Wednesday, June 16, 2010

Speculations on the Higgs Boson

New ideas are being bandied about regarding the Higgs particle, which is expected possibly to be the signature discovery of the Large Hadron Collider in Europe. As I discussed in a 2007 posting, the Higgs is theorized to serve as a differentially permeable screen that gives different masses to various kinds of particles.

According to a blog at Discover magazine, findings from Fermilab's Tevatron collider have led some scientists to speculate that there may actually be five varieties of Higgs particle, instead of just one. Just to be clear, though, no discovery of a Higgs has yet been made. Quoting from the Discover blog:

Given, that the Fermilab found this [recent] result, we might wonder if they too will find these fascinating, elusive Higgs boson particles, perhaps stepping on the toes of their higher-energy rival, the Large Hadron Collider.

Wednesday, April 07, 2010

Physics of Butler University's Last-Second Basketball Shot

ESPN has produced a brief "Sport Science" segment analyzing the physics of how close Butler University's potential game-winning shot (released 46 feet from the basket) came to going in, at the end of the Bulldogs' NCAA men's basketball championship battle vs. Duke. A video of the segment is available here. The video identifies three parameters of a shot's trajectory: "launch angle, release velocity, and aim."

The 54-degree launch angle would be considered "good," according to the video. The release velocity, which was 28 miles per hour, was considered close to ideal; had the shooter, Gordon Hayward, heaved the ball with a velocity 0.5 mph less, the shot "has a chance."

With the two aforementioned variables optimized, according to the video, if aim were such that the ball "hits just 3 inches to the left on the backboard [compared to where it actually hit], Butler wins."

There actually has been considerable physics research on the trajectory of the basketball shot. A book came out a few years ago entitled The Physics of Basketball, which I reviewed here.

Tuesday, March 30, 2010

LHC Particle Collisions at Half of Ultimate Energy

There's been a flurry of news coverage in the last 24 hours about successful particle collisions taking place at the delay-plagued Large Hadron Collider in Europe (specifically at a facility known as CERN). However, as I discussed last November, the present activity is taking place at only half the particle energy ultimately intended for the LHC (3.5 TeV instead of 7). As today's New York Times reports:

The success in producing proton collisions represents a remarkable comeback for CERN, but the lab is still only halfway back to where it wanted to be. Only a year and a half ago, the first attempt to start the collider ended with an explosion that left part of its tunnel enveloped in frigid helium gas and soot when an electrical connection between two of the powerful magnets that steer the protons vaporized...

Because of the defective joints and some mysteriously underperforming magnets, it will still be three years at least before CERN’s collider runs at or near full strength. According to theoretical models, that would stretch out the time it should take to achieve the collider’s main goals, like producing the Higgs boson and testing more exotic ideas like extra dimensions.

Until then, the Tevatron
[at Fermilab near Chicago] will chase CERN for big goals like the Higgs boson, physicists say. The CERN experimenters will spend the next four to six months learning how their detectors work and rediscovering known physics. Then, anything is possible...

A blog from ATLAS, one of the experimenter groups within the LHC, provides some initial reactions from the attending physicists to last night's collisions (via Not Even Wrong).

Saturday, March 13, 2010

Study Supports General Relativity with Dark Matter

The theoretical account of gravity that currently appears to enjoy the greatest support from physicists and astronomers is Einstein's general relativity with allowances for dark matter (see here for background). Not all scientists agree, however, and they have tried to develop theories of gravity that don't need to invoke dark matter.

A new study has come along that comes down on the side of general relativity with dark matter (thanks to my wife for bringing it to my attention). As described in this article, the Princeton-based investigation:

...was one of the first rigorous tests of this theory of gravity beyond our solar system. The research found that even over vast scales of galaxies and clusters of galaxies, the equations of general relativity predict the way that mass pulls on other mass in the universe.

The new work also helps rule out a competing theory of gravity that seeks to do away with the need for bizarre concepts like dark matter and dark energy that have irked some scientists. This research indicates those pesky ideas may be here to stay.


Led by graduate student Reinabelle Reyes, the researchers obtained three types of measurements from roughly 70,000 galaxies. Statistical analyses then showed the data to be more consistent with general relativity than with two other, competing theories (one of the competing theories was described as yielding numerical values "somewhat different from those observed, but still ... within the margin of error").

***

Yesterday was officially the fifth anniversary of this blog, the first posting of which occurred on March 12, 2005 (in that initial entry, I referred to myself as an associate professor of human development and family studies, but in 2007 I was promoted to full professor). I have enjoyed writing this blog and I will continue to do so. Only in the past year or so have I begun monitoring hit-counts for this site. As it turns out, the most recent complete month (February 2010) has been the best month for visits to the blog, with 196. That translates into 7 visits per day (February, of course, having 28 days). That may not seem like much, but I'm thrilled and thankful that anyone visits at all! If you've stumbled upon this site, I hope you'll continue to check back every so often.

Sunday, February 07, 2010

Timetable for LHC

Another update on the Large Hadron Collider: According to a recent New York Times article, the LHC will "operate at only half power for the next two years and then shut down for a yearlong repair session." Based on what I've read at some prominent particle-physics blogs (here and here), major (potential) discoveries such as the Higgs boson probably won't occur until 2013, but important new findings are possible before then.

Tuesday, February 02, 2010

Physics of Aerial Skiing

The New York Times has a nice article on the physics of freestyle aerial skiing, one of the sports in the upcoming Winter Olympics in Vancouver. The Times article also has an accompanying video, on which diagrams of curves and arrows are periodically superimposed to illustrate physics concepts. The primary concept discussed is angular (or rotational) momentum. I wrote about angular momentum as pertaining to figure skating four years ago, in connection with the last Winter Olympics.

Monday, February 01, 2010

Websites to Promote Astrophysics and Math Understanding

Here are a couple of notes on links I came across this weekend. The associated websites intend to boost public understanding and appreciation for, respectively, astrophysics and mathematics.

The first link is to the American Museum of Natural History's video "The Known Universe." Starting from earth, the video takes the viewer on a simulated voyage outward, to the solar system, the Milky Way galaxy, and beyond. According to a caption at the beginning of the video, "Every satellite, moon, planet, star and galaxy is represented to scale and in its correct, measured location according to the best scientific research to date." As the images in the video get more distant from earth, a caption at the bottom of the screen fills in the number for "Light travel time from earth..." The following pages from the Wikipedia and Science Clarified discuss the concept of light years and the inferences that can be drawn from them (e.g., "If you look at something in the sky that is eight light-years away, you are seeing light that left that object eight years ago").

The second link is to the initial column by Cornell Professor Steven Strogatz, as part of a new series in the New York Times in which he will attempt to convey mathematical concepts to the public. Strogatz literally starts at the beginning, discussing why we have numbers in the first place. And he uses a Sesame Street illustration to show us!

Wednesday, January 13, 2010

Video on Expanding Universe

The latest edition of the Michigan Today online newsletter, which I receive as a UM alumnus, features a six-minute video of physics professor Tim McKay explaining the evidence for an expanding universe. It's definitely worth a look.

Wednesday, December 23, 2009

Solar Energy

I've fallen behind in my postings lately, in part because of final exams, grading, and other end-of-semester activities. Now, however, I have some time to write about a talk I attended at Texas Tech back on November 18 as part of the Maddox Solar Energy Series. The speaker was Sarah Kurtz of the National Renewable Energy Laboratory and her presentation was entitled "The science behind high-efficiency solar cells and why we might care."

Thanks to Richard A. Muller's book Physics for Future Presidents (which I reviewed here), I had a little bit of background knowledge of what Dr. Kurtz would likely be talking about.

Besides reinforcing what I learned from Dr. Muller's book, Dr. Kurtz's talk also exposed me to several pieces of solar-energy terminology, which I could use to search the web and discover resources to increase my knowledge of the area. Indeed, I was able to find a number of layperson-friendly summaries of solar energy, which I summarize in the following paragraphs.

As described in this transcript from a PBS NOVA episode on solar energy:

A solar cell is like a sandwich; the top part is for protection, the bottom is its base and the middle layer, made of silicon, is where the action is.

When particles of sunlight, called photons, strike individual atoms of the silicon, they easily break the weak bond between silicon's nucleus and its outer orbit of electrons. Once freed, the electrons travel to the top of the silicon layer, where they move in a current along metal conducting strips. Then it's across the panels to wires that feed the electricity to the house.


Dr. Kurtz participated in this NOVA episode, as seen in this part of the transcript:

NARRATOR: ...rooftop solar arrays are not very efficient. Even now the very best panels and coverings convert only 15 percent to 20 percent of the sun's rays into electricity, about half the conversion efficiency of a coal plant.

SARAH KURTZ (National Renewable Energy Laboratory): We'd like to be able to improve upon that, so we've been researching how to use more sophisticated materials to put together a high efficiency cell.

NARRATOR: Back at the National Renewable Energy Lab, Sarah Kurtz leads a team that is developing something called a multijunction solar cell. It looks like a miniature version of a normal solar cell, but even at this tiny size, it's much more powerful because it contains several micro-thin layers of light-absorbing materials.

The light from the sun is revealed as a band of colors, each color a different wavelength of energy. Traditional silicon solar cells absorb only the red spectrum of the sun's rays. The rest of the energy bands are blocked.

SARAH KURTZ: You could do better if you could use two different types of materials, or even three different types of materials, to attune them to the color of the light that's coming down.

NARRATOR: The extra layers allow the cell to absorb additional wavelengths of light, greatly increasing its efficiency...


Indeed, as Muller discusses on page 82 of his book:

The best efficiency achieved so far, 41%, has been with a "triple junction" cell that has separate layers for different colors of light. But they are expensive, about $65 per square inch. If the cost can be brought down, and if we don't run out of the specialized materials needed to make them, then solar could become an important source of energy in the future.

This U.S. Department of Energy document explains some of the basic physics in converting light to electricity:

When certain semiconducting materials, such as certain kinds of silicon, are exposed to sunlight, they release small amounts of electricity. This process is known as the photoelectric effect. The photoelectric effect refers to the emission, or ejection, of electrons from the surface of a metal in response to light. It is the basic physical process in which a solar electric or photovoltaic (PV) cell converts sunlight to electricity.

Sunlight is made up of photons, or particles of solar energy. Photons contain various amounts of energy, corresponding to the different wavelengths of the solar spectrum. When photons strike a PV cell, they may be reflected or absorbed, or they may pass right through. Only the absorbed photons generate electricity. When this happens, the energy of the photon is transferred to an electron in an atom of the PV cell (which is actually a semiconductor).


Finally, this document from the Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory reviews some of the leading ideas (as of 2004) on the types of materials that possibly could increase efficiency beyond 50 percent.

I've checked to see if Dr. Kurtz's PowerPoint slides from her Texas Tech talk were available online, but haven't been able to find them. I did, however, find another presentation of hers online, which seems to cover some of the same topics she addressed at Texas Tech.

Friday, November 20, 2009

LHC Turned Back On

Hours ago, the Large Hadron Collider was turned back on for preliminary test runs after being closed down for more than a year due to a major accident and subsequently discovered design problems. According to a recently posted New York Times article, tonight's events included sending protons around the large loop in one direction, with low-energy collisions soon to follow. However, actual operation at full capability for major physics discoveries is still a long ways away:

When the collider begins to do real physics next year, it will run at half its original design energy, with protons of 3.5 trillion electron volts. The energy will be increased gradually during the year, but it could be years, physicists say, before the machine reaches its full potential.

Thousands of the troublesome junctions will have to be rebuilt during a yearlong shutdown in 2011, and engineers have to figure out why several dozen of the superconducting magnets seem to have lost their ability to operate at high intensities.


From May-July 2007, I wrote a series of postings on the LHC and collider physics in general. I invite readers who might be interested in this background discussion to visit the earlier postings via the blog archives in the right-hand column.

Thursday, November 05, 2009

Author John Moffat's (Reinventing Gravity) Talk

This afternoon, I attended a talk at Texas Tech University by John W. Moffat, author of the 2008 book Reinventing Gravity. Moffat, a retired University of Toronto professor who more recently has been associated with the Perimeter Institute in Waterloo, Ontario, has proffered a modified theory of gravity (MOG) that, he claims, can explain a great deal of astrophysical data without having to resort to dark matter. I had seen Reinventing Gravity in the bookstores over the summer, but was unsure if I wanted to read it. Then, when the list of this semester's physics colloquium speakers came out during the first week of classes, I noticed Moffat's name and decided to get the book.

Before I discuss the book and the talk, some background. Dark matter has never been detected directly; it was proposed only via inference from astronomical observations. The rationale for invoking dark matter is conveyed in the following passage from the American Museum of Natural History on the 1970s-era observations of Vera Rubin and Kent Ford:

The stars far from the centers of galaxies, in the sparsely populated outer regions, were moving just as fast as those closer in. This was odd, because the visible mass of a galaxy does not have enough gravity to hold such rapidly moving stars in orbit. It followed that there had to be a tremendous amount of unseen matter in the outer regions of galaxies where the visible stars are relatively few.

As Moffat notes in his book, "To save Einstein's and Newton's theories [of gravity], many physicists and astronomers have postulated that there must exist a large amount of 'dark matter' in galaxies and also clusters of galaxies that could strengthen the pull of gravity and lead to an agreement of the theories with the data" (p. x). In Newton's law of gravity, of course, gravity's attractive force is proportional to the masses of the objects in question.

During today's talk, Moffat was soft-spoken, though spirited. He described himself as a "particle-buster," one who does not like to see the proliferation of new types of matter. Hence, as noted above, he has been developing his theory over the years, so that by modifying conventional theories of gravity, he can account for the kind of astrophysical data described above without resorting to dark matter. Moffat cautioned during the talk that, "I'm not saying dark matter doesn't exist. I'm someone who is intellectually curious..." and thus wants to see if alternative conceptualizations are possible.

Modified gravity appears to have two main revisions to conventional (i.e., Newtonian and Einstein's general relativity) gravitational theories. Moffat adds a fifth force of nature to the existing ones (gravitational, electromagnetic, weak nuclear, and strong nuclear), plus allows for variation in Newton's gravitational constant, G. "Together with the fifth force, this varying element strenthens the pull of gravity in faraway galaxies and in clusters of galaxies" (p. xiii).

Both in the book and in the talk, Moffat emphasized the considerable difficulty in successfully establishing a modified gravity theory. On pages 144-145 of the book, he lists nine major astrophysical findings with which any new theory must be consistent. With the older gravity theories, he noted in the talk, there were far fewer established findings to account for.

Any new theory also, of course, must make testable predictions that are different from the predictions that could be derived from other theories. Both in the book and in the talk, Moffat proposed two tests for MOG. One involves data from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS), which currently appears to suffer from a sparseness of observations. In the figure caption on page 198, it says, "When more data points are available, either MOG or cold dark matter will be verified." The other possible test entails an experiment on board a space station (p. 191).

In the few years I've been attending physics colloquia at Texas Tech, this is the first time I've seen the room filled to capacity (probably around 60 people). Further, the question-and-answer part of the talk lasted longer than I recall ever seeing. The professor who introduced Moffat described him as an "unorthodox" thinker. In spite of this -- or perhaps because of it -- the audience seemed receptive to hearing Moffat's ideas, although it would also be fair to say that, during the Q&A, some skepticism toward them was also in evidence.

I definitely would recommend Reinventing Gravity. For readers interested in further background on dark matter (and dark energy, which Moffat also addresses in the book), I would in addition recommend Dan Hooper's 2006 book Dark Cosmos, which I previously reviewed here.

Wednesday, October 14, 2009

Book Review: "How Many Licks?" (on Mathematical Approximation)

In physics and other sciences, researchers must sometimes make approximations in the calculations they perform. Aaron Santos, a post-doctoral researcher in engineering at the University of Michigan, has applied this idea to a number of quirky questions for the general public in his new book How Many Licks? The title of Santos's small paperback volume is, of course, based on the old TV commercial about getting to the center of a Tootsie Pop. (In the interest of full disclosure, Santos's publisher contacted me with the offer of a free copy to review and I accepted.)

After an introductory overview chapter on approximation in science, Santos provides 70 brief chapters (each 2-3 pages), tackling different enumeration questions. The problems in roughly the first half of the book (we're into estimates, right?) involve magnitude. Examples of such questions include "How many miles does a person walk in a lifetime?" and "How many times can you outline the continental United States in shoelaces [from all the shoes owned by Americans]?" For each problem, Santos outlines for the reader (but doesn't immediately give away) the component quantities needed to solve the problem, plus how to construct the (approximate) solution via formula.

In the latter half of the book, Santos goes beyond simple magnitude-focused problems to ones invoking substantive concepts in physics. For example, the question "[Over] how much area would you need to have solar panels [to power] the entire United States?" requires the concept of electrical efficiency for its solution.

How Many Licks? would seem to be a fun way to get young (or maybe even not-so-young) people interested in math and science. Reflecting on my own education, I think the book would probably be most appropriate at the high-school level or above. However, really bright students may be able to profit academically from the book at younger ages. Approximately speaking, that is...

Saturday, September 26, 2009

Book Review: "Physics for Future Presidents"

When I first saw the book Physics for Future Presidents (2008) by Cal-Berkeley professor Richard A. Muller on the shelves of a local bookstore, I knew I had to read it. Any book attempting to provide an educated layperson audience (including members of that audience who may aspire to the U.S. presidency) with explanations of physics concepts and their applications to major public policy issues was something I had to read!

I have now finished reading Physics for Future Presidents and I would definitely recommend it to readers of this blog. It is well-written, educational, and a fairly quick read. Although the book is most directly informed by a physics perspective on the actions of molecules, atoms, and nuclei, Muller also incorporates related disciplines such as chemistry and engineering.

The title's reference to future presidents is not just a rhetorical touch. On topic after topic, Muller revisits the issue of how a president (or any head of state) will often have to make difficult policy decisions, and that such decisions will probably be of a higher quality if the president knows something about the underlying science of the matter (no pun intended) at hand.

The issues covered in the book fall into a few major categories: national security (including terrorism and nuclear weapons), energy, and space-based applications.

For whateaver reason, what I found to be the most fascinating topic in the book is radiation poisoning, discussed in conjunction with nuclear power and nuclear weapons. Muller starts with a straightforward definition of radiation:

Radiation is the name for the fragments that fly out when the nucleus explodes. Just as with a hand grenade, it's the fragments that do the damage... They spew out with enormous velocity, sometimes approaching or equaling the velocity of light. When these chunks rip into your body, they tear your molecules apart. If enough cells are killed, you will die quickly. Lesser levels of damage can still induce cancer (pp. 95-96).

Muller presents the relationship between exposure to radiation (in units called rem) and likelihood of developing cancer in mathematical/ probabilistic terms. He notes that "the dose of radiation needed to cause cancer has been measured to be approximately 2500 rem" (pp. 98-99). However, at doses smaller than that -- even much smaller -- there is some non-zero probability of developing cancer:

But even at [a] low dose, there is some probability that one of the regulatory genes that controls unlimited cell growth will be damaged by radiation and not be repaired. As a consequence, 1% of a cancer dose will have a 1% chance of triggering an eventual cancer. For larger doses, it is proportional. Four percent of a cancer dose has a 4% chance of triggering a cancer (p. 99).

It is also possible, however, that the relationship may not be perfectly linear. As Muller notes, there could be a small zone (say from 0-6 rem) at which there is no cancer risk. Only above that zone (i.e., 6-rem threshold), might a linear relationship kick in between radiation exposure (in percent of the known cancer-causing dose) and probability of cancer.

Muller's aim in providing scientific background on issues potentially threatening humanity and the entire planet is to help inform the choices presidents, other policymakers, and the larger citizenry will make. There are certainly places throughout the book where one can anticipate Muller's policy recommendations based on his tone. However, he saves for the final page of the book a clear statement of his personal recommendations.

Muller seems determined to convey an image of himself as a politically neutral analyst, committed only to scientific facts and their balanced presentation. However, criticism has arisen over Muller's treatment of climate science and electric cars. In addition, some have also contended that Muller seems to have it in for Al Gore.

A friend of mine at Texas Tech University named Lindsay Reed, founder of the Tech Renewable Energy Society, has recommended another, related book to me. It is a free online book, Sustainable Energy -- Without the Hot Air, by British professor David MacKay. Lindsay suggests that MacKay too tries to present information in a politically neutral manner; whether he succeeds better than Muller is for the reader to decide.

Tuesday, August 18, 2009

Symmetry (Math and Physics) Part VII

Links to access earlier entries in the special series on symmetry:
I, II, III, IV, V, VI

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

We've now reached Part VII, the final installment of my series on symmetry. What I would like to discuss today is Noether's Theorem, which relates various kinds of symmetries to different types of conservation. As noted in this online document, the following relations follow from Noether's Theorem:

Translational symmetry means that the laws of physics are identical at all points in space, and it also implies the conservation of linear momentum. Rotational symmetry means that the laws of physics act the same in every direction, and it also implies the conservation of angular momentum. Time symmetry means that the laws of physics are eternally unchanging, and it also implies the conservation of energy.

Virtually all of the treatments of Noether's Theorem I could find online quickly turned into mathematical discussions involving calculus and other advanced concepts, such as this, this, this, and this. I took a year of college calculus, but it was 28 years ago so I couldn't really follow the mathematically based explanations. This one document, however, attempts to convey Noether's Theorem with real-life (albeit fanciful) scenarios. I found these fairly helpful.

The life of Emmy Noether (1882-1935) is also noteworthy for her overcoming of the barriers that existed at the time for women in science, including the outright opposition of male professors to women joining their ranks. She studied under many famous mathematicians such as Hermann Minkowski and David Hilbert, and her career contributions to math and physics have been praised by scholars such as Leon Lederman, Hermann Weyl, and Albert Einstein.

Saturday, July 25, 2009

Symmetry (Math and Physics) Part VI

In my previous posting, we covered the symmetry group U(1) and the electromagnetic force. Today, in Part VI of my symmetry series, we'll take a "watered-down" look at more elaborate symmetry groups and their physical applications. Of particular interest today will be the group SU(3), which is associated with the strong force (also known as Quantum Chromodynamics, QCD, or the quark model). The weak force is associated with the symmetry group SU(2), but I'll leave it for interested readers to consult outside sources to study this connection.

The key player in linking SU(3) symmetry to quark-based particles (and in fact, co-inventing the quark model in the first place) is Murray Gell-Mann, who in several weeks will celebrate his 80th birthday. Gell-Mann's accomplishments in this area occurred in the early 1960s. As noted in this Wikipedia entry, "Throughout the 1950s and 1960s, a bewildering variety of particles were found in scattering experiments. This was referred to as the 'particle zoo'." Gell-Mann's contribution was in developing a classification scheme -- analogous to the periodic table of the elements in chemistry -- that could bring order to the proliferation of newly discovered particles (baryons and mesons).

Two of my favorite physics writers, Dan Hooper and Robert Oerter, discuss Gell-Mann's process of discovery. According to Hooper's book Nature's Blueprint, "In particular, [Gell-Mann] knew that the symmetries behind the theory of quantum electrodynamics... could be described by a mathematical structure called the U(1) symmetry group. Gell-Mann began to wonder whether there might be another symmetry group that described the behavior of the mesons and baryons" (pp. 69-70).

The core concept of symmetry, of course, is that one can perform operations on an object and leave some essential property unchanged. As this set of lecture notes from the University of Utah describes, SU(3) fulfills this requirement in some sort of technical way that is above my mathematical knowledge ("As a symmetry group, SU(3) leaves the inner product of C3 invariant").

Eventually, Gell-Mann learned about the SU(3) groups and began comparing the organizational structures that could be generated from SU(3) with the properties of the newly discovered particles. The key SU(3) structures could either accommodate eight particles, referred to as an "octet" (a hexagon, which has six sides, plus two data points in the center) or ten particles, referred to as a "decuplet" (a tiered, triangular arrangement, with one row have one particle, the next having two, the next having three, and the last having four).

Several websites illustrate octet and decuplet diagrams, such as this one from the Encyclopedia Brittanica, this one from the Wikipedia (which explains Gell-Mann's borrowing of Buddhist terminology to call the octet model the "Eightfold Way") and this one from Florida State University (which makes a humorous distinction between the "quark" and "cork" models). Physicists can be real characters with their terminology, especially Gell-Mann, who also coined the term for "strange" quarks.

The Encyclopedia Brittanica provides a concise summary of how particles can be classified:

With the introduction of strangeness, physicists had several properties with which they could label the various subatomic particles. In particular, values of mass, electric charge, spin, isospin, and strangeness gave physicists a means of classifying the strongly interacting particles -- or hadrons -- and of establishing a hierarchy of relationships between them. In 1962 Gell-Mann and Yuval Neʾeman, an Israeli scientist, independently showed that a particular type of mathematical symmetry provides the kind of grouping of hadrons that is observed in nature.

The location of the data points on these octet and decuplet graphs are determined by plotting properties of the particles along three axes (the "3" in SU(3) stands for the number of dimensions). However, as Tommaso Dorigo explains, depictions on just two dimensions -- electric charge and strangeness -- can suffice (at least for laypersons).

One, labeled by the letter 'Q', describes the electric charge of the states, and goes from -1 to +2, increasing toward the top right corner. The second, labeled by the letter 'S', describes the 'strangeness' of the states. S is the number of strange quarks the baryons contain, and it increases instead as one moves down. Forget the third axis, it is of no use for you.

Instead of electric charge being plotted against strangeness, another particle property known as isospin sometimes is plotted against strangeness. Isospin is a property that, among other aspects, can distinguish a proton from a neutron (Oerter, The Theory of Almost Everything, pp. 144-146).

Dorigo also expresses the symmetry aspect of a decuplet triangle, referring to one on his website as:

...an example of the many possible representations of the symmetry group SU(3), in this case applied to describe the symmetries of quark flavors. You exchange a quark flavor with another by jumping along one of the three directions along the sides of the triangle, and you obtain a new baryon, whose properties are somehow connected to those of the former one.

To recap the key ideas to this point, the mathematical rules of SU(3) symmetry specify where data-points on octet and decuplet diagrams must fall. Gell-Mann found that plotting particles' locations along the dimensions of isospin and strangeness produced visual configurations analogous to those of SU(3). In fact, where there were "empty" locations on SU(3) structures (i.e., data-points without an associated known particle), Gell-Mann predicted that new particles with the necessary characteristics would be discovered. And, lo and behold, they were discovered! (See Oerter, pp. 160-164.)

The Eightfold Way led further to the ultimately successful model of fractionally charged quarks. Oerter explains that Gell-Mann "began with the observation that, although all the known heavy particles could be arranged in SU(3) multiplets, the simplest possible multiplet, a three-particle triplet, was nowhere to be found in the subatomic zoo... Perhaps all the particles in the subatomic zoo were built out of these three fundamental particles. He decided to call the quirky little things quarks..." (164-165). In order for three quarks to form a larger particle, such as a proton (two up quarks and a down) or neutron (two downs and an up), quarks needed to have fractional electromagnetic charges, a controversial idea at the time. The later idea of quark confinement explains why individual, free quarks have not been detected.

Finally, putting together what we know about the electromagnetic, strong, and weak forces' respective Lie groups, we arrive at the conclusion that, "The standard model is based on a Lie group called SU(3) X SU(2) X U(1)," according to this University of Montana document.

In his book Why Beauty is Truth, Ian Stewart gives a crude analogy to the melange of terms comprising the standard model of particle physics:

[I]t just lumps all three gauge groups together as SU(3) X SU(2) X U(1). This construction is simple and straightforward but not terribly elegant, and it makes the standard model resemble something built out of chewing gum and string.

Suppose you own a golf ball, a button, and a toothpick. The golf ball has spherical symmetry SO(3), the button has circular symmetry SO(2), and the toothpick has (say) just a single reflectional symmetry O(1). Can you find some unified object that has all three types of symmetry? Yes, you can: put all three into a paper bag
(p. 239).

As Stewart discusses, some Grand Unified Theories of the electromagnetic, strong, and weak forces have attempted to achieve more streamlined configurations using Lie groups such as SU(5) and SO(10).

The Lie groups that have been matched to the physical forces are not the only ones, however. The characterization of one of the "exceptional" Lie groups, E8, was reported in 2007 in the New York Times. Some of the mindboggling properties of the E8 object and how mathematicians studied it are as follows (quoting from the Times article):

It required the work of "[e]ighteen mathematicians spen[ding] four years..." culminating in "77 hours of supercomputer computation..."

E8 "describes the symmetries of a 57-dimensional object that can in essence be rotated in 248 ways without changing its appearance."

"To understand using E8 in all its possibilities requires calculation of 200 billion numbers."

"'You can’t really picture it,' Brian Conrey, executive director of the American Institute of Mathematics, said of E8."

If that last claim isn't the understatement of all time, I don't know what is!

Sunday, July 12, 2009

Symmetry (Math and Physics) Part V

Today, in Part V of our series on symmetry in math and physics, we examine Lie groups (pronounced Lee). Lie groups, which can be used to determine if differential equations (in calculus) are solvable, can be seen in part as an extension of Galois groups (which we discussed in Part III), which tell us about the solvability of algebraic equations. As Ian Stewart writes in his book Why Beauty is Truth:

Most of the important equations in physics -- those that concern the flow of a fluid, the action of gravity, the motion of the planets, the transfer of heat, the movement of waves, the action of magnetism, and the propagation of light and sound -- are differential equations (p. 162).

Lie groups also, however, have the property of mapping onto defining features of three of the forces of nature -- the electromagnetic, weak, and strong forces -- and their force particles.

Dan Hooper's book Nature's Blueprint details the mapping of Lie groups onto physical forces and their particles, noting the contributions of Murray Gell-Mann to advancing physicists' understanding of this topic. Before we get to Gell-Mann's contributions, however, we'll start out with some of the more basic ideas. Notes Hooper:

Mathematically speaking, the U(1) group describes the most simple of all possible local gauge symmetries. In terms of particle physics, it corresponds to a single type of boson (the photon) that acts on a single kind of quantum number (electric charge) (p. 70).


In layperson's terms, we can simply think of an ordinary circle. We can rotate this circle by any amount, whether an infinitesimally tiny nudge or a large number of degrees, and the circle will retain its appearance -- which, after all, is the signature definition of symmetry.

To get a little bit mathematical, as described in this document by Clark University's David Joyce, "The unit circle is the circle of radius 1 centered at 0." The unit circle follows the equation x-squared + y-squared = 1. Among the points on the circle would be (1, 0), (-1, 0), (0, 1), (0, -1), (.707, .707), (.707, -.707), etc. Spicing things up a bit, we must also incorporate complex numbers, in particular the imaginary square root of -1, denoted i in this terminology.

As stated on the Wikipedia page on unitary groups (that's where the "U" in "U(1)" comes from), "...the group U(1) corresponds to the circle group, consisting of all complex numbers with absolute value 1 under multiplication."

U(1), as we noted above, pertains to the electromagnetic force. The physical analogue to electricity, as explained by Rachel Thomas in Plus Magazine, is as follows:

"...the electromagnetic field around a conducting wire is symmetrical around the wire -- you can rotate the wire (around an axis running along the wire) and it won't affect the electromagnetic field. This kind of symmetry is described by the group of rotations on a circle, called U(1), and this defines how particles behave in an electromagnetic field."

One other source that readers might find helpful in understanding the U(1) symmetry group is Peter Woit's book Not Even Wrong (pp. 35-41).

The strong and weak forces correspond to much more elaborate Lie groups than U(1). We'll get to that in the next entry...

Sunday, June 21, 2009

Symmetry (Math and Physics) Part IV

Continuing with our series on symmetry, in Part IV we discuss a frequently encountered term, gauge symmetry. Terry Tao, who among his many distinctions earned full professor status at UCLA at age 24, has addressed the concept of a gauge, on his blog:

“Gauge theory” is a term which has connotations of being a fearsomely complicated part of mathematics – for instance, playing an important role in quantum field theory, general relativity, geometric PDE, and so forth. But the underlying concept is really quite simple: a gauge is nothing more than a “coordinate system” that varies depending on one’s “location” with respect to some “base space” or “parameter space”, a gauge transform is a change of coordinates applied to each such location, and a gauge theory is a model for some physical or mathematical system to which gauge transforms can be applied (and is typically gauge invariant, in that all physically meaningful quantities are left unchanged (or transform naturally) under gauge transformations).

Writers have offered several everyday examples of gauge systems. The main idea I extract from them is that, if you add a constant to every value in a system, the behavior of the system is unchanged.

Dan Hooper, whose previous book Dark Cosmos I reviewed here, uses the example of mountain-climbing and altitude to explain the gauge concept in his new book, Nature's Blueprint. The amount of upward climbing a person does from the base to the top of Mount Everest is the same -- 11,528 feet -- whether the frame of reference is sea level (where the base is said to be at 17,500 feet and the top at 29,028) or the reference is the lowest point on earth beneath the oceans (53,338 to 64,866).

As Hooper notes, "With global gauge symmetries, the arbitrary scale can be changed without affecting anything, but it must be changed at every location at the same time" (p. 64). If, therefore, in our discussions of altitude we added a constant 35,838 feet all throughout the earth in order to change the baseline from the depths of the oceans to sea level, we would have a global gauge symmetry.

Another kind of symmetry, where one type of change is made at one location but a different type of change is made at another, is called local gauge symmetry. Hooper credits Hermann Weyl with realizing the implications of local gauge symmetries for physics.

Ian Stewart, in his book on symmetry, Why Beauty is Truth, uses monetary systems to illustrate local gauge symmetry:

Suppose that you are traveling in a different country -- let us call it Duplicatia -- and you need money. The Duplicatian currency is the pfunnig, and the exchange rate is two pfunnigs to the dollar. ...everything costs twice as many pfunnigs as you would expect to pay in dollars.

This is a kind of symmetry. The "laws" of commercial transactions are unchanged if you double all the numbers. To compensate for the numerical difference, though, you have to pay in pfunnigs, not in dollars.

...Just across the border, in neighboring Triplicatia, the local currency is the boodle, and these are valued at three to the dollar. When you take a day trip to Triplicatia, the corresponding symmetry requires all sums to be multiplied by three. But again the laws of commerce remain invariant.

Now we have a "symmetry" that differs from one place to another. In Duplicatia, it is multiplication by two; in Triplicatia, by three. You would not be surprised to find that on visiting Quintuplicatia the corresponding multiple is five. All of these symmetry operations can be applied simultaneously, but each is valid only in the corresponding country...

This local rescaling of currency transactions is a gauge symmetry of the laws of commerce. In principle, the exchange rate could be different at every point of space and time, but the laws would still be invariant provided you interpreted all transactions in terms of the local value of the "currency field"
(p. 231).

If you go to the "Review of the Universe" summary of particle physics, particularly the section entitled, "Gauge Theory and the Standard Model," you will find a graphical representation of the distinction between global and local transformations in Figure 15-06a. The original and globally transformed objects (spheres) look identical, whereas the locally transformed one looks very different.

The next figure, 15-06b, shows (schematically) the process of local transformation. Between steps 1 and 2, the small dial on the right appears from visual inspection to have been rotated 180 degrees, whereas the other two dials have been rotated by amounts other than 180. Yet as step 3's caption says, the gauge field compensates for the change, and as step 4's caption says (pointing upward on the right), "The original field configuration is restored." (Note that the term "compensation" was also used by Stewart in his above quotes about the hypothetical monetary unit, the pfunnig.)

Such local symmetries are behind many of the major concepts of physics. Writes Stewart:

The possibility of changing the phase arbitrarily at each point of space-time, with no global constraint to make the same change everywhere, is a gauge symmetry of Maxwell's equations, and it carries over into the quantum version of those equations, quantum electrodynamics (p. 233).

Tuesday, June 02, 2009

Symmetry (Math and Physics) Part III

In Part III of our series on symmetry, we introduce symmetry groups, which fall within a branch of mathematics known as group theory. According to this Wikipedia document, "In mathematics, a group is an algebraic structure consisting of a set together with an operation that combines any two of its elements to form a third element." A very simple example of a group, as noted on the Wikipedia page, is that of ordinary numbers (integers, technically), with addition as the operation: "For any two integers a and b, the sum a + b is also an integer. In other words, the process of adding integers two at a time can never yield a result that is not an integer. This property is known as closure under addition."

This overview document from Minnesota-Morris professor Barry McQuarrie introduces mathematical groups and uses the example of how equilateral triangles can form a symmetry group of operations (turns) that leave the appearance of the triange unaltered.

Over the last year or two, I've been reading books on symmetry that I hoped would be accessible to a non-physicist, non-mathematician such as myself. When one reads a book on symmetry, one inevitably seems to confront the concept of Galois groups. It took a while, but I think I finally understand the general concept. At a very basic level, Galois groups can inform someone performing mathematical calculations if a given equation is solvable.

In particular, Galois groups are focused on algebraic equations with x raised to different powers. An equation with x-squared (x^2) as the highest power is known as a quadratic equation and can be solved using the quadratic formula. Mark Ronan's book Symmetry and the Monster contains a chapter ("Galois: Death of a Genius") that traces the history of how the quadratic formula was followed hundreds and thousands of years later with formulas for solving cubic (x^3) and quartic (x^4) equations. The ideas of Galois enter at the level of quintic (x^5) equations, as summarized in Ian Stewart's book Why Beauty is Truth: A History of Symmetry:

Now we begin to see the beauty of Galois's idea. Not only does it prove that the general quintic has no radical solutions, it also explains why the general quadratic, cubic, and quartic do have radical solutions and tells us roughly what they look like. With extra work, it tells us exactly what they look like. Finally, it distinguishes those quintics that can be solved from those that can't, and tells us how to solve the ones that can (p. 116).

As noted in the above-linked Wikipedia document, solving equations "by radicals" refers to "solutions expressible using solely addition, multiplication, and roots."

In other words, some quintics, such as the very simple x^5 = 1, can be solved (x = 1). Among other quintics, some can be solved by radicals and some cannot. Galois groups can distinguish the solvable from the unsolvable -- on the basis of symmetry. John Baez, who writes an online series, "This Week's Finds in Mathematical Physics," wrote the following in an entry about Galois and symmetry:

The basic idea is something like this. In general, a quintic equation has 5 solutions - and there's no "best one", so your formula has got to be a formula for all five. And there's a puzzle: how do you give one formula for five things?

Well, think about the quadratic formula! It has that "plus or minus" in it, which comes from taking a square root. So, it's really a formula for both solutions of the quadratic equation. If there were a formula for the quintic that worked like this, we'd have to get all 5 solutions from different choices of nth roots in this formula.

Galois showed this can't happen. And the way he did it used symmetry! Roughly speaking, he showed that the general quintic equation is completely symmetrical under permuting all 5 solutions, and that this symmetry group - the group of permutations of 5 things - can't be built up from the symmetry groups that arise when you take nth roots.

The moral is this: you can't solve a problem if the answer has some symmetry, and your method of solution doesn't let you write down a correct answer that has this symmetry!

An old example of this principle is the medieval puzzle called "Buridan's Ass". Placed equidistant between two equally good piles of hay, this donkey starves to death because it can't make up its mind which alternative is best. The problem has a symmetry, but the donkey can't go to both bales of hay, so the only symmetrical thing he can do is stand there.

Buridan's ass would also get stuck if you asked it for the solution to the quadratic equation. Galois proof of the unsolvability of the quintic by radicals is just a more sophisticated variation on this theme. (Of course, you can solve the quintic if you strengthen your methods.)


Not that solving quintics is easy. According to a different Wikipedia page, this one on quintics, sometimes “the solution requires about 600 symbols to write.”

I urge interested readers to check out the websites and books I've referenced. One other book, which I found too technical for my own knowledge level but others of you might find worthwhile, is entitled Fearless Symmetry: Exposing the Hidden Patterns of Numbers, by Avner Ash and Robert Gross.

Next time, we'll look at another type of symmetry group, Lie groups.

Saturday, May 02, 2009

Symmetry (Math and Physics) Part II

In Part II of my series on symmetry, today, we'll take an initial look at what physicists see as the importance and usefulness of symmetry for their work. Harvard's Lisa Randall, in her book Warped Passages, writes that:

It is difficult to overstate the importance of symmetry in physical laws. Many physical theories, such as Maxwell's laws of electrodynamics and Einstein's theory of relativity, are deeply rooted in symmetry. And by exploiting various symmetries we can usually simplify the task of using theories to make physical predictions. For example, predictions of the orbital motion of the planets, the gravitational field of the universe (which is more or less rotationally symmetric), the behavior of particles in electromagnetic fields, and many other physical quantities are mathematically simpler once we take symmetry into account (pp. 193-194).

UCLA Emeritus Professor Marvin Chester has written an introduction to symmetry. In it, he quotes Nobel Laureate Leon Lederman as follows:

Fundamental symmetry principles dictate the basic laws of physics, control the st[r]ucture of matter, and define the fundamental forces in nature.

From my own layperson perspective, symmetry would appear to suggest that if we can transform "Situation A" into "Situation B" without altering important features, then we might be able to study Situations A and B with one mathematical formulation instead of two. The following quote from a University of Winnipeg webpage appears to be consistent with my thinking (although I obviously cannot claim it as an exact endorsement of my thinking):

By assuming that physical systems have, at least approximately, a high degree of symmetry, it is possible to radically simplify the equations that describe them.

In the next few postings, I will talk about how physicists and mathematicians are aided by symmetry-based formulations such as Galois groups, Lie groups, and Noether's theorem.

Sunday, March 01, 2009

Symmetry (Math and Physics) Part I

Today, we begin a multi-part series on symmetry. I'm not sure how many installments there'll be, but I plan to approach symmetry from multiple perspectives. In this first posting, we'll introduce some definitions and visual illustrations of symmetry. In the next posting, we'll look at physicists' writings on the importance of symmetry for physics. Later on, we'll look at the mathematical concept of symmetry groups, the notations of which, such as SU(2) and SO(3), often show up in physics books for educated laypersons. We'll also examine Galois groups and Lie groups.

Much of this material is impenetrably way over my head, and probably capable of being understood only by mathematicians and mathematical physicists with specialized advanced training. However, I feel I can at least sketch out the major ideas.

Let's start by looking at the following diagram of a soccer field (also known as a "pitch"):


One might say the field is "symmetric" because, emanating from the vertical center line in rightward and leftward directions, the two halves of the field look identical. One could also rotate the field 180 degrees (or any whole-number multiple of that) and it would look identical to how it had looked before.

This leads us to our formal definition of symmetry: that things “appear unchanged when certain transformations are applied.” This definition comes from a site called Mathematics Illuminated, which also provides some nice visual illustrations of different types of symmetry, including mirror/bilateral and rotational.

Another web resource, this one from the University at Buffalo, presents some artistic depictions and interactive demonstrations of symmetry in physics (when the page comes up, scroll down a bit and click on the heading for the Flash presentation on symmetry).