interesting illustration of discrete, whole-number phenomena -- to me at least -- is the Bohr model of the atom (sometimes also known as the Rutherford-Bohr model), with electrons orbiting the nucleus like the planets orbiting the sun in the solar system. These orbits have discrete distances from the nucleus. According to an Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) document:
Each orbit around the nucleus represents an energy level, and electrons cannot exist in between orbits. Orbits closer to the nucleus have lower energy. If energy is added, an electron can be "excited" to jump to a higher energy level--an orbit farther from the nucleus. Eventually, though, the electron will return to its original state, and the atom will give off energy equal to the difference between the two orbits.
In some materials, the energy is given off as X-rays; other materials produce specific colors of visible light, or other types of electromagnetic energy.
The University of Colorado's Physics 2000 website has an interactive activity where you can click to move the electron to an orbit closer to or farther from the nucleus and see what happens. In this demonstration, when the electron moves to a more inner orbit, it gives up a photon (a particle of light, also known as a quantum of light). When it moves to a more outer orbit, it takes on a photon.
According to the aforementioned EPA document, the Rutherford-Bohr model was not perfect. However, Schrodinger (a name we've seen in the past) was able to propose some corrective modifications.
Frequently during this series, I've noted Albert Einstein's objections to many ideas that emerged from quantum mechanics. In fact, Einstein actually played a major role in launching quantum mechanics!
Washington University (St. Louis) physicist John Rigden argues in a Physics World article that, of the multiple landmark papers published by Einstein in 1905, the one characterizing light in terms of discrete particles is the one that really stands out:
The big idea in Einstein's March paper was his gentle suggestion that light consists of individual, discrete, localized and indivisible quantum particles. This blithely made, audacious claim contradicted a century of compelling empirical evidence, and it challenged the crowning achievement of 19th-century theoretical physics: the electromagnetic theory of light. It can be argued persuasively that Einstein's March paper was the start of quantum physics.
According to a document from the Stanford Linear Accelerator Center (SLAC), specifically a section entitled, "Discrete Energy, Momenta, and Angular Momenta," here is how one could think of quantum mechanics:
To get some idea of how counter-intuitive this idea of discrete values is, imagine if someone told you that water could have only integer temperatures as you boiled it. For example, the water could have temperatures of 85º, 86º or 87º, but not 85.7º or 86.5º. It would be a pretty strange world you were living in if that were true.
In fact, according to the Wikipedia, the word quantum "is often used in the more specific sense which it has in physics, where a quantum refers to an indivisible, and perhaps elementary entity."
Perhaps the most interesting illustration of discrete, whole-number phenomena -- to me at least -- is the Bohr model of the atom (sometimes also known as the Rutherford-Bohr model), with electrons orbiting the nucleus like the planets orbiting the sun in the solar system. These orbits have discrete distances from the nucleus. According to an Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) document:
Each orbit around the nucleus represents an energy level, and electrons cannot exist in between orbits. Orbits closer to the nucleus have lower energy. If energy is added, an electron can be "excited" to jump to a higher energy level--an orbit farther from the nucleus. Eventually, though, the electron will return to its original state, and the atom will give off energy equal to the difference between the two orbits.
In some materials, the energy is given off as X-rays; other materials produce specific colors of visible light, or other types of electromagnetic energy.
The University of Colorado's Physics 2000 website has an interactive activity where you can click to move the electron to an orbit closer to or farther from the nucleus and see what happens. In this demonstration, when the electron moves to a more inner orbit, it gives up a photon (a particle of light, also known as a quantum of light). When it moves to a more outer orbit, it takes on a photon.
According to the aforementioned EPA document, the Rutherford-Bohr model was not perfect. However, Schrodinger (a name we've seen in the past) was able to propose some corrective modifications.
Frequently during this series, I've noted Albert Einstein's objections to many ideas that emerged from quantum mechanics. In fact, Einstein actually played a major role in launching quantum mechanics!
Washington University (St. Louis) physicist John Rigden argues in a Physics World article that, of the multiple landmark papers published by Einstein in 1905, the one characterizing light in terms of discrete particles is the one that really stands out:
The big idea in Einstein's March paper was his gentle suggestion that light consists of individual, discrete, localized and indivisible quantum particles. This blithely made, audacious claim contradicted a century of compelling empirical evidence, and it challenged the crowning achievement of 19th-century theoretical physics: the electromagnetic theory of light. It can be argued persuasively that Einstein's March paper was the start of quantum physics.
Saturday, September 10, 2005
Quantum Mechanics Part V
As has been discussed in this series of postings on quantum mechanics, probability and uncertainty are key elements of the subatomic world. Einstein found this aspect of quantum mechanics particularly distasteful, making a famous statement that "God does not play dice with the universe" (the exact wording of this quote differs, depending on the source one looks at).
Physicists have come up with some creative ways of conceptualizing probability within quantum mechanics. A particle may take on one property or another, each with some probability. How the different possibilities are represented is where the ideas get, shall we say, interesting.
Three excellent sources on quantum probability include the 1959 book The Strange Story of the Quantum by Banesh Hoffmann, the 2002 book Quantum Physics: A Beginner's Guide to the Subatomic World by John Gribbin, and a June 2005 profile of Sir Roger Penrose in Discover magazine by Tim Folger.
One approach, known as the Copenhagen Interpretation, essentially says that a system shifts around between possible outcomes while not being observed, but settles upon one definite outcome upon observation. According to Gribbin:
The Interpretation says that a quantum system does not exist in a definite state until it is measured. For example, an electron traveling through the double-slit experiment does so as a spread-out wave, and does not have a precise location in space. It is only when it arrives at the detector screen that it makes a "choice" from the probabilities (like a tumbling die finally settling with three spots facing up) which causes the wave function to "collapse," as Bohr put it, onto a single point (p. 30).
(My earlier discussion of the double-slit experiment is available here.)
Hoffmann uses a different analogy:
When we flip a coin, it is neither heads nor tails until it actually lands... The state would be changed from a combination to a pure state, and it would be changed by the very act of observation... we might even imagine the coin could be twirling... The only trouble would be that we had no way of observing the actual twirling itself... the joke is that we really do not know whether the coin was twirling at all... (excerpts from pp. 161-164).
Another approach, known as the Many Worlds Interpretation, says that each possible outcome can exist in a definite state, but each would do so in a different world (or "Parallel Universe"). As described by Folger, in his profile of Penrose:
Called the many worlds interpretation, it was proposed in 1957 by Princeton University doctoral candidate Hugh Everett III. Its adherents take the laws of quantum theory at face value: Every possible quantum outcome really exists -- but in worlds parallel to our own. In one universe, Penrose is talking with me in Oxford; in another, he is watching a monster-truck rally (p. 32).
Folger notes that, "Penrose cannot believe anyone finds either the Copenhagen interpretation or the many worlds picture satisfactory" (p. 32). Penrose has his own gravity-based interpretation, which the Discover article spells out.
Another famous vehicle for examining these issues is the Schrodinger cat scenario, which I'll also leave for readers to read about on their own.
In conclusion, unlike Einstein, others are not bothered by the probabilistic foundation of quantum mechanics. Notes Hoffmann:
...probabilities are potent things -- if only they are applied to large numbers... we really place far more confidence in the certainty of probabilities than we sometimes like to admit to ourselves when thinking of them abstractly... Roulette casinos rely on probabilities for their gambling profits... (p. 175)
Physicists have come up with some creative ways of conceptualizing probability within quantum mechanics. A particle may take on one property or another, each with some probability. How the different possibilities are represented is where the ideas get, shall we say, interesting.
Three excellent sources on quantum probability include the 1959 book The Strange Story of the Quantum by Banesh Hoffmann, the 2002 book Quantum Physics: A Beginner's Guide to the Subatomic World by John Gribbin, and a June 2005 profile of Sir Roger Penrose in Discover magazine by Tim Folger.
One approach, known as the Copenhagen Interpretation, essentially says that a system shifts around between possible outcomes while not being observed, but settles upon one definite outcome upon observation. According to Gribbin:
The Interpretation says that a quantum system does not exist in a definite state until it is measured. For example, an electron traveling through the double-slit experiment does so as a spread-out wave, and does not have a precise location in space. It is only when it arrives at the detector screen that it makes a "choice" from the probabilities (like a tumbling die finally settling with three spots facing up) which causes the wave function to "collapse," as Bohr put it, onto a single point (p. 30).
(My earlier discussion of the double-slit experiment is available here.)
Hoffmann uses a different analogy:
When we flip a coin, it is neither heads nor tails until it actually lands... The state would be changed from a combination to a pure state, and it would be changed by the very act of observation... we might even imagine the coin could be twirling... The only trouble would be that we had no way of observing the actual twirling itself... the joke is that we really do not know whether the coin was twirling at all... (excerpts from pp. 161-164).
Another approach, known as the Many Worlds Interpretation, says that each possible outcome can exist in a definite state, but each would do so in a different world (or "Parallel Universe"). As described by Folger, in his profile of Penrose:
Called the many worlds interpretation, it was proposed in 1957 by Princeton University doctoral candidate Hugh Everett III. Its adherents take the laws of quantum theory at face value: Every possible quantum outcome really exists -- but in worlds parallel to our own. In one universe, Penrose is talking with me in Oxford; in another, he is watching a monster-truck rally (p. 32).
Folger notes that, "Penrose cannot believe anyone finds either the Copenhagen interpretation or the many worlds picture satisfactory" (p. 32). Penrose has his own gravity-based interpretation, which the Discover article spells out.
Another famous vehicle for examining these issues is the Schrodinger cat scenario, which I'll also leave for readers to read about on their own.
In conclusion, unlike Einstein, others are not bothered by the probabilistic foundation of quantum mechanics. Notes Hoffmann:
...probabilities are potent things -- if only they are applied to large numbers... we really place far more confidence in the certainty of probabilities than we sometimes like to admit to ourselves when thinking of them abstractly... Roulette casinos rely on probabilities for their gambling profits... (p. 175)
Saturday, September 03, 2005
Quantum Mechanics Part IV
Where I last left off, Einstein (with colleagues Podolsky and Rosen, a trio sometimes known as EPR) had questioned the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle's suggestion that a particle could not simultaneously have a definite position and a definite velocity, and had questioned quantum mechanics more generally. One of the arguments put forth by EPR leads into a discussion of the topic I'd like to cover in today's entry, quantum entanglement.
In his book The Fabric of the Cosmos, Brian Greene notes how there are analogies in particle physics to the example of two people standing back to back then each starting to walk in opposite directions at the same speed. However many miles east, let's say, of the starting point one person is, the other person would be the same number of miles west of it. Greene notes that:
...if an initial single particle should disintegrate into two particles of equal mass that fly off "back-to-back"..., something that is common in the realm of subatomic particle physics, the velocities of the two constituents will be equal and opposite (p. 100).
According to Greene, EPR's argument followed thusly:
...imagine you measure the position of the right-moving particle and in this way learn, indirectly, the position of the left-moving particle. EPR argued that since you have done nothing, absolutely nothing, to the left-moving particle, it must have had this position, and all you have done is determine it, albeit indirectly (p. 101).
The research that ultimately contradicted EPR and supported quantum mechanics and all its weirdness showed that measurement of one particle of a pair actually did appear to affect the properties of the other particle. This type of finding has now been demonstrated with the two particles being as far as 11 kilometers (over 6 miles) apart. Adds Greene:
On the microscopic scale of the photon's wavelengths, 11 kilometers is gargantuan. It might as well be 11 million kilometers -- or 11 billion light-years, for that matter. There is every reason to believe that the correlation between the photons would persist no matter how far apart the detectors are placed (p. 115).
When two particles of a pair had corresponding (correlated) properties, skeptics initially could argue that such correlation may have been preprogrammed into the pair from their common origin. Such an objection was ultimately overcome by a statistical type of argument (credited to John Bell) and experiments supportive of it. This is all summarized at great length in Greene's chapter on quantum entanglement.
On this whole phenomenon and whether special relativity's provision that nothing can travel faster than the speed of light is possibly violated, Greene offers some reflections:
At the end of the day... two widely separated particles... somehow stay sufficiently "in touch" so that whatever one does, the other instantly does too. And that seems to suggest that some kind of faster-than-light something is operating between them. Where do we stand? There is no ironclad, universally accepted answer... (pp. 117-118).
Quantum entanglement may also serve as a mechanism for teleportation, which is sort of like "faxing" a physical object from one place to another. Greene discusses this in another of his chapters.
For further reading, general-audience articles on quantum entanglement and its possible implications are available here and here.
In his book The Fabric of the Cosmos, Brian Greene notes how there are analogies in particle physics to the example of two people standing back to back then each starting to walk in opposite directions at the same speed. However many miles east, let's say, of the starting point one person is, the other person would be the same number of miles west of it. Greene notes that:
...if an initial single particle should disintegrate into two particles of equal mass that fly off "back-to-back"..., something that is common in the realm of subatomic particle physics, the velocities of the two constituents will be equal and opposite (p. 100).
According to Greene, EPR's argument followed thusly:
...imagine you measure the position of the right-moving particle and in this way learn, indirectly, the position of the left-moving particle. EPR argued that since you have done nothing, absolutely nothing, to the left-moving particle, it must have had this position, and all you have done is determine it, albeit indirectly (p. 101).
The research that ultimately contradicted EPR and supported quantum mechanics and all its weirdness showed that measurement of one particle of a pair actually did appear to affect the properties of the other particle. This type of finding has now been demonstrated with the two particles being as far as 11 kilometers (over 6 miles) apart. Adds Greene:
On the microscopic scale of the photon's wavelengths, 11 kilometers is gargantuan. It might as well be 11 million kilometers -- or 11 billion light-years, for that matter. There is every reason to believe that the correlation between the photons would persist no matter how far apart the detectors are placed (p. 115).
When two particles of a pair had corresponding (correlated) properties, skeptics initially could argue that such correlation may have been preprogrammed into the pair from their common origin. Such an objection was ultimately overcome by a statistical type of argument (credited to John Bell) and experiments supportive of it. This is all summarized at great length in Greene's chapter on quantum entanglement.
On this whole phenomenon and whether special relativity's provision that nothing can travel faster than the speed of light is possibly violated, Greene offers some reflections:
At the end of the day... two widely separated particles... somehow stay sufficiently "in touch" so that whatever one does, the other instantly does too. And that seems to suggest that some kind of faster-than-light something is operating between them. Where do we stand? There is no ironclad, universally accepted answer... (pp. 117-118).
Quantum entanglement may also serve as a mechanism for teleportation, which is sort of like "faxing" a physical object from one place to another. Greene discusses this in another of his chapters.
For further reading, general-audience articles on quantum entanglement and its possible implications are available here and here.
Saturday, August 13, 2005
Quantum Mechanics Part III
As has been discussed in my recent series of essays on quantum mechanics, an entity's location involves a lot of weird ideas. According to the concept of a probability wave, based on the size of a wave at a given location, an object might be here with some probability or there with some probability. It might even be in two places at once.
Another major topic in quantum mechanics related to this theme is the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle. Brian Greene, in his book The Fabric of the Cosmos, characterizes the principle as follows:
It says, roughly speaking, that the physical features of the microscopic realm (particle positions, velocities, energies, angular momenta, and so on) can be divided into two lists, A and B... the more precise your knowledge of a feature from one list, the less precise your knowledge can possibly be about the corresponding feature from the second list... As an example, the more precisely you know where a particle is, the less precisely you can possibly know its speed (p. 96).
A common explanation of the Uncertaintly Principle, which Greene cites, but acknowledges as "incomplete," is as follows:
When we measure the position of any object, we generally interact with it in some manner... Even light [for seeing an object to locate it], when bouncing off an object, gives it a tiny push. Now, for day-to-day objects such as the book in your hand or a clock on the wall, the wispy little push of bouncing light has no noticeable effect. But when it strikes a tiny particle like an electron it can have a big effect: as the light bounces off the electron, it changes the electron's speed... (pp. 96-97).
Greene later cautions that:
The explanation of uncertainty as arising through the unavoidable disturbance caused by the measurement process has provided physicists with a useful intuitive guide as well as a powerful explanatory framework in certain specific situations. However, it can also be misleading. It may give the impression that uncertainty arises only when we lumbering experimenters meddle with things. This is not true. Uncertainty is built into the wave structure of quantum mechanics and exists whether or not we carry out some clumsy measurement (p. 98).
Although I tend to stay away from mathematical aspects on this website, the Uncertainty Principle is embodied in an equation. As John Gribbin notes in Quantum Physics: A Beginner's Guide to the Subatomic World:
...the uncertainty in position multiplied by the uncertainty in momentum is always greater than Planck's constant. We do not notice Planck's constant in everyday life because it is so small, but it is very important for an electron (pp. 33-34).
In other words, the uncertainty in these physical features can never be reduced to zero and must exceed a certain value (Planck's constant), albeit a small value.
The Uncertainty Principle also played a role in the famous debates between Albert Einstein (critiquing quantum mechanics) and Niels Bohr (defending it), each of whom was joined by other colleagues.
As I read Greene's discussion on pages 99-103, Einstein's position (with colleagues Podolsky and Rosen) was that particles do simultaneously possess definite positions and velocities, but the inability to determine both was a limitation of quantum mechanics. Bohr (joined by Pauli and perhaps others) argued that, whether or not particles really do have simultaneously measurable positions and velocities, all that matters to science is what can be measured.
An essay by Rochelle Forrester probes aspects of the Bohr-Einstein debate in greater detail.
Another major topic in quantum mechanics related to this theme is the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle. Brian Greene, in his book The Fabric of the Cosmos, characterizes the principle as follows:
It says, roughly speaking, that the physical features of the microscopic realm (particle positions, velocities, energies, angular momenta, and so on) can be divided into two lists, A and B... the more precise your knowledge of a feature from one list, the less precise your knowledge can possibly be about the corresponding feature from the second list... As an example, the more precisely you know where a particle is, the less precisely you can possibly know its speed (p. 96).
A common explanation of the Uncertaintly Principle, which Greene cites, but acknowledges as "incomplete," is as follows:
When we measure the position of any object, we generally interact with it in some manner... Even light [for seeing an object to locate it], when bouncing off an object, gives it a tiny push. Now, for day-to-day objects such as the book in your hand or a clock on the wall, the wispy little push of bouncing light has no noticeable effect. But when it strikes a tiny particle like an electron it can have a big effect: as the light bounces off the electron, it changes the electron's speed... (pp. 96-97).
Greene later cautions that:
The explanation of uncertainty as arising through the unavoidable disturbance caused by the measurement process has provided physicists with a useful intuitive guide as well as a powerful explanatory framework in certain specific situations. However, it can also be misleading. It may give the impression that uncertainty arises only when we lumbering experimenters meddle with things. This is not true. Uncertainty is built into the wave structure of quantum mechanics and exists whether or not we carry out some clumsy measurement (p. 98).
Although I tend to stay away from mathematical aspects on this website, the Uncertainty Principle is embodied in an equation. As John Gribbin notes in Quantum Physics: A Beginner's Guide to the Subatomic World:
...the uncertainty in position multiplied by the uncertainty in momentum is always greater than Planck's constant. We do not notice Planck's constant in everyday life because it is so small, but it is very important for an electron (pp. 33-34).
In other words, the uncertainty in these physical features can never be reduced to zero and must exceed a certain value (Planck's constant), albeit a small value.
The Uncertainty Principle also played a role in the famous debates between Albert Einstein (critiquing quantum mechanics) and Niels Bohr (defending it), each of whom was joined by other colleagues.
As I read Greene's discussion on pages 99-103, Einstein's position (with colleagues Podolsky and Rosen) was that particles do simultaneously possess definite positions and velocities, but the inability to determine both was a limitation of quantum mechanics. Bohr (joined by Pauli and perhaps others) argued that, whether or not particles really do have simultaneously measurable positions and velocities, all that matters to science is what can be measured.
An essay by Rochelle Forrester probes aspects of the Bohr-Einstein debate in greater detail.
Tuesday, August 02, 2005
Quantum Mechanics Part II
As a way of introducing quantum mechanics (QM), many sources begin with what are known as the double-slit experiments. I had initially wondered whether the double-slit experiments were a straightforward (or necessary) vehicle for discussing QM. Now, however, after reading (and re-reading) descriptions of the experiments in several non-technical books and articles, I have a better idea of their usefulness. Specifically, the double-slit experiments convey at least two central concepts of QM, its probabilistic nature and the idea of a small particle seemingly being able to be at two places at the same time.
In fact, in John Gribbin's book The Search for Superstrings, Symmetry, and the Theory of Everything, it is indeed a double-slit experiment that he cites as "contain[ing] the essence of quantum physics and lay[ing] bare its central mystery" (p. 27).
Those of you who took physics or other science courses in high school may remember the idea of light existing as both a wave and a particle. I’ll first describe the double-slit experiment from the perspective of light as a wave.
Whether from being in the ocean at the beach or among a crowd at a sporting event doing “the wave,” we know that a wave is a curvy, undulating structure with some segments that are high (a rising wave or a section of fans rising out of their seats) and other segments that are low. One type of wave might look like the following:
^^^^^^^^
In his book The Fabric of the Cosmos, Brian Greene describes an experiment where a laser pointer shines light at a sheet of a certain kind of film with two vertical lines scratched away (the double slits). On a detector screen behind the double-slit screen, what will show up is a series of vertical light and dark stripes, varying in their thickness and intensity. Summarizes Greene:
Light is an electromagnetic wave; when it passes through the two slits, it splits into two waves that head toward the screen. …the two light waves interfere with each other. When they hit various points on the screen, sometimes both waves are at their peaks, making the screen bright; sometimes both waves are at their troughs, also making it bright; but sometimes one wave is at its peak and the other is at its trough and they cancel, making that point on the screen dark (p. 85).
The following website by Dave Jarvis, though focused primarily on quantum entanglement (a topic I'll take up at some future point), begins with an excellent introduction to waves, including discussion of how waves combine with each other.
So far, everything probably seems reasonable. What if, instead of shining waves of light through double slits, we sent particle entities of various sizes through the slits?
As described in a June 2005 Discover magazine profile of Sir Roger Penrose (here's another profile of him), as well as in Greene’s book (pp. 86-87) and other sources, if we shot bullets (everyday life-sized particles) through two slits, we’d end up with a pile (or distribution) of bullets behind each of the slits. If the bullets stuck in a board behind the slits, they might look something like this:
o o
o o
o o
o o
o o
(If the bullets were shot at varying angles through each slit, they might not end up in two perfectly straight lines, but you get the idea. A University of Colorado webpage illustrates such a shooting exercise with an animation.)
Experiments have been conducted where electrons (and other extremely tiny particles) have been fired at a double-slit apparatus, and this is where things start getting bizarre! As summarized in the aforementioned Discover article in a sidebar box about the double-slit experiments:
When electrons or atoms run through the double-slit experiment, they create interference patterns. In other words, the particles act like waves, not like bullets. Weirder, the same pattern appears even if the particles pass through the experiment one at a time. Since there is no other “wave” to interfere with, the only way this can happen is if each particle passes through both slits, interfering with itself along the way! …This behavior sounds crazy, but it has been confirmed by countless experiments.
Another book by Gribbin, the small (72 pages) paperback Quantum Physics: A Beginner’s Guide to the Subatomic World, also has a nice display on experiments that send single particles through double slits. This book notes that, in addition to those with electrons, “Exactly equivalent experiments have also been done with photons (particles of light)” (pp. 28-29).
Let’s recap for a minute. A light wave going through double slits will split into two waves, which then either reinforce or cancel each other in certain places to produce a multi-stripe band of alternating lightness and darkness (known as an interference pattern). Electrons (or other small particles), when fired one at a time, will eventually build up an interference pattern, too. This suggests that each individual electron must pass through both slits (i.e., be in two places at once). As the Discover profile of Penrose states:
…the ability of particles to exist in two places at once is not a mere theoretical abstraction. It is a very real aspect of how the subatomic world works, and it has been experimentally confirmed many times over. One of the clearest demonstrations comes from a classic physics setup called the double-slit experiment (p. 31).
Not only must a particle have been in two places at once in terms of passing through both slits. It presumably must have some type of wavelike property to do the interfering with itself. Here, things continue to get bizarre. Greene provides a nice summary of this area:
If an individual electron is also a wave, what is it that is waving? …In 1927, Max Born put forward a different suggestion… The wave, he claimed, is not a smeared-out electron, nor is it anything ever previously encountered in science. The wave, Born proposed, is a probability wave… Places where the probability wave is large are locations where the electron is most likely to be found. Places where the probability wave is small are locations where the electron is unlikely to be found… No one has ever directly seen a probability wave, and conventional quantum mechanical reasoning says that no one ever will… (excerpts from pp. 88-89).
Gribbin, in The Search..., cites the physicist Paul Davies as making an analogy between probability waves in physics and crime waves. As Gribbin quotes Davies:
Crime waves are not waves of undulating stuff but probability waves... crime waves, like fashions or unemployment, may move about -- they have dynamics -- but an individual crime still occurs, of course, at a place. It is the abstract probability which moves (Gribbin, p. 47, quoting Davies).
Here's also a web document that illustrates probability waves.
After noting that, “…there is still no universally agreed-upon way to envision what quantum mechanical probability waves actually are,” Greene offers the following as a possible explanation of the single-particle, double-slit experiments:
…the explanation quantum mechanics gives for individual electrons, one by one, over time, building up the pattern of light and dark bands… is now clear. Each individual electron is described by its probability wave. When an electron is fired, its probability wave flows through both slits. And just as with light waves and water waves, the probability waves emanating from the two slits interfere with each other (pp. 91-92).
To me, a probability wave seems like a mathematical curve that might be used in a statistics lecture, not something that would actually travel through double slits. Gribbin, in his summary of the single-particle, double-slit experiments in Quantum Physics, tries to comfort readers about these unusual phenomena: “You don’t have to understand this – nobody understands it. You just have to accept that this is the way the quantum world works” (p. 28).
Some physicists suggest that even human beings are subject to probabilistic waves, in terms of someone's location. Michio Kaku is quoted as follows in a BBC documentary on Einstein (transcript):
The quantum theory makes even bizarre events possible. For example walking across the street we expect to wind up on the other side, however there is a finite calculable probability that you will dissolve and wind up on mars, dissolve and wind up on the earth again. Of course we will have to wait longer than the lifetime of the universe but in principle it could happen.
A few months ago, I was participating in a research meeting with some Texas Tech graduate students and fellow faculty members. One of the other faculty members, who was in charge of organizing the meeting, had sent out conflicting e-mails leading up to the meeting, in terms of where the meeting would be held (either in Room 102 or 224). Once everybody finally showed up to the room where the meeting actually was taking place (102), I quipped that, "Under quantum mechanics, it's possible that the meeting is taking place in both 102 and 224."
In fact, in John Gribbin's book The Search for Superstrings, Symmetry, and the Theory of Everything, it is indeed a double-slit experiment that he cites as "contain[ing] the essence of quantum physics and lay[ing] bare its central mystery" (p. 27).
Those of you who took physics or other science courses in high school may remember the idea of light existing as both a wave and a particle. I’ll first describe the double-slit experiment from the perspective of light as a wave.
Whether from being in the ocean at the beach or among a crowd at a sporting event doing “the wave,” we know that a wave is a curvy, undulating structure with some segments that are high (a rising wave or a section of fans rising out of their seats) and other segments that are low. One type of wave might look like the following:
^^^^^^^^
In his book The Fabric of the Cosmos, Brian Greene describes an experiment where a laser pointer shines light at a sheet of a certain kind of film with two vertical lines scratched away (the double slits). On a detector screen behind the double-slit screen, what will show up is a series of vertical light and dark stripes, varying in their thickness and intensity. Summarizes Greene:
Light is an electromagnetic wave; when it passes through the two slits, it splits into two waves that head toward the screen. …the two light waves interfere with each other. When they hit various points on the screen, sometimes both waves are at their peaks, making the screen bright; sometimes both waves are at their troughs, also making it bright; but sometimes one wave is at its peak and the other is at its trough and they cancel, making that point on the screen dark (p. 85).
The following website by Dave Jarvis, though focused primarily on quantum entanglement (a topic I'll take up at some future point), begins with an excellent introduction to waves, including discussion of how waves combine with each other.
So far, everything probably seems reasonable. What if, instead of shining waves of light through double slits, we sent particle entities of various sizes through the slits?
As described in a June 2005 Discover magazine profile of Sir Roger Penrose (here's another profile of him), as well as in Greene’s book (pp. 86-87) and other sources, if we shot bullets (everyday life-sized particles) through two slits, we’d end up with a pile (or distribution) of bullets behind each of the slits. If the bullets stuck in a board behind the slits, they might look something like this:
o o
o o
o o
o o
o o
(If the bullets were shot at varying angles through each slit, they might not end up in two perfectly straight lines, but you get the idea. A University of Colorado webpage illustrates such a shooting exercise with an animation.)
Experiments have been conducted where electrons (and other extremely tiny particles) have been fired at a double-slit apparatus, and this is where things start getting bizarre! As summarized in the aforementioned Discover article in a sidebar box about the double-slit experiments:
When electrons or atoms run through the double-slit experiment, they create interference patterns. In other words, the particles act like waves, not like bullets. Weirder, the same pattern appears even if the particles pass through the experiment one at a time. Since there is no other “wave” to interfere with, the only way this can happen is if each particle passes through both slits, interfering with itself along the way! …This behavior sounds crazy, but it has been confirmed by countless experiments.
Another book by Gribbin, the small (72 pages) paperback Quantum Physics: A Beginner’s Guide to the Subatomic World, also has a nice display on experiments that send single particles through double slits. This book notes that, in addition to those with electrons, “Exactly equivalent experiments have also been done with photons (particles of light)” (pp. 28-29).
Let’s recap for a minute. A light wave going through double slits will split into two waves, which then either reinforce or cancel each other in certain places to produce a multi-stripe band of alternating lightness and darkness (known as an interference pattern). Electrons (or other small particles), when fired one at a time, will eventually build up an interference pattern, too. This suggests that each individual electron must pass through both slits (i.e., be in two places at once). As the Discover profile of Penrose states:
…the ability of particles to exist in two places at once is not a mere theoretical abstraction. It is a very real aspect of how the subatomic world works, and it has been experimentally confirmed many times over. One of the clearest demonstrations comes from a classic physics setup called the double-slit experiment (p. 31).
Not only must a particle have been in two places at once in terms of passing through both slits. It presumably must have some type of wavelike property to do the interfering with itself. Here, things continue to get bizarre. Greene provides a nice summary of this area:
If an individual electron is also a wave, what is it that is waving? …In 1927, Max Born put forward a different suggestion… The wave, he claimed, is not a smeared-out electron, nor is it anything ever previously encountered in science. The wave, Born proposed, is a probability wave… Places where the probability wave is large are locations where the electron is most likely to be found. Places where the probability wave is small are locations where the electron is unlikely to be found… No one has ever directly seen a probability wave, and conventional quantum mechanical reasoning says that no one ever will… (excerpts from pp. 88-89).
Gribbin, in The Search..., cites the physicist Paul Davies as making an analogy between probability waves in physics and crime waves. As Gribbin quotes Davies:
Crime waves are not waves of undulating stuff but probability waves... crime waves, like fashions or unemployment, may move about -- they have dynamics -- but an individual crime still occurs, of course, at a place. It is the abstract probability which moves (Gribbin, p. 47, quoting Davies).
Here's also a web document that illustrates probability waves.
After noting that, “…there is still no universally agreed-upon way to envision what quantum mechanical probability waves actually are,” Greene offers the following as a possible explanation of the single-particle, double-slit experiments:
…the explanation quantum mechanics gives for individual electrons, one by one, over time, building up the pattern of light and dark bands… is now clear. Each individual electron is described by its probability wave. When an electron is fired, its probability wave flows through both slits. And just as with light waves and water waves, the probability waves emanating from the two slits interfere with each other (pp. 91-92).
To me, a probability wave seems like a mathematical curve that might be used in a statistics lecture, not something that would actually travel through double slits. Gribbin, in his summary of the single-particle, double-slit experiments in Quantum Physics, tries to comfort readers about these unusual phenomena: “You don’t have to understand this – nobody understands it. You just have to accept that this is the way the quantum world works” (p. 28).
Some physicists suggest that even human beings are subject to probabilistic waves, in terms of someone's location. Michio Kaku is quoted as follows in a BBC documentary on Einstein (transcript):
The quantum theory makes even bizarre events possible. For example walking across the street we expect to wind up on the other side, however there is a finite calculable probability that you will dissolve and wind up on mars, dissolve and wind up on the earth again. Of course we will have to wait longer than the lifetime of the universe but in principle it could happen.
A few months ago, I was participating in a research meeting with some Texas Tech graduate students and fellow faculty members. One of the other faculty members, who was in charge of organizing the meeting, had sent out conflicting e-mails leading up to the meeting, in terms of where the meeting would be held (either in Room 102 or 224). Once everybody finally showed up to the room where the meeting actually was taking place (102), I quipped that, "Under quantum mechanics, it's possible that the meeting is taking place in both 102 and 224."
Wednesday, July 27, 2005
Quantum Mechanics Part I
I would now like to return to summarizing the major theories and conceptual approaches throughout the history of physics. The next one I would like to discuss is quantum mechanics (QM). So rich a topic is quantum mechanics that I will be writing several entries on different aspects of it over the next few months (I will also intersperse entries on current events, where appropriate).
The Wikipedia's summary of quantum mechanics introduces its many facets. The major scientific contributions promoting the development of QM occurred in the first few decades of the 20th century. To start off, the main idea to grasp about QM is that it applies to phenomena at an extremely small level (atomic and subatomic).
The word quantum itself is defined as, "The smallest unit of something that it is possible to have. Originally used for the quantum of light, now called a photon" (John Gribbin, Quantum Physics: A Beginner's Guide to the Subatomic World, glossary).
To laypersons and professional physicists alike, two features of quantum mechanics are its complexity and weirdness. A recent (July 5) New York Times article alluded to "the bizarre realm of quantum mechanics, where matter is both a particle and a wave and where the predictable stability of Newton gives way to probabilistic uncertainty."
As we'll see in future entries, there is even the idea that an object can be in two places at the same time!
As seen in the quote below from the transcript of the PBS documentary of Brian Greene's The Elegant Universe, even an MIT professor of physics admits he doesn't have a deep intuitive grasp of quantum mechanics:
EDWARD FARHI (Massachusetts Institute of Technology): You have to learn to abandon those assumptions that you have about the world in order to understand quantum mechanics. In my gut, in my belly, do I feel like I have a deep intuitive understanding of quantum mechanics? No.
From my own, non-physicist, perspective, I want to make a point about the complexity of quantum mechanics. Due to the advanced mathematics needed to fully understand seemingly any topic in physics, I would say the discipline of physics as a whole is complex. Once the mathematical aspects are put aside, however, I think several areas of physics (e.g., what happens under special relativity when an object travels extremely fast) can be grasped at a conceptual level by the non-expert. Where I think QM differs is that, even after the mathematics has been stripped away and we're left with just concepts, QM can still be baffling!
As I've read various books and articles on QM over the last several months, I've spent a lot of time scratching my head. At this point, I think I have a decent enough understanding to proceed. Since I am not a physicist, my policy all along with this website has been to stick to the original sources as closely as possible, both through web links and quotations of text passages; in this case of QM, I plan to stick very closely to my source materials. I hope you'll come along for the journey as I write my next several entries on QM.
The Wikipedia's summary of quantum mechanics introduces its many facets. The major scientific contributions promoting the development of QM occurred in the first few decades of the 20th century. To start off, the main idea to grasp about QM is that it applies to phenomena at an extremely small level (atomic and subatomic).
The word quantum itself is defined as, "The smallest unit of something that it is possible to have. Originally used for the quantum of light, now called a photon" (John Gribbin, Quantum Physics: A Beginner's Guide to the Subatomic World, glossary).
To laypersons and professional physicists alike, two features of quantum mechanics are its complexity and weirdness. A recent (July 5) New York Times article alluded to "the bizarre realm of quantum mechanics, where matter is both a particle and a wave and where the predictable stability of Newton gives way to probabilistic uncertainty."
As we'll see in future entries, there is even the idea that an object can be in two places at the same time!
As seen in the quote below from the transcript of the PBS documentary of Brian Greene's The Elegant Universe, even an MIT professor of physics admits he doesn't have a deep intuitive grasp of quantum mechanics:
EDWARD FARHI (Massachusetts Institute of Technology): You have to learn to abandon those assumptions that you have about the world in order to understand quantum mechanics. In my gut, in my belly, do I feel like I have a deep intuitive understanding of quantum mechanics? No.
From my own, non-physicist, perspective, I want to make a point about the complexity of quantum mechanics. Due to the advanced mathematics needed to fully understand seemingly any topic in physics, I would say the discipline of physics as a whole is complex. Once the mathematical aspects are put aside, however, I think several areas of physics (e.g., what happens under special relativity when an object travels extremely fast) can be grasped at a conceptual level by the non-expert. Where I think QM differs is that, even after the mathematics has been stripped away and we're left with just concepts, QM can still be baffling!
As I've read various books and articles on QM over the last several months, I've spent a lot of time scratching my head. At this point, I think I have a decent enough understanding to proceed. Since I am not a physicist, my policy all along with this website has been to stick to the original sources as closely as possible, both through web links and quotations of text passages; in this case of QM, I plan to stick very closely to my source materials. I hope you'll come along for the journey as I write my next several entries on QM.
Wednesday, July 06, 2005
PowerPoint Presentations from Einstein Symposium 2005
I just learned of a conference held in June in Alexandria, Egypt called Einstein Symposium 2005. Many prominent physicists spoke at this event, with some of the talks geared toward the general public. The symposium put together a nice website that includes PowerPoint presentations of many of the talks. For each presentation, the viewer can click along at his or her own pace to bring up each new slide.
Many of the concepts discussed in the talks -- particularly those related to the forces of nature -- mesh well with topics I've covered in my previous writings on this blog. Among the symposium presentations, I would most highly recommend Edward Witten's. His slides contain extensive text, making it very easy to follow (also, because Witten's talk doesn't include as many pictures and diagrams as some of the others, the slides come up faster).
(I want to acknowledge Peter Woit's blog as the source where I learned of the Einstein Symposium 2005 link.)
Many of the concepts discussed in the talks -- particularly those related to the forces of nature -- mesh well with topics I've covered in my previous writings on this blog. Among the symposium presentations, I would most highly recommend Edward Witten's. His slides contain extensive text, making it very easy to follow (also, because Witten's talk doesn't include as many pictures and diagrams as some of the others, the slides come up faster).
(I want to acknowledge Peter Woit's blog as the source where I learned of the Einstein Symposium 2005 link.)
Wednesday, June 22, 2005
Physics of Automobile Traffic
I was in Los Angeles recently, visiting family. While riding in the car on our family outings, we -- shockingly -- encountered considerable traffic on some of the major surface streets, as well as on smaller parallel-running streets that many drivers apparently thought would offer a respite from the snail's pace they had been experiencing.
These slow-downs on the road reminded me of what Cornell University applied mathematician Steven Strogatz describes in his book Sync as the "emerging field of traffic physics" (p. 269).
Strogatz discusses two research teams -- one consisting of Dirk Helbing and Bernardo Huberman, and the other of Boris Kerner and Hubert Rehborn -- that have come up with interesting findings within the past decade.
Given that we think of physics as dealing with, well, physical systems, and traffic involves human behavior, how can the two be joined? As noted in this Science News article, scientists have drawn analogies in their research between traffic flows, on the one hand, and physical phenomena such as phase transitions between liquids and solids, or the clumping behavior of granular substances such as sand or salt, on the other. The field of physics under which these issues would be studied is that of statistical physics.
Other magazine-type articles on the physics of traffic, geared to the layperson, are available here and here. You might want to read one or more of these articles before you go out on the road the next time. They might not make you feel any better when you encounter traffic, but at least you'll probably have a better idea of the underlying dynamics of what's going on!
These slow-downs on the road reminded me of what Cornell University applied mathematician Steven Strogatz describes in his book Sync as the "emerging field of traffic physics" (p. 269).
Strogatz discusses two research teams -- one consisting of Dirk Helbing and Bernardo Huberman, and the other of Boris Kerner and Hubert Rehborn -- that have come up with interesting findings within the past decade.
Given that we think of physics as dealing with, well, physical systems, and traffic involves human behavior, how can the two be joined? As noted in this Science News article, scientists have drawn analogies in their research between traffic flows, on the one hand, and physical phenomena such as phase transitions between liquids and solids, or the clumping behavior of granular substances such as sand or salt, on the other. The field of physics under which these issues would be studied is that of statistical physics.
Other magazine-type articles on the physics of traffic, geared to the layperson, are available here and here. You might want to read one or more of these articles before you go out on the road the next time. They might not make you feel any better when you encounter traffic, but at least you'll probably have a better idea of the underlying dynamics of what's going on!
Saturday, June 04, 2005
General Relativity
Having covered special relativity in recent weeks, let's now move on to general relativity. Special relativity pertains only to objects moving at constant velocity, whereas general relativity applies to acceleration, with a focus on gravitational acceleration. As noted in this Einstein timeline, special relativity came out in 1905, whereas general relativity did in 1915-16.
The Wikipedia has a nice page on general relativity, including a section explaining the connection between special and general relativity. A key concept from the earlier discussion of special relativity involved frames of reference, how different observers might view the same event. According to the Wikipedia document:
In relativity theory, all events are referred to a reference frame ...all motion is defined and quantified relative to other matter. In the special theory of relativity it is assumed that reference frames can be extended indefinitely in all directions in space and time. The theory of special relativity concerns itself with reference frames that move at a constant velocity with respect to each other (i.e. inertial reference frames), whereas general relativity deals with all frames of reference.
Perhaps the best-known element of general relativity is Einstein's conception of warped gravity.
If you were to find some soft, flat surface in your home such as your bed or a large seat cushion on your couch, and place a heavy object (such as a bowling ball) in the center of it, the surface would depress in the center while remaining flat along its outer perimeter. The resulting downhill curvature toward the center (like a funnel) is a simplified analogy to warped gravity. What makes one object have a tendency to fall toward another, such as you or me toward earth, is an invisible funnel-shaped slide.
A University of Winnipeg webpage provides an excellent visual illustration and discussion of warped gravity.
Warped gravity also explains the orbit of the earth around the sun and what would happen were the sun to disappear. As described in a Perimeter Institute document:
According to Newton’s theory, if the Sun were to suddenly disappear when the Earth was at [a given point in its orbit], the force [of gravitation] would instantly disappear, allowing the Earth to break out of its circular orbit and continue on [a] straight line... Einstein, on the other hand, argued that there is no way the Earth could know that the Sun had disappeared until at least eight minutes after..., eight minutes (or thereabouts) being the time it takes light (or any other signal moving at the speed of light) to travel from the Sun to the Earth. In other words, Einstein reasoned that the Earth should continue on its circular orbit for at least another eight minutes after [the Sun's disappearance] before breaking orbit.
Earlier this year when I was visiting with family in Los Angeles, my mother and I went to the Einstein exhibit at the Skirball Cultural Center. Among the displays were demonstrations of warped gravity.
One final note: Although the name "Einstein" is synonymous in many people's minds with the pinnacle of genius, even geniuses sometimes need help. In formulating general relativity, in fact, Einstein needed to draw upon the mathematical wisdom of Marcel Grossman. According to a Vectorsite document on the web, when it came to the curvature aspect of general relativity:
This was a revelation, but Einstein's intuition wasn't enough, he had to be able to "do the math". He didn't have a precise idea of where to start, so he contacted his friend Marcel Grossman, now a professor of math, who scratched his head for a bit and found what Einstein was looking for, which was a mathematical theory known as "tensor calculus", known in modern times as "differential analysis". Grossman told Einstein it was nasty, too nasty for a physicist to want to tinker with, but there wasn't anything else that would do the job. Einstein struggled with it using his friend's help, and in 1915 he announced the result, his theory of General Relativity, to the world.
The Wikipedia has a nice page on general relativity, including a section explaining the connection between special and general relativity. A key concept from the earlier discussion of special relativity involved frames of reference, how different observers might view the same event. According to the Wikipedia document:
In relativity theory, all events are referred to a reference frame ...all motion is defined and quantified relative to other matter. In the special theory of relativity it is assumed that reference frames can be extended indefinitely in all directions in space and time. The theory of special relativity concerns itself with reference frames that move at a constant velocity with respect to each other (i.e. inertial reference frames), whereas general relativity deals with all frames of reference.
Perhaps the best-known element of general relativity is Einstein's conception of warped gravity.
If you were to find some soft, flat surface in your home such as your bed or a large seat cushion on your couch, and place a heavy object (such as a bowling ball) in the center of it, the surface would depress in the center while remaining flat along its outer perimeter. The resulting downhill curvature toward the center (like a funnel) is a simplified analogy to warped gravity. What makes one object have a tendency to fall toward another, such as you or me toward earth, is an invisible funnel-shaped slide.
A University of Winnipeg webpage provides an excellent visual illustration and discussion of warped gravity.
Warped gravity also explains the orbit of the earth around the sun and what would happen were the sun to disappear. As described in a Perimeter Institute document:
According to Newton’s theory, if the Sun were to suddenly disappear when the Earth was at [a given point in its orbit], the force [of gravitation] would instantly disappear, allowing the Earth to break out of its circular orbit and continue on [a] straight line... Einstein, on the other hand, argued that there is no way the Earth could know that the Sun had disappeared until at least eight minutes after..., eight minutes (or thereabouts) being the time it takes light (or any other signal moving at the speed of light) to travel from the Sun to the Earth. In other words, Einstein reasoned that the Earth should continue on its circular orbit for at least another eight minutes after [the Sun's disappearance] before breaking orbit.
Earlier this year when I was visiting with family in Los Angeles, my mother and I went to the Einstein exhibit at the Skirball Cultural Center. Among the displays were demonstrations of warped gravity.
One final note: Although the name "Einstein" is synonymous in many people's minds with the pinnacle of genius, even geniuses sometimes need help. In formulating general relativity, in fact, Einstein needed to draw upon the mathematical wisdom of Marcel Grossman. According to a Vectorsite document on the web, when it came to the curvature aspect of general relativity:
This was a revelation, but Einstein's intuition wasn't enough, he had to be able to "do the math". He didn't have a precise idea of where to start, so he contacted his friend Marcel Grossman, now a professor of math, who scratched his head for a bit and found what Einstein was looking for, which was a mathematical theory known as "tensor calculus", known in modern times as "differential analysis". Grossman told Einstein it was nasty, too nasty for a physicist to want to tinker with, but there wasn't anything else that would do the job. Einstein struggled with it using his friend's help, and in 1915 he announced the result, his theory of General Relativity, to the world.
Tuesday, May 24, 2005
Famous Physicists from Ohio State University
I recently returned from attending the U.S. Conference on Teaching Statistics at Ohio State University in Columbus. I love college campuses and in recent years, I've developed the hobby of taking pictures of ones I visit. My pictures of the Ohio State campus can be seen by clicking here.
Among the buildings I photographed was OSU's Physics Research Building. The edifice not only exhibits some neat modern architecture; the OSU department also has been home to some of the finest physicists in modern history. Two in particular are Kenneth Wilson, who won the 1982 Nobel Prize in physics (while at Cornell ) and has been at OSU since 1988, and the late Robert Mills, famous for a concept known as Yang-Mills physics (which I barely understand).
I plan to blog in the future on the work of Wilson and Mills, as my understanding of it increases. For now, though, take a look at the lovely OSU campus...
Among the buildings I photographed was OSU's Physics Research Building. The edifice not only exhibits some neat modern architecture; the OSU department also has been home to some of the finest physicists in modern history. Two in particular are Kenneth Wilson, who won the 1982 Nobel Prize in physics (while at Cornell ) and has been at OSU since 1988, and the late Robert Mills, famous for a concept known as Yang-Mills physics (which I barely understand).
I plan to blog in the future on the work of Wilson and Mills, as my understanding of it increases. For now, though, take a look at the lovely OSU campus...
Monday, May 23, 2005
Special Relativity Part II
Let's continue on with special relativity. My previous entry focused on the time aspect of special relativity, on how time elapses more slowly on an object moving through space at high speed. Today, I'd like to take up the space aspect and the joint concept of spacetime. Just to be clear, there are three things to be concerned about: space, time, and spacetime. As before, I will be drawing from Brian Greene's book, The Fabric of the Cosmos.
First, in discussing relative space, Greene gives the example of how two city planners could design different street grid systems for the same town, which would be equally valid. Within the limits of my keyboard, one might look like this:
_ _ _ _ _
_I_I_I_I_
_I_I_I_I_
_I_I_I_I_
_I_I_I_I_
_I_I_I_I_
and another might look like this:
_ _ _ _ _
_/_/_/_/_/
/_/_/_/_/_
_/_/_/_/_/
/_/_/_/_/_
More interesting yet is the combination of space and time into spacetime. For this, Greene invokes the idea of a flipbook, a little book of sequential photographs on soft cardboard pages stapled together. When you run your thumb over the pages from beginning to end, of course, the pages appear to show a movie.
A flipbook -- comprised collectively of pages that each depict what happens at "a region of space at one moment of time" (p. 53) -- thus represents spacetime. What makes this topic so interesting is that two observers to the same event do not have to have the same "still photo" images on their respective flipbook pages. Writes Greene about the introduction of special relativity:
Until 1905, it was thought that everyone experiences the passage of time identically, that everyone agrees on what events occur at a given moment of time, and hence, that everyone would concur on what belongs on a given page in the flip book of spacetime. But when Einstein realized that two observers in relative motion have clocks that tick off time differently, this all changed (p. 55).
Whereas one observer can think that certain things are going on at one point in time, "Another observer, moving relative to the first, will declare that the events on a single one of these pages do not all happen at the same time" (p. 55).
"Instead, observers moving relative to each other cut a block of spacetime up into pages, into time slices, in different but equally valid ways" (p. 56).
Another metaphor, similar to the flipbook, Greene uses for spacetime is a loaf of bread, which different observers can slice at different angles. At this point, Greene then introduces the "kicker" to the story: "not everything in relativity is relative" (p. 58). He continues:
Even if you and I were to imagine slicing up a loaf of bread in two different ways, there is still something that we would fully agree upon: the totality of the loaf itself. Although our slices would differ, if I were to imagine putting all of my slices together and you were to imagine doing the same for all of your slices, we would reconstitute the same loaf of bread. How could it be otherwise? We both imagined cutting up the same loaf (p. 58).
Absolute space does not exist. Absolute time does not exist. But according to special relativity, absolute spacetime does exist (p. 59).
I hope this information is clear to readers, at least "relatively" so.
First, in discussing relative space, Greene gives the example of how two city planners could design different street grid systems for the same town, which would be equally valid. Within the limits of my keyboard, one might look like this:
_ _ _ _ _
_I_I_I_I_
_I_I_I_I_
_I_I_I_I_
_I_I_I_I_
_I_I_I_I_
and another might look like this:
_ _ _ _ _
_/_/_/_/_/
/_/_/_/_/_
_/_/_/_/_/
/_/_/_/_/_
More interesting yet is the combination of space and time into spacetime. For this, Greene invokes the idea of a flipbook, a little book of sequential photographs on soft cardboard pages stapled together. When you run your thumb over the pages from beginning to end, of course, the pages appear to show a movie.
A flipbook -- comprised collectively of pages that each depict what happens at "a region of space at one moment of time" (p. 53) -- thus represents spacetime. What makes this topic so interesting is that two observers to the same event do not have to have the same "still photo" images on their respective flipbook pages. Writes Greene about the introduction of special relativity:
Until 1905, it was thought that everyone experiences the passage of time identically, that everyone agrees on what events occur at a given moment of time, and hence, that everyone would concur on what belongs on a given page in the flip book of spacetime. But when Einstein realized that two observers in relative motion have clocks that tick off time differently, this all changed (p. 55).
Whereas one observer can think that certain things are going on at one point in time, "Another observer, moving relative to the first, will declare that the events on a single one of these pages do not all happen at the same time" (p. 55).
"Instead, observers moving relative to each other cut a block of spacetime up into pages, into time slices, in different but equally valid ways" (p. 56).
Another metaphor, similar to the flipbook, Greene uses for spacetime is a loaf of bread, which different observers can slice at different angles. At this point, Greene then introduces the "kicker" to the story: "not everything in relativity is relative" (p. 58). He continues:
Even if you and I were to imagine slicing up a loaf of bread in two different ways, there is still something that we would fully agree upon: the totality of the loaf itself. Although our slices would differ, if I were to imagine putting all of my slices together and you were to imagine doing the same for all of your slices, we would reconstitute the same loaf of bread. How could it be otherwise? We both imagined cutting up the same loaf (p. 58).
Absolute space does not exist. Absolute time does not exist. But according to special relativity, absolute spacetime does exist (p. 59).
I hope this information is clear to readers, at least "relatively" so.
Saturday, May 14, 2005
Special Relativity Part I
Next in my series of summaries of major theories in physics, I'd like to discuss Einstein's theory of special relativity. Under the rubric of "relativity," Einstein actually had two theories, those of special and general relativity. The former, being a "special" case, applies only to instances of constant velocity, where acceleration can be ignored. Einstein's later theory of general relativity incorporates acceleration, most prominently gravity; general relativity will be discussed in a later posting.
As I noted in a previous posting, special relativity was one of four major ideas Einstein published within a single year, 1905, the centennial of which is currently being celebrated as the World Year of Physics.
As with many other concepts discussed on this blog, I was introduced to special (and general) relativity by Brian Greene's book The Fabric of the Cosmos. As the term "relativity" implies, people's experiences of time and distance are not absolute, but relative (at least under certain conditions). Writes Greene:
The relativity of space and of time is a startling conclusion. I have known about it for more than twenty-five years, but even so, whenever I quietly sit and think it through, I am amazed. From the well-worn statement that the speed of light is constant, we conclude that space and time are in the eye of the beholder. Each of us carries our own clock... The same is true of distance. Each of us carries our own yardstick... (p. 47).
One of the things Greene initially does is get the reader to think of space and time -- which many people may think of as separate concepts -- in integrated fashion:
Newton thought that motion through time was totally separate from motion through space -- he thought these two kinds of motion had nothing to do with each other. But Einstein found that they are intimately linked. In fact, the revolutionary discovery of special relativity is this: When you look at something like a parked car, which from your viewpoint is stationary -- not moving through space, that is -- all of its motion is through time... But if the car speeds away, some of its motion through time is diverted into motion through space (p. 48).
In other words, with special relativity, motion through space -- at extremely high speeds -- makes time move along more slowly!
One research study that supports special relativity was done with objects very familiar to laypeople, namely clocks and an airplane. As Greene describes it:
In 1971, Joseph Hafele and Richard Keating flew state-of-the-art cesium-beam atomic clocks around the world on a commercial Pan Am jet. When they compared the clocks flown on the plane with identical clocks left stationary on the ground, they found that less time had elapsed on the moving clocks. The difference was tiny -- a few hundred billionths of a second -- but it was precisely in accord with Einstein's discoveries (p. 50).
This website provides further detail on the experiment (when the new page comes up, it may look as though there is only one screen of information, but scroll down for more).
Also, for those of you old enough to remember Pan Am airlines, here's an historical website on the company.
I'll have more on special relativity next week...
As I noted in a previous posting, special relativity was one of four major ideas Einstein published within a single year, 1905, the centennial of which is currently being celebrated as the World Year of Physics.
As with many other concepts discussed on this blog, I was introduced to special (and general) relativity by Brian Greene's book The Fabric of the Cosmos. As the term "relativity" implies, people's experiences of time and distance are not absolute, but relative (at least under certain conditions). Writes Greene:
The relativity of space and of time is a startling conclusion. I have known about it for more than twenty-five years, but even so, whenever I quietly sit and think it through, I am amazed. From the well-worn statement that the speed of light is constant, we conclude that space and time are in the eye of the beholder. Each of us carries our own clock... The same is true of distance. Each of us carries our own yardstick... (p. 47).
One of the things Greene initially does is get the reader to think of space and time -- which many people may think of as separate concepts -- in integrated fashion:
Newton thought that motion through time was totally separate from motion through space -- he thought these two kinds of motion had nothing to do with each other. But Einstein found that they are intimately linked. In fact, the revolutionary discovery of special relativity is this: When you look at something like a parked car, which from your viewpoint is stationary -- not moving through space, that is -- all of its motion is through time... But if the car speeds away, some of its motion through time is diverted into motion through space (p. 48).
In other words, with special relativity, motion through space -- at extremely high speeds -- makes time move along more slowly!
One research study that supports special relativity was done with objects very familiar to laypeople, namely clocks and an airplane. As Greene describes it:
In 1971, Joseph Hafele and Richard Keating flew state-of-the-art cesium-beam atomic clocks around the world on a commercial Pan Am jet. When they compared the clocks flown on the plane with identical clocks left stationary on the ground, they found that less time had elapsed on the moving clocks. The difference was tiny -- a few hundred billionths of a second -- but it was precisely in accord with Einstein's discoveries (p. 50).
This website provides further detail on the experiment (when the new page comes up, it may look as though there is only one screen of information, but scroll down for more).
Also, for those of you old enough to remember Pan Am airlines, here's an historical website on the company.
I'll have more on special relativity next week...
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)